Indian cricketer and former Indian team captain MS Dhoni retired from his Indian Premier League (IPL) playing career on 17 November and was named team mentor for Chennai Super Kings (CSK) starting in the 2027 season. Now, Dhoni has retired from all forms of cricket. He stopped playing international cricket in 2020.
The right-handed batter and wicket-keeper captained the Indian cricket team in limited-overs formats (ODIs and T20Is) for about a decade, from 2007 to 2017, and in Test cricket from 2008 to 2014. As captain of India, he won three major ICC white-ball trophies, plus two Asia Cup titles as captain.
ThePrint asks: Is MS Dhoni the best captain Team India has ever had?
MS Dhoni was a tactical leader, not a strategic one
Anindya Dutta
Sports columnist and author
Dhoni was the master of situational leadership. He could read the game as it was at a moment in time and decide what the appropriate way to react to it was. The decision to walk in near the end of the 2011 chase or to throw the ball to Joginder Singh in the T20 2007 WC final are typical examples.
But his strength was as a tactical leader in a time-bound or an over-bound play situation, not a strategic one. He was a very average Test captain, and when things didn’t go his way, he looked helpless and bereft of ideas. So was he India’s greatest white-ball captain? Yes. In Test cricket, Virat Kohli and Sourav Ganguly were far better leaders.
MS Dhoni was blessed to become the captain in the internet era
Norris Pritam
Sports journalist and author
Dhoni can be called the best Indian captain ever, but with a bit of a disclaimer. The former captains like Sunil Gavaskar, Kapil Dev and Sachin Tendulkar, even though great players and captains, did not have the benefit of having as many tournaments and matches as Dhoni. Therefore, I feel Dhoni can surely be called the most successful captain—certainly for the Indian masses who evaluate the captain by the number of victories.
Without taking an iota of credit away from Dhoni’s success as captain of Team India, I would say he was also blessed to have been the captain in the Internet era. The former captains may have played a similar role, but much of it went unnoticed—at least to the masses due to a lack of aggressive 24X7 TV and non-existent social media.
No other captain in the world has ever won the treble that Dhoni has
Abhimanyu Bose
Journalist, Cricinfo
In cricket, the yardstick by which a captain is judged is largely the silverware they win. And for India, MS Dhoni won it all. In white-ball cricket, he led India to the three major ICC trophies—the T20 World Cup, the Champions Trophy and the biggest one of them all, the ODI World Cup. Winning the inaugural T20 World Cup in 2007 changed the landscape of cricket in India, paving the way for the IPL’s massive success.
The World Cup win at home in 2011, sealed by a six by the captain himself, brought home the crown for only the second time, and the first time in 28 years. No other captain in the world has ever won the treble that Dhoni has. There are questions over his Test captaincy – the performances away from home, and the home drubbing against England, a couple of big blips in his tenure – but even in that arena, he helped India win the Test mace by reaching No. 1 in the ICC rankings for the first time ever.
So, objectively, it is hard to argue against him being the best captain India has ever had. And if you want to speak subjectively, from Indian stalwarts like Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma to international stars who are serial winners like Matthew Hayden and Shane Watson, just speak to them about Dhoni and you will know how loved and respected he is as a leader. And just go back to replays of any CSK match, even over the last few years, and watch youngsters from every team crowd around Dhoni to get a few words of golden advice from him, and you will know where he stands among youngsters looking to make it big in the game.
(Edited by Ratan Priya)
