Tuesday, 17 May, 2022
HomePoliticsGovernor Malik jumped the gun in dissolving J&K assembly, it’s advantage Congress-NC

Governor Malik jumped the gun in dissolving J&K assembly, it’s advantage Congress-NC

Text Size:

Mehbooba Mufti’s letter to Satya Pal Malik was meant to prevent BJP-backed Sajad Lone from forming the government. But the governor took the bait.

New Delhi: Jammu & Kashmir Governor Satya Pal Malik and the BJP jumped the gun in dissolving the state assembly Wednesday evening. It was meant to pre-empt a non-BJP coalition from forming the government, but it was a panic reaction, as the prospective alliance partners were yet to arrive at any agreement on even the modalities of their alliance.

Ambika Soni, the Congress’ general secretary in-charge of Jammu & Kashmir, PDP chief Mehbooba Mufti and Omar Abdullah of the National Conference did have telephonic conversations, and they did agree in principle on the formation of a “democratic, secular government” to prevent the BJP from coming to power, allegedly by engineering defections. But it was at a very incipient stage, those involved in the deliberations told ThePrint.

The three leaders had no discussions on whether the Congress and the NC would be part of the government, or would support it from outside. There was no discussion on the chief ministerial candidate either.

All that they had agreed on was to form a committee comprising two or three members from each party to discuss how to take things forward. The Congress had convened a meeting of 40 senior leaders from the state in New Delhi Friday to seek their feedback.

Mufti’s letter to the governor, which didn’t reach him, was meant to be “an expression of intent” to form the government, and to put it on record that 56 non-BJP MLAs — in the 87-member state Assembly — were together, and so the governor could not invite the BJP if it staked claim, leaders in the know said.

“We knew what Sajad Lone (the People’s Conference leader who claimed to have the support of 25 BJP MLAs and 18 others) and the BJP were up to. Our priority was to prevent the governor from inviting him to form the government, and so Mehbooba Mufti sent the letter,” said a Congress leader.

“We don’t know how things would have unfolded if the governor had not dissolved the assembly. But we are happy about what he did. We want early elections now.”

Also read: In Jammu & Kashmir’s rocky political stakes, Congress, NC & PDP outmanoeuvre BJP

Advantage Congress-NC

Malik showed a clear lack of understanding of the state of play when he took Mufti’s bait.

As it is, the Congress and the NC look set to form an alliance and are seen to have an advantage, given the beating the PDP’s image took in the Valley due to its tie-up with the BJP.

It’s difficult to comprehend how these two parties would help the PDP salvage its image to an extent by letting it lead a non-BJP coalition. These issues would have come up for serious discussion when the Congress and the NC would’ve started internal deliberations, and the proposed committee would’ve met to thrash out the modalities of the alliance and the government.

The inherent contradictions in this incipient alliance would have got exposed sooner than they had bargained for. But the governor and the BJP saved them the blushes.

Also read: Jammu & Kashmir needs fresh polls, says BJP slamming PDP-Congress-NC alliance

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Much was made of the fact that a “ political person “ was being appointed Governor of the troubled border state. Quite ignoring the fact that the Governor does not have the agency to get his fax or geyser repaired, summon a cook on a holiday. The contrast with Governor Vohra, who served with distinction for a decade, respected across all shades of political opinion, is slowly becoming apparent.

  2. Ever since Modi government has come into power, it has discovered an “ingenious use” for governors — constitutional post for exercising extra-constitutional powers! Well I cannot really say “extra-constitutional” because I do not know much about our Constitution, but Modi government has definitely been using governors for interfering in the working of “democratically elected governments” in states.

    Take the most obvious case of all: interference in the working of Delhi government; Ram Naik was overly eager about the functioning of the U.P. government during Akhilesh Yadav’s time; then there was Uttarakhand case; then something in North East which I don’t quite remember now. Perhaps a better description would be: “An Extended Arm of the Centre”, in describing the new ingenious use of governors by the Modi government.

    Arbitrariness has become a norm under the present central government. Same holds true in the present, Satya Pal Malik case. FAX machine works/breaksdown “selectively”. A whiff anyway, somehow, reaches the governor that the “enemy” (not of the J&K or India, but of the BJP) is likely to gain an upper hand, so he recommends fresh elections within half hour!! I think only a nuclear response would be faster than this!

    But no one should challenge this decision. It has happened FOR THE GOOD of both J&K and India. BJP will be routed, even in Jammu, as everywhere else in India. The darkest and most horrible period in the history of free J&K and free India will end in 2019. Thank you, Satya Pal Malik.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular