scorecardresearch

Monday, November 16, 2026

Support our Journalism

Depth, context and analysis

Subscribe
HomeOpinionSonia Gandhi’s father, the Holocaust and the history her book chooses to...

Sonia Gandhi’s father, the Holocaust and the history her book chooses to forget

To erase Stefano Maino from her story altogether would have been a legitimate choice—no child ought ever be held to account for the crimes of their parents.

Stay updated with ThePrint:

Lenin’s Way, the farm used to be called: The stables, ironworks and barns overlooked a rolling green paddock where the bodies of insurgents hung from the gallows, swaying in the gentle breeze. Enemy officers were marched to the edge of the farm, then “forced to get naked, and one at a time, made to lie down in the pit with their faces to the ground, at which point they were killed with a bullet in the back of their head.” Lower-ranked prisoners were left to disease, hunger and cold. Each morning, tens of bodies—sometimes hundreds—were tossed into open graves. Guards amused themselves by setting their dogs on prisoners too worn to walk.

Fleeing Little Saturn—the Soviet envelopment that crushed the Royal Italian Eighth Army along the Don, north of Stalingrad—the detritus of the 3rd Cavalry Division washed up around Lenin’s Way at the end of 1942. Among them was a young non-commissioned officer whose survival would shape the course of modern Indian history.

In Dnepropetrovsk, the railway hub from which he would be evacuated home, sergente-maggiore Stefano Maino befriended the children who hung around his unit’s kitchen. “He was haunted by the pleading expression on the children’s tiny faces, the avidity with which they devoured the little that could be spared, and the gaze of gratitude in their eyes,” Sonia Gandhi records in her new book. Years later, he would later name his two older daughters after the girls of Dnepropetrovsk: Anouchka and Sonia.

There is a strange quality to the story Sonia Gandhi tells of her genesis, as if parts of the truth had been amputated to hide maggot-infested wounds. Living in Dnepropetrovsk, sergente-maggiore Maino would have heard the stories of other children—the Jewish ones torn from their mothers’ breasts and buried alive. He would have heard his comrades boast of executing unarmed civilians and burning down entire villages. And he would have learned that the élite Alpini mountain troops who secured his escape through Soviet lines at Nikolayevka were led by the sadistic Lenin’s Way commandant, colonel Raffaele Marconi.

Long after the war, the sergente-maggiore remained unrepentant about his support for Benito Mussolini and Fascist Italy’s wars. Residents of Sonia Gandhi’s home town, Orbassano, told the journalist Vaiju Naravane that Stefano Maino had been part of the so-called Salò puppet republic, founded under Nazi occupation in 1943.

The Maino we are introduced to—il Leone, ‘Maino, the Lion’—is a creature of a loving daughter’s imagination: patron saint of starving Ukrainian children, venerated by his family and worshipped by his former comrades. To close her eyes to the evil done by loved ones makes Sonia Gandhi human. To hide his role in the greatest crime in human history makes her complicit.

Children of the genocide

Four storeys high, its stone facade held up by dramatic archways of glass, the Main Department Store had been planned as a palace for the working class: elevators and sweeping staircases led up to shops, a mother and child room, a hairdresser, showers. The store closed when war broke out, and stayed shut until Nazi guards gave it a new purpose in October, 1941. The city’s Jews were made to line up there, leaving jewellery, watches, cigarette cases and warm clothes in neat piles. Then they were marched past the botanical garden to the edge of the Krasnopovstancheskaya ravine and machine-gunned in the back.

Eleven thousand Jews, at least, were killed in Dnepropetrovsk over two days. Eyewitnesses and Soviet intelligence units described babies torn from their mothers and tossed into the open pit, to be buried alive.

Contemporary accounts suggest that few Italian soldiers took part in the massacres that marked the Final Solution’s eastward progress. The historian Lilia Tomachuk records that many Jewish survivors remembered Italian soldiers as kindly, letting them eat scraps of macaroni in return for cleaning pots and pans. This might not have been altruism, but it sometimes meant life instead of death.

However, large numbers of Italian troops participated in the Holocaust in other ways. Through the summer of 1942, Eighth Army units helped hunt down Jewish families around Krasny Gorodok. Others handed arrested Jews over to the Germans, knowing they would be sent to concentration camps. Some took cash and jewellery in return for safe passage to Hungary, then delivered their victims to the Nazis.

General Giovanni Messe’s troops, which included the 3rd Cavalry Division, helped capture the Kryvyi Rih iron-ore mines in August, 1941, and must have seen Jewish inmates being worked to death building the road to Dnepropetrovsk.

Gandhi praises her father’s moral sensibility, claiming he punished a comrade who tried to sexually assault a woman. This might be true, but the exploitation of Jewish women, cynically dressed up as compassion, was common among Italian soldiers.

After the war, the soldier Bartolomeo Fruttero told the historian Benvenuto ‘Nuto’ Revelli—himself a veteran of the Alpini on the eastern front, later an anti-Fascist guerrilla—that he first heard of the Nazi genocide from a “young, beautiful, and sharp” Jewish doctor his unit sheltered in their train car for two days in 1942. The woman, Fruttero recalled, was stripped to her underclothes as she described death in the extermination camps: “We give her food, take turns going in to make love.”

“The tale I remember,” Gandhi writes, “that always brought a lump to my throat was the one of Father offering his ragged blanket and his last morsel of bread to an emaciated Russian child holding its hand out to him in supplication.”

Late in 1942, Riva Goldtman, then not much younger than Sonia or Anouchka, wrote of crawling out of the shallow grave into which her entire family had been dumped. Local communists gave up their own lives to ensure Goldtman survived to bear witness.

Did the sergente-maggiore’s gaze ever fall on children like Riva Goldtman? We do not know. Perhaps Gandhi never asked her father the question; perhaps she does not wish to share the answer.


Also read: The US cannot blame Abdul El-Sayed’s family and ignore its own jihadist past


Acts of heroic amnesia

Sonia Gandhi’s book offers little detail on her father’s military record, other than that he was a Bersagliere, a member of the élite light infantry in the expeditionary corps Mussolini despatched to the eastern front in the summer of 1941. The 3rd Bersaglieri Regiment helped seize the rail hub at Donetsk, then pushed forward to the Dnieper before being assigned to protect the left flank of the Nazi 6th Army. Elements of the 6th Bersaglieri were added in March, 1942, when Mussolini committed the much larger Armata Italiana, or ARMIR, to the Eastern Front.

The book’s poor editing muddies the picture further. The memoir dates the retreat from the eastern front to the end of 1943—by which time Mussolini had been overthrown, and the Nazi war machine broken at Kursk by Marshal Georgy Zhukov’s tank armies and the granular intelligence provided by the German anti-Fascist journalist Rudolf Roessler, code-named ‘Lucy.’

Long before their defeat, though, at least some Italian soldiers had taken part in the eastern front’s war crimes. The German military’s 29 Corps—entirely Italian by August, 1942—killed hundreds of civilians in reprisals for insurgent attacks. Troops commanded by Colonel Mario Carloni burned down entire villages during the retreat from the Don in 1943. The historian Raffaello Pannacci’s work makes clear that Italian troops also tried to terrorise local communities by forcing them to witness summary hangings and executions.

Letters sent home by Italian soldiers show that many saw this kind of terrorism as legitimate: “Those guys hide, and you’ve got to drag them out by the hair,” one wrote.

Other letters show that some soldiers saw the war as a religious crusade. To rural Catholics, teachings that God did not exist and that men were descendants of monkeys were deeply offensive. Many Italians blamed the Jews, whom they believed controlled the Soviet Union.

There were flashes of sympathy for the victims. A soldier from the IV Chemical Battalion watched “seven of those poor wretches hanged in a square, and they kept them there as an example because they had derailed a train.” The military leadership moved quickly to extinguish any remorse: a circular warned of gangs of children “telling the most painful stories of being war orphans, only to gain access to quarters and poison water supplies.”

Later accounts invoked the martyrdom of Christ to portray Italian soldiers as martyrs. Lieutenant Gino Beraudi wrote: “The bodies lying in the snow assume a placid and decorative appearance, resembling wax figures. Freezing prevents decomposition, features remain rigid, neutral coloring assumes a degree of vivacity in contrast to the huge white sheet of snow.”

There were no words wasted on the frozen bodies tossed into the pits at Lenin’s Way. Amnesia is also a weapon of war.


Also read: Jensen Huang affair — The spy, the seductress and the story we keep falling for


Gentlemen-Soldiers and Génocidaires

After the Second World War, American authorities protected their Italian allies from war-crimes trials of the kind seen in Tokyo and Nuremberg, the brilliant Irish journalist Rory Carroll writes. General Pietro Badoglio, who dropped poison gas on Ethiopian villages, died in his bed and was buried with full military honours; General Rodolfo Graziani, whose troops posed holding the severed heads of their victims in Addis Ababa, served four months; Giovanni Ravalli, convicted of war crimes in Greece and Yugoslavia, was pardoned and lived on a generous pension in an upmarket home in southern Rome.

The myth of the “Good Italian”—an idea first invented to distinguish its colonial wars from those of other empires—was built with state backing. The scholar Davide Rodogno has shown that it rested on exceedingly weak foundations. Though Fascist Italy had no Auschwitz of its own, it stripped its tiny Jewish population of citizenship in 1938, and cooperated with Nazi policies in the territories it occupied.

Fascist values embedded themselves in the post-war republic, married to militant Catholicism. In one case, Christopher Duggan writes, judges acquitted a military captain who had allowed a female anti-Fascist prisoner to be tied up, blindfolded and repeatedly raped by his soldiers. The court argued this did not constitute torture, “only the maximum offence to the honour and modesty” of the woman.

Few Indians are likely to find Sonia Gandhi’s effort to sanctify her father consequential. The book’s less-than-revelatory accounts of the 1984 riots, the Ram Janmabhoomi movement or the rise of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam are—and ought to be—of far greater significance. To erase Stefano Maino from her story altogether would have been a legitimate choice: no child ought ever be held to account for the crimes of their parents.

To remake the sergente-maggiore as a saint, though, speaks of a deep contempt for both the memory of Fascism and the stories of its victims. Even the archives, almost certainly, will not resolve the issue of whether Stefano Maino was a génocidaire—but having raised the issue, the least Sonia Gandhi owes is a good-faith effort.

Like India itself, Sonia Gandhi’s history has been entwined with unimaginable trauma. There can be no liberation, though, if the truth hides in the confession box, veiled in shame and speaking only in whispers.

Praveen Swami is a Contributing Editor at ThePrint. His X handle is @praveenswami. Views are personal.

(Edited by Janaki Pande)

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

For readers who want the full picture.

You read our articles closely. Subscribe to go further, with exclusive newsletters in your inbox, flagship events hosted by Shekhar Gupta, AMAs with our senior editors, the chance to write under your own byline, and more.

Subscribe to ThePrint →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular