New Delhi: With barely three months to go for the crucial Bihar elections, the Narendra Modi government is all set to increase the income ceiling for the creamy layer of the other backward classes (OBCs) from the current Rs 8 lakh per annum to Rs 12 lakh.
Under the current rules, a household with an annual income of Rs 8 lakh or above is classified as belonging to the ‘creamy layer’ among OBCs and hence is not eligible for reservation in government jobs and government-funded educational institutions.
But apart from raising the ceiling to Rs 12 lakh, the new change also calls for including the salary in calculating the gross annual income.
According to sources, the proposal is likely to be taken up by the cabinet soon.
The elections in Bihar assume significance for the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) since despite being in an alliance with the JD(U), it has positioned itself lately as the leading partner, with Union Home Minister and senior BJP leader Amit Shah leading from the front; he even held a virtual rally on 7 June.
The election is also important for the party which recently suffered a series of losses — the BJP lost in several states including Delhi and Jharkhand, while it was unable to form the government in Maharashtra despite emerging as the single largest party.
Also read: A lesson BJP won’t learn from Delhi election: To not polarise Bihar and West Bengal
Rajnath-headed GoM drives change
ThePrint has learnt that the Group of Ministers (GoM) headed by Defence Minister Rajnath Singh, at a meeting Shah also participated in, deliberated on the issue and concluded that “this increase from Rs 8 lakh to 12 lakh and simplifying the mode of calculation of income by including all income sources except agriculture would bring benefit to the most”.
Another official pointed out that the government is confident that this would lead to “greater transparency and less manipulation at the certificate issuing level”.
“What is most important is that more people will be able to get the benefit of reservation, which they are not able to right now,” added the official.
According to sources, one of the changes that has been made to the proposal is to take an average of three years annual salary to calculate a person’s final salary rather than just the annual income.
According to sources, a few BJP leaders had said the matter should not be raised before the Bihar elections, however, officials pointed out that the beneficiaries will only increase through this exercise despite making salary as one of the components to decide on the gross annual income.
Also read: How BJP is leveraging its goodwill to ease pressure on Nitish over his Covid-19 handling
An eye on Bihar polls
After the 2015 poll debacle in Bihar and the subsequent losses in assembly elections, the BJP is not willing to take any chance. In Bihar, according to a rough estimate, over 40 per cent of the population is OBC.
“The proposal has got a go-ahead from the GoM and has been studied minutely. This will only increase the number of beneficiaries,” said another source in the government. “The few who have opposed the income limit are the salaried class but through this move, the poor and needy will benefit.”
According to the source, the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment had circulated a Cabinet note on the recommendations, seeking suggestions and inputs from other ministries. “The matter will be tabled before the Union Cabinet soon wherein a final decision will be taken,” added the source.
The BJP, which is largely viewed as a party of the “upper castes” has been promoting its own Bihar OBC leaders such as Nityanand Rai (MoS, Ministry of Home Affairs) and Sanjay Jaiswal (BJP Bihar president).
The Modi government had in September 2017 increased the creamy layer income ceiling from Rs 6 lakh to Rs 8 lakh for OBCs.
Also read: The BJP should dump Nitish Kumar in Bihar, sooner the better
GoM reviewed a panel report
The Rajnath-headed GoM was formed to consider the report of a government-appointed committee. The committee, headed by B.P. Sharma, former secretary of the department of personnel and training, was formed to examine issues related to creamy layer equivalence among the socially and educationally backward classes (SEBCs).
The committee had submitted its report on 19 September 2019 and recommended including salaries in calculating the gross annual income of households to determine the OBC creamy layer, and to raise the income ceiling from the present Rs 8 lakh per annum.
The OBCs are entitled to 27 per cent reservation in government jobs and admission to educational institutions. However, the creamy layer among them is excluded from such benefits.
Presently, those with annual parental income (excluding earnings from farming, agriculture land, etc) of Rs 8 lakh and above are not eligible for reservation benefits. Also, those who hold constitutional positions and enter Class-A positions in the government sector are automatically included in the creamy layer.
Also read: 3 Gujarat Congress MLAs quit, BJP looks to ‘settle score’ over Ahmed Patel’s Rajya Sabha win
Great step need to hike upto 15 lakh in rural areas and 20 lakhs in urban areas
Modi government has only increased the income ceiling so that the reservation is available to more people and more votes for the BJP. But increasing the number of jobs is impossible since more PSU banks and other loss making institutions are either being merged to reduce expenses or will be sold to private companies or closed down completely sooner than later. Therefore this is only an election gimmick to trick the public and come back to power. These kinds of tricks are played by all parties so the public has no option.
Providing reservation to anyone whose family income is above 5Lac is criminal.
Agreed. Reservation should be given for the people who are poor, not the rich.
Facts:
1. India’s median annual income is approx 1.2 lakhs. This cap is 10 TIMES of that. So even if a person is 10 times richer than an average Indian he or she is eligible for benefits under this quota.
2. Only 0.09% of Indians declare annual income greater than 10 lakhs. Even assuming half of them are OBC, this quota will exclude only a miniscule number. If everybody among OBC is eligible for quota, how will we ever get rid of quota? What is the point of being a merit category student in a land of perpetual quota students?
Bhakts must answer “Is this why we must all support Modi?”. The BJP under Modi is just Congress+Cow+Riots. Good governance can RIP.
Such a derogatory step when income are falling and no jobs. Only it will benefit rich and anti poor just to please creamy layer. Please don’t do this Modi ji I am your blind follower.