Monday, 5 December, 2022
HomeOpinionBrahmastraRajnath Singh’s China performance shows why Modi and Amit Shah need him

Rajnath Singh’s China performance shows why Modi and Amit Shah need him

No other Modi minister, not even Amit Shah, would have been able to pull off what Rajnath Singh did in Parliament on the issue of Chinese aggression in Ladakh.

Text Size:

The recently concluded monsoon session of Parliament was disastrous for the Narendra Modi government in terms of its ability to bring the opposition on board on crucial issues and the optics of building consensus.

The only exception, however, was the discussion around the tricky issue of India-China standoff in eastern Ladakh. And the credit for that goes to Defence Minister Rajnath Singh, who ensured that the government was not cornered by the opposition.

Through his handling of the China issue, Rajnath Singh has shown why the Modi-Amit Shah duo needs him. No other person, including Home Minister Amit Shah, would have been able to help the government tread over egg shells on such a delicate issue.

The multiple transgressions and incursions by China and the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) blocking access to areas Indian Army used to traditionally patrol are things that deeply embarrass Prime Minister Modi himself. This is because Modi has always projected himself as a sharp, strong Prime Minister with a teflon coating. He has always portrayed his closeness to Chinese President Xi Jinping – having met him 18 times since first coming to power in 2014.

However, Xi’s backstabbing has caught Modi by surprise. The reluctance to accept the intrusion in Ladakh at the all-party meeting on 19 June also led to a controversy and the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) had to issue a clarification to beat the blowback from the defence and strategic community his statement caused.

Also read: How Depsang Plains is new catchword in India-China standoff & why Rajnath not talking about it

Only Rajnath Singh could have done it

Under such circumstances, the defence minister brought with him his ability to carry along the opposition when he spoke in the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha.

Of course Rajnath Singh carefully skipped the part about the Chinese having intruded in Indian territory but he nevertheless managed to win the round by cajoling the opposition into not raising embarrassing questions and by reminding them of the operational sensitivity. He did all that while  hitting hard at China and invoking the valour of the Indian armed forces.

No other minister, including Amit Shah, would have been able to pull this off. Shah’s “termite” remark against the Bangladeshis continues to haunt the country’s bilateral ties with Bangladesh, even though it may have been a strategic move to cater to his party’s core domestic constituency. In fact, many experts feel that Shah’s claims on taking back Aksai Chin was also a factor in China doing what it has done now.

Of course, the home minister was playing to the gallery of domestic macho politics but sensitive issues need to be handled carefully instead of being sacrificed at the altar of vote bank.

In normal circumstances, the opposition would have had their knives out in Parliament over the China issue but Rajnath Singh managed to nullify their attack.

Also read: No power in the world can stop Indians from patrolling along LAC, says Rajnath Singh  

Carrying forward Jaitley’s legacy

Among Modi’s ministers since the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) came to power in 2014, the one politician who would have been able to pull off what Singh managed to was Arun Jaitley, known to be a consensus builder with a smooth communication line across parties.

With Jaitley no more, Rajnath’s skill becomes even more crucial for PM Modi whose government otherwise suffers from an embarrassingly poor bench strength.

Even in the armed forces, Rajnath Singh is looked upon with respect and admiration, something that held true in the case of his predecessor Manohar Parrikar.

Singh’s calmer and mature approach has given the military time to respond to China’s aggression in their own manner, which was quite evident on the intervening night of 29-30 August when the Army outflanked the Chinese-occupied key heights in the southern banks of Pangong Tso.

Another thing that Rajnath Singh has brought to the defence ministry is the political weight, which was missing during the tenure of Nirmala Sitharaman (the current finance minister). As I wrote earlier, Sitharaman was widely perceived as a lightweight minister who lacked administrative experience and political acumen. She was seen more as a stopgap arrangement until the 2019 Lok Sabha election, with most decisions being taken directly by the PMO.

Singh’s entry was a big change in terms of functioning within the ministry because his presence meant that outside interference is minimal.

As India Today reported in June last year: “Just hours after he was informed of his appointment as defence minister on May 31, Rajnath Singh dialled Army chief General Bipin Rawat. He wanted to spend his first working day, June 3, in Siachen. The army chief readily agreed. A little over 48 hours later, the defence minister was helicoptered into Siachen base camp, where he spent a day with troops at the world’s highest military deployment – 12,000 feet above sea level.”

I started at the top,” Singh told his close aides after the visit, “and I will stay there.”

Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. You don’t know that shah’s health is not ok from 3to4 months. He is not regularly present on his political platforms.

  2. TS Darbari- A balance is always required. Mr. Rajnath Singh has his own qualities while other leaders have their own qualities. We need all leaders who are devoted to the society and India. Whether they are from the current ruling party or opposition. Mr. Rajnath Singh has emerged as one of the strongest Defense Ministesr carrying forward the legacy of late Shri Manohar Parikkar and Shri George Fernandez. His focus is on the modernization and strengthening of Armed forces is unmatched. He has infused modernization with traditions that exist in this great Bharat for thousands of years. He has a clear vision and excellent communication skills.
    #TS_Darbari #TSDarbari #TS_Darbari_News #TS_Darbari_Blog #TS_Darbari_Views #LatestNews #ThePrint #BJP #Politics #IndianPolitics

  3. May be the opposition didn’t raise embarrassing questions to avoid being looked upon as insensitive to “operational sensitivity” mentioned by Rajnath Singh! May be his trick of mentioning “operational sensitivity” led Rahul Gandhi to raise very inconvenient questions to Modi, outside the parliament!

    What was Rajnath Singh was trying to convey to anybody when he was repeatedly saying, “the birds (5 Rafale planes) have landed”? It sounded so stupid! Why was it so important to announce the arrival of 5 Rafale planes? 5 Rafales weren’t going to change anything. The latest is that the Chinese have brought in an antidote to these -planes, i. e. The famous Russian S-400 missile system, which can shoot down a target at a distance of 400 kM: “In a worrying development for the Indian Air Force (IAF), Indian planners are evaluating the veracity of reports that the PLA has already deployed a regiment of state-of-the-art S-400 air defence missiles opposite the Chumar area; and another regiment is being moved into the Depsang sector. The Russian S-400 missile regiments, which can accurately strike Indian aircraft at ranges up to 400 kilometres, would allow the PLA to substantially neutralise the IAF’s advantage in air power.”

  4. I think the opinion that Modi-Shah duo requires Rajnath Singh, is a bit misplaced…..Everybody needs everybody….Could Rajnath Singh be what he is without Modi-Shah duo….. I am sure absolutely not…. Everybody has there importance….Everybody brings some important factor to the table….

  5. Surely the reading of the HIMALAYAN BLUNDER at his stage would be most useful to appreciate the changes if one can and wants to notice.
    Talking about the bench strength, quite difficult to match the 10 years of AK Anthony in defense, Shivraj Patil, Shinde in the home and even Chidambaram in finance with the good Doctor wanting to be at an arm’s length with the rain-coat on.
    For some reason nobody wants to accept the real strength which comes by restriction on money making.
    Most probably the knifes of the opposition could not come out because of the HIALAYAN BLUNDER now available on PDF was read.
    So unless Modi has not read this book there is no reason to believe that Xi’s backstabbing could have caught him by surprise.
    Despite all this it remains to be seen if there will be a confrontation and what will be the result. The commentators with hind sight will have a field day in any case.

  6. when in aaj tak coclave he was asked to list his biggest achievement in 2019 as home minister he was unable to count even one despite being the fact that there have been no bomb blast in the country in the last 5 years that was the level of involvemenmt he had as home minister it was all ajit doval and he along with jaishanker biapn rawat and coa are the main planner against china along with mr modi and amit shah and mark my words xi jinpeng will have to pay a heavy price for this misadventure

Comments are closed.

Most Popular