Thursday, January 26, 2023
HomeOpinionHow’s the josh? For defence sector, the real question is where’s the...

How’s the josh? For defence sector, the real question is where’s the money: Shashi Tharoor

For a Budget that began with thanking the people for validating BJP’s message on national security, defence allocation offers little cheer.

Text Size:

Last week, the new Finance Minister, Nirmala Sitharaman, announced the first Union Budget for the new term of the BJP-led central government that took office following a landslide re-election victory in the recently concluded Lok Sabha elections. Their national campaign was strongly anchored in national security, particularly in the aftermath of the Pulwama attack and India’s retaliatory strikes in Balakot, which Narendra Modi successfully packaged and sold (particularly in the Hindi heartland) during the elections as proof of his and his party’s credentials as the most muscular protectors of India’s national interest.

But for all the government’s sloganeering during the elections, frequent invocations of dialogues from war movies and wanton appropriation of the armed forces for electoral ends – with complete disregard for their sacrosanct neutrality and their status above the political fray – the message that was projected in the Budget underwhelms. After all, for a Budget that began with thanking the people of the country for validating the BJP’s message on national security (but offered no serious mention of the needs of the men and women in uniform), the actual allocations offer little cheer to the defence sector. If anything, the numbers raise worrying questions about the support the government intends to offer to our armed forces towards ensuring they meet the challenging and complex requirements of India’s national security.

Also read: Nirmala Sitharaman’s budget wipes $30 billion off Indian stocks as doubts on tax linger

In her address, Nirmala Sitharaman announced an overall allocation of Rs 4.31 lakh crore for the defence sector, a figure that was 0.01 per cent higher than what was announced in the Interim Budget presented in February.

Of this, it is true that allocations for ‘defence expenditure’ (what is left after accounting for salaries, pensions and miscellaneous civil expenditure – which accounts for about 60 per cent of the expenditure, including pending arrears of over Rs 10,795 crore in OROP payments) have crossed the Rs 3 lakh crore-mark. This news was announced amid great fanfare and thumping of desks among the BJP benches in Parliament.

What the figure belies, however, is that the current allocation for ‘defence expenditure’ represents merely a 6.87 per cent increase from last year’s allocation of Rs 2.98 lakh crore, and only 1.45 per cent of the country’s GDP, the lowest since the 1962 war.

Even with the current allocation (once adjusted for inflation), many defence experts have pointed out that the increase is insufficient to meet the urgent modernisation requirements of the armed forces.

As a report from the Institute for Defence Studies and Analysis highlights, the fiscal strain on the armed forces is currently so high that they have not even managed to fully pay for existing modernisation commitments. It has been projected that in the recently concluded fiscal year 2018-19, against a pending requirement of Rs 1.10 lakh crore for ‘Committed Liabilities’, the total shortfall was an alarming Rs 67,363 crore, or roughly 48 per cent of the overall liability. Further, for the same period, based on the allocations, the three wings of the armed forces (excluding other departments like the DRDO) jointly projected a shortfall of Rs 1.12 lakh crore, which works out to roughly 30 per cent of their total requirement. The Budget, in other words, denies the armed forces a third of what they need.

Also read: Narendra Modi govt can’t increase defence budget. Best it can do is go for reforms

It is all very well for the finance minister to begin her speech by talking about the importance of national security and the defence minister to repeatedly point out that financial constraints will not affect capacity building, but the paltry allocation and the lack of mention in the Budget address really question the intentions of this government. They can gain applause by asking “where’s the josh?” But the time has come to respond with “where’s the money?”

The implications of a shortfall in defence allocation for our national security are many, and worrying.

Earlier, in January this year, the government was rapped on the knuckles by the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Defence, which pointed out that the funds for modernisation of the Army were inadequate to make payments of nearly Rs 30,000 crore, earmarked for 125 ongoing schemes, emergency procurement of weapons for a 10-day intense war, and ordnance requirements. Pushed to a corner, the ministry, in its response to the committee, admitted: “This Ministry is bound by the budgetary ceilings conveyed by the Ministry of Finance. The reduced allocations were passed on uniformly to all the services”. So, defence is favoured when it comes to rhetoric, and treated as badly as other ministries when cost-cutting is done.

Even as recently as the week prior to the Budget, the Navy strongly urged Nirmala Sitharaman, who served as the defence minister in the previous innings of the government, to factor in the force’s upcoming ambitious expansion and modernisation plans while deciding allocation. But given the numbers in the Budget, it appears the clamour has fallen on deaf ears. The sad thing is that even in our own backwaters – the Indian Ocean, the Arabian Sea, the Gulf – a dozen other navies have a more significant and regular presence than the Indian Navy. We just don’t have the ships.

We expect our armed forces to offer ‘punitive’ deterrence against Pakistan and ‘credible’ deterrence against China, but what is the government doing to aid and assist our forces in maintaining the requirements of national security that we thrust on them? Can it reasonably expect them to do so using Soviet-era planes (and merely 30 squadrons), a fleet of ships and submarines that are far outmatched by the Chinese, and an Army facing serious shortages and saddled with “vintage” weapons systems (68 per cent are indeed vintage, according to the Army’s own testimony to Parliament).

Also read: Narendra Modi govt wants a strong military, but its defence budget can’t guarantee that

The answer is fairly self-evident. In an aspiring regional powerhouse, it would appear that the shrill fever-pitch rhetoric of the Modi sarkar outstrips its tangible support to our armed forces. Words are what our current leaders are good at; but they simply do not walk the talk. If ever our armed forces were called upon to back up the inflated boasts of our regime with effective military action, they would do so with a hand tied behind their back.

‘How’s the josh?’. For the defence sector, it is a joke, Sir.

The author is a Member of Parliament for Thiruvananthapuram and former MoS for External Affairs and HRD. He served the UN as an administrator and peacekeeper for three decades. He studied History at St. Stephen’s College, Delhi University and International Relations at Tufts University. Tharoor has authored 18 books, both fiction and non-fiction; his most recent book is The Paradoxical Prime Minister. Follow him on Twitter @ShashiTharoor. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. BJP is always full of hot air.. A lot of talk, a lot of Joomlas with little to show on the delivery side… It is true to with fake GDP growth rate numbers and it is true of Defense… Unfortunately as you can see from many of the comments there are a lot of BJP supporters who will keep supporting BJP no matter what they do or how much they lie… Unless these blind bhakts find it in themselves to stand up for India’s interests and their own interests instead of standing for Modi and BJP’s interests… There is little hope

  2. Mr Tharoor, I hope you read these comments. All that one can get from this article is good use of a foreign language.. English.. your command over it is appreciated. But your self claimed knowledge on defence sector and its teething issues are equally poor. Please also write an article topics below:
    1. If the VVIP Chopper deal with AW never went through, where did that moolah go?
    2. Why did Mr AK Antony in 2014, in the ending times of his tenure, had on national television said that his ministry, i.e defence, in 2014 had no funds for any purchases of the defence?
    3. How many deals were signed by UPA govt of 2004 – 2014 towards modernisation of the defence forces?
    Please do find time and gather knowledge, which you otherwise have shown time and again a lacking of, on these subjects and let the whole world know in your fantastic English about the misdemeanours of your government of 10 years.

  3. Vetran of 42 yrs i have realised that indian govt wants chowkidars only wanting to take on modern enemies with least matching modern systems . Citizens of india should know that FREEDOM does not come cheap .
    Having got it how to maint it is the Q ? So like Lo L shout loud.

  4. Raul Khan has declared Rs 72000 for farmers,since that programme is not going to be implemented.sasi we will use that money for defence. you don’t worry too much about India.Nationslist are ruling,better you cooperate with CBI and tell the truth of what happened to sunanda.

  5. Yes it is true that more allocations are needed but always trying to criticize the govt. with sarcastic words is not the need of the hour. Give positive suggestions about how much should be done and how to go about it.
    Sitting in the opposition does not mean opposing everything sarcastically.

  6. You can not please all the people all the time.If defence budget had been raised very high, same Tharoor will blame govt. ,for war mongering.

  7. The entire nation knows it that the Indian Defence sector was poorly looked after by the previous governments for over 50+ years and they now sitting in opposition are making noise of it. They looted the public money thru various Scams and not consent rated on strength ring the Indian Armed Forces.

  8. Nehru and Gandhi loved socialism so much that it was forced on the entire country. Subsequent governments made merry with socialism screwing the country lock stock and barrel. The result is a shabby defence sector with inadequate budget and heavy spending on freebies subsidies loan waivers puke worthy socialist welfare schemes. Socialist Modi is just following his predecessors.

Comments are closed.