The situation in eastern Ladakh at the face-off points between Indian Army and the PLA–Pangong Tso, Hot Springs and Galwan river–remains unchanged from what I wrote in my last column in ThePrint. By now, the additional formations that would have been inducted by both sides to cater to escalation and further operations as per respective operational strategies, would have fully acclimatised to operate in these high-altitude regions.
Officially, both sides have been restrained in their statements and reiterated faith in diplomacy. Defence minister Rajnath Singh has said that diplomatic and military-level talks as per existing border management mechanism are in progress. While harping on “differing perceptions” about the Line of Actual Control (LAC), Singh said the Chinese presence along the LAC was in “achhi khasi sankhya (sizeable numbers)”. Major General-level talks have been conducted on 2 June and Lieutenant General-level, that is, talks at the level of Corps Commanders, are scheduled on 6 June.
China now has an upper hand in talks
Having seized the initiative by securing approximately 40-60 square km of Indian territory in three different areas, China will be negotiating from a position of strength and will try to impose unacceptable conditions–no further development of border infrastructure on the Indian side–to restore status quo on its own terms. If diplomacy fails, China has come prepared for a border skirmish or a limited war.
India’s task is cut out. It has to ensure that status quo ante 1 April, 2020 prevails for quasi sanctification of the “un-demarcated” LAC, so that China does not advance similar claims in future to gain tactical advantage and embarrass/humiliate India at will. If it cannot be done diplomatically, then it must be done by force. However, rather than evolving a clear strategy and broadly sharing it with the nation, the Narendra Modi government and the military have gone into ‘denial’ about any loss of territory, attributing the present situation to differing perceptions about the LAC.
Some journalists and activists are also busy peddling their interpretation of the alignment of the LAC to prove that no territory has been seized by China. A perception is being built for diplomatic acquiescence. What else does China want? We are playing into its hands.
I explain the ground situation in the three areas where loss of territory has taken place and analyse the dangers of justifying the loss to “differing perceptions of the LAC”.
Also read: ‘Unprecedented’ — India, China deploy Lt Gen-rank army officers to solve border row
Pattern of defence in Ladakh
The term LAC is not demarcated through a formal agreement, either side can vary in its perception. And this has remained the case despite the numerous confidence building agreements signed since 1993, and two informal summits. Out of the 857-km-long border in Ladakh, only 368 km is international border (IB) and the rest of the 489 km is the LAC. This was the line reached by China in 1962, which is exactly as per its 1960 claim line.
It is a treacherous high-altitude terrain with the valley height being 14,000 – 15,000 ft and hill features being at heights of 16,000-18,000 ft. The main defences cannot be physically located along the LAC because the terrain is not tactically suitable. These are located on the Ladakh Range, Pangong Range, along Shyok River and in the Depsang plains. The distance to the LAC varies from 10 to 80 km, depending upon the terrain. The main defences are manned by the Army and the LAC is secured by the Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP). The security of the vast spaces ahead of the main defences is ensured by covering elements deployed at selected places, mechanised forces and by physical/electronic surveillance. The ITBP posts are along the routes of ingress and in disputed areas, but are not continuous like we have on the IB in plains.
There are vast gaps between the ITBP posts along the LAC. There are areas where the ITBP posts are well short of the LAC due to lack of infrastructure. To defend the entire length of the LAC, in strength and man, the main defences, as we do at the LoC, we will require at least 4-5 divisions instead of just one that is committed now. Even in the present pattern, the ITBP strength has to increase tenfold to effectively cover the entire length along the LAC.
Also read: Not Pangong or Galwan, why India must worry about Hotsprings-Gogra region most
Pangong sector
The map shown above is at slight variation from the one in my last column based on fresh inputs.
Some journalists are misinterpreting the ‘Fingers’ north of Pangong Tso to justify the denial of loss of territory. The annotated satellite image of Google Earth above gives the correct location of the Fingers and the territory lost. In 1962, we were holding the area up to Sirijap. This was captured by the PLA in 1962 and consequently the LAC runs west of it at Finger 8, on to Ane La pass. The PLA post with a jetty (in pic above) is located east of Sirijap. Till 2011, our ITBP post was located well to the rear at Phobrang. The Chinese Claim Line is up to Finger 4. ITBP patrolled up to Finger 8 and the PLA up to Finger 4.
In 2013 – 2014 we developed a road to Finger 3 and Ane La pass. The ITBP established a new post near Finger 3 in 2013. The PLA patrols started blocking our patrols between Finger 4 and 8. The Chinese considered the establishment of the post at Finger 3 a violation of border management agreements. The frequent patrol blocking by either side led to a violent scuffle on 15 August 2017 and thereafter jostling by patrols became common. The PLA post remained at Sirijap and no post was established between Finger 4 and 8. Our patrols continued to patrol upto Finger 8.
In end April and beginning May this year, the PLA moved in regular troops and physically secured the area between Finger 4 and Finger 8 and now sits on top of Finger 4 . As per my assessment, based on my experience and media reports, the PLA has secured the entire area from Finger 8 to Finger 4, a distance of 8 km, and are overlooking our ITBP post between Finger 4 and Finger 3. It has also secured the heights along Fingers 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 up to height of 4,500 – 5,000 meters ie 4-5 km to the north. Total area secured by the PLA is 35-40 square km. The PLA has deployed one or two battalions to defend the area as marked (on Image 1) with one or two battalions as reserve at Sirijap.
Also read: India, China need to break stalemate, greater challenges ahead: Former envoy Ashok Kantha
Galwan sector
In Galwan sector, the PLA has secured the heights north and south of the Galwan river with. The PLA seems to have come across the LAC for 2-3 km in the valley and then climbed up the heights. It is also possible that it climbed the heights from China’s side of the valley and then moved along the heights westwards up to 3-4 km. What matters in mountains/ high-altitude is the control of the heights. The valleys become untenable when surrounding heights are with the enemy.
It is likely that the PLA has secured the heights with two battalions with one held as reserve at the LAC.
For the apologists of the “differing perceptions” who have theories to deny loss of territory, it is pertinent to point out that there are no differing perceptions about the LAC along the Galwan River. The intrusion here is deliberate to threaten the Darbuk-Shyok-Daulat Beg Oldie (DS-DBO) Road and prevent us from defending it by securing the Galwan valley and the heights north and south of the river.
Also read: Chinese intrusion in Galwan lasted for two weeks before it was cleared by Indian troops
Hot Springs
As per my assessment, at Hot Springs/Gogra, the PLA with nearly a battalion has almost surrounded the post and effectively denied the approach to Kongka La pass, which lies on the LAC but is not held by us. The aim here is to prevent road construction by India to the Kongka La pass. At Hot Springs and Kongka La, which is 4-5 km away from Hot Springs, there is no “differing perception” about the LAC.
Also read: Chinese intrusion in Galwan lasted for two weeks before it was cleared by Indian troops
Playing into the hands of the Chinese
The justification of “differing perceptions” is just playing into the hands of the Chinese. We are very clear about the alignment of the LAC as we have cremated/buried our comrades who were killed in action in 1962. China stopped exactly on its claim line of 1960 and our rear posts were located on this line during the ’62 War. It is the Chinese claim line that has been changing since 1950.
It should be clear to the discerning reader that to be in denial and acquiesce to explain the loss of territory to “differing perceptions” will open pandora’s box, and in future, result in loss of more territory, possibly at Chumar, Demchok, Fukche, Kailash Range, Hot Springs, along the Shyok River and in Depsang Plains. Who knows China may apply the same logic at Tawang in the near future?
China cannot be allowed to get away with usurping Indian territories like it has done till now. This confrontation must end with status quo ante 1 April, 2020 and sanctification of the LAC with formal exchange of maps. Major Shaitan Singh, PVC and Major (later Lt Col) Dhan Singh Thapa, PVC who defended Rezang La and Sirijap in 1962 and 3,000 of our soldiers who were killed in action would be very unhappy in Valhalla. They died fighting in areas that lie along the current LAC. It would be a shame if we now acquiesce to give up those areas without firing a shot using the fig leaf of “differing perceptions”.
No wonder the Chinese military strategist and philosopher Sun Tzu said some 2,500 years ago: “For to win one hundred victories in one hundred battles is not the acme of skill. To subdue the enemy without fighting is the acme of skill.”
Lt Gen H S Panag PVSM, AVSM (R) served in the Indian Army for 40 years. He was GOC in C Northern Command and Central Command. Post-retirement, he was Member of Armed Forces Tribunal. Views are personal.
When did you retire,And don’t give your opinion You are a political party worker AAP Delhi
see who is commenting so called army general, that shithead is khalistan sympathiser and wanted coup against Indian govt. Get a life !
But isnt it time that we also sometimes have “wrong perceptions” of LAC and we should also stray inside their side of LAC forcing talks like they do. Is it that our army does not have the courage or army has courage but is not sure of political backing or politicians have told army not to retaliate in similar fashion? Why this pussilanimity?
Shame on you general, India in land of warrior such as Major Chandpuri who decided to defend post against 2000 odd no. at longewala, in 1971. And you served Indian army in high ranks speaks like cowards !! Better die you shameless creature, No one could dare China what present India is doing , your favorite congress had put our nation into this difficult side today! It’s all their legacy.
Look this is an literate India , you few people cannot impose you bullshit thoughts on us, we have better judgement abilities, The print and it’s associate have set agenda to show country into bad light in every case, reason is very simple “no one bothers them” expect few frustrated pro-azadi gang. Shame on your journalism and ethics which are no use for our country.
And General once again “you are an total disgrace and disrepute to our country and army, shame on you”
It is time to declare war on china with 10 day notice to return back to 1960 border demarcation between India and China…. With The support of most powerful countries with India, now it is time to get Akshai Chin, POK and Gilgit area…. War declaration as early as possible to take advantage of situation….. First attack Pakistan and take over all POK and Akshai Chin….. China will bend for negotiation…. Take him back to pre 1960 border and also two km buffer from China area….
War is must do now…
CORRECT bro
What if you lost the war?
What if China loses the war? As a chinese you are always brainwashed by your communist party in to thinking that you have not taken others territory. Xinjiang and Tibet are not Chinese territory. And Ladakh, Gilgit also are not chinese territory. What makes you think that Chinese are an invincible people?
Where are those RSS goons or Bollywood heroes from proganda movies against Pakistan? It is time to send them to face Chinese Army. It does not help to just beat innocent people or doing action in a movie. It is now time to do some action otherwise year is 2022 and we will be watching movie called “Ek Tha India” 🙂
No tension.we shall hire pakistani terrorist
To those that say China is stronger and so we should ‘cut our losses’, what then if the Chinese come to your house next? I suppose you would prepare to pack your bags?
At what point do you say enough is enough? The whole world is sick of the chinese and fascists.
For God’s sake, grow a pair, grow a spine, and stand up.
Thank you sir HS Panag for briefing the current situation.
People abusing you in the comments are paid workers of the IT Cell, so don’t focus on 2rs per tweet paid workers, they are just trying to defend their fathers in govt.
We can just hope that whatever our government do tomorrow will be good for us!! India is already in so much chaos right now. These are some crazy times for the whole world. I don’t think anyone wants war. https://dailybugle.in/
realistic
The print you are nothing but a pathetic limpho antinational.. Shame on you.. Can you tell me for how many bucks you have sold your soul to china.. Your loyalties don’t lie with india it lies with the dragon…
Why truth gets painted se being anti national…….This article is written by a highly decorated army officer who had served in this region……Even he had become anti national for u?
Ha!! Ha!! You forget how Indians are bought like vegetables by foreign powers!! There is no nation on earth with as many Chinese planted communists, Jihadi & western planted leftists traitors!!
You couldn’t slander the author this time? Because he is ex-army and not a muslim???
Ha!! Ha!! We know the loyalty of Muslims!! All Muslim nations have even chosen to abandon Islam & Uighur Muslims in Xinjiang, China!! So they are not even faithful to their faith when it comes to their balls!!
Sir, the truth is like Modji,s 56″. Fake is like feku
Firstly we Indians never wake up unless and until someone comes and gives us 1962 or kargil….
We have this habit of getting caught off the guard….
When we started developing infrastructure in that area we should have well fortified these critical openings near LAC with China….. instead we who never learn anything from past experiences left it unguarded and hence today again in this catch 22 situation….
China simply preempted us…. now either fight this military mammoth or forget the territory….. utter failure of intelligence…..how many times we are going to repeat same and same mistake……
Another issue with us we are utterly lazy when it comes to signing defense deals on time….. so when such situation arises we are always like COUNTRY IS FEELING ABSENCE OF RAFALE…..why wasted so many years to procure in the first place???? By the time we get those weapons world already moves ahead with next generation technology…..
Why we could not procure Rafale is unfortunately we had a moron A.K.Anthony as defense minister.
In india we have ministers leave it to bureaucrats, and say we are following proper procedures.
He is more worried about his image and somebody makes some statement about corruption he will appoint committee.
Generally the minster should hold regular meetings and clear any blocks and push it fast.
He was more politician than person most ill suited to defense ministry.
An apolitical and non-judgmental view on this matter of “Chinese intrusion”
Any action is best defined by its intention. If authorities are withholding exact positions here, it is possible that this information has tactical / diplomatic ramifications, on which they are / have to act.
I fail to understand the intention of Veteran soldiers commenting in public on the actual possible ground situation(s) in the face of an enemy. How does that help the situation?
THAT is intriguing.
Well said sir!!
If the government and army are not being honest about the situation – by claiming that the current problem is merely about differing perceptions about the LAC when in fact the LAC was quite clear and the Chinese have violated it – then it is the duty of those in the know to call it out. Gen. Panag has done the right thing. It’s a very informative article and he’s absolutely right in his conclusion about what needs to be done. Our army and government must not be allowed to sweep this under the carpet. Give the Chinese an inch and they will take a mile.
Hi Ajay,
Thanks for the response.
I am a bit perplexed at your conclusion that the Army / Government is not doing anything!
Let us assume that the enemy has come into our territory. Trumpeting that publicly does not help strategically / tactically / diplomatically. On the other hand it may inhibit our response. This is NOT a cricket match for a ball by ball commentary to be broadcast to the public.
In these matters whipping up public sentiments also does not help.
Very simple to understand if someone wants to,,,, why China should shout that China has occupied indian territory,,,,, IF YOU listen to Chinese media believe me there is no mention of India in their news ,,,,why they should cry,,,,, we have lost our territory that’s why we are crying,,,, the fact is that our army and police can only fight with the people without weapons,,,,, And the government is sucking our blood to Feed this Army,,,,,when the time comes Army cannot do anything,,,,,, Shame shame shame on this ANIMAL GOVERNMENT. AND they’re changing the reality,,,,, if China did not take your land,,,,then what you want to talk with China,,,,stop fooling,,, actually this government is fooling the country because of Fools (Bhagats) ,,, If you criticise this government you are Anti National (Desh Drohi) ,,,,,, In fact Actually this government is the real Desh Drohi,,,,,,,
Your name matches well with your comment. Right on the expected line.
Yeah u are right bro
Shahabul Islam: You are a LIAR Pakistani which sold Islam & even their own Muslims to China!!
Even we have a doubt who are indian , where is india whatever we have passed long 80 years. We had forgot about kashmir, LOC line of control not actual border..anyone can come in india under the border tanel and in future able elected prime minister. Atleast on 2020 we able to find who are indians and where is india. 80 long years we pass yet ..we finding who we are!!
1947 we got our country , 1962 we lost part of country , 1967 we fought again .. since 2014 … still we dont know what is actual indian border .. LOC .. line of actual control but it is not indian border.. you cant say tibbat is ours even political forgotten kashmir is ours .. even we did not know who are indian and where is india ?
Lol
. But this time we know who are indian and definitely we able to know where is india… not LOC .. Indian border.
A tiny nation like Vietnam have taught a lesson to a super power like China
Lt Gen HS Panag (Retd) claims at initial para of the Article that China has acquired 40-50 Km at 3-4 strategic height. PLA,is now in Position of strength in bargaining. If Diplomacy fails, PLA has come prepared for border skirmishes or Limited War. Our retired Hero Lt Gen Panag does not say a word about what Indian Army is doing now? If Chinese PLA is well prepared for a Limited War or Border skirmishes, what his Indian Army is doing? Only our former Hero Lt Gen Panag( who is sitting in his house enjoying hefty army pension) knows what Chinese are doing & Indian Army does not know what our retired Hero knows. ?Lt Gen Panag think Indian Army is Just eating Nut seeds & drinking army drinks at Borders and not prepared for Limited War? Our retired Hero Mr Panag was a senior Rank Army man & was part of higher level management of Army which has been using compromising strategy with China since 1962 & now he is retired, claims as if compromising Policy with China happening after his retirement. If limited war occurs, our retired Hero Lt. Gen HS Parag must be re-called for war duty,by giving one notch higher rank & send him to war front to fight PLA army. It is easy to talk sitting in home with peg of Army whisky in hand commenting on behalf of some vested interest. People are not pools to believe what ever our retired Hero says.
Perfect reply!
Modi will quietly negotiate with the Chinese and grant them the concessions that they demand, in order to get them to withdraw from our side of the LAC. Having gotten what they wanted, the Chinese will be happy to keep quiet and wink and nod while the loudmouthed BJP ministers tom-tom India’s “great victory” under Modi’s “strong leadership”. For Modi and the BJP, only headline management matters, not the truth.
Don’t forget that china lost the battle from Vietnam. Such a small country then also. India lost the battle due to UPI government.
Today Indian military is much powerful to tackle with China.
Your rank and post give you authority to say things on China India border but pessimistic pictures drawn by you is very disheartening. Govt doing to bloster infrastructure at Loc it is what Chinese trying to stop. Chinese took lot of land by slami slice tactics before and gone uncontested they are now being contested different of perception of lAC apply for both it is time buying tactics We have to create enough capabilities to deter them. They win battle not by actual but by pschydological one Getting intimidated by Thier capabilities is also one that you talked here. Actual battle outcome not necessarily will go in favour of them nothing permanent on earth not even Loc and LAC we have to think in long term and create capacity accordingly. Print more often appears as branch of Global times
Where is chappan inch chati now ?
56 inch was a typo, somebody missed a decimal point.
You got china fund to run your print media ,you are using wrong language which I can say instigating us against you.
How for this is true required to be verified, as fake facts can affect moral of forces and unrest in public by large. News for the sake of news can cause irrepairable loss to esteem of indians
The writer has presented facts and data that are open to counter but it looks like many have nothing but schoolground insults instead of solid counters. Subjective you say? Well, if that is so the pre-1962 situation that the writer speaks of is easily countered. Where are these factual rebuffs? The fact is that the nationalism rife in India today is so fragile that many would rather construct a grand delusion when reality is unpalatable. Nationalism my ass! If one truly loves one’s nation then there is no alternative to clear sighted pragmatisn and determination.
China is just “salami slicing” Indian territory as pointed out by an American expert. And we are in denial mode.
Let us unite and support Modi, whatever the consequences.
Respected Panag sir you should share this articles with PMO n Defence Ministry i am sure they will reward you accordingly,great job sir pls keep it up.Best rgds/Common Citizen
The Print operates from India, but not for India. Media thugs like The Print is the reason this nation couldn’t come together as one.
The Print/Quint etc. & such media operate from Jihadi lands, China or the west!! This is India, the land of the maximum traitors any nation has on the globe!!
When India clashes with Pakistan
Bhakts : War with Pakistan!
When clashes with China
Bhakts : Uninstall China apps!
??
Mansoor shah: When In India, Allah bhakts cry Islam! When In Pakistan, they sell Islam to China!!
If there’s a terrorist hiding in a house at Kashmir the army blows the house to pieces,
But I guess the case is quite different in this case.
No bang bang this time,
Only blah blah this time ok.
India should initiate a surprise and a major all-out two-front war in the very near future with whatever resources it has. Arrogant China thinks that the rest of the world is weak and distracted and is therefore using this opportunity to expand its influence and territory. India should scuttle China’s plans by giving China a bloody nose with everything India has got. Whether India wins or loses, devastate China to the greatest extent. Yes, China’s economy has become five times bigger than India’s, but that also means that China has a lot more to lose than India. For every $1 that India will lose, China will lose 5$. The devastation for China will be much more when USA, Taiwan, Japan, and others join the war. After seeing India’s bravery, when these other anti-China countries join in, then for every $1 that India will lose, China will lose $100. ….
Unless we see the maps that both the sides have how will we know if the general is right or not?
This article is bad in taste , completely based on conjectures and surmises. He may have spent 40 years in Army, yet not learnt the lesson that to sin over an adverse situation, you need to motivate soldiers and people. How does this article help any Indian ? I can tell many points that clearly shows it helps Chinese.
For example, the headline itself gives an impression that China has won a War already ! (And The writer is so happy…..!)
One of the biggest weapon in a War is the Propaganda by respective countries. I feel this article will help China in their Propaganda. against India
At the time of crisis, one needs to help the PM who has the responsibility to protect the country you live in. In the name of Journalism, you do not forsake all your duty towards Country.
The biggest joke is ,the writer has written article based on his dreams and presented pictures as if CIA reports to him and provide all satellite photo exclusive to him.
He being in Army for so long, should remember ,that before actual war happens, psychological battle takes place.This article by Mr Penag ( I deliberately removed Lt Gen) is writing clearly in favour of Chinese in psychological battle.
For these reason, I do not support even ThePrint..Because it looks like the Editorial team is deliverately blind to their duty in the name of journalism.
This article is bad in taste , completely based on conjectures and surmises. He may have spent 40 years in Army, yet not learnt the lesson that to sin over an adverse situation, you need to motivate soldiers and people. How does this article help any Indian ? I can tell many points that clearly shows it helps Chinese.
For example, the headline itself gives an impression that China has won a War already ! (And The writer is so happy…..!)
One of the biggest weapon in a War is the Propaganda by respective countries. I feel this article will help China in their Propaganda. against India
At the time of crisis, one needs to help the PM who has the responsibility to protect the country you live in. In the name of Journalism, you do not forsake all your duty towards Country.
The biggest joke is ,the writer has written article based on his dreams and presented pictures as if CIA reports to him and provide all satellite photo exclusive to him.
He being in Army for so long, should remember ,that before actual war happens, psychological battle takes place.This article by Mr Penag ( I deliberately removed Lt Gen) is writing clearly in favour of Chinese in psychological battle.
For these reason, I do not support even ThePrint..Because it looks like the Editorial team is deliverately blind to their duty in the name of journalism.
You are absolutely correct!! The Print, Quint.. /communist/leftist western planted Indian media along with their bought out communist/Jihadi stooges are the first dangers this nation has to tackle before it can take on any external enemies!!
If this is true than what are doing our so called ‘chowkidar’ in diplomacy
I have generally been a support of Modi’s policies. But, it would be too dangerous and disastrous for his government to hide the facts from the public and parliament and play along with Chinese with the hope that they will disappear. Nehru made this mistake, and India is still rankled by that humiliating defeat. I hope Modi government does not perpetuate same error by defending Chinese action or denying their action in the public.
Same author has no article on pok. That was occupied, may be when the author was in duty. It’s easy to blame a new person for a problem created from history. What was the author doing when he was in duty. Useless governments in the past gave away large tracts of land to China and Pakistan.
And also the insulting title by the author does not go well for the position he held.
This UT is belongs to India officially. The neighbour thieves unnecessarily occupied due to their greedy. Like under the name of pattibiraman said. Dai mutta pundai poi nemla pesuranane. Unga ama kuda china varan vandhu paduthal ena panuva.
Be careful of the comments you post, Keep them soft and sweet, you nevertheless know which ones you will have to eat
Writer supported coup if modi re elected in 2019. There is deep sense of alienation towards bharat inside this man. He must do something constructive for his community. He can help lot of reforms in his community. There are two gurudwaras,two cremation grounds and two dharmshala in sikh community one for jat sikhs and one for dalits . Sikh guru preached against castes . Lt. Gen should follow gursikh maryada and give up his surname (panag) of jat sikh to become a true gursikh.
In addition to the rank of Lt. General (Retd) and Member of Armed Forces Tribunal why is it not mentioned that the author is also a member of Aam Aadmi Party since 2014? At least it will provide a background of the author’s perspective, prejudices and compulsions. And just out of curiosity what representation has Lt. Gen. Panag made to the army or government on how not to let China get away with this…as he so eloquently put it? What happened to the credo of “once an army man always an army man”?
Writer seems to be more biased and intimidated from Chinese army and system. This is true that China is stronger than India and is naferious country but India must exert pressure and advocate strongly for status co as it was two or three months before.
Must remember China aslo need and depend on Indian market and business, it’s unfortunate that our own industrialists and entrepreneurs don’t take initiative and bold decision for strong industrial scenario in India ,they are more interested in Govt subsidy and loan that they don’t want to return.
No idea people like you exist from where ?
This news and also the wire always published the article those against the govt or against the national interest. ❓backed by anti Indian or pak or Congress. ? About india china I saw daily there news too but not like these fingers….
Nation become by people not by land so dear Chinese and Indian don’t try to make you fool. There is nothing to achieve. We can make world happier with be together. Don’t be a witness of fool who still trying to fight for land.
Cheer
ofcourse political leadership’s have everything to be done for the nation. But what about those officers who is drawing hafty pakage for defending the border .To save themselves deny the actual position .The officer who is responsible for maintaining sanctity of lac should be thrown out ofthe force immediately.
All give there opinions without having witnessed what actually has happened. Nobody knows clearly whether chinese troops have acquired our land or not. Our opinion is as per our love for the bjp govt which is actually the reason for slow growth of our country. Its the time to stand above our personal preference and give our true opinion.
Certaim Lt Gen are over active and judge themself as final supreme judge. USA was badly beaten in Viatnam and Korea, Prathavi Raj Chauhan bashed up Md Gauri mant times, Ram killed Rawan much powerful in strength, Israel won 6 day war. Germany won many wars from 1939 to 42. Then Germany faught mighty armies of many
Countries from 1942 to 45.
Wait for final results. This Gen has already surrendered even before start of negotiation.
Kindly teach him war philosophy of Vidhure, Chanakya, Bhisma pitamah, Guru Govindji Maharaj and Arjun Devji.
Sikhs never ever planned to surrender. Its not in their blood.
No credibility to the article
Pls don’t share unauthentic comments If that is true news it would have been accross world . And opponent political parties would have started to blame ?
“It is well said that Rome was burning and Nero was fiddling.” Before raising a finger against a warrior who served Bharat Mata for 40 yrs. The Andh Bhagats should be ashamed of at their act. Some pseudo desh bhakats, by their Man Ki Baat are befooling the whole nation, with out listening to the concerns of real desh bhakats. Salute to the great soldier of Bharat Mata.