scorecardresearch

Friday, November 20, 2026

Support our Journalism

Depth, context and analysis

Subscribe
HomePageTurnerBook ExcerptsConservation, caste, and the hierarchy of work I discovered in Sawai Mansingh...

Conservation, caste, and the hierarchy of work I discovered in Sawai Mansingh sanctuary

In ‘For Whom Do The Tigers Flourish’, Trishant Simlai documents the hidden politics of conservation in India.

Stay updated with ThePrint:

‘Namaskar. My name is Ramsingh Gujar, Kheri chowkie forest guard, bharti in 1996, native place Bundi,’ the man rattled off in a single breath, as if the entire biography had been coiled on his tongue for years, waiting for someone to ask. Bharti was the local term for the periodic statewide recruitment drives, when hundreds of posts were announced at once and filled through a single, often chaotic process. There was something oddly wholesome about hearing a complete life story delivered that way, without pause or flourish.

We moved our things into the room on the first floor, unpacked supplies of rice, flour, potatoes, onions, spices and an optimistic mountain of Maggi packets, then settled on the wide balcony. Ramsingh offered to cook, but we were impatient for the simple comfort of instant noodles. We sat there as the sky bruised into evening, slurping Maggi from steel bowls, watching the scrub darken and the distant Aravallis catch the last light. A small Indian fox called once, sharp and clear. Far away, a rain-heavy cloud drifted across the horizon, and pied cuckoos began their liquid song. When full night arrived, the jackals took over, their long, wavering howls rising from the forest and drifting towards the farmlands beyond.

We woke early the next morning, ready for our first patrol. The scrub was loud with the rattling calls of grey francolins as we stepped out.

‘I will show you my beat today,’ Ramsingh said. ‘This entire area behind the chowkie and into the hills beyond comes under me. Today we will go up to the foothills.’

We followed him into the dense scrub, cameras and notepads in hand. Ramsingh spoke of the hills as though they were old acquaintances.

‘This one has a leopard female. You see that cave under the ridge? She has reared two litters since my time here.’

His voice dropped with sudden disgust.

‘Among the Prosopis you will find dens. Do not approach during the day. Jaraks are ruthless animals.’

‘Jarak? What do you mean?’ Vishal asked.

‘In your English it is the striped hyena,’ Ramsingh replied. ‘It is a disgusting animal. It does wrong things with the humans it kidnaps and kills.’


Also read: Tagore’s three points on nationalism during World War I


‘Social outcasts’

That was a first for all of us. In rural Rajasthan, the striped hyena had long been placed by many communities in the same polluted category reserved for social outcasts.

Its scavenging habits – feeding on carrion, bones and, in times of famine, even human corpses – marked it as permanently impure, a creature that blurred the line between clean and unclean. The comparison came easily when Ramsingh spoke next.

‘There are Moghiyas in these parts,’ he said, gesturing towards the hills on the far side of the road. ‘Hyenas are like them: nocturnal, dirty eating, and kabhi ek din idhar, dusre din udhar – here today, gone tomorrow.’

The parallel was unremarked yet unmistakable.

We came upon a small handmade waterhole, almost dry, its edges cracked and pale. Ramsingh looked up at the sky, which had been heavy with cloud for days but still refused to yield rain.

‘Inside the park the water trucks come to fill the holes,’ he said. ‘Here we have to do it manually. I sometimes hire men to load canisters and carry them in.’

A paradise flycatcher dived into the remaining puddle, its long tail streamers flashing, then lifted away.

‘If it doesn’t rain for a few more days, the leopard will leave this ridge,’ Ramsingh said.

‘Where do you get the water from?’ I asked.

‘The closest handpump is four kilometres away, near the government school in Halonda village. Maybe you boys can fetch some tomorrow and fill this hole. I need to go to the range office for kaagazi kaam – paperwork.’

Vishal and I nodded. Deepak, a young biologist with a keen interest in herpetology, looked unimpressed. He had already been planning a systematic reptile survey for the next day.

‘Is this what I have come here to do?’ he muttered. ‘Fill waterholes? I am a biologist.’

Vishal wiped sweat from his forehead and gave a short laugh.

‘Well, Mr Biologist, we did sign up to experience what the forest guards actually do.’

Deepak’s jaw tightened.

‘This isn’t conservation work.’

‘And looking for stupid skinks under rocks is?’ Vishal shot back.

The exchange was sharper than either of them probably intended. I said nothing at the time, but the question lodged deep. What exactly counted as ‘real’ conservation? In the world we had grown up admiring, the answer seemed obvious: elegant science, grids, species richness, population models, papers in peer-reviewed journals. Knowledge production. The kind of work that earned visibility and quiet respect. Filling a drying waterhole with canisters hauled four kilometres from a village handpump was grunt labour – necessary, unglamorous and somehow beneath the dignity of a trained biologist.

It was a hierarchy we had absorbed without ever naming it. The mind-work of the scientist was noble; the body-work of the guard, the villager and the daily-wage labourer was simply what had to be done so the scientists could get on with their important business. Beneath that hierarchy lay an older one of caste and class, the same invisible lines that allowed us to arrive as volunteers while men like Ramsingh, and the young Meena boy who had rolled up the maps, remained permanently positioned as the ones who carried water, patrolled in the rain and were called by their caste name in a single breath.

This excerpt from ‘For Whom Do The Tigers Flourish’ by Trishant Simlai has been published with permission from Juggernaut.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

For readers who want the full picture.

You read our articles closely. Subscribe to go further, with exclusive newsletters in your inbox, flagship events hosted by Shekhar Gupta, AMAs with our senior editors, the chance to write under your own byline, and more.

Subscribe to ThePrint →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular