scorecardresearch

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Support our Journalism

Depth, context and analysis

Subscribe
HomeOpinionTele-scopeThe great Indian lap debate. Rahul Gandhi, PDA and television’s moral police

The great Indian lap debate. Rahul Gandhi, PDA and television’s moral police

Rahul Gandhi’s ‘lap’ remark had Indian media dissecting prudery, piety and privacy.

Stay updated with ThePrint:

Lap it up or wrap it up? That is the question.

Should there be an NDA on PDA? That’s the second question.  

And question no.3: Can we take a leap of faith from the lap of the gods to, er, Rajiv Gandhi’s lap?

These questions and many more have been challenging the intellectual acumen of people on social media, television news and YouTube channels.   

All because Rahul Gandhi spoke frankly about his parents’ displays of affection at the family dining table, and not about the cutlery.

His remarks during the launch of his mother Sonia Gandhi’s memoir Belonging have provoked a public debate over prudery, piety and privacy.

BJP has been provoked into prudery. It pinched its nose, sympathised with Sonia Gandhi for her “embarrassment” over Rahul’s comments made in front of chief ministers, party leaders and a hall full of people, not to mention a nationwide audience which watched the book launch on live television.

BJP declared there ought to be an NDA on PDA—a non-disclosure agreement on public displays of affection. That isn’t in Indians’ DNA or parampara. It’s “buffoonery,” said a BJP spokesperson on Times Now.

On social media, Rahul Gandhi was trolled for being explicit and praised for being explicit. Take your pick.

Television news and YouTube news shows, their anchors and their guests, scratched their heads as they tried to decide if Rahul Gandhi’s disclosures had been “inappropriate” on such an occasion or touchingly “intimate”?

‘Candour or cringe-worthy?’

We don’t know what possessed Rahul to open the doors to his family’s dining room but he might be surprised at just how much is being read into it.

Rahul Shivshanker, on CNN-News 18, made the tallest claims of all:  Has Rahul Gandhi challenged the “prejudice or prudery’’ that prevented “married couples from embracing intimacy without shame”?

Did he spark “a major debate on Indian social mores, customs and traditions”?

Was his “candour refreshing or cringe-worthy…?”

Shobhaa De put up her hand: “It was cringe,” she told Barkha Dutt on Mojo Story. “Rather absurd… a lost political opportunity,” she added.   

Other anchors were keen to share their personal feelings or state their moral stand on the Lap: “To describe in detail how Papa and Mama sat (at the dining table)… Are you serious?” fumed the Republic Bharat anchor on Tuesday evening.  

“Shamelessness, not simplicity,” moralised a Times Now anchor.

One NDTV reporter set aside morality for sentiment. “I was present (at the launch) … and it (Rahul’s comment) was heard in that spirit, to convey the happiness of a family snatched by the assassination (of Rajiv Gandhi)… Rahul highlighted Soni’s struggle,” he said on air.

Some, like Barkha Dutt, found Rahul’s remarks had set up an “intriguing debate”. Had he “finally” normalised public figures, even “netas” speaking “about love, romance and yes, even PDA?’’ she asked.

Ravish Kumar on his YouTube channel went all soft and gooey – it was all about loving your family in these times of hatred, he said. The problem for the RSS is that this portrait of a loving family may appeal to people, he said in Hindi.


Also read: When the Rahul and Priyanka Show took over Indian TV news


The Shiv and Parvati justification

Rahul Gandhi would have gotten a much more sympathetic hearing had he not brought the gods and goddesses to the dining table.

In response to BJP’s criticism, the Leader of the Opposition cited Shiv-Parvati iconography in support of his references to his revelations about his parents’ displays of affection. 

Now, even moist-eyed TV anchors were upset. A Times Now anchor spoke for many others when he said: “It can touch the heart; nobody can deny that. I don’t have a problem with what he said. My problem is he tried to counter critics with Shiv-Parvati (image).”

An anchor on the Lallantop show had a counter argument: it was Rahul Gandhi, “the son, not the politician,” who had spoken, and answered the BJP, the anchor said.

However, Republic TV’s host begged to differ. He said that many political leaders were present at the book launch and Rahul had crossed the “Holy Grail”. 

“Akhilesh Yadav has a different understanding of PDA,” the anchor stated, although how he knew Yadav’s feelings is another matter.

He said that using an idol to “justify” his comments was just plain wrong of Rahul Gandhi.

Academic and frequent TV commentator, Anand Ranganathan found himself caught between the personal and the pious. So he took the middle path to extricate himself.

“Nobody is right or wrong,” he said on CNN-News18. He did not think Rahul Gandhi was wrong, but argued that most Indians would not describe their parents’ loving relationship in the terms Rahul had used.

He then went into raptures about Shiva and Parvati, calling theirs the “most glorious thing”, and added that Indians didn’t have “such prudery” about physical displays of affection before the “Mughals and the British”.

NDTV anchor Shiv Aroor chose to ignore the “lap” controversy and said a book written by Sonia “matriarch” Gandhi was “always gonna be a volcano”. 

He found the seating arrangement of politicians who attended the book launch the most important aspect of the event: Akhilesh Yadav seated beside Sonia Gandhi. TVK next to Rahul Gandhi – and Captain Amarinder Singh right there in the front row.

The author tweets @shailajabajpai. Views are personal.

(Edited by Ratan Priya)

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

For readers who want the full picture.

You read our articles closely. Subscribe to go further, with exclusive newsletters in your inbox, flagship events hosted by Shekhar Gupta, AMAs with our senior editors, the chance to write under your own byline, and more.

Subscribe to ThePrint →

1 COMMENT

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular