A quarantined area during the bubonic plague outbreak, Karachi, 1897. | Wellcome Library archive collection
A quarantined area during the bubonic plague outbreak, Karachi, 1897. | Wellcome Library archive collection
Text Size:

While the latest coronavirus pandemic rages across the world, India has been no exception to its march. To contain the spread of COVID-19, the Narendra Modi government invoked the 1897 Epidemic Diseases Act which the Britishers had framed to deal with an epidemic that claimed 12 million lives after its initial outbreak in Bombay Presidency in 1896. The historical conditions of its creation as well as the resonances of the Act today warrant a careful study.

In 1896, select British officials were tasked with containing the bubonic plague that first erupted in Bombay Presidency, and soon after raged across the colony. These men observed with alarm a pattern of Gujarati and Marwari grain traders, labourers, Brahmin residents and magistrates fleeing Poona. In his Report on the Outbreak of Bubonic Plague in Bombay, 1897, P.C.H. Snow, the Municipal Commissioner of Bombay, feared, in addition, the rapid flight of cart-drivers, sweepers, cleaners and sanitary workers, for it was this poor, lower caste section of people that the city’s health depended on.

The chairman of the Bombay Plague Committee, Brigadier General W.F. Gatacre, joined Snow in making a fevered case for a strong law that cracked down on people who fled municipal limits. The outcome was the passage of the Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897. The Act has, since then, been invoked to fight dengue and malaria in cities like Chandigarh in 2015, cholera in Vadodara in 2018.

A man being inoculated after the bubonic plague outbreak, Bombay, circa 1897. | Wellcome Library archive collection
A man being inoculated after the bubonic plague outbreak, Bombay, circa 1897. | Wellcome Library archive collection

Over 100 years later, on 1 March, 2020, the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 as a pandemic, following which the Modi government announced its decision to invoke the Epidemic Diseases (ED) Act, 1897.

Though the exodus is hardly comparable, there have been many reported instances of people fleeing from quarantine, such as one involving the wife of a Bangalore Google employeetwo persons who fled from Jammu, and an American couple from Kerala, all in this month. Section 3 of the Epidemic Diseases Act allows authorities to deem the violation of a regulation to be an offence punishable under Section 188 of the Indian Penal Code. Eventually, the wife and father-in-law of the Google employee was booked under the Epidemic Diseases Act for resisting quarantine and non-cooperation with health officials.

The startling historical conditions that led to the implementation of the Epidemic Diseases Act also saw the creation of an early infrastructure of medical surveillance, involving plague passports, exemption certificates, plague inoculation certificates and above all, detentions.

This infrastructure of medical surveillance was then extended to the presidencies and provinces such as Bengal, Madras, Delhi, Punjab, Central Provinces, and the city of Bangalore in Mysore Residency. Such surveillance was marked by all too common ‘epidemics’ of rumour, official flows of misinformation and a frequent subversion of this infrastructure. Medical surveillance and fake news, quack science, and social panics have resurfaced in similar forms in 2020.


Also read: Karnataka’s Kalaburagi first district to be locked down after India’s first COVID-19 death


How the Epidemic Diseases Act abetted medical surveillance

While the deaths due to COVID-19 have risen globally to 10,405, they nowhere resemble the numbers that the vicious bubonic plague claimed of Indian lives, a staggering 12 million at least across the two decades after 1896.

It is the bubonic plague, caused by the recalcitrant rat flea, and manifesting itself in the form of buboes or swollen lymph nodes, nausea, and fever, that prompted the colonial government of the time to pass the Epidemic Diseases Act. In addition, authorities added ‘bubonic fever’ to the list of infectious or contagious disorders in the Indian Railways Act, 1895.

The combination of both these moves authorised expansive and stringent medical examination and surveillance that included dispatching medical officers for door-to-door examination of bodies, detain and segregate plague suspects at railway stations and ports, and the scrutiny of corpses. In Bombay Presidency, a painstaking system of railways surveillance entailed the creation of certificates of health that attested to the health of all the passengers and railway staff, while Bills of Health signed by the port Health Officers cleared passengers and crew from bubonic plague for travel on steamers. Today, we have the Maharashtra government stamping the left hand of all those who have been sent to home quarantine with indelible ink as a means of curbing the rising trend of fleeing suspects.

In the late 19th century, colonial medical opinion on the extent of stringency to be used varied. The historian, Valeska Huber has argued that colonial medical policy relied to some degree on the strictures of the delegates of the 1897 Venice International Sanitary Conference. These delegates wished the colonial surveillance regime to resemble ‘semi-permeable membranes’ that adopted selective policing rather than be one that was a rigid cordon sanitaire. This meant that colonial authorities were expected to restrict the mobility of certain groups and individuals like the Hajj pilgrim while keeping the borders ‘permeable’ for others.

Authorities disinfecting plague patients in wooden tubs, Karachi, 1897. | Wellcome Library archive collection
Authorities disinfecting plague patients in wooden tubs, Karachi, 1897. | Wellcome Library archive collection

In the early days after the outbreak, these ideas enjoyed some credence in Bombay Presidency. Third class passengers were examined on the platform, while second class passengers were examined in their carriages, and first class passengers were usually exempted altogether. In Central Provinces, the Chief Commissioner issued orders to not detain all third class passengers, but those ‘regarded by reason of their appearance, by symptoms or dirty conditions of their clothes and effects’. Rather than cancel religious fairs, seen to be glaring sites of potential mass infection, officials often sought to cancel third class railway tickets as they did with the Urs fair held at a dargah in Ajmer in the year 1898.

Medical control was exercised through a bevy of regionally variable identification documents. Madras Presidency introduced plague passports issued to the traveler after she or he had undergone examination and disinfection over 10 days, Bombay Presidency, Bengal Presidency and Punjab issued anti-plague inoculation certificates to those who underwent inoculation. Bombay Presidency issued exemption certificates to those who could provide certificates of health from employers and doctors, permits to regular travelers across causeways after a census, and passes to migrants.


Also read: 1994 Surat plague has many lessons for India on how to beat coronavirus


A bag of assorted tricks

Unsurprisingly, a colorful panoply of petitions, rumour, innuendo, forgery, and a bag of assorted tricks greeted Plague Officers rendering certain practices untenable. If authorities thought they should catch fleeing plague railway suspects, passengers decided that they may as well make the officials run. In response to the practice of plague-marking railway tickets of those who had boarded at infected stations on the Bombay Baroda and Central India (BBCI) Railway Line and the Great Indian Peninsular Railway Line (GIPR), passengers would alight at a station en route and book fresh tickets. And while authorities caught on to this trick and came up with fresh orders to prohibit alighting and booking at intermediate stations, these government regulations caused unspeakable confusion. In some places, such official practices were given up because they were not worth the bother.

The tricks, however, refused to exhaust themselves owing to the large remit of caste, religious taboos and untouchability. The Parsi medical scientist and doctor attached to the Arthur Road Hospital of Bombay during the plague, N.H Choksy wrote that families ended up abandoning, concealing or indiscriminately throwing out their suffering relatives.

These pre-emptive antics were the byproduct of fear of caste pollution, resulting from quarantine in common hospital wards, as well as autopsy and dissection. Procedures such as the insistence on death certificates before corpses could be buried were silently relaxed owing to the simmering anger that the European touching of corpses provoked. Historian David Arnold, in an article titled Touching the Body: Perspectives on the Indian Plague 1896-1900, cites the 6 April 1897 issue of Tilak’s Marathi newspaper Kesari, to narrate the story of a Brahmin who had to live on milk while in hospital because the food had been polluted by a Shudra’s touch. There was outrage against closure of the Hindu Plague hospital, where caste observances were respected, and appreciation for the setting up of caste-based hospitals, 30 of which came up by early 1898.

Waves of rumour crashed against just about every medical move of surveillance but particularly those intended at achieving a success rate of inoculation. When the Russian bacteriologist Waldemar Haffkine came up with an inoculation fluid capable of producing resistance to plague, he first tested it on himself and then on the inmates of the Byculla prison in Bombay. But this could not stem the flow of fast-flying rumours that inoculation induced infertility, and so, authorities had to take to calling on a crop of medical practitioners such as vaids and hakims, ‘native gentlemen’ including Tilak and Aga Khan, as volunteers for inoculation.

Printed on the inoculation certificate were several ‘incentives’ such as 4 annas, a day off from work, and exemption from detention for 6 months. W.L. Harvey, the Municipal Commissioner of Bombay in 1900, noted that some Indians underwent inoculation as many as 10-30 times in light of these incentives.

While the colonial establishment complained, these practices must not be seen purely as Indians causing misinformation, but also as providing critical information of socio-cultural prisms such as caste through which Indians act.

Besides, colonial officials were themselves guilty of a chaos of medical doctrines that prevailed, with miasma theory (or the theory that epidemics spread through noxious fumes emerging from cesspools, open drains, slums) firmly ensconcing itself until the arrival of Haffkine’s prophylactic. Bacteriologist Robert Koch, who discovered the cholera bacillus, was greeted with hostility by British administrators like the Sanitary Commissioner J.M. Cuningham, who felt that these findings would engender unnecessary medical quarantines and embargoes on international trade. Limewashing of buildings and eviction of slum residents continued apace even after inoculation was conceived.


Also read: China’s love for wildlife meat to its authoritarianism — how coronavirus got out of hand


Right Wing bio-politics and COVID-19

As we consider the medley of medical surveillance, official medical misinformation and manipulation, it is hard to ignore similar contemporary trends manifest in gaumutra squads, WhatsApp messengers of fake news, and fleeing relatives fearful of government hospitals. Authorities at Delhi’s Nigambodh Ghat refused to carry out the cremation of the only woman to have died in Delhi. Even when an AIIMS doctor, and other high-profile experts asserted that the disease spreads only through ‘respiratory secretion’, which a dead body cannot generate, such fears abound, with state administrations not able to dispel fears.

A scholar of technology and society, Zeynep Tufekci notes, ‘the coronavirus revealed authoritarianism’s fatal flaw’ under Xi Jinping’s rule of containing the disease in China through a regime of surveillance and censorship which refused crucial information shared by whistleblowers and social media. In contrast, the Indian government has enabled misinformation through other means of right-wing bio-politics.

The Akhil Bharat Hindu Mahasabha was recently allowed to host a party where they peddled medical knowledge that drinking gaumutra or cow urine and taking a bath in cow dung would fend off the virus. Meanwhile, fake advisories such as the one touted to be by UNICEF are making the rounds on WhatsApp, urging people to not eat cold foods, frequently wash their clothes, with others calling for the heavy intake of Vitamin C. Popular YouTube channels such as Prajapati News (with 6.21 million subscribers) are showing the virus resulted from a leak in a Chinese government lab experiment intended to attack rival nations.

While the government does little to counter such fake news, it has also encouraged gaumutra theories (through the advocacy of individual BJP party members) as well as the efficacy of homeopathy and other herbal treatments (through the aegis of the AYUSH Ministry). In the face of all this, the imposition of the Epidemic Diseases Act to enforce colonial rule-styled medical surveillance and punishments can only go so far. Hence, investing in a system of public health that improves universal faith in, and access to, government hospitals is essential.

Tarangini Sriraman teaches history and politics at Azim Premji University, Bengaluru. Views are personal.

ThePrint is now on Telegram. For the best reports & opinion on politics, governance and more, subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel.

4 Comments Share Your Views

4 COMMENTS

  1. What was India before the Bits and the Mughas ? Indians moved in a loin clot hand shat from trees and used leaves as toilet paper

    All that the Indians have achieved is due to the whiteman ! That is the record of History ! dindooohindoo

    The Hindoo “owe it all” to the “Whiteman with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair”

    The “Hindoo Gods and the Inspiration” for the Hindoo ” of the “RigVeda” are all “Whitemen with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair” (Like Limpet Limpdick Indra etc)
    It was the white Scythians with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair, who”brought horses and chariots”, into the shit hole of Dindoosthan, for the Hindoo
    It was the white Romans with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair,who built the “gold chest” of the Hindoo (by importing the shit silk and spices)
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair,from whom the Hindoo “copied the chronology of all the Kings of the Puranas”
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair,like the “Greeks and others”, from whom the Hindoo “learnt about Krishna ”
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes from whom the Hindoo learnt about “animal worship – Nandi and Jallikattu”
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes,from Persia, from whom the Hindoo learnt about “Fire Worship and the concept of the soul” and the “land of Persia” , described in the “Rig veda” as the “land of the Aryans”
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes from whom the Hindoo learnt about “astronomy and the basics of the movements, of the planets and stars”
    It was the “French and American Generals” (General Jean Baptiste Ventura and Jean Francois Allard) in the army of Ranjit Singh which won the Khalsa wars – with EU artillery and cavary – else there would have been, no Khalsa Military success, ever
    If the French and American Generals “had not been” in the army of Ranjit Singh, the “Khalsa would have been destroyed by the Mughals”, before the Brits raped the Khalsa,and the “Mughals would have gained in strength, to drive out the Brits” – converting the Hindoo into Muslims
    It was the “Brits who destroyed the Mughals” – else these Hindoo would be Muslims toay
    It was the Brits who “taught English” to the Hindoo
    It was the Brits who laid down the “education,railways, administrative and bureaucractic process”,for these Hindoo ( sample the Engineering Skills)

    It was the Brits who “planned,structured and executed the army and airforce”, for these Hindoo
    It was the Brits who “brought modern science” to these Hindoo
    It was the Brits who “institutionalised the Martial Race Theory”,in the Military
    It was the Brits who “educated Ambedkar, who wrote the constitution” for the Hindoo
    It was the Brits who “educated and trained Gandhi” and “built him into a Global Icon and Brand” – else the Hindoo /Africans, would have devoured Gandhi,a long time ago
    It was the Brits who taught the Hindoo “how to eat with a spoon and a fork ”
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair,who brought the”condom” the Hindoo
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair from Communist Russia – who “gifted all the space and military technology”, to the Hindoo and built the infrastructure for the Hindoo
    It was a Whiteman with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair,”Max Mueller”who introduced the Hindoo to the world
    It is the Whiteman with Blue Eyes and Golden Hair from Communist Russia,who “prevented the rape and pillage” of the Hindoo by the “Chinese and the Pakistanis”
    Which is Y the “Hindoo are only fit” to “drink Gau Mutram” – which is Cow Piss Cola

  2. Hindu Plague, Parsi Plague Hospital, Muhammadan Plague Hospital were established in Poona on official encouragement and patronage. Bal Gandadhar Tilak was a moving spirit behind establishment of Hindu Plague Hospital. It’s admission rule barred admission of the low caste in the hospital despite plague afflication. When Charles Rand, Plague Commissioner and Lieutenant Ayesrt, on plague duty were assassinated by Damodar, Bal Krishna and others bogey of patriotism sounds strange to cover up the heinuous crime.
    Result millions, more than official reports admit, were carried off by plague. Why those deaths never ever raised questions or concerns in Indian minds?
    If few killers of highbreed were considered greater and precious than millions of Indians, the motive of the nationalists is doubtful and pernicious. Radical change in outlook and analysis are most urgently warranted.

  3. India is a diverse, poor and large country with its own rich history. One chapter was its slavery for thousands of years. Now we are free but why the eff do we keep talking about the US lap dog which was involved in a sad chapter of Indian history. It provides no educative value and looking at it as a model will be a cruel joke. Wale up India. Build your own self esteem and screw the bad past.

    • Pop psychology aside, Indians have to cope and develop. Psychology does zilch towards developing country. Screw them. If denial is a coping mechanism, so be it.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here