Friday, March 31, 2023
HomeOpinionBJP is in power because only one Congress can rule India at...

BJP is in power because only one Congress can rule India at a time

In its existing form, the Congress doesn’t offer people any hope.

Text Size:

The Congress is going through its worst electoral phase. But the problem is not poor representation in Parliament – after all, the Bharatiya Janata Party had only two members in 1984 Lok Sabha.

The Congress’ biggest worry is that it does not have an ideological base, which also translates into not having a vote-bank. On most policy matters, the Congress doesn’t seem too different from the BJP, which explains why the 135-year-old behemoth has slipped into irrelevance: a political system can’t have two parties of the same kind in the ruling position.

A closer look reveals that except a flimsy difference in their ‘pseudo-secularism’, there is not much that separates the Congress from the BJP. Both have the same social base, same economic outlook; both parties lack internal democracy. Perhaps, the only difference is that while the BJP has firmly established its hardcore Hindutva policy for all to see, the Congress’s top leadership has to repeatedly remind people that its leader is a Brahmin.

Given the similarities, why is it that the BJP is in power and the Congress isn’t? That’s because the Congress lost its core support base, while the BJP consolidated its vote-bank.

Also read: A ‘Congress Singh’ takes charge of BJP’s UP unit as party hopes to win OBC votes

Gradual decline of Congress

The Congress, since its formation, has been a party of the elites. Before Mahatma Gandhi’s entry into politics, it was a party of land owners (zamindars) who demanded ‘home rule’ under the British Raj. After Independence, when the country adopted a democratic system of governance, the Congress finally connected with the Dalits, minorities, and the tribals and ruled for subsequent decades.

But things started changing in the 1960s. After India’s humiliating defeat in the 1962 war, there was a growing disenchantment with Jawaharlal Nehru.

Over the next few decades, the increasing prosperity of the elites, the deteriorating condition of the poor and the rise in corruption and inflation made people turn away from the Congress. Various developments like Bihar’s JP movement, Gujarat’s Navnirman Andolan led by students, and the Emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi broke the Congress’ charm.

By the 1980s, the aggressive entry of parties like the BSP and the Janata Dal made the feudalistic,Manuwadi Indian society uncomfortable. The BJP took advantage of this social churning. Its Rath Yatra in 1990 from Gujarat to Uttar Pradesh, coming right after the V.P. Singh government tabled the Mandal Commission’s report, which gave reservation to the socially backward, heralded the BJP’s entry into India’s political scene as a major player.

Also read: When Chandra Shekhar’s Young Turks beat Congress old guard with Indira Gandhi’s support

Rise of regional powerhouses

This period also witnessed the rise of Dalit-backward politics. If it was Mulayam Singh Yadav, Kanshiram and later Mayawati in Uttar Pradesh; it was Lalu Prasad Yadav in Bihar. The Congress began to lose support in the Hindi-speaking states.

In Jharkhand, the Congress lost the support of tribals. The minorities remained with the party for a while but soon began to support political groups in their regions that seemed more likely to defeat the BJP.

Upper castes by then had anyway started gravitating towards the BJP when they sensed that the Congress would not be able to respond to the aggressive politics of the parties representing Dalits and the backward groups.

Way out for Congress

But the bigger problem for the Congress today is not that it can’t win elections. The party is facing an existential crisis because it can’t take a high moral ground on issues that can help it launch mass movements and win supporters.

When the Congress launches a movement against corruption, it forgets that students’ agitation in Bihar was against the corrupt Congress government. When the Congress talks about Narendra Modi government’s dictatorship, people are reminded of Emergency. When it mentions democracy, they look at the absence of democracy within the Congress. If it says that the BJP is being managed by the RSS, then the same holds true for the Congress as well, which is managed by one family.

Also read: Congress today doesn’t need a leader or an election win, it needs an ideology

In its existing form, the Congress doesn’t offer people any hope, because it doesn’t provide an alternative to the politics of the BJP.

If the Congress wants to revive itself, this is how it can do it – offer an alternative economic policy; practice real secularism instead of pseudo-secularism; stay true to Constitutional beliefs of equality and freedom; and run the party democratically.

The author has been associated with the JP movement, and has penned a novel ‘Samar Shesh’. Views are personal.

This article has been translated from Hindi. Read the original here.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Congress party ayega.mujhe freebies subsidies reservation loan waiver dega. Mein khet mein jhak maroonga MNREGA ke naam pe.

  2. 1. We know that during many years of the Congress party’s rule, political class joined hands with corrupt bureaucracy and businessmen and made huge money at cost of exchequer, most of which was unaccounted and misused to fund and win elections. 2. Who can save the Congress party at this juncture? Neither Ms Sonia Gandhi nor son Rahul Gandhi, though many may have unbreakable faith in members of Nehru-Indira Gandhi family. Then the next question is this: who can rebuild the Congress party which is in pathetic situation today? If someone wishes to revive Congress party and rebuild it, he must find out why it has been reduced to status of a regional party. Obviously, he/she cannot afford to rely what Smt Indira Gandhi did years ago when she was out of power in 1977. 3. Citizen-voters like me who believe that the Congress party has a future as a centrist (to be precise, left of the centre) political party, wish that senior Congress leaders should make viable plans to reorganize the party. 4. I feel that as and when new Congress Working Committee (CWC) is formed, Smt Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi and Ms Priyanka Gandhi-Vadra should ideally be not part of CWC. This would be better future of the Congress party and also for ensuring internal democracy in the party. 5. My unsolicited suggestion is that the Congress would do well if it gets done a SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats) analysis of the organization and take remedial steps to move out their party from the current pathetic situation.

  3. Congress was never there in Tamil Nadu after DMK uprising, same was the case in West Bengal and Kerala after Commies captured power. Nehru fooled India with more than 90% illiteracy for first 15 years until China’s taking over of Indian territory. Nehru did not survive for more than 3 years then and then the family politics started after short tenure of outside family being in control of congress. As the politics of family is deep routed in congress, then came Nehru;s daughter, grand sons, grand daughter-in-law and great grand son. Nehru had his own way of controling the party and his daughter had created slogan of garibi hatao, which even today is only on paper. Enough money has been swindled and then came chaiwala to tell everyone about 60+ years of misrule, with new promises. End of the corruption was so deep routed, it will take time for India to improve. Given the way it is, Congress will be more like regional party one here one there.

  4. As more are being from Congress are being allowed, BJP is no longer party with difference, it now looks like a different party not the same under Vajpayee and many others who sacrificed their younger days without taste of power but never sacrificed its core principle. It is unimaginable that they would ever allowed Tom dick Harry. BJP is now no longer B team of Congress it is almost turned as Congress, they also have Maneka and Varun Gandhi.

Comments are closed.