Tuesday, 17 May, 2022
HomeOpinionSick doctors, shut hospitals, no guidelines — a Wockhardt doctor on India’s...

Sick doctors, shut hospitals, no guidelines — a Wockhardt doctor on India’s Covid response

Authorities must resist shutting down hospitals with infected staff because each bed and healthcare worker is an essential resource in India’s battle against the pandemic.

Text Size:

Governments around the world are rapidly expanding their healthcare capacity in response to the coronavirus pandemic. In India, however, hospitals are faced with a different kind of threat. Instead of being at the frontline providing treatment to Covid-19 patients, healthcare professionals themselves are falling prey to the disease. And overcautious local health authorities – in an attempt to limit the virus spread — have shut down many hospitals with infected staff such as Wockhardt, Jaslok, Bhatia, Hinduja Khar, and Breach Candy among others, and designated them as ‘containment zones’. This has shaken public faith in the healthcare system.

Unlike in China’s Wuhan, where healthcare workers (HCW) were infected while treating Covid-19 patients, many unsuspecting Indian healthcare workers have been infected by asymptomatic patients visiting for non-Covid treatments. For instance, a patient in Mumbai visiting Jaslok Hospital for a routine dialysis treatment later tested positive and may have infected others at the hospital.

Also read: To meet world average, India must add at least 10 lakh doctors to healthcare force

Why did this happen?

Although many will brand these unfortunate incidents as unforeseen, they represent a broad systemic failure. While it remains a matter of probe, the reasons for these cases are a mix of the refusal to accept community spread of Covid-19, the lack of official guidelines to private hospitals in treating asymptomatic patients, and a lack of foresight from hospital administrators in setting up personal hygiene and social distancing norms within hospitals.

One can draw comfort from Wuhan’s experience. After an initial spurt of infections among healthcare workers, improved understanding of the virus’ transmission mechanism, official guidelines on hand hygiene and the use of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) reduced the incidence of accidental infections.

Also read: Why India has not started using rapid test kits and the efficacy of HCQ & BCG vaccine

Good intentions can lead to bad consequences

India’s guidelines on the use of PPEs need to be examined. A cap, goggle, mask, face shield, water-resistant coverall, gloves and shoe cover are all vital components. Instructions on re-use of PPEs are not based on any significant scientific study and must be withdrawn immediately in the interest of safety of healthcare workers. Instead, the use of PPEs and N95 masks by civilians and government functionaries must be discouraged to ensure their exclusive availability for healthcare workers.

In response to the hospital closures, the central government has also issued an advisory to hospitals for managing non-Covid patients. Healthcare workers in different parts of a hospital are exposed to different levels of risk of exposure. Therefore, advising mandatory use of N95 mask in all clinical settings is not rational. In contrast to the UK’s National Health Service’s guidelines for health professionals, the Indian advisory is highly ambitious and doesn’t account for the limited availability of N95 masks and PPEs in the country. We must not allow fear to overrun science.

Also read: My virologist dad says coronavirus vaccines won’t be ready for distribution till 2021

What should be done?

Every patient or their relative entering a hospital should be presumed to be Covid-positive, irrespective of their lack of symptoms or health certificate. This is needed since some antibody tests may come negative even in the presence of coronavirus and an antibody test provides a positive result only after eight days of catching the infection.

Barrier nursing protocols, increased payouts

Healthcare workers and hospital management are well-versed with barrier nursing protocols for managing patients infected with previous viruses, such as H1N1. Extending these protocols for all patients is definitely not an insurmountable logistical exercise for hospital administrators. The cost of care is likely to significantly increase with the use of PPEs, social distancing between patients, and increased time required for sanitisation of the operation theatre and common areas between procedures. The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA) should allow a 30-50 per cent increase in the payout for procedures for at least one year.

Also read: India’s poorest states have a ‘triple’ burden. Will struggle in a full-blown Covid strike

Avoid hospital shutdowns, set up ‘back up zones

Local health authorities must resist shutting down hospitals with infected staff, as each bed and healthcare worker is an essential resource in India’s battle against the coronavirus pandemic. Protecting vulnerable healthcare workers from infection should be the foremost priority. A comprehensive staff evaluation must be undertaken and healthcare workers over the age of 65 and with co-morbidities must be asked to work from home or take up administrative responsibilities for the duration of the pandemic.

