Friday, 19 August, 2022
HomeOpinionIndian intelligence failure again? Heroism at Galwan must lead to reforms

Indian intelligence failure again? Heroism at Galwan must lead to reforms

India was napping in the 1950s when a strategic highway was built in Aksai Chin. Then again in 1999 at Kargil, and now in Ladakh.

Text Size:

Home they brought her warrior dead” — goes the opening lines of Alfred Tennyson’s famous poem. Unfortunately, it is now being repeated in at least 20 homes in India, and in the hearts of crores of Indians. While the immediate family and friends of those who died at the Line of Actual Control in the stand-off with China grieve with a pain that only they can feel, the rest of us wonder how this has come to pass.

Are we a country of perpetual sleepers? We were found sleeping in the 1950s when our northern neighbour went about building a strategic highway in Aksai Chin. Then it happened again in 1999 at Kargil, and now when the Chinese hoodwinked us and have come prepared with a plan in Galwan, Pangong Tso in Ladakh and Naku La in Sikkim.

Also read: Doklam team of Jaishankar-Doval-Rawat let Modi down but he has an option

Intelligence failure

We have been napping despite the creation of the Defence Intelligence Agency and the National Technical Research Organisation (NTRO) – both charged with collecting intelligence. The NTRO has no dearth of funds and operates its own unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). Then there is the Research and Analysis Wing (R&AW), with its operatives and links abroad; there are the intelligence wings of the Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP), the Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB), and others — pray, what have they all been doing as the Chinese planned this operation?

The Cabinet Secretariat has specialised aircraft as part of its Aviation Research Centre with a task just to avoid a Galwan-like situation. And if they indeed did their job and had raised the red flag, who in the hierarchy didn’t follow up?

After Kargil happened, the Director of Air Operations of the Pakistan Air Force, Air Commodore Kaiser Tufail, wrote that when he visited Skardu in Gilgit-Baltistan, he saw hectic activity – intense helicopter flying, messes abuzz with war-is-coming murmur –and was sure that Indian intelligence would have picked it up. We were none the wiser and got a rude shock when Capt. Saurabh Kalia’s mutilated body was returned even as we were stirring into action.

Now, the injuries to Indian soldiers have been replicated at Galwan, in a most brutal manner. Defence Secretary Ajay Kumar tweeted: “A zillion salutes to the brave hearts…(sic)”. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh tweeted his condolences, and Prime Minister Narendra Modi said that they “..died fighting… maarte maarte mare” and observed a two-minute silence with all the chief ministers in their honour.

Tennyson came back to mind, for he had followed up his “Home they brought her warrior dead…” verse with “Then they praised him, soft and low; called him worthy to be loved; truest friend and noblest foe…”. This was 1847 being repeated in 2020. Have we changed?

Also read: Chinese have changed the rules of engagement at LAC. It’s time India did too

Getting down to real work

When will we change from our habit of just appreciating and going gaga over the words of our brave soldiers who said, “Yeh dil maange more” and climbed the hills of Kargil, never to return? Perhaps, a similar quote will form the narrative of Galwan when the full story of 16 Bihar regiment is written, and we will go to town with it in another round of symposia and seminars presided over by people in power – amidst much cutting of ribbons and garlanding of photo frames. But when will we get down to work — real work?

When will the head of capital acquisitions in the Ministry of Defence, and our political executive, understand that deterrence is derived from hard power, which our armed forces project, and not from ‘zillion salutes’ that are offered after an armed engagement? When will the Secretary of Defence Production accept that his/her department is in charge of, and responsible for, defence manufacturing output of not just government Defence Public Sector Undertakings (DPSUs) but private ones too, and work towards capability and capacity accretion?

Can we have a Union minister looking after defence production only? Can the ponderous Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) be stirred into action to give us cutting-edge technology? If we had that kind of power, our adversary China would not have launched the adventure that it has embarked on. And the power deferential shows in the way we reacted to Kargil and the way we are responding now.

Also read: Modi govt and military leaders have soldiers’ blood on hands. PM’s dilemma now same as Nehru

No petty politics

Power flows through the barrel of a gun, said Mao, but a gun is not built in a day. It’s time that a long-term view of our capabilities and capacities is taken; the Chinese have a 100-year time-span to return to their claimed glory, as they see it.

At present, let the head rule the heart, our (rightly) inflamed passions notwithstanding. National security has to override political expediency, for only then will a bi-partisan approach emerge. Let us not have the spectacle of the photos of our 20 braves adorning election posters and platforms, a la the CRPF soldiers who died in Pulwama; let them not be used for petty political gains. The opposition of the day (tomorrow it may be another party) must be part of the process so that there is a strategic continuum, like in the nuclear and space sector.

