Thursday, 19 May, 2022
HomeOpinionDear Sheikh Hasina, if the Rohingyas were Hindus or Buddhists, would you...

Dear Sheikh Hasina, if the Rohingyas were Hindus or Buddhists, would you give them shelter?

Text Size:

You have wept for the Rohingyas. But you made me a refugee. For the last 24 years, I have been roaming from one country to another.

You have felt for the Rohingyas. You’ve cried after hearing what they go through. When no other country offered the most persecuted minority shelter, you have. I don’t see another benevolent prime minister like you today. You are perhaps being compared to Germany’s Angela Merkel.

About 40,000 Rohingyas have entered India. The government has taken the decision to throw them out. Rich Islamic countries will also not accept them. Pakistan will not take them in either. Muslim fundamentalist countries who otherwise shout in support of Rohingyas, don’t want them in their countries. A poor country like Bangladesh had to finally step in.

You have saved lakhs of Rohingyas from drowning in Naf River or killing themselves or starving to death. There have been talks about giving you the Nobel Prize. I feel proud of you. Though the Nobel Prize isn’t something that I consider the greatest. Many undeserving people have got the Prize, like Aung Saan Suu Kyi. Doing something for a prize, and doing something for the poor without thinking of a prize are two completely different things. My belief is, you didn’t stand up for the persecuted for a prize. The real prize is the love people have for you now, especially the Rohingyas, the Nobel is nothing compared to that.

You have said, “Bangladesh feeds 16 crore people. Feeding 7 lakh Rohingyas won’t be a problem. We have the capacity to feed them.” The richest countries of the world have not been able to say what you have. A poor country like Bangladesh has shown hope and humanity.

You have said, ‘We are with the refugees of Myanmar and will help them till they can return to their own country.’ – how many people are even saying this much? Some Rohingyas may be inclined to become Islamic terrorists, therefore no one is willing to trust them. But you have said if any selfish group tries to take advantage of this situation, action will be taken. You have also said to your citizens not to behave inhumanely toward the refugees. Only you have shown that Muslim nations can be humane too.

Though you have said Myanmar should take back Rohingyas, grant them citizenship, assure them safety, you perhaps know that Myanmar will not welcome back Rohingyas. They will continue to live in Bangladesh for generations to come. A large unskilled, unemployed population will resort to theft, alcohol or terror. This has happened before, and will happen again.

You have said in 1975, you’ve had to stay as a refugee in Europe, which is why you can empathise with them.

But what I don’t get is why you can’t and don’t want to understand my pain. You have made me a refugee. For the last 24 years, I have been roaming from one country to another. Living, but not living in my own country. Because you will not let me enter my own country. You won’t lift the ban on even my book. I want to give the power of attorney to my own sister and you are not letting the Bangladesh Embassy officials sign it. How much more can one person be censored, humiliated, and rendered powerless in one life time?

You are crying for others’ lives, while destroying one yourself. The one who is kind, is kind to all. I have not killed or harmed anyone. Where did you keep aside your humanity when you closed the door of my own country on my face. If you believe in the freedom of speech of only some people and not of others, then you do not believe in freedom of speech. Then you don’t believe in democracy.

You protested Rajib Haider’s murder till you came to know he was an atheist. One after another, progressive thinking youths are being murdered in the country. You have not mourned when atheist bloggers have been murdered. You have not sought justice for them. You weep for Muslims coming back from foreign lands but not for the dead progressive youths of your own country. You don’t perform the role of a prime minister if you don’t speak out against these brutal killings.

Dear Prime Minister, you constantly forget that you are the prime minister of both the religious and the non-religious. Rich, poor, men, women, Hindu, Muslim, religious, non-religious, you have the same duty to all and everyone should be equal before you. All expect the same kindness from you. If not, then your humanity is false, as are your tears.

Some say you are giving shelter to Rohingyas for votes. You’ll get the Muslim vote. If the Rohingyas were Hindus or Buddhists, would you give them shelter? Perhaps not. Hindus in Bangladesh are being persecuted, evicted, their homes are being burnt – have you been standing by their side? Or cried for them? You are not letting me enter my own country to get the majority vote, neither are you showing compassion for the minority, and not even acknowledging the death of atheists. You just want to win. You just want to rule. How can we call a cunning and selfish person free or humane?

Yours

The One you made a refugee for two decades.

Taslima Nasreen is a celebrated author and commentator.

(Translated from Bengali by Neera Majumdar) 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism

4 COMMENTS

  1. Sheikh Hasina became a leader after killing lakhs of muslims by Pakistani forces in march 1971 and after 16 December 1971 by the mukti bahni of biharis,at the cost of 30 lakhs Bengali and biharis and displacement on one crore Bengali and beharis two leaders came up Z.A.Bhutto and Sheikh Mujib and after that next generation Benazir and sheikh Hasina.Dont preach Islam to Taslima try to understand history of islam first your self then others,go back to history of your mother.
    Also go back to history of a muslim nation Pakistan came into being slaughtering lakhs of indian muslims and Sikh and hindus.
    Islam is a religion of peace but always used for slaughtering human being,Syria and Iraq yemen palestin are the current example.

  2. Taslima Mam, You writes more than you read. You know a little about Islam. YET, you talks lot about it. I would recommend you to read a book named “Sirate Mustafa (sw.)” Published by Kaosar Prokashony, Bangali language.
    Prime minister Sheikh Hasina is like Mother to us. So, please stop writing against our mother. She is more intelligent you.

  3. Tasleema is her best, as in this article, when writing about her experienced truth! However, when she speculates on comparative religious deficiencies and opines about imagined problems of others her words are not as effective.

  4. We should be happy that Bangladesh, by no means a prosperous country, has made place in its heart for the Rohingya refugees from Myanmar. They have been traumatised, subjected to ethnic cleansing, war crimes. One hopes China, using its good offices with Bangladesh and Myanmar, will ensure their safe return to their homes.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular

×