scorecardresearch
Tuesday, March 19, 2024
Support Our Journalism
HomeOpinionPoVDear Muslims, Tablighi Jamaat committed a crime against humanity. Don’t defend them

Dear Muslims, Tablighi Jamaat committed a crime against humanity. Don’t defend them

I am not encouraging Islamophobia, it is a prejudice that needs fierce opposition but if this isn’t plain stupidity in the name of Allah, then what is?

Follow Us :
Text Size:

Religion has often caused harm to the world and humanity as a whole, whether in the form of environmental damage by filing the Yamuna and Ganga with ‘religious waste’ or turning the densely populated and congested Nizamuddin Basti into a Covid-19 hot spot for the sake of an Islamic gathering.

Tablighi Jamaat, an Islamic reformist group, had a large gathering of more than 3,000 people on 13 March in Nizamuddin with foreign nationals from Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, Kyrgyzstan, and Malaysia, a hot spot for the deadly virus. Infact, the Jamaat has also been held responsible for having spread the virus to half a dozen nations in its February gathering in Malaysia.

Now, people across India who had participated in the Islamic congregation are testing positive for Covid-19 — from as far as Andaman and Nicobar Islands — and 10 have already died, including the Jamaat’s Kashmir head. All of this happened because of an annual Islamic gathering.

I am not encouraging Islamophobia, it will always be a prejudice that needs vehement opposition. But if this isn’t plain stupidity in the name of Allah, then what is?

Whether India had implemented strict travel restrictions by 13 March or not isn’t the question here, the point is why gather in such huge numbers, with ‘red’ travel history for the sake of preaching religion? People from the gathering continued living in the area even after 13 March. Their orthodox movement has exposed all of us to a greater risk of contamination, from Assam to Telangana to the Andamans. And we can’t justify it by saying that other religions had also kept their doors open for a long time. All doors should have been shut.


Also Read: Tablighi Jamaat congregation and how religion has been the ‘super spreader’ of coronavirus


Ignorance in Islam’s name

Unfortunately, even amid this global crisis, some people are trying to veil the Jamaat’s irresponsibility by bringing up a 13 March PTI report about government officials having still not declared coronavirus a public health emergency and hence the Sunni Muslim group didn’t violate any norms.

Here is a fact-check; Delhi government on 13 March prohibited any gathering of more than 200 people under the Epidemic Diseases Act. Moreover, they also directed people coming from any Covid-19 affected country to self-isolate. Members of the Tablighi Jamaat in Nizamuddin violated both these directions.

Some have also argued that the Janata curfew was imposed a week later on 22 March and not during the Jamaat’s celebrations, which is also completely ridiculous. The question here is of moral and social responsibility along with the Delhi government’s order, which prohibited religious gatherings of over 50 people from 16 March. Covid-19 had already created chaos in the world by 13 March and the Jamaat made its contribution to it, not once, but twice.

Some others are now comparing this gathering with the exodus of migrant workers in the national capital. What these people fail to understand is that those workers had to walk home together because there was no other option. No one chooses to walk hundreds of kilometres with their children and no food if they have another option. But what Tablighi Jamaat did was sheer negligence and idiocy.

This outdated and orthodox movement has committed a crime that has put several others at the risk of coronavirus infection. No one knows the whereabouts of those 3000 people and who they have contacted in the last 16 days. Sadly, all of this was done in the name of Islam.


Also Read: More than 2,100 foreigners linked to Tablighi Jamaat entered India since 1 January


Liberals are missing

Surprisingly, India’s ‘liberals’ including actors, journalists and authors are quiet on this. They have only tried to whitewash the Jamaat’s doing by pointing out the loopholes of the government and the administration. This entire fiasco, caused solely for the purpose of preaching Islam, does not seem to be a matter of concern for them. Ironically, if such irresponsibility was shown by some other religious group in the country, the same liberals would have ridiculed it, like they did for Yogi Adityanath’s Ayodhya celebrations.

We need to understand that speaking against a wrong committed by an orthodox religious group from a particular religious community doesn’t mean you’re stereotyping them. Of course, Muslims in India have always been discriminated and faced Islamophobia. However, this does not mean that you should not speak up against crimes committed by a group of orthodox people.

Not speaking up against this gross violation of human safety exposes your hollowness and your lack of balance. More so, it throws light on why there will never truly be an Indian liberal.


Also Read: What is Tablighi Jamaat? Organiser of Delhi event behind spike in India’s Covid-19 count


Speak against Jamaat, not ISIS

When ISIS attacked a Gurdwara in Kabul last week, there were some who said they were ashamed of the crimes of this terrorist organisation in the name of Islam. There were others who not only tried defending Islam in the wake of the Islamic state’s activities but also tried their best to establish the difference between ISIS and Islam.