Keeping at least 30 per cent workforce away from the hospital can provide a back-up for infected staff in a situation faced recently by hospitals in Mumbai and Delhi. As consultations and planned procedures are on hold in hospitals all over the country, the implementation of this measure shouldn’t be challenging. Similarly, a strategy to lock up and conserve non-essential floors can help build a ‘hospital back-up’ while infected areas are being sanitised after a diagnosed contamination.

Simplifying care protocols is essential for reducing the risk of infection. In Wuhan, the basic training of hand hygiene, avoidance of touching face and use of PPEs helped protect HCWs from catching the infection.

Also read: 10 reasons why Covid-19 data on testing and fatalities might not be accurate

A financial package

Besides manpower training and sensitisation, hospitals will need investments to deliver consistently safe outcomes, even for non-Covid patients. These include the construction of assessment zones, dedicated patient lift, conversion of positive pressure operation rooms into negative pressure ones, and particle arresters for surgeries to protect surgical teams and to prevent cross-infection of future patients. A financial package for private health care providers combined with massive investment in public healthcare should be high on the government’s agenda.

Protection from unfair media and legal scrutiny

In Italy, doctors were forced to choose which patients could avail the limited ventilators and beds. During the course of this pandemic, healthcare workers and hospitals in India can be compelled to make difficult choices too, exposing them to unfair media and legal scrutiny. It is therefore essential that the healthcare system is insulated from union pressure, official probes, unfair media scrutiny and litigations during this period, in line with their counterparts protecting India’s borders.

The author is Director of Bariatric Surgery at Wockhardt Hospital, Mumbai; and President of the Indian Association of Gastrointestinal Endo-Surgeons. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. LOL. It is a Joke if doctors and hospitals want guidelines on what to do from government. This is nothing but a rinse and repeat article aimed at govt bashing to cover up their good up.

    Grow up.

  2. In the absence of adequate PPE and N95 masks Eye cate caps for Medical staff actively engaged in Covid 19 infected patients , the availabilty if these Vital inadequatele available but essential gear MUST be limited to actively treating infected patients only. Any other person NOT connected but found using these MUST be booked by law or amend one.
    All personnel actively engaged in the treatment must be kept uo todate with protocols evolving on a daily basis by a responsible supervisor. There must be a local, then regional next district, then state then nation wide data of treatment plan, its efficacy its drawbacks, assessed and a common nation wide plan of handling various stages of and modalities of recieving, initiation and maintenance of treatment plan , and procurement of additional equipment, (ventilators and Hyperbaric O2 chambers, physiotherapy paraphernalia), Medication, positioning In short a National Consesus of standardised treatment. A weekly review of all staff, doctors and nurses, ambulance services in bringing in and taking a recovering patient to isolation abd even home. Uniform Standardised Upgradable plans must be the National norm The Virus is NOT area specific as of now so that a standardised protocol in place would permit even smaller hospitals to initiate treatment sparing larger ones purely for tertiary care.

  3. Wockhardt has totally mismanaged itself and got into trouble. Being in a senior leadership instead of fixing problems internally, this doctor is trying to blame others. And also asking for Govt dole (public money) to fund private hospitals. During COVID times, it is mostly Govt hospitals and staff who are on the front lines. Wockhardt ignorant or careless staff got into trouble by not following protocols and spread it to all others.

  4. How come the ” Professional Incompetence ” of doctors and health workers is not a reason behind the High infection rate of hospital staff???

    You have blamed everyone under the sun except the people who knowing there is a pandemic worldwide, were reckless in examination of patients and contracted coronavirus due to low standards of professional competency – yet you blame the Govt and ICMR ??

    Whether or not it is stage 3 or stage 2 – basic precaution and common sense is the same while examination of patients. This classification is meaningless in the practise of medicine. Further, the reuse of PPEs being blamed is yet another lousy argument – worldwide there is a PPE shortage, even in the US doctors are reusing not just PPEs but even respirators and using surgical masks instead of respirators!

    This article is not just medically ignorant it is also a scapegoating rant for attention. Instead of asking the medical fraternity to rise to the challenge, we see these kinds of articles blaming PPEs, local administration and even ridiculously the ICMRs “classification” of the epidemic or lack of “protocols” – as if Pvt. Hospitals follow Govt protocols in the first place?

  5. I agree with the doctor. Hospitals are scarce resources in India and all efforts should be made to keep them operational in this crisis ridden moment

    • This doctor is like a kirana shop owner crying his shop is forced to close during panic buying…this is not about saving lives by saving his and private hospitals livelyhood!

Comments are closed.

Most Popular