With #MainBhiChowkidar, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has turned Congress president Rahul Gandhi’s ‘Chowkidar Chor Hai’ barb at him into a campaign slogan for 2019 elections. BJP leaders and supporters added the ‘Chowkidar’ prefix to their social media names and now Modi will address 25 lakh ‘chowkidars’ on March 20 and March 31.
ThePrint asks: Has chowkidar barb turned into advantage-Modi or are real poll issues being sidelined?
BJP has the ability to convert its counter-attack into a national movement
Nalin Kohli
National spokesperson, BJP
The accomplishments of the Narendra Modi government over the past five years have been impressive. It would be patently unfair to say that real issues are being sidelined while campaigning today.
Let us consider the government’s performance on attacking corruption. From setting up the SIT on black money in the very first cabinet meeting to strengthening laws, chasing the corrupt like Christian Michel and bringing them back to face the law in India, or ensuring that the legal noose tightens around the likes of Vijay Mallya, Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi — the BJP government has lived up to its promise of fighting corruption and those guilty of indulging in corrupt practices.
The Narendra Modi government has also implemented several welfare programmes for every segment of society, including women, farmers, downtrodden, youth and middle class among others. Schemes such as direct cash transfer and Ayushman Bharat to provide free healthcare, sanitation, financial inclusion and infrastructure development have been undertaken at a pace like never before. The fact that the Indian economy has grown at an average rate of 7.3% consistently over the five years and that India has become one of the most attractive investment destinations in the world are testament to the success of the Modi government on the economy.
Overall, the BJP has adhered and implemented an agenda of positive change.
At the same time, if we are politically attacked with fabricated and manufactured agenda such as ‘Chowkidar Chor Hai’, then we have the ability to convert our counter-attack into a national movement. We have shown that not only is PM Modi a Chowkidar who protects the interests of the country, but also that citizens from across the country are joining the movement for a clean and developed India.
This is evident from the fact that #MainBhiChowkidar hashtag was retweeted by 20 lakh people with over one crore people having so far joined the campaign. This shows Indians are repudiating the false and fabricated agendas of the Congress party.
BJP’s campaign is defensive and proves Narendra Modi’s admission of guilt
Priyanka Chaturvedi
National spokesperson, Congress
Through his highly defensive campaign, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has finally admitted that he has robbed the citizens of the country not only of the many things they have a rightful claim over, but also of the many things he had promised to deliver.
While in power, Modi has robbed people of their jobs, robbed them of self-dignity and empowerment. He has robbed farmers the double-income promise, robbed Indians of Rs 80 lakh crore worth of black money that he promised to bring back, robbed them of the promise of Rs 15 lakh deposit in every account. Not only that, he has also robbed the youth of this nation two crore jobs for each year of his tenure that he had promised.
A reduced cost of living and an economic growth story were also promised by the PM, but none of these have been delivered.
The dissent note from the defence ministry against the intervention of the Prime Minister’s Office in the Rafale deal showed that PM Modi has also compromised the country’s national security.
His rebuttals and campaign now only go on to prove that ‘Chowkidaar (Modi) hi chor hai’. This campaign is anything but advantage Modi or advantage BJP. If anything, it absolutely endorses Rahul Gandhi’s words about the chowkidar being a chor.
Opposition may keep hitting out at the government, it is not a winning formula
Dilip Cherian
Image consultant and political strategist
It takes a brave prime minister to take on a nasty allegation like the Congress’ ‘chowkidar chor hai’ barb at Narendra Modi. The move is brave because real ‘chowkidars’ come from a different background, and image analysts can hardly decide whether a ‘chowkidars’ is a move up from a chaiwala. Moreover, by bringing the chowkidar reference to the front, Modi has brought all the allegations against him into play. But that is not something Modi is ever worried about.
But in all of this, are major issues of electoral importance like jobs, economic growth, agricultural distress and the situation at the borders being buried swiftly under a range of attacks and counter attacks? It remains to be seen whether this is only a starting point and the government would soon turn its focus on highlighting its achievements and successes as the days go by. The hard fact about elections is that an incumbent government is bound to defend its track record, but the opposition always has the advantage of benefitting from the allegations it levels against the government.
While it may be convenient for the opposition to keep hitting out at the government, it is not a winning formula. The young electorate is looking for solutions and new hopes. And while their earlier hopes have come crashing down, Modi juggernaut won’t stop unless the opposition can come up with real solutions and realistic hopes.