The fact is ISIS is a global terrorist outfit that kills people, and rapes women. It has much less to do with Islam than it has to do with power. But Tablighi Jamaat should force us to think of our religious practices in every day life.

This congregation is probably the worst thing that these 3,000 Muslims could have ever inflicted on humanity in the name of preaching Islam. Ultimately, the brokers of Islam have added to this coronavirus mess.

Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

259 COMMENTS

  1. @MainaBismee: still waiting for an update on the above outlandish report… for eg :

    ‘Scapegoat’: Court’s biting remarks on FIRs against Tablighi Jamaat members : hindustantimes.com
    Lucknow CJM court quashes cases against 11 Indian, 8 Indonesia Jamaatis : hindustantimes.com
    COVID-19 double standards: Muslims without mosque, Hindu with Kumbh Mela bathing : asianews.it
    Tablighi vs Kumbh: The Politics of Selective COVID-19 Policing : thequint.com
    The Indian government’s silence over Kumbh Mela crowds during Covid-19 exposes its bias :qz.com

    Eagerly waiting for you latest article, headlined, in the interest of fairness :

    “Dear Hindus, Kubh mela 31 Lakh devotees committed a crime against humanity. Don’t defend them”

    Won’t hold my breath, with O2 be in short supply.

  2. Dear Bismee,

    Would love your take on Kubu mela,
    The amount of religious people gathered there were 2000.
    Today at Kubh mela 31 Lakh people are gathered.

    Looking forward to your unbaised view on this.

  3. Since the Supreme court asked news agency to apologise for presenting people of Jamat as Monsters and the prime reason for Covid spread.
    I think the author and the new agency responsible for this article should also tend apologies, irrespective of what you say, this article is Islamophobic.

  4. Its better to investigate into the things before judging, gathering was conducted before corona virus was declared as serious issue. And after knowing Governments new rules,Tabligi people approached the local police explaining the situation and asked for help to vacating the place.none listened to them,as they need a space goat,at the end truth came out.Tabligi’s were made spacegoats.

  5. You are spreading Islamophobia, the fact that you are judging these people because of their religion is alone immoral, and even it you insist that it isn’t Islamophobia, it is still hate and bashing against Tablighi Jamaat as a religious minority.
    I am an Arab from Algeria, a country far far away from India, and some Hindus (not all of them are hateful) do insult me everyday in the internet and they know i have even no idea of what is going on in India.
    Therefore, i stand with Indian Muslims, shame on you India, you were a country that was loved and respected in the Arab world. now, no more, nobody respects a bully, no body respects those who use hate for political agendas.
    As for Muslims in India, we pray for you brothers, and ask Allah to give you strength and patience Ameen.

    • It is clear now that they have been wrongly accused of a crime they did not commit and it is reassuring that justice remains impartial in India
      the Bombay High Court ruled there was “virtually persecution” of the “scapegoat” foreign devotees.
      NOW THE QUESTIONS IS WHERE IS THE ARTICLE TO APOLOGISE AND CONFIRM THAT THE TABLEEGH GROUPS WHERE INNOCENTS OF WHAT THEY HAVE BEEN ACCUSED???

  6. Imagine if 1.8 billion people start killing, you’d be dead by now, almost every friend I have is a Hindu, they’re still alive and well, this proves your argument is bullshit .

  7. “Tirupati temple “tirumala temple naam to suna hi hoga aaagye suwaad” bhoomi pujan k bad head priest ko hogya use kisne bola tha tableegh me janeko

  8. How stupid is the author of this article is… ? Just 5 km away from the markaz building both the parliaments were running in full swing until the evening of 23 march 2020. Is it that C virus doesn’t bear entry pass to enter parliament building makes the entire premises safe?
    Secondly, suppose even if thousands of infected people are isolated within a closed premises then how could they become the cause of spread? Is it not safe to remain at one place instead of scattering around and spreading the infection?
    Were the officials in adjacent police station sleeping despite several representations from T. Jamaat for getting permit to come out for proper treatment and shifting to their home places in govt’s supervision?
    With egard to the foreign delegates it was totally govt’s responsibility who issued visas, allowed to enter without proper check and quarantine. Where would they go after lockdown?
    Just a single incident of Ahmedabad crowd gathering on 24 Feb 2020 of 1 lakh plus people to inaugurate Motera stadium at the hands of an American, the most infected nation in the world who had already called state of emergency due to pandemic a month earlier.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular