Wednesday, December 7, 2022
HomePoliticsNorth Bengal gets ready for epic Mamata-Modi battle — Didi’s image vs...

North Bengal gets ready for epic Mamata-Modi battle — Didi’s image vs Dada’s charm

Modi is popular, but local leaders say BJP's polarisation is reaping dividends on the ground. There is no clarity, though, if that will be enough to overcome Mamata. 

Text Size:

Cooch Behar, Alipurduars, Siliguri: With the BJP firmly setting its sights on West Bengal, the poll narrative in the northern part of the state appears to be veering towards a Didi versus Dada contest.

Of the eight Lok Sabha constituencies in North Bengal, the BJP is eyeing Cooch Behar, Alipurduars, Jalpaiguri and Darjeeling. In the past 10 days alone, the party has held two high-profile rallies in the region — Prime Minister Narendra Modi held one at Siliguri on 3 April while BJP president Amit Shah was at Alipurduars on 29 March.

The BJP is hoping to build on the momentum it has created in the past few years. Ahead of the elections, the word on the streets here is that the region may end up witnessing a two-horse race between Modi’s BJP and the Trinamool Congress (TMC) of Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee.

Be it the dwellers of the former Bangladeshi enclaves in Cooch Behar, the tea workers in Alipurduars or the labourer harvesting potato in Jalpaiguri, the common refrain here is that there is a wave for both — Didi (elder sister in Bengali but referring to Banerjee) and Dada (older brother in Bengali but referring to Modi).

Didi has a good image and is clean but the Trinamool workers are bringing a bad name to her and the party,” says Mano Barman, a resident of Cooch Behar’s Mashaldanga Enclave. “Whatever development work has been carried out in the enclaves by the state government after they became a part of India in 2015, is because Modi’s central government gave them funds.”

Even being mentioned among the frontrunners is an achievement for the BJP, which finished third in three of the seats in the region in the 2014 Lok Sabha elections. But it has a lot of ground to cover, at least in two of the constituencies, if it wants to catch up with the TMC.

In 2014, the BJP won in Darjeeling and performed creditably in Alipurduars where despite finishing third, the party garnered 27.41 per cent of the votes. The Trinamool, which won in Alipurduars, managed 29.58 per cent of the votes.

The TMC won the other two seats relatively comfortably, polling 39.5 per cent of the votes in Cooch Behar and 37.93 per cent in Jalpaiguri. In contrast, the BJP polled 16.33 per cent votes in Cooch Behar and 16.99 per cent in Jalpaiguri.

It was the Left Front — of the All India Forward Bloc (AIFB), Revolutionary Socialist Party (RSP) and CPI(M) — that bagged the second place in the three constituencies.

The AIFB secured 32.96 per cent of the votes in Cooch Behar while the RSP managed 27.84 per cent of the votes in Alipurduars. In Jalpaiguri, the CPM garnered 32.6 per cent of the total votes polled.

This time around, Cooch Behar and Alipurduars go to the polls on 11 April while Jalpaiguri and Darjeeling will vote on 18 April.

Also read: Communists who once sided with BJP now irked over no alliance with Congress in West Bengal

Polarisation along religious lines

The BJP’s rise in the region is being attributed to its religious polarisation tactics.

Among those who believe this is CPM leader and Siliguri mayor Ashok Bhattacharya, who says that it’s the Hindutva and the nationalist discourse of the BJP that has resulted in a Hindu-Muslim divide in the region.

He, however, adds that Banerjee has to take some of the blame for this. “Her appeasement politics of the minority community, be it giving imam bhata (a monthly salary for imams) or a 2014 election poster that showed her offering namaaz, provided the BJP with an easy opportunity to come and play the Hindutva card,” Bhattacharya says.

The BJP appears to be mindful of this. Party president Shah, during his rally in Alipurduars on 29 March, said if BJP comes to power it will replicate the National Register of Citizens in West Bengal and throw out all “infiltrators”.

“We will ensure that Hindu refugees are not touched,” he had said.

That sentiment appears to be resonating on the ground. “Because of her (Mamata’s) appeasement of Muslims, Hindus have become wary of Trinamool,” says Mrinmoy Ghosh, who runs a sweetmeat shop in Jalpaiguri. “This has helped build up support for the BJP, which is perceived as a party that will protect Hindus.”

The BJP’s strategy appears to be working despite the region being overwhelmingly Hindu.

As per the 2011 Census, Hindus constitute 74.06 per cent of the 28 lakh population in Cooch Behar while Muslims are 25.54 per cent. In Alipurduars, 97.59 per cent of the 65,232 population is Hindu. Muslims account for just 1.68 per cent of the population.

In Jalpaiguri, of the 38 lakh people, Hindus constitute 81.51 per cent while Muslims account for 11.15 per cent. In Darjeeling, Hindus constitute 74 per cent of the total 18.46 lakh population while Muslims are 5.69 per cent.

Popularity of Modi

In 2014, West Bengal was one among the handful of states where the Modi wave failed to make a splash — the TMC had won 34 of the 42 seats here. This time, however, the prime minister appears to be having an effect, with the Balakot air strikes only adding to his aura.

“For the first time, we have a leader who has taken strong action against Pakistan. He is very decisive and makes India look good,” says Manotosh Das, a 25-year-old who works in a private company in Naxalbari.

In many of these areas, voters seem ignorant of the BJP candidate but say they will vote in the name of Modi. “We have seen the work that he has done in the last few years. It’s enough for me to make up my mind,” said Sunita Barai, a primary school teacher at the Majhedabri tea estate in Alipurduars.

Residents of Majhedabri tea estate in Alipurduars | Moushumi Das Gupta/ThePrint

There are many, though, who are wary of him and his party’s politics.

“Earlier, we never thought in terms of Hindu-Muslim. But BJP has introduced this communal divide in the political discourse,” says Saddam Hussain, who is doing his MA in political science from Cooch Behar University. “It’s a very dangerous trend and will increase the divide further.”

Also read: Coming soon, a BJP report card on how Mamata, KCR, Kejriwal & co failed their states

A relegated Left 

In all of the churn in North Bengal, it is the Left parties that appear to have lost out.

Despite a creditable performance in 2014, where the front finished second in three seats and third in Darjeeling, the communist parties have now been relegated to the sidelines.

On the ground, except for a few pockets in Cooch Behar and Alipurduars, one hardly sees any festoons or banners of the Left Front parties.

“Many of the Left Front leaders have joined either the BJP or the TMC, leaving the organisation rudderless,” said a local CPM worker, who did not want to be named.

“Senior AIFB leader Paresh Adhikary, who was a minister in the Left Front government, joined TMC last year and has been given ticket from Cooch Behar. There have been many switchovers like this at all levels.”

That has led to a feeling in the region that voting for the Left Front is a futile exercise. “The parties hardly have any presence,” says Rony Sen, a taxi driver in Jalpaiguri. “They do not have any leaders. Why should I waste my vote on them?”

With the Left in disarray, the BJP and the TMC have stepped up their campaigns. Modi held a rally in Siliguri on 3 April and another rally is planned in Cooch Behar on 7 April.

Mamata, on her part, held rallies in Cooch Behar, on the same day that Modi was in Siliguri, addressed a rally on Cooch Behar on 4 April and one in Naxalbari on 5 April.

But Didi’s popularity, locals allege, is being hamstrung by her party workers.

“Trinamool workers indulge in violence, especially in rural areas,” says Mahadev Pal, a government school teacher in Naxalbari. “You should have seen the terror they indulged in during the last panchayat elections. Many of the leaders of the party are also involved in corruption.”

Trinamool Congress Lok Sabha MP, Professor Sougata Roy, however, denies the charges. “There have been stray incidents of violence but by and large West Bengal is a peaceful state.”

He also emphasised that the TMC’s policies towards Muslims were all about righting a wrong.

“Muslims constitute 30 per cent of West Bengal’s population and they are backward. Even the Sachar committee report has said this,” said Roy, who is now contesting from the Dum Dum Lok Sabha constituency in Kolkatta. “So any development that happens in the state has to take Muslims along. Taking them along is not appeasement.”

Also read: Mamata Banerjee ‘vindictive & revengeful’ — ex-IPS officer blames Bengal CM in suicide note


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

Most Popular