Friday, 2 December, 2022
HomeOpinionPolitically CorrectCommunist Party of China has a solution for India’s opposition that Modi-Shah...

Communist Party of China has a solution for India’s opposition that Modi-Shah won’t mind

Indian polity is witnessing a melting away of opposition parties with some putting up a fight on Twitter. But China’s CPC may have a permanent solution.

Text Size:

The Communist Party of China (CPC) is curious about the rise of the Bharatiya Janata Party in India. Chinese leaders were “shocked” to know how the BJP trumped the CPC to become the largest party in the world. The BJP’s organisational heft in elections amazes them.

What they may not know is how BJP-led India, the world’s largest democracy, has a real chance of achieving through elections what they enforced through coercion and repression in China — the “multi-party cooperation”, a misnomer for one-party rule.

In the Chinese political system, the CPC is the sole ruling authority but eight “non-Communist” parties “cooperate” by participating in state affairs and giving policy inputs whenever and wherever required. These parties together have 11 lakh members; the CPC has nearly nine crore. It prevents “power rotation” and “nasty competition” among parties, Chinese president Xi Jinping said last year. He is trying to re-brand it as a “new type of party system” — different from the Western model but more in sync with the Chinese adage “only your feet know whether your shoes fit well”.

Also read: Amit Shah raises questions about India’s multi-party democracy

Party politics, made in China

As China seeks to justify its authoritarian political system, India is witnessing a debate on its own. An 11-member BJP delegation was in China for a week in August-September on the CPC’s invitation. A couple of weeks after they returned, BJP president Amit Shah raised questions about the political system India has adopted. “After 70 years of Independence, a question was arising in everybody’s mind whether our multi-party parliamentary democratic system has failed, whether the… system would be able to achieve our goals, would make a Bharat that our Constitution-makers had envisaged,” he said on 17 September.

This debate has started when the Indian polity is witnessing a voluntary multi-party cooperation and the melting away of the opposition parties even though they are putting up a valiant fight on Twitter. Prime Minister Narendra Modi tells Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina “not to worry” about the National Register of Citizens (NRC) even as Home Minister Amit Shah vows to drive out “termites” (his nomenclature for Bangladeshi infiltrators).

So, if Modi has no plans to send them back to Bangladesh, is he planning to keep them in detention centres/refugee camps? There are no opposition leaders to ask this — not beyond sundry press conferences. A powerful BJP functionary told this writer the other day in Kolkata, “Don’t you bother about what happens to them. We have to first identify them.” Pressed further, he added in exasperation, “They will be disenfranchised first, then made ineligible for all government schemes, civic amenities…. Let them work as manual labourers.” That’s the BJP’s plan for ‘infiltrators’, whose numbers it estimates to be at least two crore.

Also read: Is Lalu son a BJP ally? Tejashwi Yadav’s tirade against Nitish raises question in RJD

Indian opposition’s voluntary cooperation

Barring some noises from West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and a few pressers and TV bytes by others, there is no opposition worth the name to communal NRC politics. How many opposition leaders did you hear protesting when the Enforcement Directorate decided to register a case against veteran politician Sharad Pawar, timed on the eve of Maharashtra assembly elections? Did you hear any noise from any non-Congress leader — or from even most Congress leaders — when central investigation agencies went after P. Chidambaram or D.K. Shivakumar? These politicians may not be paragons of virtue and innocence but similar moves by central agencies in the past used to draw huge opposition outrage in solidarity.

So where are the opposition leaders? Well, most of them have chosen to “cooperate” with the BJP, not going beyond token protests or criticism and siding with it when needed. See how quickly Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Jagan Mohan Reddy has forgotten about his once vociferous demand for special status for his state.

Many political pundits would stammer and fumble if they were to face rapid-fire questions today: Is Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) a part of the BJP-led NDA? Naveen Patnaik’s Biju Janata Dal (BJD) is an ally of the BJP, isn’t it? Do Mayawati of Bahujan Samaj Party and Akhilesh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party provide outside support to the NDA at the Centre, the way they once did for the Congress-led UPA? Has the son of jailed RJD leader Lalu Prasad, the former Bihar deputy CM Tejashwi Yadav, given his word to the BJP that he would be a good boy?

Also read: Democracy devouring itself, people too stupid to sustain it — academic paper creates furore

Congress resigned to fate

The Congress may still be holding out against the BJP, but the principal opposition party is fast becoming a social media entity, with party activities mostly confined to cyberspace. The implosions in the Congress seem inexorable. Speak to any of its leader in poll-bound Maharashtra or Haryana and you will be flummoxed by their confidence level: “We will do better than what Rahul Gandhi did in Lok Sabha elections. BJP leaders think we won’t get the post of the leader of the opposition (which requires winning at least 10 per cent of the total seats in the assembly). We will prove them wrong.”

The Congress today looks resigned to fate and at the mercy of the BJP — in case it has any role in the multi-party cooperation model. There are a few opposition leaders such as TMC chief Mamata Banerjee and DMK president M.K. Stalin in distant corners who are putting up resistance but they are insignificant in the BJP’s larger scheme of things.

Opposition parties in India are clueless today. Modi has changed the game completely. They were used to playing snakes and ladders. Put in a rugby game by Modi-Shah, they are mortally scared. They would prefer to sit it out. It may be a risky strategy though. Voters may not be excited about the snakes and ladders game again.

No wonder, many opposition parties are now looking at the Chinese multi-party cooperation model to recoup and survive. Sceptical about the multi-party parliamentary democratic system, Amit Shah may not mind it— for 50 years of the BJP rule, so to say.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Democracy fails when opposition parties become “neech” and work to make the people and nation suffer instead of giving constructive ideas or debates so that the incumbent can be criticized and made to lose elections.

  2. Lol BJP is fulfilling what the people voted then for according to their manifesto ie abrogation of article 370, Nation wide NRC and next to come is the great holy place of Ram Mandir and Uniform Civil Code and atlast making India more free market economy and no to minimum Socialism

  3. Nah, the Maoist in India are the only cuckoos in the world following a dead man no one cares a hoot about now.

  4. Author seems to be under influence of a strong dope or the teachings he has learnt from a road side madarssas he/she has studied in. Amit Shah and Narender Modi are governing the country because of the strong mandate they received from citizens of India based on their manifesto which clearly talks about abrogation of Article 370 and implementation of NRC. It’s called Democracy.

    Over the past, a non-muslim and non-christain of this country has realised how tolerant he/she had been to a level that they were taken so much for granted that they had developed an apologetic behaviour towards their faith and relegion. But a society of this country is now awake and not ready to take any bullshit.

    So, I would like to request the author here to pls SHUT UP. Your propaganda won’t work anymore..

    • Modi has vot mandated to govern the country according the Constitution made by sardar patel and Ambedkar.They are not their to change the Constitution. You ever think Modi Shah are more good and wise then Patel and ambedkar seriously.
      Bhai it is constitution and multi party democracy that give opportunity to modi became PM. Tell me when any obc or dalit become priest or king in india before constitution. It must be solemn duty of every citizen to uphold constitution and in the way patel and ambedkar.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular