New Delhi: The Congress on Tuesday termed as rhetoric and hollow on specifics the prime minister’s address to the nation, saying there was no mention of a financial package or concrete steps to revive the economy.
Congress chief spokesperson Randeep Surjewala asked where is the country’s roadmap to fight coronavirus.
He said leadership does not mean making people realise their responsibilities but to fulfil the government’s duty of accountability towards the people of the country.
“A lot of talk has taken place. But, where is the roadmap to fight corona,” he asked.
Senior Congress leader P Chidambaram said, “The poor have been left to fend for themselves for 21+19 days, including practically soliciting food. There is money, there is food, but the government will not release either money or food. Cry, my beloved country,” he said on Twitter.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday announced that the lockdown across the country will be extended till May 3 to fight the coronavirus pandemic, saying the measure has produced a significant outcome in containing the infection.
Congress spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi said the PM’s address was like Hamlet without the Prince of Denmark.
“Amazing PM address. Exhortation, rhetoric, inspiration…..yet hollow on specifics! No financial package, no details, no concrete item. Neither for poor nor middle class nor industry nor businesses. Lockdown is good but cannot be end in itself! Where is single livelihood issue,” he asked.
He said the PM be assured that all stakeholders will do their duties and will strictly observe lockdown.
“After this: should we pray? We want concrete palliatives for these deprived classes and even for middle india and MSMEs,” he said.
“Pm address wo single specific and without guidelines is like Hamlet without Prince of Denmark. Like PM without details! We want increased GDP allocation; specific targeted monetary injections; Keynesian spending; loosen FMRB etc. not a single word!,” he tweeted.
Chidambaram also said that he welcomed the lockdown and understands the reason for its extension.
He, however, said the CMs’ demand for money elicited no response.
Also read: India can prevent long-term lockdown, contain Covid if 90% people download Aarogya Setu
“Not a rupee has been added to the miserly package of March 25, 2020. From Raghuram Rajan to Jean Dreze, from Prabhat Patnaik to Abhijit Banerji, their advice has fallen on deaf years,” the former finance minister said.
While supporting the PM’s announcement of extending the lockdown, Congress leader Shashi Tharoor said the PM should have also announced serious relief for those who cannot make ends meet.
“I support the announcement by @PMOIndia @narendraModi of Lockdown extension. Can’t discard the gains being made,” Tharoor tweeted.
“But he should have also announced serious relief for those who cannot make ends meet. MNREGA payments, JanDhan accounts, GST dues to states and aid to sweeten the pill,” the MP from Thiruvananthapuram said.
Also read: Lockdown extended across India until 3 May, PM Modi says adequate stock of food, medicines
Financial help in cash terms necessary. Not only to feed poor. Lower middle class, middle class, self employed professionals and businessmen (including MSMEs and small businesses in unorganized sector) who have lost income have to be given direct cash help. Like many countries are doing. Tea sector and other labour intensive industries are bleeding. Tax deferments, cash to few poor having Jan Dhan accounts does not help nor cover all affected. If not done that will kill more households and livelyhoods than the virus itself and 20-30% small businesses and MSMEs which have closed will not be able to start business again— think about the trickle affect. The government is quiet on this and Niti Aayog says it is not time yet and they will help if need is there…. WELL, NEED IS ALREADY THERE. Nurture the people and businesses, keep them alive. Real money has to flow to all.
Has anyone given a sector wise estimate of the possible financial damage( by Putting a figure) that will need making up.
It is the same story of opposing the AADHAR, we do not want numbers but results.
We want money from the government in the name of poor and that should be give to various kinds of brokers who excel in the art of making that money disappear. So the likes of Raghuram Rajan to Jean Dreze, from Prabhat Patnaik to Abhijit Banerji, Shashi Tharoor and P Chidambaram are quoted as the advise givers.
If only all these luminaries can sit down to gather and make an estimate of the damage, and propose how it can be made up it would be a lot easier.
In stead all we hear from them is financial package, concrete steps to revive the economy, poor have been left to fend for themselves ,there is food, but the government will not release either money or food.
The trouble is everyone compares Modi with the past PMs not realizing he is different, when all CMs talk about extending till 30th April, he makes it 3rd MAY, why think think…….