Wednesday, December 7, 2022
HomeOpinionGlobal PrintFighting her own students, Bangladesh PM Hasina shouldn't take Modi’s support for...

Fighting her own students, Bangladesh PM Hasina shouldn’t take Modi’s support for granted

Text Size:

Bangladesh’s students have written the course of history, from 1952 to the present, in their own blood.

School and college students have been out on the streets for the past few days in Dhaka to protest against a bus ramming into two of their compatriots on 29 July. Their simple demands were restricted to improving road safety measures in Bangladesh – get licensed drivers, not underage boys who are running riot behind the wheel, working for transport companies that are hand-in-glove with corrupt politicians.

Dhaka is littered with memories of students rising up against oppression and dictatorship.

It happened on 21 February 1952, when Dhaka University students immortalised their protest against West Pakistan’s one-language diktat by preferring to die rather than submit. This was ‘Ekushey’, and it sowed the seeds for independence in 1971, when Dhaka University students were massacred by the Pakistan army because they led the resistance against Pakistan.

Five years ago, in February 2013, thousands of students led a civil society awakening at Shahbag Square, demanding that the war criminals of 1971 be given death penalty. That agitation underlined the enormous support and affection for Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina’s Awami League government. It also reminded the country that Bangladesh’s students were both unwilling and unable to forget the lessons of history.

Also read: Student protests bring Dhaka to a standstill, leave Bangladesh in chaos in election year

It is a measure of Hasina’s impatience that this time she sent the police to deal with the protesting students with a heavy hand. Along with the police, came the party’s youth wing, the Chhatra League, a willing accomplice to the mayhem. Hasina forgot that Bangladesh’s students have protest written in their gene pool — by the weekend, the agitation had spread from Dhaka to Chittagong, Khulna and Rajshahi.

The Chhatra League’s demolition squads were carrying machetes and sticks and attacked the protesting students with vengeance. Several were injured and sent to hospital. It is also true that the protests have lately been infiltrated by the Jamaat-e-Islami and perhaps even the opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP).

It’s a pity that Hasina, ‘Bangabandhu’ Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’s daughter, has forgotten the lessons of history. The biggest irony is that the Jamaat, which led the fight against Bangladeshi independence, and therefore against Mujibur, is now supporting the students in their fight against corruption.

Is Hasina so out of touch with her own people that she cannot see that the BNP and its ideological ally, the Jamaat, is taking full advantage of the people’s growing anger against Hasina and the Awami League?

Also read: Delhi supports ‘dictator’ Sheikh Hasina despite Khaleda Zia’s entreaties

It has been clear for the last year or so that if free and fair elections were to be held in Bangladesh today, Hasina would lose badly. The corruption in the party’s ranks, the dismissal of sane advice from older Awami League folk, the coterie around Hasina that prevents her from seeing the reality, are some of the reasons.

Unfortunately, all of this is accompanied by a securitisation of the state. In the name of fighting extreme, right-wing fundamentalist Islamists, Hasina is raising battalion after battalion of police and paramilitary. Those who speak up against her, for example the media, are now being seen as the enemy. Cases against critical journalists are increasingly common in Bangladesh.

With elections slated to be held in December, Hasina knows she cannot afford to take any chances. She must win. Equally, India is keenly aware that after Hasina, the deluge beckons. New Delhi cannot be happy with the fact that photographers like Shahidul Alam are picked up by the detective branch without a warrant in the dead of night, or that he has been beaten black and blue in custody. But it knows it must hold its nose and bite its tongue.

The alternative, a BNP government hand-in-glove with the Jamaat, is too awful to behold. Nor should Hasina take Delhi’s support for granted.

Certainly, the soft-spoken Prime Minister, whose political baptism was forged by the assassination of her entire family, save her sister, in 1975, knows her country like few others. She understands the passion of Bangladesh’s students, which is why she is considering the students’ demand for death penalty for reckless driving.

But surely, it is time Hasina removed the blindfold from her eyes. She must start by asking herself why she has become so unpopular, why her cabinet of ‘muktijoddhas’, or freedom fighters, are so out of touch with the new Bangladesh.

The answers are not far to find.

Perhaps, Hasina is emboldened by the fact that her authoritarian behaviour is matched by strong personalities in her neighbourhood, whether it be Prime Minister Narendra Modi or Chinese president Xi Jinping.

But imagine if she were to go for a drive in Dhaka tonight and talk to the student protesters who believe they cannot give up their fight for their beloved country. Correctly, she has told them to go back to their classes.

At the end of the day, the battle for a democratic Bangladesh must be fought in Parliament, not on the streets. That is a learning for all sides.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Some of the points are well taken. I am critical of the way Shahidul Alam was taken, but it was not in the dead of night. Not for expressing his views. But for declaring on the channel Aljazeera, which has it’s own dubious agenda, that the govt was illegitimate.
    The students protest was marvellous and the govt has to agree there. They are claiming that it’s the infiltrators who have received the brunt of the govt s ire. Things are not very clear at the moment. We hope we will know soon.

  2. It is dishonest to suggest that Jamat/BNP have or may have infiltrated the protests. That is physically not possible. What may have happened is, thinking that the children should not be left to face the wrath of AL thugs on their own, they have joined them in support.

  3. Very thoughtful and fair article, that explains the historical lessons learnt and not learnt as well the current political climate that rests on those histories. Thank you for articulating both sides of the story in a well written article.

  4. China intervened in the election process in Nepal recently. It will amost certainly do so now in Bangladesh and Sri Lanka. A leader must win her battles, fair and square, not rely on external support.

Comments are closed.