Army chief M.M. Naravane’s insinuation that Kathmandu was protesting over the boundary issue on the behest of another country is insensitive, uncalled for, and deeply damaging for the two armies in which he holds the rank of General, India and Nepal. As honorary General of the Nepal Army, Naravane has undermined his own position, waded into a domain that is clearly non-military, and brought unnecessary stress on a relationship unique to the two armies. Especially because the seven Gorkha regiments in the Indian Army make up almost 40 battalions, and most of the soldiers are recruited from Nepal.
In speaking out of turn, Gen Naravane followed the unfortunate precedent that has been encouraged to flourish in the recent past — voluble military chiefs doubling as spokespersons.
India and Nepal not only have the most cordial and interwoven societal relations among sovereign countries, but also the deepest military relationship possible. No two armies are as closely interlinked as those of India and Nepal, and this incomparable time-tested bond has been placed under a strain by an utterance that is both avoidable and unmilitary.
Speaking at an online seminar organised by the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies Analyses on 15 May 2020, Gen Naravane said, “I don’t know what they are actually agitating about. There has never been any problem in this Corps in the past. There is a reason to believe that they might have raised this problem at the behest of someone else and that is very much a possibility.”
Forgetting Cariappa’s guidebook
The reciprocal appointment of Generals in both armies began with late Field Marshal (then Gen) K.M. Cariappa, when he assumed office as Chief of Army Staff (COAS) in 1950. The Royal Nepal Army conferred the honorary rank of General on him, and since then it has been followed as a gesture of respect and honour seldom seen between two sovereign armies. As COAS, Field Marshal Cariappa penned the last word on what is expected of an officer with his handbook on etiquette for gentleman cadets. It seems to have been misplaced, since this is possibly the first occasion when an Army chief has raised doubts about the political and diplomatic actions of Nepal.
It brings to mind one of the oft-repeated quotes of the inimitable, and legendary, Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw. He joined 8 Gorkha Rifles after India was partitioned and his original Frontier Force battalion became part of the Pakistan Army. Sam Bahadur, as he came to be fondly called, left behind a treasure trove of quotes relevant for the nation and its Army. As a Gorkha, he would have been particularly dismayed by the current controversy as is clear from his very prescient observation: “The problem in India is that as soon as one of us is put in a position of power, he feels that he has the monopoly of the entire knowledge.”
Citizens of Nepal train and then take an oath to uphold the national security interests of India. And over the decades they have been living up to that oath, many times making the ultimate sacrifice. Army’s seven Gorkha regiments depict a closeness and confidence unparalleled today. The numbers drawing an Indian Army pension in Nepal is slowly nudging toward 130,000. So much so that Army officers posted in the Indian embassy in Nepal would be the highest number in a diplomatic mission, and include military medical staff, which is an apt testimony to the importance given to Nepali Gorkha soldiers and their families.
Also read: Nepal map row: Has India provoked Kathmandu or is China instigating trouble for New Delhi?
Indignation brought by an Army chief
Gen. Naravane has undermined the credibility of Nepal, which has given so much to India in terms of soldiers, service, and many a times sacrifices, too. Indians with deep-rooted family connections in Nepal see yet another needless controversy between the two countries. Even as the ire over the Madhesi agitation persists in Kathmandu and beyond, India’s meddlesome attitude toward Nepal is once again a point of heated discussion there.
Except this time, a first ever, the indignation is because of an Army officer, and a chief at that. No soldier, in India or in Nepal, believes that General Naravane’s inconsiderate remarks have not been instigated by someone within the Narendra Modi government.
That is indeed a harsh whisper to circulate, which once again brings to mind another gem from late Sam Bahadur when former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi asked him about military coup rumours. Mutual respect was of a different order then, and he quipped, “You mind your own business, I’ll mind mine. You kiss your own sweetheart, I’ll kiss mine. I don’t interfere politically, as long as nobody interferes with me in the Army.” Sam Bahadur would obviously dissect this episode very differently.
The author is a Congress leader and Editor-in-Chief of Defence & Security Alert. Views are personal.
Nepal government who is trying to patronize China to gain in the form of free money. But nothing comes free in thia world especially from China.
Actual damage is being caused by circulating this mindless writing……shame!
The Print showing it’s true colors again. You people never leave any chance to defame Indian Military. Very soon your propaganda will be busted by our very own military. This statement by this officer have nothing to do with Nepali citizens and Gorkha battalions but you people in media have fallen to this level of disgrace that you are ready to create headlines defaming our army.
What are you trying to do? Inculcate timidity in Indian Army also, as though our timid political leadership is not enough? It is clear as day light that China is pulling strings in Nepal. One doesn’t need mirror to look at a wound on the palm! Stop writing such defeatist articles.
He pointed towards the communist Nepali government not the Nepalis.Gurkha Regiment is one of the decorated and proud Regiment of Indian Army and we Indians our proud that we have fearless Gurkha soldiers.
This is a foolish writer who thinks that general Naravane has questioned the faith of Gurkhas.He pointed towards the communist Nepali government not the Nepalis.Gurkha Regiment is one of the decorated and proud Regiment of Indian Army and we Indians our proud that we have fearless Gurkha soldiers. Love u Gurkhas..
Dude, he is a congressi. Why are you calling him foolish seperately? They have never ever supported Indian interest.
LOL. The biggest joke is the author calling Sam Bahadur a Gorkha. He was a Parsi both from his father’s and mothers side. He is on about a rant how Gorkha sentiments are hurt whereas the fact is we Indians have nothing against the Nepali people. We have long historical and cultural ties. It is the communist party that is causing tension and to prove my point I would ask anyone disagreeing to just look up the detoriating relations between India and Nepal whenever the communists have been in power.
Wake up my Nepali brothers and sisters. Your people work here and indians work in Nepal. They always feel at home. We a re brother nations. Don’t forget how India has always been by your side in time of crisis . Please don’t fall for the chinese propaganda. Today they are claiming mount everest , tomorrow they will claim pokhra and Kathmandu. Dont belive me, go ask Sri Lanka, pakistan or Maldives.
I do not want to comment much. Just wonder why don’t you look your face in the mirror first. The whole world knows that India hates China but at the same time India is doing trade with China, more than 80 billion US dollar with trade deficit. This is just an example. There are no of other things to list. I guess Indian see China card only for others not for India and Indians. The whole world is laughing when you talk about China card for others which may not be in Indian media. Wake up guys! Stop making people laugh around you.
Regarding Nepal and India, there is a good relation in people to people level. I bet you if Gurkha Army is not there in Indian Army probably, the Indian history and present status would be different. You should know that there could be alternative for almost everything but not for neighbor and water (flowing from Nepal).
My friend, Nepal communist party workers wanted to hoist flag on Indian side , their own people living at the border area for generstions stopped them from doing so, because they understand the relations we people share .
Ofcourse this is politically motivated from some angle but not an issue that we can solve easily, Nepal also has border issues with China and after Covid can use China’s ports for it’s good as tourism has taken a hit , me having personally travelled to Nepal quite a few times have felt this growing feeling of pro China from a certain group , however at the grass route level people are very friendly towards India as we share the same culture .
Nepal also has to see it’s interests as a nation and only when the time is tough relationships are tested , else all is happy and jolly always .
There is not doubt that Nepal-India has special relationship and close to each other than any one else in the world. This is fact and need to accept by all. But, I think you are not correct that Nepal communist party workers wanted to hoist flag on Indian side, it is other way around and happening since 1962. Nepal-India border is defined by Sugauli treaty of 1816 and accepted by both. Please do not forget that there is not other treaty between Nepal-India to define border. That is the only one. Maps are there and they also have signed on that. So, my Indian friends need to accept the reality based on fact and evidence. You might show the current distorted map as a evidence which may change the whole course of treaty and make people laugh for the logic. When treaty is signed on 1816, maps should be of 1816 or around. And river around mountain does not change its source like in plain. This is fact. So, this needs to be sorted out for good relation of Nepal-India. One should not vow and shout ignoring the fact and evidence to save own country’s interest and should not blame to other. Otherwise, it is useless to say that Nepal-India has special relationship. We are saying we are very common in terms of everything and understand each other and at the same time some of Indian including media is saying China is playing. Laughable!!
I am sure no Indian wants if their own house or land is taken by other neighbor distorting the maps from Indian department of land resource. You will definitely speak with evidence and you may go to court and debate and discuss to find out the truth. And, I believe truth always win. Shouting for sake of patriotism ignoring the truth is the evil way where it may not end up peacefully and cannot be good neighbor by any means. So, stop blaming game and read the history and evidence and support the truth.
This is a foolish writer who thinks that general Narvane has questioned the faith of Gurkas.He pointed towards the communist Nepali government not the Nepalis.Gurkha Regiment is one of the decorated and proud Regiment of Indian Army and we Indians our proud that we have fearless Gorkha soldiers.Love u Gorkhas..
Misleading and brainless opinion by the author. The print should distant itself from publishing such opinions and articles.
Even if it had not been said by him still Nepal would have bright this up because this unique relation between the two armies (and Nations) is not in China’s interest and they want it to end. The CCP will use all the influence it has in Nepal’s ruling party to undermine Nepal -India ties.
If elder brother have 32 lakh and younger have 2 lakh and elder brother give 400 to younger then elder become more bigger and wealthy
Worthless article .Totally biased. Without observing the true facts , author tried to impress upon us his own ideology. Print magazine should think twice before publish such type of articles. Otherwise , less people pay attention and internet to read.
Unacceptable article in the time of crises that works follows. Everyone has a right to express his or her opinion. But the author is expressing China’s opinion. Gorkha have always been the pride for India. They are now integral part of India. We respect them. Nepal is certainly under influence of China as it’s government is saved by then and is heavily intervened at not only government but at making and breaking or political party as well. Such insensitive and irrilivant (because Indian Army chief never said anything about Gurkha even indirectly) comment clearly states that Indian security can be compromised if such, hopefully China funded, politition comes to power in India.
They reqruits army from nepal???? And we Indians are joblessssss…. Yyyyy!!!!are we unfit for the job…..???or the seat are limited for us or maybe (maybe) we fall under general category
..Great going….
So, no doubt Indian govt is puppet of someone. Instead of recruiting their own people, they are recruiting Nepali Army. and making their own ppl jobless, distrusting on Indian citizen. Laughable right? Can you find out why Indian government became puppet since long? This is just a reply for your message.
They reqruits army from nepal???? And we Indians are joblessssss…. Great going….
I think this article has been funded by the Chinese embassy. Otherwise any media channel who is Indian cannot publish such an irresponsible article towards India’s safety. These types of authors are like traitors living inside my country.
I do not want to comment much. Just wonder why don’t you look your face in the mirror first. The whole world knows that India hates China but at the same time India is doing trade with China, more than 80 billion US dollar with trade deficit. This is just an example. There are no of other things to list. I guess Indian see China card only for others not for India and Indians. The whole world is laughing when you talk about China card for others which may not be in Indian media. Wake up guys! Stop making people laugh around you.
Regarding Nepal and India, there is a good relation in people to people level. I bet you if Gurkha Army is not there in Indian Army probably, the Indian history and present status would be different. You should know that there could be alternative for almost everything but not for neighbor and water (flowing from Nepal).
Under present BJP government rule the defence/ army chiefs have become more bold and vocal. They are making statements which might be true or false but are certainly objectionable because they are overstepping the limits of authority. May be a beginning of military rule or dictatorship.
Whether Nepali Gurkhas take offence or not but this article definitely ensure that they do and animosity is spread… Congrats to Print…
Everyone who has written against the foolish author is praiseworthy and an intellectual. The reality is that only that the foolish author is mongering about friction between the two sides. Please be aware of such type of black ship.
From where such authors come. Rubbish article
The author is biased & has prejudiced opinion. Print invite rotten writing with clear intent to malign govt face. This time over Army chief is simply not acceptable.
The author is immature in analysing army or govt strategy. His father too could not fare well in politics as well.
Shekhar Gupta has now become notorious for negative narratives.
Mind you, the author is a Congress cadre. What more can you expect out of him? General Naravane has stated facts. He is within his limits by all means. The world understads the complicity between Nepal and China. Nepal is fast becoming a stooge of China.
I support Gen Naravane. Nepal’s political scenario is changing, India respond or not Nepali politicians will distance themselves from India. They will ask for more sovereignty in future. So why we Care for them.let them be China’s Pakistan or China’s sri Lanka.
India must focus on self reliance and powerful economy. Let the time go….. they will come around.
Shrey, What do you mean by ‘They will ask for more Sovreignty”? Every country has to respect other country’s sovereignty. Being country does not mean that they have big sovereignty and small country mean small. Every country is equal in terms of sovereignty. If you are accepting for what you have said, probably India is less sovereign than China and other bigger country. You are making people laugh.
You said truth that Indian at least should focus on self reliance and powerful economy other than interfering other neighboring country. Regarding Lipulekh, let me tell you that you should read some history how Nepal lost 1/3 of territory with British and how the border were defined with Sugauli treaty in 1816 and see the maps carefully during treaty. Probably, you will have more idea to discuss and tell your other friends.
Well, the author is a congress leader. No wonder why congress is in shit. They are full of people who want to spread hate. This is pure bullshit. The article needs to be taken down. I expect better from ThePrint
I v stayed at Dharchula. People cross to Indian side, take a bus to barelli or tanakpur, again cross to Nepal. This is easier than travelling through Nepal. Labour come in morning and work in Indian side. Brides and grooms are from both sides. What oli is doing. And this persistent needling by China. They have spoiled relationship with neighbors in entire South East Asia, with Japan, and now manipulating pak, Sri Lanka, Maldives to go against India
There is a tendency to undermine Army generals. Even an entry level journalist we know why Nepal is doing it. Army chief said so. China’s postering is not new. It tries to hobnob with India’s neighbours and forment trouble.
Writer is not clear what he wants to say
I guess you have no idea about diplomacy and you do not see the difference between diplomats and army. Army will come in-front and speak only when diplomacy line becomes weak. If you agree on expression of Indian Army General, then there is no doubt that your diplomats and diplomacy is world’s poorest diplomats and diplomacy in the world. Nepal-India is not in state of war and war between these two nations is far away from reality.
Looks like you are also writing article at behest of someone else…or funded by someone else to criticise COAS. And pls don’t show symptoms of verbal diarrhoea
Let’s be careful. There are 40,000 thousand Gurkha soldiers in Indian Army and may be there are 70,000 army pensioners from Nepal. Add lakh of Nepalese employed in public/private sector in India. Nepal has a huge stake in this country.If they are being guided by China, in the long run they run the risk of putting themselves in trouble as geographically, culturally and historically they are more vigorously linked to India than China.
NEPAL IS OUR FRIEND. AND INDIA ALWAYS RESPECT NEPAL.
NEPALIES ARE IN INDIA LIVVING GOOD IN INDIA AND WE INDIANS LOVE THEM.
I DO NOT THINK THERE IS ANY PROBLEM WITH NEPAL .EVERY THING IS SOLVABLE .
MEDIA SHOULD NOT TRY TO DO UNDUE REPORTING ABOUT OUR RELATIONSHOP WITH NEPAL.
Call spade a spade !
The author being from congress party, it is not surprising that he is indulging in such anti-India rhetoric. Congress had developed chronic habit of taking anti-India line as it’s only desperate policy. Shamelessly so.
well, clearly this piece has rankled someone in the hierarchy, given the number of similar looking posts on the article. It is indeed disappointing that Army chiefs start commenting wrt foreign policy aspects. This kind of behavior is more suited to army of our pesky neighbor on the western border, but not a professional army like that of India.
It is expected that the officers maintain the professionalism and dignity of the post and leave foreign policy to the govt and the foreign service. Everyone has a different role to play and it’s best if they respect and appreciate that.
I 100% support your views and that is how it should be. Why most of the Indian thinks Gen. Naravan is correct? I still feel many Indian need better education other than like you.
I am not sure if the issue is 200 years old. But, definitely know that British ruled for more than 200 years. Don’t you think same thing is applicable at the time when India got independence? If the kind of ppl like Gopal Das were there during that time probably, India at present would still under British. Do not forget how East India Company treats Indians in past.
Gopal Das, you guys must be there around 1945 to 1947 to vow the same views of what you called illogical. I am sure Indian history would be different. 🙂
‘Mr. Manvendra singh’ aka ‘The Print’.
The more u try create animosity between Indians and common Nepalis, the more u r going to be shunned by the Indian Public.
Every word/statement you said, falsely implicated the General, who simply mentioned that Nepal Communist Gov is acting on Behalf of China.
Instead, Mr. Oli, of Nepal threatened India of dire consequences, instead of talking to the govt.
Mr. Manvendra singh aka ‘The Print’, you r trying to create a narrative to show India as an unresponsible aggressor.
This clearly shows your Anti-India stance, Very Clearly!
2ndly, whatever u hv mentioned here, nobody in India is going to buy it, neither the Gorkhas working with the Indian Army.
3rdly, Your very unresponsible way of making ‘A fuss out of Nothing’ is not going to go well with the people you are living with.
Remember, when the truth is going to come out and shine, you will be out in the middle, having to explain the people, why you always have everything against India.
The Print, its time, you have a lot to explain people here.
Who is the writer of this article of ThePrint ??? Some uncle who sends across idiotic whatsapp analysis or some intern learning how to write without having subject knowledge! Whomsoever it is, simply a shame.
This is not worth a full read. Mindless writing.
True the print as you know is a leftist leaner obviously they are pro communist hence the the mindless crap
Exactly! CoAS will never say or do things which vitate the atmosphere. Senior Generals with years & years of experience are extremely careful when they open their mouth. Its these dirty journalists who play spoil sport, shameless creatures..
More damaging are comments of congreds leaders which are always National intrest. We all understand what Nepal PM mean but still Congress leaders blame our selves…..typical slave mentality
Agree. Print is in the habit of creating news where none exists.
Shame on you Indians .If you’re saying Nepal is playing China card then what about your Trump card to rule South Asia?? J&k Indian boarder is saved by gorkha battalion so you got your freedom to speak .why don’t you ask your government to fence or build a wall between NEPAL AND INDIA boarder ??our Nepal army didn’t respond answer or he seems worthless to speak about your chief general statement because actions speak louder. All Indians government chiefs are speaking like politicians then what the politicians are doing there. Kalapani , lipulekh and limpiyadhura is our Nepal land we have enough evidence , proof and facts it’s not a funny joke as your TV anchors spread hate without ground report, it seems there are less educated people working in TV channels whose work is to divide the country and terrorise minority .
Change your name from Amrit to zehar because your comments skewers that you are full of it
Hello bro,
I totally agree with your comments of the relationship between India and Nepal since a long time. Both the countries like brothers arm in arm. However, whatever is happening Will hamper our relationship through which the third nation will take advantage. And this effect the greatest ever bonding of brother nations which is as old and prestigious as no other nations in the Universe. As a citizen, let’s pledge to not harm anyone’s images and have a respect for each other
For seventy years, India hard always respected Nepal’s sovereignty. But will your new “master in the name of friend, i.e., China” respect your freedom even for 10 years? China is going your whole government. China cannot be anyone’s friend. And Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Various African and European countries and even the USA and we (India) had already suffered the severe consequences and betrayal of thinking China as our friend. So Nepal, please come out of the Chinese trap before is too late.
Do you think India is a good friend to their neighbor? No way! India is only concern with their security and very afraid of China. Do you mean to say :
if there is Indian influence, it is very good and if the influence is Chinese, it is very bad?
Check the trade figure between China and India. (more than 80 billion US dollar, are Indian stupid?)
What kind of logic is this. AFAIK, India never cares of neighbor other than their own security, control on neighbor’s foreign policy and resource. Let me tell you, India can(will) not take Nepal for their own sake. It is out of imagination. What India wants from Nepal is,
1. Make Nepal weak internationally and domestically so that India can play around in every aspect.
2. India can take control of natural resources which are there and India thinks they have sole rights. China and other third party should not come in between
3. With a big population, the supply of drinking water and for irrigation doesn’t seems to match at all so, India wants to have control on all the water resource
4. Nepal’s Himalaya is giving free security for India’s security. If India need to deploy its army on Chinese border, India’s financial growth may not be able to deal with it which will make India poor from what you are now.
6. Nepal probably in the top 5 in Indian economy to receive money from Nepal from Indian workers to send home remittance.
7. The development projects were never completed on time and the completion status is very poor. Majority of projects have probably 5 to 10% completion status that were suppose to complete some 15 years ago. You need to know like I said before. India wants to control resource and water and security not the development in Nepal
8. long list to go… So, be optimistic and positive. Look into both sides and debate. Do not be like wild bull.
This Paki handler
Dearest brother from Nepal, I respect your sentiments, indian and Nepal are not just friend but blood brother, yes blood brothers, Nepal is pure Hindu country. But china is playing the card of divide n rule. Gorkha regiment is the respect, honour and pride of indian army. But india has never shown aggression towards any country. We are the largest army courageous bravest strongest, but we respect every one.
Why China is playing in Nepal not in India? Are you sure? Do not make the world laugh. I would say China is playing in India far better than in Nepal. Check your trade and trade deficit with China that is more than 80 billion US dollar. I would suggest you to check face in the mirror first. China is making you more dependent on them. Nepal is a small country and dependency would be very less compare to India. So, tell me who is playing where and why Indian keeps their mouth shut. Wake up guys!
You know nothing about teh internal politics of india. Stop commenting garbage. The chinese literally saved your communist party by directly interfering in your internal politics. What do you have to say about that? Then you stupid people will say that india interferes in your internal matter.
Check the video in YouTube what Indian scholar and expert says. It used to be India who breaks out Nepali government the way India wants. You may have look for series of interview on this.
Search
“Speech of S. D. Muni on Importance of Nepal – India People to People Relations at IIC 5”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSXTzQ0TlTI&feature=youtu.be&fbclid=IwAR0iwiyhM3yRXvBtTg25STj3Li2XCUJvjHDAwn4o78ph5eqdmmlSg3F-tOo
More Emotion, less logic, understanding, study, research or learning. Naam Amrit hai par ghol rahey ho Zeher. I was confused as to what pained me more ? The Nonsense Sponsored Article or your Response. It seems ISI and Commie Agenda is working overtime. People like you are just a pawn. The early you wake up the better or maybe you are being paid.
Shame on you Nepalis.
When China says that Mt. Everest (Sagarmatha_the pride of Nepal) is in Tibet, you people don’t have the courage to speak against China.
NEPAL HAS BECOME A PUPPET OF CHINA.
Becoz Chinese ambassador to Nepal saved the Communist govt.
Shame on you. Go and see your face in the mirror first. China had occupied many Indian land and stationed Chinese Army there, India is helpless. Pakistan had occupied and Indians are helpless. This has been happening since 1947 and 1962. Coward! British used to say “Indians and dogs are not allowed” and treat you like more than slave. You are still happy and good friend.
Comments can be anything but need to be true. What you have accused is false. I agree there is Chinese influence but what I have said here is 100% true. So, don’t come to debate and comment with cheap words.
Hard but true. Nepal communist govt was saved with money power by China. Whole world knows. So border issue raked by by Nepal govt at behest of China is also known. Wait for some time and truth will prevail out. If military chief of India said something, must got meaning, whether u like or not.
Ashish, probably, you might be partially true that there is Chinese influence. But you should never forget that Indian is growing up due to Chinese. Chinese is helping and making India grow even though there is trade deficit in India and China. It is hard but true. There is more than 80 billion US $ trade with China. Even Indian people want to stop, Indian govt will not. Because they became puppet of China. You may not agree on this because you do not have habit to look your face in the mirror. Check your news on India and China and trade deficit. True but Hard, right?
India had trade relations with China only to not interfere in South Asian Politics. If Chinese don’t abide then India cannot keep quiet. Everybody knows that KP Oli has been in Power because of China. The policies of Nepal vis- a- vis India are not the same as it was previously.
Your comment that India-China trade reason does not justify with what you are accusing Nepal. If you agree with India-China reason for trade, you have already seen what is happening in South Asian politics. Either you stop blaming stupid way or wake up and raise your voice to the Indian govt that China has violated the agreement and stop the trade if you are true Indian. I’m sure Indian govt. will not listen to your voice. Either of your sentences are clashing on each other. So, study the evidence, be realistic and support truth. Both side has to accept the truth. Showing Patriotism to override the truth and fact is the evil way.
Oh, what the Nepali PM said in his parliament made the Army give this statement. What the Nepali PM said have you read it? Grow up..!
You guys should read your facts correct. You are employed by india and dont make whole in the plate which serves you food. Relax and be practical, no one needs india we are good on our own.
Hold up. The comments by Indian General is on the Govt working in Nepal, not the army and definitely not the citizens of Nepal. Nobody hates anyone unless provoked to. That’s what happening in Nepalese Political circles and they’ve been setting up meetings with Chinese Ambassadors and envoys. Nepalese communist politicians want to sell Nepal to China and that is a fact.
Sundara, it used to be other way around before since many years. Search in YouTube
Speech of S. D. Muni on Importance of Nepal – India People to People Relations at IIC 5
When China is seen , it is different view but When Indian Govt. was acting same before what would you say?
Different from your comments, I would say India Govt. became Chinese puppet. you should never forget that Indian is growing up due to Chinese. Chinese is helping and making India grow even though there is trade deficit in India and China. It is hard but true. There is more than 80 billion US $ trade with China. Even Indian people want to stop, Indian govt will not. Because they became puppet of China. You may not agree on this because you do not have habit to look your face into the mirror. Check your news on India and China and trade deficit. True but Hard, right?
Idiots. You think we don’t understand what is going on between you Nepalese and China. You bootlick India for decades to improve your economy, and taking sides with China now. We will construct the roads, possibly inside your territory as well. What Will you do? Possibly what can you do? All small nations around India trying to test our patience. This is the limit… Don’t play with fire. This shithole author believes he can write anything against India.. let us not give anyone anymore chance
We’re not saying anything to disrespect the gurkhas and the people of nepal. Do read the comment of our COAS. We’re commenting on the actions of the communist government of nepal who’s seriously trying to disrupt the historic relations between India and Nepal with the background support from China.
Also the COAS was speaking in a defence seminar not in a press conference and he was right in what he said.
Bro this is an anti-national element author to make conflicts between two countries funded by Anti india and anti Hindu , let’s not read this tiwisted artical , jai mahakali
Ohh…trump card…. sweetheart…do you remember that hospitality our prime minister got when visiting USA….when trump visited us , we went a step ahead of them….this our way of treating guests …you cheap people won’t understand….and India’s Constitution has given right to speech to each and everyone so don’t tell our chief what say about or not….and don’t forget if your guys are working in our army they are getting paid … And probably more than any other job in your village (Nepal)
I am not sure if you are educated person who can read the facts. I believe Indian constitution has not given rights to prove wrong to right and speak whatever they have in mind without knowing the value of professionalism. Correct me if I am wrong-being eye doctor, he should not do surgery of bone. I guess Indian constitution do not give rights like this. These kind of discussion can leads to the never ending debate.
India has so many job less people, why do not recruit their own instead of Nepali. Either you are hiding the truth or do not have courage to face the truth. If Nepali Gurkha army are not helping Indian Army probably, you may not be able to proud as Indian citizen at present and your nationality would have been different. Search in google and in your history.The contribution from Nepal to save your Nation cannot compare by any means. See the current situation and realize who is protecting in Kashmir and Chinese border of India. If you are wise person, do some research and read the fact. So, wake up guys, know the truth. Apart from Gurkha army, the water you get for irrigation and drinking is coming from Nepal. Nepal is top 5 country that Indian is getting money as remittance from Indian worker working in Nepal and is contributing to Indian economy. I doubt how prosperous India can be if Indian govt has to spend 3 times of your security budget to protect India-China border if Nepal did not help in between. I wonder with your knowledge that India is doing trade with China more than 80 billion US $ with trade deficit and becoming Chinese dependent country (Chinese puppet). So, guys wake and see the truth. See the geography and history of Nepal-India treaty. There is only one treaty to define border of Nepal-India and study the maps and facts during the treaty. Patriotism ignoring the truth and fact is the evil way.
People of both countries are good friends with special relationship. And, some crappy people are ignoring the facts and truth and the good relationship to play around blaming different kind of non-sense card.
Dear foolish author…there isn’t any rift among people of both nations nor within army, it’s a misunderstanding between two governments which will be dealt by talks…now just shut up and stop writing blunders and don’t ever dare in your career to question General of Indian army
Well said
Ahh..
China, Print aur Manvendra Singh.
Sahib, Biwi aur Gulam
Yes rightly put
Well said
Well said. Thums up.
So here You are comparing 40 battalions, 70 year old battalion , more important than a 75 year old capable army? As a Congress leader You are thinking exactly as Pt. J NEHRU as he thought in 1962, and You want it to be repeated but sorry it won’t be repeated now.
Idiot commie bootleaker author.
True
Congress always damages on own country
Well said
Without reaching the end of this piece it was obvious where it was going,what was intended and who was the author.No mention of insensitive and absurd remarks by Nepali PM,but remarks made by General made to look like insult to Nepali soldiers ,what a construed mentality these Congress people have,they are just trying to put words in people mouth.
They cannot provide solution for anything but their only obsession is to fan anti India feeling everywhere by any means but you Congress idiots can’t wedge a gap between Indians and Nepalis who have relations since time immemorial and we very well understand your agenda.
Shame dul media.. Shekhar Gupta show some shame. I am sure you even sold your soul.
Stupid author….Army chief is tslking about the present communist Government in Nepal. And not Nepalese people.
Indian army chief said that about Communist party of Nepal, why are you brigning Gurkhas in this. If your proud of Gurkha Valour, Please help the 500,000 stranded Nepali workers in gulf waiting to go home. If you cant take them, please let us know. We will be glad to welcome them and give them land in Kashmir.
Communist party may think Nepalese are their property. That explains why you are silent while 400,000 girls get trafficked every year under your nose.
Ohhh stop you are going too far
Kashmirs land is not owned by your father and doggy modi..
It’s disgusting how easy it’s is now a days to publish anything without proper facts.
Here what the general said is absolutely spot on and New Delhi has also suggested what P.m Oli is doing is at behest of someone else.
Stupid writing !!!!
Manabendra singh your father is still in Coma… don’t give him shock by your lack of understanding of geopolitics and immaturity in stating it’s sensitive, Napalese Army per say is was against Commies taking over their country. The present Chief is a statigist I trust him, not you
This comment section showcases the utter ignorance of self-acclaimed Indian internet experts. You know nothing about what India has been doing in Nepal. You’ve been taking the pill your media and government is feeding you without a second thought, thus being in this illusion of self-righteousness. India supported the Maoist revolution, providing them with arms, ammunitions and monetary help at the same time imposing blockade and terminating supply of arms to Nepalese army to overthrow the king. Then, Durbar massacre by mobilizing RAW with the help of some internal gaddars. Then, the 12 point agreement signed in Delhi to bring (unwanted)democracy in Nepal. After that, India used the Maoist government of that time so that lakhs of Indian nationals could attain Nepali citizenship. Then, India stripped us of our Hindu country and imposed secularism. Almost all of the projects India is part of in Nepal are in India’s favour and most are just not completed even after decades. Even after all this, Nepalese people were cordial, then came the 2015 earthquake and Indian blockade, right after (only a very “good” neighbour would do that, isn’t it?). The motive of the blockade? To meddle in Nepal’s constitution! And, you ask why Nepal is acting the way it is right now? India is spreading communal hatred between Pahadiyas and Madheshis. We were silent even after all that. And, now army chief and media outlets of India say that Nepal is doing this at someone else’s behest! This is what has irked the majority of Nepalese. Most Nepalese don’t know or care anything about China. But, as a landlocked country, which has only two neighbours, what would you do if one of the neighbour whom you trusted and supported so much, imposed a blockade? It’s obvious, we had to look for an alternative. We Nepalese aren’t aligned to China, not in any way. We are well aware of China’s and India’s geopolitical interests, thus have taken a non-aligned policy. Till now Nepal has always been acting in India’s favour, what we have got from India for all that, I’ve already listed above. On top of all that, almost all of India is being so insensitive regarding this issue and bullying Nepal. This simply isn’t acceptable.
It was Congress who supported regime change in Nepal then and since then. It’s high time to bring Nepal back to it’s old Golden Glory of Hindu Rashtra
Your government is the problem here not people ; Nepal government is acting aggressively by printing a updated map of a disputed area that has existed for long time ,the area of 440 sq km is a crucial elevated area that allows Indian army to keep an eye on Chinese border.
We can’t compromise security our including your too in a way.
Your Oli government has a political motive behind this aggressive act and China is involved in the agitation or supporting this cause as it has so much to gain.
You have quoted all the events from history. There is no GK test going on here. This is a open argument about Army General’s statement about being right or wrong. Once again I reiterate to please have a look at Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan. Civic rights are gone. Children’s future is in abeyance. Property and asset accumulated is of no value. All because their military power is destroyed. All Indian comment writers should avoid writing anything against Indian military. Now a days it has become a fashion in India to criticize Indiana military. Please think of their importance in our life. Foreign investment is coming to this country which is generating jobs is only because of one prime reason that is our powerful military.
Though I am Indian, I partially agree with your comments. Nepal needs careful handling since we have got the same cultural roots. You will agree that both have to act in a mature way. Now your point about COAS point, everybody in the international arena right now is fully convinced that Nepal is putting across this dispute at the critical time when China is in thick soup, it has lost its credibility. Nepalese communist government is trying to help them out to ensure that India does not side with anti-China forces at the global level.
Well explaimed.
Yes I know , we are from eastern India and we understands Nepal better then northern plains of India as our state is 10 % Nepali as well. We know Nepals history probably little more then many Nepali due to shared history from 7th century AD.
Yes I agree that India is deeply involved in Nepal in order to keep is influence but all that meddling is not necessarily conspiracy. In 1 sentence let me tell you.
“It is Nepal’s royal and political class which failed Nepal and whenever they fail Nepal they show India as the reason and sand bag ” a very convenient politics in Nepal.
Each time your irresponsible politicians brings a new revolution to alter Nepal’s course of action in order to control Nepal like a royalty, India rushes to get involved as a reaction to save geo political situation. All you remember is India’s post situation involvement . Which is an reaction not action. After the mess up , begins the favourite slogan India responsible for our situation a slogan which is very dear to Nepali political breed . As for RAW if your claim they are involved in everything in Nepal then either RAW knows it’s China or RAW it’s doing it itself @ either way it is wrong claim right?
Personally I have visited those areas of claim , yes I know what the villagers there feels about Nepal . We India whether pahadi or from plains love Nepal but not the Nepali political breed. Sorry !
Then go to nepal and leave India and lick chinese boots
Agree Ashar. Unfortunately we forget that Nepal and India are bind by the same umbilical cord. As every political party is scoring goals, on both sides, its the people connect which matters as well as addressing each others’ woes and taking care of that. Congress is scoring goals here but we all know what they did earlier. Communists in Nepal are scoring goals as they change sides over time. Its the people who suffers in reality. Personally, I have many Nepalese friends and we are one family to take care of each other. Hope, good sense prevails on both sides urgently.
Dear Manvender,
You have no idea whom you are disrespecting. This person has earned his designation with sheer dedication. There is nothing like “it’s his subject or not”. He has all the right to comment as you are ready to digest undesirable politicians statements as per your convenience. Go and have a look at Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan, coz when any military crumbles, value of your assets, cash and property becomes zero. Therefore, you should be thankful that your so called financial backing is driving your words which is purely relies on the fate of Indian military.
Sir you are saying that India involved with Nepal needlessly to bring communists to power by supporting them, I agree maybe Indians were involved sir but it was in the time of UPA, it the Congress government which is no less from a leftist party who wants to destroy Hindu culture in the name of secularism.Sir,we Indians were happy that Nepal is the only Hindu country in the world.But the so called Indian communists,liberals and leftists could not digest it and it was on their initiative that communists took power. Most of the communist of Nepal were educated in JNU which is a hub for communism which brain washes students to create new cadre.The Nepali communists in league with Indian communists and congress party which was in power brought communism in Nepal. The new BJP government which the people chose to save Hindu culture in 2014 was against the revolution in Nepal, by the time they got into power, Communists of Nepal were ready with constitution which is secular which Nepal doesn’t need. So please don’t see all Indians as One, there is a battle going on in India between left and conservatives .China doesn’t need to involve sir, all the maoists of the world have natural tendency to bend towards China, it’s like a second nature to them, thank you
This is how congress salami slices India’s sovereignty. It is silly politicians like the author who establishes what the order should be. They act like the high priest giving advice to armies, how they should behave professionally etc. when these guys shoot their gutter mouth off everywhere uncontrolled. First go and decide what the party stands for. Remove forces in the party that are foreign and inimical to India’s core interests. They you can advice the army chief.
Your house is a mess and you have prescriptions for everyone. Jackass!!!!
Somehow the print always writes the stories other way round and with a biased manner. Sadly, the morale of our own people suffers when you make them read this….
Very very poor analysis i wonder why this this is allowed to be aired the bosses should be taken to task.
Till the time his father Jaswant Singh was minister in NDA, he was staunch supporter of Indian army and of BJP point of view. When he was denied ticket , he jumped ship and now he is finding fault with Army and its view point..idiotic stand…
Only an idiot & lackey of treacherous political party can write a piece like this. It is done with a malaise intent of targeting the Govt. It seems he is batting for the chinese like the traitor communists of india are doing.