Illustration by Arindam Mukherjee | ThePrint Team
Illustration by Arindam Mukherjee | ThePrint Team
Text Size:

The Prime Minister has drawn attention to the fact that only 1.5 crore people in India pay income tax. He is right to complain, since more than that number buy two-wheelers in a year. The two-wheeler population is about 18 crore. The cheapest scooters cost about Rs 50,000, and the more popular models cost over Rs 65,000. It is therefore not unreasonable to expect that someone earning enough to own a scooter or motorbike should be paying income tax. Unfortunately, less than 10 per cent do.

So Narendra Modi is right to complain, but he is the wrong person to be doing it. For, while Modi puts the blame on citizens for the small number paying tax, asking them to pay taxes honestly, he should also be blaming himself or his finance minister of 2019, who in the run-up to the Lok Sabha elections that year exempted from tax all those earning up to Rs 5 lakh. That allowed a reported three-quarters of all taxpayers to get out of the tax net. Pre-election giveaways are par for the course, but Modi should be conscious that it was his choice to slash the number of taxpayers from 6 crore to 1.5 crore.

International comparisons are instructive. In the US, a single person starts paying income tax at an income level of about $12,000 (approx. Rs 8.6 lakh), which closely parallels the level of the poverty line for an individual. Couples filing together must earn twice that before they are obliged to pay tax. Importantly, the tax-paying threshold is about $25,000 (Rs 17.9 lakh) for a four-member family, broadly the same level as the poverty line for such a family. There is logic to these numbers. The implicit principle seems to be that once you are above the poverty line, you should pay tax. That is the picture in the UK as well. While the country has many definitions of poverty, tax kicks in at broadly the level of poverty line income, which is about £12,000 (Rs 11.2 lakh).


Also read: Modi hasn’t done so badly on the economy. But more needs to be done on many fronts


Compare this with India, where the tax-paying threshold is now multiples of the income for a family at the poverty line. It is also twice the level of the household income for an average family of four, at about Rs 2.5 lakh. This figure was in fact the tax threshold until a year ago, before it was doubled to Rs 5 lakh. The primary problem, therefore, is not with the taxpayer; rather, it is with the tax rules that have taken the tax threshold to much too high a level. You would quadruple the number of people paying tax if the tax threshold were to be reverted to its earlier level.

There is an issue with the tax rates as well. India starts with 5 per cent, whereas in Britain the lowest rate of tax is 20 per cent. In the US, it is 10 per cent at the federal level, plus varying rates at state levels. Here, according to the latest rules, you have to reach Rs 10 lakh, or four times the annual income of an average family of four, before you start paying tax at 20 per cent. The fact is that income tax rates in India kick in at too high an income level, and at unusually low rates.

We are deeply grateful to our readers & viewers for their time, trust and subscriptions.

Quality journalism is expensive and needs readers to pay for it. Your support will define our work and ThePrint’s future.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

The government’s other failure, it would seem, has been to carry through the cross-checking of tax returns with the spending and saving habits of the individual concerned — like foreign travel, vehicle ownership, and level of electricity consumption. Since the permanent income tax number has to be disclosed for most high-value transactions, effective cross-checking should have been able to catch most tax evaders. While it is indeed true that demonetisation and other measures sharply increased the number filing tax returns, the overall situation today is manifestly disappointing.

The Prime Minister is therefore right in what he said. But it is his government that has added to the problem. And it is in its power to change the situation — if it has the stomach to ignore the inevitable howls of protest from a very vocal middle-class.


Also read: How a reform on Modi govt agenda can protect your deposits & keep banks from failing


 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

News media is in a crisis & only you can fix it

You are reading this because you value good, intelligent and objective journalism. We thank you for your time and your trust.

You also know that the news media is facing an unprecedented crisis. It is likely that you are also hearing of the brutal layoffs and pay-cuts hitting the industry. There are many reasons why the media’s economics is broken. But a big one is that good people are not yet paying enough for good journalism.

We have a newsroom filled with talented young reporters. We also have the country’s most robust editing and fact-checking team, finest news photographers and video professionals. We are building India’s most ambitious and energetic news platform. And we aren’t even three yet.

At ThePrint, we invest in quality journalists. We pay them fairly and on time even in this difficult period. As you may have noticed, we do not flinch from spending whatever it takes to make sure our reporters reach where the story is. Our stellar coronavirus coverage is a good example. You can check some of it here.

This comes with a sizable cost. For us to continue bringing quality journalism, we need readers like you to pay for it. Because the advertising market is broken too.

If you think we deserve your support, do join us in this endeavour to strengthen fair, free, courageous, and questioning journalism, please click on the link below. Your support will define our journalism, and ThePrint’s future. It will take just a few seconds of your time.

Support Our Journalism

36 Comments Share Your Views

36 COMMENTS

  1. What bullshit article is this. Blaming the government for giving relief to the middle class. Why not ask the freeloaders of the country to do something for themselves.

  2. You have to feel ashamed to write like this. You are comparing USA and Europe for the incometax rates. In those countries, all the people will pay incometax. But in our country, only salaried people will pay taxes genuinely, remaining all are not paying as per the actual income. Those countries are giving free education upto 12 th class and giving unemployment allowance. You are asking government to collect taxes from poor people. Shame

  3. How many were paying income taxbefore 2014 and what is increase in the number of tax payers during 2004 to 2014 ?

  4. In most of the developed countries MLM industry boost their economy because this industry is clear through channel business and pays the Tax in advance. According to the reports and calculations India is very behind in promoting this industry.

    After 73 years of independence the rulers of India is closing their eyes towards this industry.

  5. Income tax department is not equipped to assess the real income of professionals like doctors, engineers, builders, lawyers etc who hide their real income.As soon as they acquire a new asset like real estate,luxury cars, gadgets, or undertake costly foreign tours there should be a mechanism to know the source of income and if such income is taxed earlier. But middle class is an easy target and will accept anything with a murmur. Less said about the politicians better. Finally who eats our tax? Does it reach the poor through welfare measures or eaten by middle men and politicians?

  6. SHEKHAR GUPTA YOU KNOW ALL WHY WHERE AND HOW BUT YOU TOO WANT YOUR DOUBLE BREAD AND BUTTER BUT SHAME MONEY COMES FIRST FOR YOU THAN COUNTRY

  7. Ninan why you anti India compare USA with India look at their system do they have all type of schedule classes where Indian Gov. shell out billions ?
    how many Gov. VVIP ARE THERE SEE HERE MORE THAN 5 LAKHS COUNT THEIR PERKS AND FACILITIES WHO IS PAYING YOU AND ME MAY BE NOT YOU
    Previous Gov. layed down many perks for them free phone free electricity free house security gas free travelling in plane train free petrol and list is endless AND YES WAIT THIS gOV. WILL STOP OR REDUCE ALL THIS EXPENSES PROVIDED YOU MEDIA STOP CRITICIZING AND BE FAITHFUL TO COUNTRY PLEASE THINK BEFORE YOU WRITE AND IF YOU ARE DUFFER THEN CHECK gOOGLE

  8. This article is incredulous. What a sham of an article and what a terrible prognosis and policy suggestion. It’s so superficial even a comment is a waste of time. But let’s indulge the author shall we? As long as India’s politicians practice welfare, keep our economic shoe laces tied and provide poor public goods, this will continue. Successive Indian Governments are like the Nizam of Hyderabad – A Rich king presiding over a poor populace. When they demolish the welfare state, dismantle sanctuaries of the poor, stop calling the middle class whiners, implement superior governance, then people will queue up to pay taxes. Not like this. Why would anyone pay taxes when it is all being squandered away? How many decades will we pay to carry the baggage of bad governance and the stubbornness of people who don’t want to change and instead choose to live on handouts?

  9. You look arrogant, when you call the prime minister of the country just Modi. Does it take a lot to add PM in front? Or it’s something you don’t want to use? Please note, that you have to respect the position, even if you hate the bearer! And lastly, the article is rubbish.

  10. Our useless govt double or triple taxes salaried class, eg TDS on salary, GST on consumed items, foreign travel and remittance to students abroad etc. Why the same govt does not tax rich farmers, politicians and many other religious institutions?

  11. Wosrtever article. Please don’t compare US, UK governance with India they provide all the basic facilities education, health and social security in return of getting tax. But in india if some middle class loose his job he has to sell his house to survive. Govt will not say hey you paid tax I will help you.

  12. Worst ever article. Please don’t compare US, UK governance with India they provide all the basic facilities education, health and social security in return of getting tax. But in india if some middle class loose his job he has to sell his house to survive. Govt will not say hey you paid tax I will help you.

  13. I am a retired person, but still I pay tax on the amount that I get from interest earned from different investment. But what I get. How many politicians pay tax. Income tax should be abolished. Collect expenditure tax, tax on more than one house, more than one car, more than 2 children. Nothing should be given free to politicians. They should pay for accommodation, electricity, traveling. There should not be pension for politicians. Bureocrates should travel in economy class only.

  14. Government are misusing our taxes.if you see the structure of allowances given to a politician, you will never agree to pay taxes.I will tell you a thing which is basic, it is out mobile phone, unlimited calling in whole india was for Rs 149 per month and politicians get Rs 30000 per month for two connections.why we pay taxes if our taxes does benifit us.

  15. Of course comparisons are instructive. And everything is the fault of the, “vocal middle class” !!

    The high income countries spends in excess of 5% of their GDP on healthcare. India spends less than the average low income country.

    Same story with education. We spend abysmally low on education compared to some of the countries whose tax rates experts are fond of comparing ours with. The quality of our education ? Ah lets not go there !

    We pay road taxes and drive on roads that represent bomb craters. Of course, it is our fault.

    We pay cess for basic sanitation and cleanliness and end up having public places a garbage dumping grounds.

    Sure – we should include more individuals in the tax net. And how do we do that ? By squeezing the last drop out of a class that is already being bled dry by a combination of direct and indirect taxes. We won’t talk about rich farmers earning in crores who pay less taxes than a software engineer earning a few lakhs. We wont talk about tax breaks to corporate fat cats, never mind the fact that they are unable to demonstrate any visible growth or employment creation. But we won’t talk about these groups. They are helpless without any power to influence. All the problems are due to the , “vocal middle class”.

    Yes, Mr. Ninan, comparisons are very instructive indeed !!

  16. The writer is supporting tax evaders & wants people who have income of 2to 5 lacks to be taxed which is peanut income for middle class what about professionalscommercial rent earners & top businessmen who earning crores how much they are declaring? It is right time to abolish income tax for middle class & catch big tax evaders.

  17. TN Ninan love to preach Modi but hate to support Modi doing the same things suggested by Ninan. This is the usual trick used by people whose job start and end with preaching. All of the previous opinion posts of Ninan just do preaching only to Modi as if he alone has to work and all opposition should pull his legs and then abuse and accuse him.

  18. Taking into account the widespread reach of GST on every citizen who makes any transaction and also the very low poverty line, it looks fair enough if the tax rates are lower here in India. WHy make middle and lower income groups pay IT when they are already contributing handsomely to the economy via GST ?

    But as the author says, someone must remind the PM that it is the freebies of the BJP GOvt that has taken many millions out of the tax net. They need not have done this.

  19. So, according to this wise experienced journalist, Rs.5 lakh is too high a level and five percent is too low a level of tax. The remedy is to emulate West, eh? If 20% is fixed for Rs.5 lakhs plus slab, straight away, Rs 1 lakh income is lost. For someone earning Rs.20 lakhs a year or more loss of Rs.1 lakh hurts less, than when compared to someone earning Rs. 5 lakhs. India is following progressive taxation policy – higher the income, more tax you pay. Arm chair advice is always easy to dispense.

  20. 1. Though it is easy to make comparison, on subject of taxpayers’ base with other countries, it is not logical to do so. Further, if number of individual Income Taxpayers is abysmally low, successive governments in the Centre have to be held accountable for this state of affairs. 2. I also believe that tax evasion may be just one of many reasons of the lower number of taxpayers. Better tax compliance can be achieved if all stakeholders- Union Finance ministry, Central Board of Direct Taxes and Income Tax Department (ITD)–come together and show administrative will to ensure that the ITD officials work in a professional and efficient manner. 3. I think the ITD has to make appropriate and intelligent use of modern technology to widen taxpayers’ base. 4. Incidental observations: (a) Even as efforts are made to increase taxpayers and revenue, we must discuss how tax revenue needs to be utilized. Past experience tells us that when government earns more tax revenue, bureaucracy finds way to spend it rather unwisely. (b) It is an open secret that tax-free agricultural income is a very effective vehicle used by politicians, government officials and of course business community to evade tax. No political party has shown courage to tax agricultural income or to close loopholes in our tax law provisions which make tax avoidance/evasion quite easy. (c) My last observation is that to minimize scope for tax evasion and to improve fiscal discipline, particularly of indirect taxes, there should be good coordination between the Central and State governments. Unfortunately, there is very little cooperation today and that leaves scope for tax evasion.

  21. By definition, a government that makes you pay tax at $12,0,00 Rs 72,000 bankrupt. No one can live on Rs.6000 per month and pay tax in
    India. The writer is a cuckoo blindly comparing a country that is 132 out of 192 countries in world with the same yardstick.

  22. This exemption is given under Section 87A. Previously, it was up to Rs.3,50,000/-. Now it is extended up to Rs.5 Lakh. Not a great deal. However, the government has to think twice before extending any tax benefit. Whatever is afforded, it is very difficult to withdraw it later. This is bound to cause resentment.

  23. Yes increasing the income tax exemption limit must equalised to an amount worked out by standard formula of four family members
    Who has been below poverty lines??
    Surprising even rickshawala rehriwala washerman has good savings in their banks
    I have seen many times such poor people depositing cash daily
    Each one has chunks of agricultural lands in village
    Thirdly auch people’ enjoy freebies like free school education meals there books bags uniform free all

    By no stretch of imagination such people could be termed as below poverty line
    Each one must pay taxes though five percent or lump sum
    Government shouldn’t give freebies to anyone
    Important field is to tap agriculture

  24. Not sure if the US and UK are apt comparisons considering what they give back to citizens in terms of healthcare, education, law and order etc. Additionally Indians pay some of the highest indirect taxes, which kick in irrespective of income. Most importantly India is a low trust country where government distrusts citizens and vice versa. Add to this the complexity, venality and unfairness of the tax system puts off even the most motivated tax payer.

  25. So Mr Ninan, the expert, whose fault it was for 70 years that the number was not even this. Also Modi. Psuedo intellectuals like you have no solutions except complains .

  26. you have given your spin to the modi’ s statement . Modi was not talking about the threshold but for whom who constitute upper class like khan market people. as he speak about only 2200 professionals who declare their income 1 crore or above.

  27. Uk has free healthcare. Better infrastructure. In India none of this is provided and you want to increase the tax . There should be no increase in tax, without benefits to those who are paying. First stop corruption in government and government offices, prove that my existing tax money is being honestly used, rather than being swindled away. Make sure things can get done in govt offices without giving bribe. Then talk about increasing taxes.

  28. I believe that Modi had in mind the tax evading nature of Indians rather than the absolute number of tax payers, though he sought to make his point by referring to the number. Whatever Tinan says is factual but as a strategy, it is not worth wasting time and incurring cost on Income Tax collection. But we need to think out of box on this issue.

    We should abolish Income Tax as it stands completely but substitute with an asset tax to be determined based on the average market value of financial and real estate assets of a person in. Government has all the details through Aadhar and PAN cards and knows the value of financial assets like shares, bonds etc and real estate through government rates table. The IT Department can collate the data and send the e-notice and collect taxes with minimal administrative cost. The threshold could be set at say 2 crores and tax could be levied at say, 0.5% of the average total market value of the assets during the year. This will simplify lot of issues and yet government can hope to get lot of revenue with minimal cost and pain to the tax payer.

    If Modi could think of demonitization and pull it off politically, why he cannot do this in the name of poor?

    • If there are only assets and no income, whether Department will collect taxes by selling them. … Many individuals also have Non-performing assets like Banks

  29. I’m a tax payer who pays few lacks as incometax every year. That being said, I strongly disagree with Mr/Mrs TN Ninan. Why the small fish?! What happened to the buyers of ultra luxury/luxury/sadan/hatchback car buyers in India. What is the average income-tax payed by those? If you know the numbers your jaw will drop. Let the country take a fair share of tax in an efficient manner before thinking of sucking the blood out of those who just crossed the poverty level & by the way the poverty line is what? Rs. 27,000 per annum? What The Fork?!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here