scorecardresearch
Friday, March 29, 2024
Support Our Journalism
HomeOpinionIt’s hard to be optimistic about Congress. Easier to praise leaders like...

It’s hard to be optimistic about Congress. Easier to praise leaders like Tejashwi Yadav

Narendra Modi wins largely because the Congress does not know how to stop him

Follow Us :
Text Size:

There are three ways in which central governments lose elections in India. The first and most common is that voters turn against them. This is what happened to Indira Gandhi in 1977 and to the Congress again in 2014.

The second way is if voters feel that an opposition alternative is far more attractive than the incumbent. That is probably what helped the BJP sweep the polls in 2014 on the basis of Narendra Modi’s popularity in North India. When two of these factors combine (as they did in 2014) the incumbent government goes down with a humiliating defeat.

The third way is arithmetic. An arithmetic calculation is the sole basis for all the hype about opposition unity over the last few weeks. The argument goes something like this: the BJP’s vote share is only around 35 to 37 per cent. But it won landslides because the opposition was divided. Suppose the 60 per cent of India that did not vote for the BJP came together? Wouldn’t a united opposition candidate be able to defeat BJP in each constituency?

It is this argument that is at the root of all the stories we read every day in the papers. Is Sharad Pawar doing a side deal with the BJP? Will Nitish lead a united opposition? Will the Congress agree to be part of an Opposition alliance where it is not regarded as the senior partner? And so on.

These questions are hard enough to answer. But they are also based on a flawed argument. Yes, the BJP’s national vote share may hover at around 37 per cent. But that’s not the important figure. There are large parts of India (much of the South, for instance) where the BJP is not a serious electoral player. Nor does it contest every seat.

The important figure is the vote share for the areas in which the BJP wins its seats. And in such states as Uttar Pradesh — which it sweeps — it has the same vote share (41.29 per cent in the last assembly election when people were not even being asked to vote for Narendra Modi) as any party that has ever won the state.


Also Read: BJP has done a huge favour to Rahul Gandhi — gifted him his lost credibility


Regional equations

The problem with all talk of opposition unity is that many if not most of the parties that want to unite are essentially regional in character. Assume for the purposes of argument that Sharad Pawar and Nitish Kumar do unite. Even then, an alliance with Pawar will not help Nitish win a single extra seat and vice-versa.

Yes, a show of opposition unity may help in convincing voters that if Narendra Modi is defeated the regional parties could come together to form a stable coalition. But we are a long way from that and anyway judging by present performance, nobody is going to be very convinced about the stability of any future coalition.

Besides, as veteran psephologist Yashwant Deshmukh points out, the various regional parties have been fighting the BJP quite effectively already in their own states and it hasn’t been enough to force a change at the national level. The key to defeating Narendra Modi depends on two factors.

The first is UP, where the BJP picks up such a high proportion of the seats that its rise to power is much easier. UP’s politicians don’t need to be persuaded of the need to forge an alliance. Take Akhilesh Yadav. He linked up with the Congress and ran a joint campaign with Rahul Gandhi in the 2017 assembly election. That did not work. The SP aligned with the BSP in the last Lok Sabha election. That didn’t work either: the BJP won both times.

The problem as Akhilesh Yadav and the SP have discovered is that politics is about more than arithmetic. Voters are not always willing to transfer their loyalties. Just because the BSP has aligned with the SP, it does not follow that all of the BSP’s voters will now vote for the SP.

So, it is hard to see how opposition unity can do too much damage to the BJP in UP. All the alliances have been tried. And they have failed. For the BJP’s numbers to go down significantly in UP, voters would have to be attracted to a better electoral alternative — which is unlikely because it is going to be the same old faces in the fray. Or the BJP’s popularity has to come down. So far, at least, there is no sign of that happening.


Also Read: Prashant Kishor is right. Modi’s nationalist pitch makes him undefeatable, not Hindutva


Reviving the Congress

That leaves us with the elephant in the room: the Congress. The truth is that opposition unity can do only minimal damage to the BJP. The best way to dent the BJP’s chances of pulling off a third landslide is to electorally revive the Congress.

As Yashwant Deshmukh points out, there are up to 200 seats where the battle is really between the BJP and the Congress. One reason why the BJP wins general elections is because the Congress offers no real resistance in those seats. In Madhya Pradesh, for instance, the BJP won 28 of the state’s 29 seats (the Congress won just one).

If the Congress is able to revive itself and give a good fight to the BJP in states such as MP, Rajasthan, Gujarat, and Maharashtra, it could severely reduce the number of BJP MPs in the next Lok Sabha. It might not be enough to keep Modi from taking office but it would either reduce his majority or make him dependent on allies.

But can the Congress do it? The rest of the opposition does not believe so. It is now a hallmark of opposition behaviour to make fun of the Congress and to ridicule it for its temerity in believing that as the only national player, it must be treated as the senior partner in any alliance. Even AAP, which was humiliated by the BJP at the last Lok Sabha election, feels that it has the moral right to push the Congress around.

Much of this is the Congress’ own fault. Over the last few years, it has committed ritual hara-kiri in state after state in full public view. Not only has it failed to effectively oppose the BJP it has also, out of sheer stupidity, taken states such as Punjab where it was strong, gift-wrapped them and ceremonially presented them to AAP. In states such as Gujarat where it was showing signs of revival, it lost interest halfway through the process and threw it all away.

So yes, it is hard to be optimistic about the Congress. It is much easier to praise someone like Tejashwi Yadav who will at least reduce the BJP’s numbers in Bihar.

The Congress’s leaders say, in its defence, that after the Bharat Jodo Yatra, the party is on the road to revival. Perhaps it is. And if that is indeed the truth it will hurt the BJP much more than any temporary peace between squabbling regional leaders and the chances of opposition unity.

But as long as the Congress fails to put up an effective fight even a united opposition can do the BJP very little harm.

Narendra Modi wins largely because the Congress does not know how to stop him.

Vir Sanghvi is a print and television journalist, and talk show host. He tweets @virsanghvi. Views are personal.

(Edited by Theres Sudeep)

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular