Sunday, 22 May, 2022
HomeOpinionModi MonitorA message for the PM from ‘mentor’ Mukherjee’s Nagpur speech

A message for the PM from ‘mentor’ Mukherjee’s Nagpur speech

Text Size:

The PM can hardly ignore the lesson in pluralism and nationalism from a man he professes to admire so much.

At the Governors’ Conference earlier this week, on 5 June, Prime Minister Narendra Modi reminded his audience that the need of the hour was to strengthen the ‘Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat’ initiative. What better occasions to do this, he pointed out, than during the forthcoming Kumbh Mela in January 2019, the 150th birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi later in the year, and the 75th anniversary of Independence in 2022?

Seems the Kumbh could become the springboard for a much bigger political initiative — the renaming of Allahabad, where the mela is taking place this time, to Prayag. Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath, having lost several byelections in Uttar Pradesh recently, seems to want it; the mahants, of course, are already clamouring for it.

With the political temperature so high these days, is the good Yogi presenting a fait accompli to the PM? Or is the PM on board such a decision already?

Certainly, the drum roll for the general election next summer has already been sounded. Kairana lit the fuse and Pranab Mukherjee’s speech at the RSS headquarters in Nagpur Thursday added fuel to the fire. The opposition is particularly chuffed that villages in Kairana constituency, which faced the brunt of the Muzaffarnagar riots in 2013, voted for RLD candidate Tabassum Begum.

So, as the Prime Minister sets off Saturday for Qingdao in China to meet Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and other world leaders at the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation summit, he will likely spend time aboard Air India One strategising on how he can get the most out of the coming year.

The familiar third person, in which the PM likes to think of himself, could emerge. How does Modi cut through the political antagonism and lead the way for another victory in 2019? How does Modi ensure that India’s boat remains stable in the choppy waters of international disingenuity?

We have some answers to these questions — courtesy of Pranab Mukherjee. In an interview with NDTV last October, a couple of months after he demitted office as President, Mukherjee said of Modi, “He has the unique capacity to work very hard, with a strong determination to achieve his objectives.

“Secondly, he is clear in his vision, what (he) wants to achieve. And he works hard to achieve that. This, one should remember, that he came straight from the state to the Centre, (he was) not even an MP for a few years, but he grasped the intricacies of the administration, internal dynamics of Indian politics, foreign policy, relationships with the neighbours,” Mukherjee said.

It is worth remembering, as the dissection of the former President’s visit to the RSS headquarters takes place, that Modi and Mukherjee have shared an unconventional relationship. The PM has been a ‘pracharak’ for a substantial part of his life and his cordial ties with Mukherjee would have certainly played a role in him accepting the RSS’ invitation.

The PM has also publicly returned the compliment. At a book launch last July, Modi had said of Mukherjee, “Yeh mere jeevan ka bohot bada saubhagya raha ki mujhe Pranab da ki ungli pakad kar Dilli ki zindagi main apne aap ko set karne ki suvidha mili.

It has been a deep privilege that I could hold Pranab da’s finger and settle down in Delhi, Modi said. Pranab da helped me negotiate the Byzantine corridors of this benighted city, he could have added.

Now that Mukherjee has spoken in Nagpur, the PM can hardly ignore the lesson in pluralism and nationalism (“Any attempt at defining our nationhood in terms of dogmas and identities of religion, region, hatred and intolerance will only lead to dilution of our national identity”) from a man he professes to admire so much.

Mukherjee’s final thrust, quoting Kautilya, the PM’s favourite strategist, may have hurt:

Kautilya tells us that in the happiness of the people lies the happiness of the King. Their welfare is his welfare. The State is for the people.

As he flies to China, Modi knows that, at least for the rest of his tenure, he will have to ensure that right-wing Hindu outfits that have taken the law into their hands these past few years cannot be allowed to contradict Mukherjee’s message from Nagpur.

The admiration for Pranab Mukherjee has now become Modi’s responsibility.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. What most people do not understand that Mr. Modi has already understood what Mr. Mukherjee has said at the RSS function. Mr. Modi has himself said the same things many a times. Remember the spontaneous statement by him when some Hindus and Muslims in an election rally in 2014 in Bihar became hostile because a bomb had gone. Personal courage: Mr. Modi stayed put. He did not leave. Personal value: he immediately went to the podium and said you must decide whether you want to fight each other or do you instead together want to fight against poverty?

    Mr. Modi is already there. It is just that most of the Congress, secular (what a joke) priesthood refuse to listen. It is also true that not every BJP affiliated politico has the same spirit of generosity and big-heartedness as Mr. Modi. And yes, Mr. Modi may need to be more aggressive in taming that wild-eyed right wing crowd.

    But be clear. Mr. Modi is the best thing that ever happened to India if you want India to be a prosperous and strong country with a chance at social justice.

    It is simple. Modi is the best India has. It may not be good enough for some, but again, India has none better.

  2. looks like liberal gang learnt nothing in last four years.
    they live in their own system rules mostly set by them (or their patrons).
    irony is that they expect Govt, Modi, BJP and RSS act according to these rules.
    sorry they do not!
    think a little. what are BJP/RSS goals? Just congress-mukth bharat and power. Vajapayee initiated that and even Advani could have achieved it.
    All that required for BJP to hang to power is “minority appeasement”. Join hands with IUML in Kerala, AIMIM in Hyderabad. They can run a coalition with nearly 400 LS but keep congress out.
    True! They need power to meet their objectives, which author may not like, but not the expense of the objectives itself.

    so do not bother to preach, rather scare BJP. It know its ways.

  3. Many resets are happening, not just in foreign policy. The worth of coalition partners has been rediscovered. Some outreach in Kashmir is discerible. Tamaam umra ka hisaab, Maangti hai zindagi is the thought that comes to mind as the incumbent prepares its Report Card, the basis for seeking a second term.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular