Thursday, 6 October, 2022
HomeOpinionLetter From PakistanIs she 18? How Pakistan's forced conversion of minors gets legal cover

Is she 18? How Pakistan’s forced conversion of minors gets legal cover

If your kidnapper-husband says you are 18, or have had your first period, no more questions are asked in Pakistan about abduction-conversions of young girls.

Text Size:

Their names change, their dreadful stories remain the same. It can be Kavita, Maria, Simran or Huma, what bonds their doomed fates in Pakistan are their faiths. The forced conversion of minor girls from minority communities to Islam is a pandemic that won’t end on its own.

Prime Minister Imran Khan can say Pakistan will take strict against anyone targeting minorities, but this practice has continued for years with impunity.

Pakistani contractors preach the world on Islamophobia, while Pakistan persecutes its own Shias and Ahmadis. We are triggered over Muslim rights in Europe and India, while oppressing our own minorities with state patronage.

And now, there is another popular way to hide forced conversions to Islam — say the minor girl was 18 and show a fake certificate or say she has had her first period. She is an adult then, and no more questions are asked by the state.

Also read: Imran Khan lectures Modi on minorities. He must ban forced conversions in Pakistan first

‘Free-will affidavit’

Last month, a teenage Hindu girl, Simran Kumari from Ghotki in Sindh, was kidnapped and then miraculously resurfaced at the shrine of Bharchundi Sharif, infamous for converting thousands of Hindu girls to Islam. Kumari’s family members are now forbidden to see their daughter because they are ‘kafirs’ and she has been married off to her Muslim kidnapper.

In another case earlier this month, 14-year-old Parsha Kumari from Khairpur was abducted, forced to convert and married to Abdul Saboor. Like in most conversions cases, the family produced a school certificate to verify age, but a ‘free-will affidavit’ from the kidnapper-husband set the minor’s age at 18. Thus, showing that the girl is an adult and can make her own decisions.

The dilemma of each forced conversion is that no medical examinations are done to determine the age of the minor independently by the authorities.

And automatically, the system, which has been rigged by the religious and social VIPs, sides with the captors and not the aggrieved families in most cases. Questions arise on why only minor Hindu and Christian girls ‘fall in love to get converted’ for men thrice their age? Why don’t Sindhi Hindu boys fall in such love?

Also read: For Pakistani men, Aurat March is the real coronavirus

With court sanction

How does the system help even if a girl escapes? There’s not even the pretence of carrying out justice then.

Maria Shahbaz, a 14-year-old Christian teenager who recently escaped her abductors, provided testimony on how she was raped, forced to convert and then married to her kidnapper. She was videotaped while being raped and was threatened with release of her video if she didn’t obey orders. Maria was then pushed into the prostitution ring — from where she escaped. Even after braving the ordeal of repeating what happened to her, Maria and her family are being threatened, and justice remains a far cry.

The Lahore High Court had earlier ordered her to go back to her kidnapper after her family protested. And when her family contested that she wasn’t 18 and was forced, the court said: “The statement of Maria Shahbaz as well as her general appearance unambiguously show that she is a grown-up young lady who seems to have attained the age of puberty.”

Huma Younas, another Christian girl who was abducted and converted at 14, is now pregnant from rape by Abdul Jabbar. In her case, the Sindh High Court ruled that a girl can get married after her first menstrual cycle under the Sharia law. It did not matter if Huma was non-Muslim, or that her school and baptism certificate showed she was born in 2005, or that she was kidnapped and forcefully converted and married. Her forced marriage was given a legal cover despite the fact that in Sindh, the Child Marriage Restraint Act 2013 prohibits marriage under the age of 18. The federal government of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) had vehemently opposed the bill to set the marriageable age of girls at 18 saying it was un-Islamic.

Also read: In Imran Khan’s Naya Pakistan, a minority commission without minority

A lesser god

In the absence of any law against forced conversion in Pakistan, there is hardly any will from the provincial Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) government or the federal Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) government to effectively implement the child marriage laws in place. There is no dearth of cases but the seriousness of the government is visible because it is still deciding on the “definition of forced conversion” with the help of the clergy. Wonder how many more minors have to be kidnapped and converted for lawmakers to define what a forced conversion is, what is free will and what is statutory rape, how to independently verify age of minors, and how the law should see sexual relationships with anyone below 16.

The fear of kidnapping and conversion has had an impact even on affluent Sikh and Hindu families, who, over the years, have stopped their girls from getting an education after primary school. They say that it is the only way for them to protect vulnerable girls.

Conversions coupled with discriminatory laws and societal prejudices make life miserable for the non-Muslims who want to survive in the country. But when notorious men such as Mian Mithoo of Bharchundi dargah hobnob with powerful men, it is a clear message for Hindu parents — your daughters are children of a lesser god.

The author is a freelance journalist from Pakistan. Her Twitter handle is @nailainayat. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. India invited Hindu community from Pakistan to come to India but those who migrated to India were left without any support. Many were killed, snatched of their valuables or forced to suicide. Girls were raped or forced to prostitution in India. Why Moodi govt is not patronizing these migrated Hindus?

  2. t’s allowed in some US states to marry from the age 10
    And in 1 state there’s not even a minimum age for marriage
    So stop the BS

    • So basically you’re comparing Pakistan with USA. If that is the level of your understanding of the difference between these two countries then God help you my friend.

  3. You must be a darling of the Hindutva brigade always spewing venom against and defaming your country. Is there nobody in Pakistan to read your tirade. You are definitely helping the Hindutva brigade lynch more Muslim with these articles. People can go to any extent to defame their country for a fat paycheck.

  4. They indeed are children of a lesser God. The Indian liberal/secular cabal never stands up on their behalf. The Amnesty Internationals of the world dont speak up for them even half as forcefully as they do for minorities in India.
    When one sees the plight of minorities in Pakistan one wonders how can Islam still be labeled as a peaceful and tolerant religion?

  5. Naila there are Muslims in India who believe India is unsafe for them and they get discriminated. Will Pakistan take some of them?

  6. ”The fear of kidnapping and conversion has had an impact even on affluent Sikh and Hindu families, who, over the years, have stopped their girls from getting an education after primary school. They say that it is the only way for them to protect vulnerable girls.” They should migrate to India. Millions did, what are they waiting for? You cannot live with animals.

  7. The attraction to go to heaven is too strong to resist and what better way to get that passport than killing a kaffir, or converting their girls to Islam.

  8. Some people projects social evils more than the need and this is what the author is doing. All problems will be solved if we accept the true spirit of Islam.

    • & who the hell are you to decide how much is Enough or not needed to talk about social evils?? when will your so called”true spirit of Islam” will be followed??after all the Minority Hindu girls of Pakistan are forcefully raped & converted to Islam??have some Shame you sick people.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular