New Delhi: On November 5, 2026, the Punjab and Haryana High Court ruled that once either spouse crosses the statutory age limit for Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART), the right to seek treatment jointly as a commissioning couple does not survive. However, it clarified that a woman below 50 can pursue ART individually even if her husband has crossed the prescribed age limit of 55.
The ruling has brought into focus a larger legal question: how should the age restrictions under the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021, apply to couples, and can embryos frozen within the prescribed age limits be transferred after a woman crosses the threshold?
The ART Act covers techniques that attempt to achieve pregnancy by handling sperm or eggs outside the body and transferring either the gamete or the embryo into a woman’s reproductive system. It defines a ‘commissioning couple’ as an infertile married couple seeking ART services, and a ‘woman’ as any woman above the age of 21 years seeking such services. A man is not separately or comparably defined for the purposes of the Act.
Section 21(g) of the Act states that ART clinics can provide services to a woman between 21 and 50 years of age, and to a man between 21 and 55. However, it does not clarify whether a couple can proceed with treatment if one spouse has crossed the applicable age limit.
This statutory silence has led to divergent interpretations among High Courts. While some have adopted a flexible reading, allowing couples to proceed jointly if one spouse meets the age criteria, others have held that the limits apply separately to each individual.
Advocate-on-Record Mohini Priya, who specialises in ART law, says the conflicting judgments risk creating geographical inequality in the exercise of reproductive rights. “Courts must be cautious about reading additional restrictions into a beneficial regulatory statute. Reproductive autonomy is protected under Article 21, and its exercise cannot depend on geographical jurisdiction,” she says.
Can couples proceed if one spouse crosses the age limit?
The question is whether a couple can seek ART treatment jointly if the husband is above the age limit of 55, but the wife is below 50, using the wife’s eggs and the husband’s sperm. The same question arises when the wife is above 50, but the husband is below 55.
In Sanchita Ghosh v. Union of India (2024), the Calcutta High Court considered a challenge to the constitutional validity of Section 21(g). The woman petitioner was within the prescribed age limit, but her husband was above it. She argued that although she was eligible for treatment, the couple could not access ART services jointly because of her husband’s age, creating unreasonable discrimination between married and unmarried women.
The court held that the ART Act, when “read in a liberal context” in the case of childless couples, did not impose a composite age limit on a commissioning couple.
“In the event either the woman or the man comprising the commissioning couple is eligible to have assistive reproductive technology, there is no reason why the bar stipulated for individual women and men should be incorporated into the purview of the commissioning couple as well. The age-related ineligibility of one of the spouses need not affect the other, if they comprise a ‘commissioning couple’,” Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya said.
The Chhattisgarh High Court adopted a similar interpretation in 2026, holding that Section 21(g) prescribed independent age limits rather than a joint restriction for couples. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad set aside the rejection of a couple’s request on the ground that the husband was over the age limit and allowed them to proceed with IVF/ART treatment, subject to medical fitness and other statutory safeguards.
The Gujarat High Court, also in 2026, cited the Sanchita Ghosh judgment while allowing a couple to undergo in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) jointly even though the wife was over 50. Justice Nirzar S Desai said it was for the treating clinic to determine the medical eligibility of the spouse who had crossed the age limit.
The Rajasthan High Court, however, took a stricter view. In 2026, it held that “a man, whether acting as a donor of male gametes or seeking ART services as a member of a commissioning couple, cannot be above 55 years of age”.
A division bench of Justices Sandeep Taneja and Inderjeet Singh clarified that a married woman who meets the prescribed age criteria can access ART services independently using donor semen, even if her husband is over the age limit. Referring to the consent forms under the Act, the court said this could be done with the husband’s consent.
The Punjab and Haryana High Court’s recent ruling in Veena Devi v. Union of India disagreed with the Calcutta High Court’s reasoning. It held that once either spouse crosses the prescribed age limit, the right to access ART as a commissioning couple does not survive.
Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya said the age restrictions applied to the spouses separately, and the absence of a specific restriction for a couple could not be a ground for the court to introduce one. Doing so, he said, would amount to reading into the law something that Parliament had not provided for.
Senior Advocate Suruchi Aggarwal, speaking to ThePrint, argues that the legislative scheme does not contemplate any joint or collective age restriction for a commissioning couple.
Also Read: Embryos frozen at 47, wife turns 50: HC says IVF age limit applies separately to husband and wife
Can frozen embryos be transferred after the age limit?
The legal dispute extends beyond the eligibility of couples to begin ART treatment. High Courts have also differed on whether the age restriction applies only when treatment is initiated or at every subsequent stage, including the transfer of embryos that were frozen when the woman was within the prescribed age limit.
In May 2026, the Delhi High Court distinguished between starting a fresh ART cycle after crossing the statutory age threshold and continuing treatment that had already lawfully commenced.
In that case, the couple was within the prescribed age limits when six embryos were created and cryopreserved. After one unsuccessful transfer, the couple was denied a second transfer because the woman had crossed the age of 50.
In Shweta Tuteja v. Union of India, the court said: “The cryopreserved embryos in question are not merely preserved biological material in abstract but are intrinsically connected with the Petitioners’ reproductive autonomy, decisional privacy and their constitutional protected choice relating procreation and family life.”
Relying on the Supreme Court’s judgments on reproductive autonomy and bodily integrity in Suchita Srivastava and Puttaswamy, Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav held that a regulatory statute dealing with reproductive rights must be interpreted purposively and in a manner consistent with the constitutional values protected under Article 21.
Aggarwal said the Delhi High Court had adopted a purposive interpretation rather than a strictly literal reading of the law. “In the circumstances, the Delhi High Court correctly allowed the already cryopreserved embryos to be utilized even when the wife marginally crossed the age limit,” she said.
Priya also believes the Delhi High Court’s judgment better reflects the purpose of the legislation. Embryo creation, cryopreservation and transfer are interconnected stages of ART treatment, she said, adding that “a purposive interpretation must balance reproductive autonomy with medical safety”.
The Punjab and Haryana High Court, however, took a different view. Justice Dahiya held that the prescribed age limit must be met both when embryos are created and when they are subsequently transferred. The fact that embryos were frozen within the age limit, the court said, did not create a vested right to have them transferred later.
In this case, the woman had crossed the age limit after the embryos were frozen but before the proposed transfer. The clinic submitted that it had no objection to the transfer as she was in good health. The court did not accept this argument.
“Merely because embryos were frozen before the woman crossed the maximum age, would not entitle her to undertake the subsequent stage of the procedure…after she has crossed the prescribed age limit as that would be violative of stipulations under the Act,” it said.
Aggarwal said the court had adopted a strict interpretation of the ART Act, holding that a provision not expressly provided for in the law could not ordinarily be read into it.
Why the Centre opposes exceptions to the age bar
The Centre has consistently opposed judicial dilution of the age restrictions under the ART Act.
In the Punjab and Haryana High Court case, the Union of India argued that the age limits were scientifically sound and constitutionally valid. It maintained that the separate limits for men and women, as prescribed by the law, should apply and that no exception should be made for commissioning couples.
The Centre also argued that the provision had been recommended by the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health and Welfare before being incorporated into the law and passed by both Houses of Parliament.
To support its position, the Union relied on the Gauhati High Court’s 2025 judgment in Pankaj Kumar Das v. Union of India, which upheld the validity of Section 21(g).
A division bench of Chief Justice Ashutosh Kumar and Justice Arun Dev Choudhury held that the provision prescribed an upper age limit based on “considerations of medical science, ethical standards, and the welfare of both the woman undergoing treatment and the child to be born”. It also said the issue fell within the legislative domain, noting that courts do not “evaluate the wisdom of legislative choices”.
The Centre also submitted a 2026 expert committee report prepared by the Department of Health Research under the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.
Aggarwal, however, questions the reliance on the report, saying it provides post-facto justification for the age limits prescribed under Section 21(g), which came into force in 2021. Such justifications, she argues, cannot be considered while interpreting the provisions of the Act.
The way forward
The central question is whether the age restrictions should operate as an absolute bar or allow courts and clinics to consider individual medical circumstances.
“Age restrictions may serve legitimate medical objectives, but a blanket prohibition based solely on chronological age can be disproportionate,” Priya says. Emphasising the need for an individualised approach given variations in reproductive ageing and medical fitness, she adds: “A protective statute should facilitate safe reproductive choices, not become a barrier to exercising them.”
Aggarwal agrees, arguing that “the primary purpose of the Act is to regulate and supervise ART Clinics and banks to eliminate commercial and unsafe practices and not to deny access to ART procedures”.
With High Courts taking divergent views on whether Section 21(g) imposes an individual or composite age bar on commissioning couples, and whether frozen embryos can be transferred after the woman crosses the statutory age limit, the scope of the ART Act’s restrictions remains unsettled.
The constitutional challenge to the upper age limits under the ART and Surrogacy Acts is already pending before the Supreme Court in Arun Muthuvel v. Union of India. Priya says the issue is not merely one of statutory interpretation, but also concerns the fundamental rights to equality, dignity and reproductive autonomy. Alongside an authoritative ruling from the Supreme Court, she says, legislative clarification is also desirable.
(Edited by Anupama Yadav)
Also Read: India’s IVF boom has a dark side. Unlicensed clinics, embryo mix-ups & DNA tests
