New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Thursday dismissed pleas by social media platforms, Facebook and WhatsApp, challenging India’s competition regulator CCI’s order directing a probe into WhatsApp’s new privacy policy.
Justice Navin Chawla said though it would have been “prudent” for the Competition Commission of India (CCI) to await the outcome of petitions in the Supreme Court and the Delhi HC against WhatsApp’s new privacy policy, but not doing so would not make the regulator’s order “perverse” or “wanting of jurisdiction”.
The court said it saw no merit in the petitions of Facebook and WhatsApp to interdict the investigation directed by the CCI.
The CCI had contended that it was not examining the alleged violation of individuals’ privacy which was being looked into by the Supreme Court.
It had argued before the court that the new privacy policy of WhatsApp would lead to excessive data collection and “stalking” of consumers for targeted advertising to bring in more users and is therefore an alleged abuse of dominant position.
“There is no question of jurisdictional error,” it had contended and added that WhatsApp and Facebook’s pleas challenging its decision were “incompetent and misconceived”.
WhatsApp and Facebook had challenged the CCI’s March 24 order directing a probe into the new privacy policy.
“We firmly believe in protecting the privacy of our users. We cannot see people’s personal messages as they are protected by end-to-end encryption. We are updating our terms to provide users with more transparency about their choices to interact with businesses, if they require. Our users are at the heart of everything we do and we’re focused on making sure our conviction on protecting people’s privacy is clear”, said the WhatsApp Spokesperson.
CCI had also told the court that only after the investigation can it be determined whether the data collection by WhatsApp and sharing it with Facebook would amount to an anti-competitive practice or abuse of dominant position.
It had also contended that the data collected, which would include an individual’s location, the kind of device used, their internet service provider and whom they are conversing with, would lead to creation of a customer profile and preference which would be monetised by way of targeted advertising and all this amounts to “stalking”.
The two social media platforms had contended that when the top court and the Delhi High Court were looking into the privacy policy, then CCI ought not to have “jumped the gun” and intervened in the issue.
They had also said that CCI’s decision was an abuse of the commission’s suo motu jurisdiction.
They had claimed that the CCI in the instant case has “drifted far away” from the competition aspect and was looking into privacy issue which was already being looked into by the apex court and the Delhi High Court.
In January, the CCI on its own decided to look into WhatsApp’s new privacy policy on the basis of news reports regarding the same.
Also read: ‘Why is Centre not waking up to gravity of the situation’: Delhi HC on oxygen crisis