Monday, 27 June, 2022
HomeOpinionPoVModi can’t ignore students anymore. They have discovered the power of the...

Modi can’t ignore students anymore. They have discovered the power of the ‘dislike’ button

Students protesting the JEE exams have discovered the power of the ‘dislike’ button as a tool to get the attention of a govt that doesn’t entertain criticism.

Text Size:

Whichever room Prime Minister Narendra Modi enters, a huge elephant now follows him. Yet, he blatantly refuses to address it.

This was seen during his recent Mann Ki Baat episode. While millions of students all over the country were protesting against the government for failing to postpone the JEE-NEET entrance exams, which began today, Modi chose to talk about the importance of … adopting Indian breed dogs and making Indian games. This, at a time when India is reeling from shocking reports about students resorting to suicide because of the mounting pressure of preparing and appearing for the JEE-NEET exams during the pandemic and through floods.

So, what did Gen Z do in response? What it does best — unleash its fury online. At the time of writing this, the latest Mann Ki Baat on the Bharatiya Janata Party’s YouTube page has more than 8 lakh dislikes, while the same video on the PMO India page and Narendra Modi’s page has 1.30 lakh and 2.20 lakh dislikes respectively. This forced the Prime Minister’s office to disable comments on the video. Yes, our Prime Minister does not want to engage in an uncomfortable dialogue with us. In internet parlance, ‘Narendra Modi has left the chat. But saying ‘imma bounce’ to lakhs of students is no longer an option, especially when they have realised the power of the dislike button.


Also read: My cousin Vikram hanged himself because of JEE pressure. September dates made it worse


Power of the dislike button

Prime Minister Narendra Modi often avoids addressing the country’s most pressing concerns. He did this when China was (still is) sitting on our side of the border — he acknowledged the India-China standoff in Ladakh only after 20 soldiers were killed, and even then categorically denied any intrusion. He didn’t mention the migrant workers crisis even once in his nationwide Covid-19 address on 12 May, when the exodus was at its peak.

Saying the Narendra Modi-led government does not entertain criticism is like saying the sky is blue. This government even made it a priority to incarcerate scholars and activists who have previously disagreed with its policies during the Covid pandemic. And when expressing dissent often invites the ‘anti-national’ tag, silently expressing your stand with a subtle thumbs-down icon, without having to fear rape and death threats from internet trolls, becomes an all-empowering tool.

‘Dislike’ buttons can be like ballot boxes that allow citizens to directly state their agreements and disagreements with the government. It will make political discourse more participatory, reducing the fear of lone voices getting lost in the noise of comment sections, giving users a way of engaging with their leaders in a more direct way.


Also read: Modi is teaching NEET-JEE aspirants what happens when a government becomes too strong


Perhaps, this is why there was a clamour to introduce a dislike button on Twitter as well. And why not? Why must we engage in tiresome arguments online every time we disagree with the government’s decision? Not only will a dislike button on a political platform such as Twitter serve as a quick way of expressing disagreement, it is also a strong way for the leader of the day to gauge public opinion as well. Unless they just don’t want to hear anyone other than their average ‘yesmen’.

The dislike button saves you from whataboutery and routine verbal abuse.

The recent bombardment of dislikes on BJP’s YouTube videos also clearly rattled outspoken BJP spokespersons, such as Sambit Patra, who faced the ire of students when a video of his press conference also received 90,000 dislikes late Monday night. For once, BJP leaders can’t blame something on Nehru.

But despite the visible outrage by students regarding the government’s decision to go ahead with the NEET-JEE exams, the government remains as impervious to feedback as ever. The BJP has now cried foul, saying there was a Congress conspiracy in the recent dislike saga, claiming only 2 per cent dislikes came for India.


Also read: With NEET-JEE, the Opposition has a shot at snatching Modi’s favourite voter — the youth


Hit them where it hurts

One might think it’s futile to resort to harmless ‘dislikes’, especially when months of protests and pleas didn’t deter the government. The relentless protests at Shaheen Bagh, and the rest of the country, didn’t make it withdraw or reconsider the Citizenship (Amendment) Act. The widespread outrage over the Una lynchings didn’t get much attention from the BJP, and cow vigilantism still goes largely unchecked. Protests over Rohith Vermula’s suicide didn’t make BJP leaders demand justice the way actor Sushant Singh Rajput’s death has made them; they were busy seeing Congress ploy in the incident.

But one has to remember that the BJP is bracing for elections in Bihar, which will be fought with online campaigns — the party’s home turf. So, any online backlash against the party will only hit them where it hurts the most.

These dislikes will spoil BJP’s game of algorithmic politics, in which political parties can learn about the internet history of users, and feed them content that will directly play into their fears or biases. As Home Minister Amit Shah had once brazenly stated, WhatsApp proved to be the mantra through which BJP won the elections, as the party could make any message “real or fake” go viral.

But with organic dislikes, this game gets spoiled because then, viral content spirals out of the control of IT cell masters, and gives the government and parties actual feedback.

Right before a key state election, students have not only voiced their frustration with the government, they also have the potential to impact an election.They have made it clear that Modi doesn’t care about students in a pandemic-hit year, even after they have been begging him to listen. Does he then deserve their vote or the dislike button?

Views are personal. 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism

16 COMMENTS

  1. Awestruck by the foolishness of the general population of our country.
    Economy worse than ever, over 14 crores jobs lost, farmers and students protesting, most news channels like Republic tv have sold themselves out for money to BJP and running diversionary news on Rhea and kangana. When they are not showing these news they are polarising communities.
    Scams left and right and at the end these foolish people can’t comprehend that modi is destruction of this country.

  2. Whatever little credibility is left, The Print should focus on fact based news, not such ill-intended , anti-India, provocative “Opinion pieces”. Shekhar Gupta, for once, do something that we could be proud of you.

  3. It can be that under educated anti CAA PROTESTORS who dislike education gave this dislikes. Sheer FAKE journalism

  4. i absolutely disagree with ur concept of supporting iit aspirants..NEET PG for medical students was conducted ..THEY JOINED they have started doing their duties…SO NEET SUPERSPECIITY..WILL GIVE EXAMS…why not IIT…r they only one deserving privilage..or they provide good brand value..and medical.fraternity just get news for being labelled malacious..

    U r absolutely wrong about GALWAN.indians removed the camp of chinese army from.no man areas land and thwarted their attempt to intrude ours…do criticism means indirectly supporting our enemies…how come such eminent think houses turn their back on sacrifices of our soldiers…are they jealous of these feat being achieved under modiji leadership…

    ..it was congress who made our country weak…and created kasmir dispute..I SUGGESST U TO DO REAL.JOURNSLISM…
    AS TODAY ..DEFAMING PUBLIC CHOSEN.PM IS TERMED REAL JOURNALISM…

  5. Dear columnist,I want to ask a question to you .How much money the congress led opposition parties are paying you as a result of which your news portal is relentlessly spreading antimodi propaganda.I have another question also.If the JEE and NEET entrance are not conducted then based on which parameter the admission into professional courses will happen.Do you want students of lesser intellect to get admission in premier professional institutes?

  6. 85 lakh people disliked a particular video and we know 85 lakh appeared for JEE right? Moments and factless opinions of liberals like these are the cotton candy world they live in !

  7. Postpone how long ? Just politics does not solve the pandemic . The hype created by media is not worth buying. One side economic crisis and other side close everything why? No answers only dislike. Because they don’t have solutions and they have only comments.

  8. Be happy with it…best of luck. Opposition can focus on counting like and dislikes while BJP focus on counting votes.

  9. Ha ha, Your wish to demonize Modi will bear no fruit.
    Youth will be always with Modi.
    Congress funded, dislike campaign will fail.

  10. may be bjp has a point. the opponents can always use the dislike handle to create an opinion and this can cut both the ways. how do we distinguish?

    • This tactic is already used by bjp trolls. There is widespread resentment among students which we as citizens should support as the government considers itself immune to criticism.

    • Probably by comparing the geometric mean of like to dislike ratio of previous videos with current video. It actually works if one wants to differentiate between troll dislikes and genuine dislikes. Although it is not full proof still it might help you. There are some other statistical methods to do it. I recommend you to learn some and devise one for your own. Hope it helps.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular

×