Also read: The participatory campaign logic behind ‘Main Bhi Chowkidar’
BJP’s Chowkidar campaign won’t fetch it any votes that it didn’t already have in its kitty
Santosh Desai
Columnist, author and brand historian
In a world where social media is playing an increasingly important role, I’d say that the Chowkidar barb may have given the BJP a mild advantage, just as any mobilising device serves as an advantage to a party.
That said, with the national elections less than a month away, I don’t believe such a campaign will give the BJP any incremental votes. It may be a show of existing strength, but no one had any doubt about the very committed cadre of the party to begin with. But besides that, it isn’t like this will fetch them votes they didn’t already have in their kitty. There is no real issue being peddled here.
I don’t think the move has backfired on the Congress. Within a small group of people, they may have been able to successfully sow a seed of doubt against the BJP. They may have been able to show that the BJP is not 100% incorruptible. So, in that, it is a limited win.
The BJP, on the other hand, has been able to convert this negative into a neutral. The Congress raised the issue of corruption against Prime Minister Narendra Modi personally for the first time, and the BJP has been able to somehow neutralise the impact. It is a bold strategy on the BJP’s part, but won’t have any conclusive impact.
By Fatima Khan, journalist at ThePrint.
Modi is too clever by half. If anybody thinks that Cowkidar campaign is going to benefit Modi, he should have immense faith in the brainlessness of the people of India. How can ‘I am Chowkidar’ be an answer to the allegation ‘Chowkidar chor hai’?
It suits Modi to have people talking about chowkidar being a chor. He believes that he can convert any expression coming from opposition to his advantage. I am always amused about this belief of his. He is probably the most expensive (cost of maintaining him and his life-style) PM India has had, even after adjusting from inflation from time of Mr Nehru. Even if he believes that he is not a chor, I am sure he knows that he is deceitful. He does not believe in fulfilling his own promises, as his party president refers to promises as ‘chunavi jumlas’. Even anecdotal evidence tells us that the cronies (read businessmen who have been praising him or supporting him in direct/indirect ways) have benefitted. Otherwise, how does a near bankrupt firm get biggest of defence contracts, becomes a preferred partner for sophisticated production?
On economy, it is visible everywhere that people are not earning enough. Even if the new jobs have come, they are low paying jobs. Why are graduating engineer’s salary stuck in the range of INR 20K per month, when the cost of engineering education has been growing faster than wages. Why is a large part of employment is only temporary and contractual? Outside the IITs and older IIMs (or high-ranking institutes in other disciplines), the graduates or post graduates don’t find a job for months and years, why? Why is the capacity utilisation of industry stuck at around 75%? Why is the auto industry struggling? Why are farmers unhappy? Why is that the farmers were not supported even after the worst drought in decades during 2014 and 2015 monsoon season? What is the desperate need for formalising the economy and kill millions of jobs and businesses? Tax thievery by small businesses will be much less than the thievery by big businesses and the incentives (for many ‘noble’ causes) that are handed out (in most cases through lobbies)? Why are we investing in new power plants when the demand for power has not been growing (PLFs are stuck)? Every one knows that solar push has helped the Chinese manufacturers for sure, has not created manufacturing jobs in India. Why are public sector firms being forced to pay large dividend, when they should be investing for growth? Why is control of fiscal deficit so important at this stage of development? Why should we let prices deflate for farm sectors when we know that the farmers are struggling?
Why should an individual and the party in power be allowed to spend public money on self-promotion and not on programmes that reduce malnutrition among children? The sum on self-promotion last totaled was in excess of a billion dollar?
Why does the PM need an armoured BMW when the ordinary people don’t have a foot path to walk in most cities?
Modi does not bother to talk about these issues and talks about personal insults. He insults rest of the country all the time – by keeping quiet when his ministers abuse (in most cases in unprintable language)?
At least during the election, the man can reflect and look beyond himself and his need to stay in power – present us with an alternative view of life in India.
The incumbent will run a magnetic levitation campaign, floating friction and vibration free above the bumps and grinds of reality. The NSSO report that has been kept away from the public domain estimates a loss of 47 million jobs between 2011 – 12 and now, a far cry from the promise to create two crore jobs a year, which contributed so much to rendering a decisive verdict. It is for the opposition to communicate its case effectively, directly to the people. Each household is hurting. What more can a challenger ask for …