Sunday, January 29, 2023
HomeOpinionChinese threat is unlikely to go away. India needs big plans for...

Chinese threat is unlikely to go away. India needs big plans for LAC to save its land

New Delhi must make the stakes high for the Chinese to take any military action against India and renege signed agreements.

Text Size:

A strong response from the Indian Army to the Chinese push at the Line of Actual Control on 15 June and the subsequent caution by Prime Minister Narendra Modi against expansionism set the ball rolling for China to ease back. The Indian response has toppled China’s carefully nurtured image of ‘invincibility’, which has prevented the northern neighbour from admitting to the number of soldiers killed in the clash at Galwan Valley in Ladakh.

But the dangers to India’s peace and stability from China’s onslaught is far from over.

The Chinese are now expected to dig-in just 1,500 metres away, at the edge of the agreed 3-km temporary buffer zone. While they do so, their artillery and tanks would remain far away but they can be brought to the front when required. This situation is identical to what they did in July 1962 after a clash at Galwan. They returned three months later with a massive force and over-ran the Indian defences.

New Delhi must make the stakes high for the Chinese to take any military action against India and renege on signed agreements. China, on its ascendency to superpower status, is not expected to back down, because doing so will mean loss of face.

It is clear that China’s decision to militarily occupy Galwan Valley and other areas of Ladakh was not taken in a spur of the moment, but was planned and had authorisation from the highest levels of the Xi Jinping government. China had huge forces standing by some distances away and had created logistical support and medical infrastructure in preparation. We must plan carefully to firmly resist and fight China.

Also read: India plays into China’s hands if we lament 1962 or criticise Modi govt and military

India has the ability to counter China

In the current standoff in Ladakh, the Chinese have been calling the shots so far and intimidating India at their whim.

After the recent talks between National security Adviser (NSA) Ajit Doval and China’s Foreign Minister Wang Yi, no common statement was released. While India desired earliest complete disengagement, China emphasised its liberty to defend ‘their territory’ that now includes Galwan. No timeline is specified, but the initiative rests with them. On a wide front, stretching some 2,000 km, Chinese forces can launch multiple operations against India.

The size of India’s military is not comparable to that of China but we certainly have the ability to counter all the forces that China can throw into Ladakh.

China’s People’s Liberation Army Air Force (PLAAF) has modernised in a big way. But they have not yet been exposed to any significant operations. In comparison, the firepower that the Indian Air Force (IAF) can bring far exceeds the parity level that we had against the Chinese in 1962. Today, our three services — Army, Navy and Air Force — are well integrated from day one in developing operational plans. Incidentally, the three service chiefs are course-mates from the National  Defence Academy (NDA), that promotes cohesion.

Despite possible distractions posed by the coronavirus crisis and economic slowdown, India’s intelligence assets are good and would certainly be monitoring the Chinese activities at LAC and beyond. Even if the US, Europe and others wish to support India, it may take months or years to form a concrete action plan.

Also read: India’s options against China shrink to two — limited war or another Wuhan

A challenging zone

One can imagine Ladakh as a ‘box’ filled with mountainous deserts, glaciers and fast-flowing seasonal rivers. It cannot accommodate large militaries, and throws serious challenges for the movement of large ground forces.

In the Ladakh ‘box’, the weather can become unpredictable, high altitudes make the planes sluggish, communication gets affected, good airfield support is far, serious limitations are imposed in manoeuvring, weapon accuracy suffers and coping with emergencies on-board becomes a challenge. The stress levels of the aircrew could go very high.

To operate in this environment at night is even more challenging. The IAF should be knowing the capabilities of all the machines that the PLA Air Force can deploy in the ‘box’. These machines are within the capabilities of our Air Force to counter. India can conduct an effective joint air/ground operation  within this ‘box’ — and can also launch a strong offensive action far beyond the ‘box’.

Like Ladakh, there are other areas along the LAC that can be described as ‘boxes’. And each ‘box’ has its own peculiarities and rulebook.

Also read: Time to run IAF in a sleek, corporate way. It’s the Force that counted in Kargil, Balakot

Steps India must take

China is never in a hurry; its strategy is to tire out the adversary with prolonged negotiations in bits and pieces and at different levels, all intended to take away the heat and focus from the given situation. India must remember that the 1962 war happened nearly 60 years ago, but important issues still remain unsettled. Our borders are still to be demarcated.

Since the Chinese threat is unlikely to go away anytime soon, India must plan in a big way.

First and foremost, we must improve access at the LAC. We need to double the speed at which we are building roads, and expand the rail projects in the Himalayas. This is happening but far too slowly.

We also must build a number of airstrips that can accommodate transport aircraft and helicopters. We need these to move soldiers and machines when in a hurry, and also maintain the infrastructure there. Our aircraft designers must, on priority, design and develop aircraft that can carry equipment, passengers and livestock safely to high altitude airstrips.

Moreover, the rulebook of Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has to be turned upside down. Air transportation in the hills must become as common as bus-services. We need gas and oil pipelines to run across the Himalayas. We need the best of business minds to create economic activity that is essential to support our building effort. Mining could be a possibility.

India also needs to build hospitals and related infrastructure. Tourism can change the shape of our lives in the hills. We can create Hiking Parks at hundreds of places and Grand Canyon-like creations are waiting to be discovered that would attract thousands of adventurers and visitors while maintaining the beauty of the region. To achieve all this, we have to believe in ourselves.

Also read: India can’t afford to be defensive against China like it has been with Pakistan on terror

Time to push the enemy back

In 1963, I stayed with the Army for a few months and walked a lot with the soldiers stationed in Ladakh. The Leh area was like a desert — it had no grass or greens, Changla Pass was not built, Chushul area was green and flat and looked like a football field, our C-119 Packet aircraft used to land there on steel strips.

But Leh and the neighbouring areas have been transformed today. It has a great number of people, buildings and even cultivation that could not be imagined in 1963. We have done a lot of development and we can do far better. Our political wrangling and television debates are draining our energy. This should stop. We need to think and discuss progression, new ideas, new ways on how to make India more prosperous. We do not want political slogans. If only we can leave it to the people and create opportunities, India can shine. The Chinese will gradually disappear and take their tents away.

While India does not wish a war, we can’t give up our land to a belligerent enemy. Having suffered subjugation under Mughal and British rules, we must firmly counter hegemony. If we give into China’s vicious plan or fail in our efforts, our future generations will not forgive us. We must guard firmly and if a war is to be fought, we shall do so in unity.

The author is a retired Air Chief Marshal, who was Chief of Staff, Indian Air Force, 2001-2004. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Every incident throws up an opportunity!
    And this is ours!
    The Air Chief is right. Let us all, the hardworking common man, the self-centred politician and the carefree youth, get their acts together. This and ONLY this, is the time to act. This is the time for innovation and hard work.
    This is the time to throw away all Chinese made stuff and come up with breathtaking innovations.
    We owe it to posterity.

  2. Fact is that Modi chickened out………he is mortally afraid of PLA. and Chinese are clever enough to smell his fears …….Compare: when IAF bombed Balakot ..Pakistan PAF retaliated within 24 hours shooting down Indian aircrafts …PAF did not say its budget is 1/10 of IAF……IT SIMPLY HIT BACK…….. When 20 brave Indian soldiers are clubbed to death what did Modi do……………Talk & only talk…………..shameful !!!

  3. India is far away to build military force compared to Chinese,both in devoloping technology and infrastructure.Even after 73 years from independence ,Indian corrupt politicians before Modi era had exploited the country .During the period of coalition Govt. by Congress party,the other political parties like DMK had dragged the country’s progress down.

  4. Not war but threat of war is the Chinese strategy. Will India venture into suicidal arms-race with China? Eternal vigilance and preparedness can have costs on the Indian economy. Should we now divert our resources from the western border to the East? India will now face an enhanced threat of two fronts war. What this incidence has done is that it belied the futile illusions of friendship and economic partnership with China. The strategy of appeasing China by event management of grandiose ceremonies has failed. China is too shrewd to be lured by such optics.

    • China plays GO and not chess
      China detests war and considers going to war a job of novices and incompetent strategists.
      In its 23 border disputes since 1949 it has used force only 3 times viz 1962 ,1969 and 1979.
      Making moves which force the opponent to react in a fashion which destroy him without a bullet being fired are possible only with great skill,long preparation and exquisite timing. This is why GO is so much more difficult than Chess.
      I use the word Play GO as a metaphor

  5. Are you ok. How can you write this
    Our political wrangling and television debates are draining our energy.
    Are you dumb. It’s democracy and free media. How debating in media draining energy of govt.

      • Such comment might have an ulterior motive
        How to report it
        There is no report button.There is only a reply button

        • Write to Shekhar Gupta, the editor-in-chief, to employ editors to screen letters submitted so that decorum and civility in the discussion are maintained.

  6. If a Chief Air Marshal says that Chinese territory now includes Galwan and also “It is clear that China’s decision to militarily occupy Galwan Valley and other areas of Ladakh was not taken in a spur of the moment” and the P.M. says there has been no transgression in Ladakh then whom to believe?

  7. The Air Chief (r) hit the nail on the head when he states “Our political wrangling and television debates are draining our energy. This should stop. “

Comments are closed.