The soldiers who died in Galwan, and the many who were grievously injured, belong to us all; they fought to protect the name of their paltan (regiment) and the nation in the highest tradition of the Indian Army. To paraphrase Tennyson — let this part be penned when we have paid our dues to our braves guarding us on those dangerous frontiers. For now, let us all, together, look the adversary in the eye.

The author is Addl Director General, Centre for Air Power Studies, Delhi. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. China has more Engineers among its leadership. India’s leaders are mostly from student wing of political parties.

    The Chinese learned how the West produces knowledge, funds its development, and employs it. They hold an edge over India in every area — our semiconductor-fabrication capabilities are almost non-existent. We depend on imports for even small things like network routers.

  2. I am aware there was no intelligence failure in Kargil or now, the build up was reported in newspapers. Who slept over the issue senior lot in; army, intelligence setup or defence ministry ?? Some one should own up

  3. As far I understand, there is no intelligence failure, nor there was any in the past. Politicians block the intelligence so the issue amplifies. And then the politician gets opportunity to show-off that how he/she tackled the problem. That’s old and tested doctrine. Bihar elections are on the horizon and those dead bodies have served the purpose for Modi. He knew everything. So did Sonia during 26/11 And so did Vajpayee during Kargil. Another issue is with our old fashioned lethargic and pampered army generals who refute any extraordinary intelligence inputs. The British legacy can only create boot licker generals. Irony is, a proactive and assertive general will be kicked out by the politician. At times I wonder if the solution is to line up all old politicians and execute them to save lives of thousands of Indian soldiers.

  4. Indian intelligence has failed not only in 1950s, Kargil, 1962, but during URI, Mumbai 26/11, when Indian submarine was blown at Mumbai dock, and Galwan. What is the point of making India a 5 Trillion Dollars economy ? If only its going to attract invaders like Khilaji and Xi Jinping ? Indian politicains have to agree that Defense of India is a joint responsibility and failure in it belongs to all. Government and opposition has to formulate mechanism share responsibility of keeping intelligence and army in active phase. Immediate action required is to change the advisers of PM.

    • Sir, with due respect, it is absolutely incorrect that Indian intelligence failed any time (excrpt 50’s). For a moment, let’s say they failed, but what about additional feeds from 5 foreign intelligence? Defence ministry is the information hub where you have two problems. 1. Compromised staff. 2. Shrewd politician. Intelligence department does its job, they never get to defend themselves as eventually they serve the politician.

  5. Agree with you Sir.
    Is the enemy build up reporting only based on a patrol’s observations. The entire infrastructure of intelligence held by multitude of agencies is held suspect now. Early reporting is what gets food on their tables. They must be answerable. Though it is hard to believe that they didn’t. In that case, agencies that were required to act on that intelligence must answer.
    Finally, not an institutionalised system, but the raw courage of our men alone bloodied the enemy. For that to happen implies that the nation is failing these men.

  6. COLLISAL FAILURE. Its not just an Intelligence failure. Its a strategic blunder. if over decades, repeatedly India is stumbling in a similar fashion, in the same region, facing the same enemy. !!!!!
    The BLIND MEN OF HINDOOSTAN do not need Lesik treatment, they need Brain transplant.
    National security cannot be a function of political party in power or Bravery of the troops alone. My heart bleeds at the plight of Troops who were put in a situation to make a charge without weapons on enemy 6-8 times in strength, at above 16000ft AMSL.
    Redemption every time is the bravery of Indian soldiers. Who is then dumped and trashed – be it OROP or even disability pension.
    Just a glance at the strategic Darbuk- DBO road in map will tell the vulnerable points. How then ALL CHEQUERED INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES you so aptly listed, failed.
    We should not settle unless 20 heads to roll in the bureaucracy to fail the 20 martyrs. That should be the start point of redemption of any kind that any government in power – serious about national security must do. Bite the bullet now or be happy glorifying the martyrdom- suits politically ?
    For immediate action all higher defence management offices should be relocated to somewhere in Ladakh so that the sacrifices of troops is not list sight if for one moment.//-

    • Sir, more than 8 sattelite with 1 meter resolution cameras are watching everything. They knew everything. Problem is seldom the foot soldier, it is the politician who makes the blunder. Let’s see if modi and rajnath announce firing of any defence ministry staff or intelligence officer. :-). If raw can record conversation of Musharraf over Huawei own switching system, they got deep links. We need to focus on these politicians and teach them a hard lesson.

  7. Congress = Corruption = Congress = Traitors =Congress = Arrogance = Congress = Duffer Gandhi = Congress = Dim Wit Gandhi = Congress = Inheritance = Congress = Half Wit Gandhi = Congress = Living on Tax Payers Expense = Congress = China voice = Congress = Pakistani
    Congress = China virus

  8. And, everytime after the situation cools a little, such articles about failure of our intelligence will apear again and again, but we are stubborn, won’t change, that is our characteristics, relax sir.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular