Saturday, April 1, 2023
HomeOpinionBloodless Bakrid or crackerless Diwali – religious whataboutery has marred festivals

Bloodless Bakrid or crackerless Diwali – religious whataboutery has marred festivals

Text Size:

Climate of polarisation has ensured questions about charity, environment and animal rights are given a religious or political tilt.

Bakrid has always been criticised by pro-vegetarians in India. Now, Hindutva supporters are sharing pictures, asking Muslims to donate to Kerala floods victims instead of slaughtering a goat.

The motive is communal, and not protection of the goats.

Incidentally, many urged Indians last week to not send money to the flood victims because Kerala is home to beef-eaters and a large population of Muslims and Christians.

Religious festivals are now the stage where India’s new politics of polarisation is being enacted. If you tell Hindus to not burn polluting firecrackers on Diwali, you will be told to go tell Muslims to not slaughter goats on Bakrid or Eid al-Adha.

If you tell Muslims to not offer Friday namaz prayers in public, you are reminded about kanwariyas and their road-rage acts. If you complain about all-night loudspeaker jagrans, you will be asked how many times you have spoken against Muslims using loudspeakers for azaan, the daily prayer.

Also read: Kanwariyas vs Namazis: Double standard over disruption in public spaces?

What were shared festivals – of feasting and gifting – are now getting boxed into ghettos.

But what complicate this picture of deliberate division within communities are the animal rights and environmental causerattis. These activists do not engage in communal whataboutery, but speak about air pollution, lung diseases and cruelty to animals. But they too are attacked by religious slander.

Every year hundreds of thousands of Hindu families bring plaster-of-paris idols of Ganesha, Durga to their homes, offer prayers for days, and then immerse them in the nearest water body. It has been reported that the new, non-earthy and non-clay idols, which are painted with synthetic colours, do not dissolve in water properly and choke the fish to death.

Appeals have been made to use natural clay Ganpatis. But every year, the size and number of idols, painted with synthetic colours, increase.

Last year, when the Supreme Court announced a ban on selling of crackers in Delhi-NCR, Tajinder Singh Bagga, the spokesperson of BJP’s Delhi unit, distributed crackers for free, and said he was opposed to “selective ban”.

Also read: Talk Point: Does public health justify the SC stalling the sale of fireworks for Diwali?

When PETA activists protest against the slaughter of goats and call for vegan Bakrid, they are chased away by the community.

Similarly, during the month of Sharavan, Hindus pour milk over the Shivling. Some people suggested symbolic pouring of a few drops of milk and donating the rest to the needy. But such an initiative never took off.

Currently, India has a high rate of stunting, 38.4 per cent, among children, and more than 50 per cent young women are anaemic, according to the latest National Family Health Survey (NHFS) report. Donating milk to poor children, therefore, can be a better alternative.

The climate of polarisation has ensured that even genuine questions about charity, environment protection and animal rights are given religious and political tilt.

Some responsibility for this resistance must also be borne by those traders who profit from this massive consumption-driven commercialisation of festivals.

It is not just religious festivals. Now even natural disasters have become a stage for communal politics. From Bakrid to Kerala floods, religious politics will continue to poison public debate.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Gadhimai, in Nepal, used to witness an annual sacrifice of buffalo, etc. for Dussehra. Outcry by international press and NGOs over this “Hindu” ritual has led to its cessation, possibly because of the financial clout wielded by Western interests on Nepal’s economic life.

    Will these same voices be willing to protest the horrific waste of animal life annually seen in Saudi Arabia? Many tens of thousands of animals are ritually slaughtered by proxy and then wastefully disposed of, without any of the prescribed sharing of meat with the needy mandated by the Quran ( as far as my scant understanding of the qurbani of Eid ul Adha goes. I beg to be corrected. ) How is the Sunna being observed, via this long-distance, for-profit, for-convenience, merely ritualistic slaughter, devoid of any real meaning or true devotion?

    Why is there no outcry, especially from the truly devout, and from the bleeding hearts among the Westerners ready to bear the White Man’s burden so anxiously elsewhere among the benighted heathen? Why this conspicuous partiality against Hinduism, children of a false God, as it were???? Is that what these Westerners are emphasizing? They should be courageous enough to clearly state their premises.

  2. In essence we all should come out of blind faith and many old rituals being followed with out understanding. Wake up time for all !!

  3. Recently I read in a column that our former PM ate non vegetarian food and occasionally enjoyed drinks. That was his personal life.

    Did that make him sinful.

    It is silly to make mountain of a molehill.


  4. Wife’s heart and soul – being a devout Jain – tremble at the thought of ritual sacrifice. Some of us who are non vegetarian may not be able to handle the totality and scale of the process. However, that cannot be grounds for chanting, Yogiji ke UP mein rehna hai, Toh eggless cake khana hoga.

Comments are closed.