In his last full budget, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley has focussed on rural distress, tinkered with taxes, but has not offered anything positive to the urban voters. The Budget 2018 appears to be reluctant to take big risks in the run-up to the looming national elections.

ThePrint asks: Has Modi just delivered a safe middle path budget in an election year?


The government has ended up neglecting the interests of the salaried middle class

Radhika Pandey
Consultant, National Institute of Public Finance and Policy

The Modi government’s budget is rural-centric and geared towards MSME, education and agriculture. The government has tried to take a balanced middle path by emphasising on these sectors. The steps proposed seek to address rural distress — like raising the minimum support price (MSP) and improving market infrastructure. While the benefits of the latter will only be determined in the long term, MSP increase could lead to inflation. Moreover, it is hard to compute a singular cost of production since it varies from place to place. It’s a short-term measure fraught with difficulties.

The government has ended up neglecting the interests of the salaried middle class. They are the major source of consumption and demand. They sustain the market. By increasing the cess and providing virtually no rebate in terms of tax, they have offered them no respite. This may lead to an adverse impact on consumption which till now has been sustained. The market may suffer a jolt as disposable incomes of consumers will reduce.

Slippage in the fiscal deficit share may also negatively affect financial markets. The government until now had stuck to its fiscal consolidation roadmap, which reflected in a better Moody’s ranking. That advantage has now slipped. Slippage in fiscal consolidation roadmap could complicate the path for monetary policy.

They have tried to take a balanced path with an eye on the upcoming election. But the short-term intended benefits are doubtful but the pain points are visible.


The Union Budget 2018-19 addresses the pain points of the economy

Kamal Bali
Chairman, CII Karnataka and MD, Volvo Group

The Union Budget 2018-19 addresses the pain points of the economy and will go a long way in facilitating the path of 8 per cent plus growth rate. It carries forward from the ongoing landmark reform measures of GST, resolution of Twin Balance Sheet (TBS) problem, Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT), and so on.

Clearly, the budget aims to mitigate agrarian distress and a directional change is seen in the finance minister’s statement that agriculture is being considered an enterprise. Hence, 22,000 rural markets will be strengthened as Gramin Agricultural Markets with physical infrastructure and digital technologies. Farmer incomes will also be supported by the increase in the minimum support price to 1.5 times of the cost of cultivation.

In yet another innovative move, the budget introduces the National Health Protection Scheme to provide benefits to 500 million people with an annual limit of Rs 5 lakh for hospitalisation. Considering that out-of-pocket expenses cause many households to slip back into poverty, this will impart a huge measure of security to lower-income families.

The education sector sees a new initiative of ‘Revitalising Infrastructure and Systems in Education’ (RISE) which would increase research investments and infrastructure in higher education institutions with a significant outlay of Rs 1,00,000 crore over the next four years.

The budget addresses job creation in a big way by extending government contribution to EPF of 12 per cent of wages for all new employees for the next three years, and also reducing the contribution for women to 8 per cent.  The MSME sector has received relief in corporate income tax rates to 25 per cent (down from 3 per cent) for companies with turnover up to Rs 250 crore, Mudra at Rs 3 lakh crore in 2018-19.

Reintroduction of standard deduction for salaried employees and removal of TDS on interest income (up to Rs 50,000) for senior citizens on FDs , which would go a long way in raising the standard of living of the middle class population.


It is not a populist budget like many had feared

Arvind VirmaniArvind Virmani
President, Forum for Strategic Initiative & Chintan, former Chief Economic Advisor, former executive director of IMF

The fears expressed by many observers that this would be a populist budget directed primarily at the next election have not come true.

The budget builds on earlier initiatives of the government while responding to widespread demands for the Union government to do more on agriculture, education, health and employment generation, much of which are state subjects. In each case it tries to combine policy reform with increases in expenditure, mostly modest, with the exception of the insurance scheme for hospitalisation.

On agriculture, a NITI Aayog committee will try to identify policy constraints on external trade to promote exports while ensuring that ad hoc policy changes don’t hurt agricultural producers. Earlier programmes like e-markets will be complemented with physical markets. On education,  the problem of low quality of basic education is sought to be improved by better teacher training, improved digital connectivity and better e-teaching resources and e-learning.

On health, the existing approach of providing endurance for catastrophic (in terms of poverty) health expenditures is to be expanded dramatically. Employment incentives and policy reforms (fixed-term employment) are also to be reformed and extended in scope to labour intensive export sectors like leather goods and shoes (from textiles).

There is also a modest amount of tax reform, but with very little simplification, perhaps awaiting recommendations of committee on direct tax reform.

My main disappointment is with respect to higher than projected deficits, which many economists had recommended.


Compiled by Deeksha Bhardwaj.

View / Post Comment

1 COMMENT

  1. MODI lost touch with people in last 4 years after he became PM.He depended fully on a clever lawyer cum Minister his friend soul mate and well wisher.Arun Jaitely who is a Virtual PM.
    Modi started dreaming of being a International world leader by his whirlwind tour of world in last 4 years whereas his internal policies made him unpopular to get votes in next LS election. He does not want to see and listen peoples voice VOX-POPULI.He is alienated from people by his hangover of power and adulation.
    He was a MONK YOGI before he was PM but after he became PM he started living in a dream world.
    He thought he has no challenge from any one as there is no alternative of him in India.But ABV alos made same mistake although he done great in his 5 years rule as NDA PM.But he forget to know pulse of people.Indian people are Greedy selfish by nature.They want everything free and vote when paid money liquor gifts.
    But Modi won by a strong negative vote against SONIANDHIs anti Hindu policies and appeasement of Christian and Muslims.She blundered as she is illiterate fool and fascist genes.MODI ought change his style of functioning and directly meet people from all walks of life by a DARBAR in his 7 RCR.HE ha sjust one year to renew his PM post for 5 years and the next 5 years are important for himself and his party.He should remove all bureaucrats as his advisors and appoint people from RSS ABVP BMS and BJP.In a parliamentary democracy your roots must be with voters as bureaucrats don’t understand the mindset of voters.They are slaves of masters/master of slaves. WISH MODI another TERM of 5 years in 2019 but I don’t see that is happening by his arrogant nature.He has alienated himself from his own supporters voters and became a Puppet in the hands of Arun Jaitely

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here