scorecardresearch

Friday, November 20, 2026

Support our Journalism

Depth, context and analysis

Subscribe
HomeJudiciaryWhy ICICI Bank board's sanction against ex-CEO Chanda Kochhar failed legal test...

Why ICICI Bank board’s sanction against ex-CEO Chanda Kochhar failed legal test in Videocon loan case

The Bombay HC ruled that RBI, not the bank's board, had the legal authority to sanction Kochhar's prosecution. It also found that the board had failed to independently examine the CBI's evidence.

Stay updated with ThePrint:

New Delhi: The power to remove a bank’s managing director and the authority to sanction their prosecution became central to the Bombay High Court’s decision to quash the prosecution sanction against former ICICI Bank CEO Chanda Kochhar in the Videocon loan case.

On 18 November, Justice Milind N. Jadhav held that the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), and not ICICI Bank’s board of directors, was the competent authority to grant sanction to prosecute Kochhar under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act). The court also found that the board had “mechanically approved” the sanction without demonstrating that it had independently examined the material collected by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI).

The high court quashed the 15 May 2023 sanction order and the subsequent proceedings before the special CBI court, ruling that the defect affected the very basis of the prosecution and was not a minor procedural lapse.

The high court ruling came after a challenge by Kochhar, who argued that the bank’s board lacked the statutory authority to sanction her prosecution.

What is the Videocon loan case?

The CBI’s case dates back to loans sanctioned by ICICI Bank to companies belonging to the Videocon Group between June 2009 and October 2011, when Kochhar was the bank’s managing director and CEO.

The agency alleged that six loans amounting to Rs 1,875 crore were sanctioned to the group despite Kochhar’s husband, Deepak Kochhar, having business dealings with Videocon promoter Venugopal Dhoot. CBI alleged that Chanda Kochhar was part of the committee that approved two of these loans and failed to disclose the conflict of interest.

The CBI further alleged that after a Rs 300-crore loan was sanctioned to Videocon International Electronics Ltd, Deepak Kochhar received Rs 64 crore through NuPower Renewables Ltd., a company allegedly set up to route the money, and where both Deepak Kochar and Venugopal Dhoot were directors. The agency described this as an indirect gratification for the loans sanctioned by ICICI Bank.

Another allegation concerned a Mumbai flat valued at Rs 5.25 crore in 1996, which the CBI claimed was transferred to a family trust linked to Deepak Kochhar for Rs 11 lakh as part of the alleged quid pro quo.

The CBI registered an FIR against Kochhar in January 2019 under Sections 420 IPC (cheating and dishonesty) and 120B of the Prevention of Corruption Act (criminal conspiracy).

In March 2023, CBI approached ICICI Bank seeking sanction to prosecute Chanda Kochhar. The bank’s board of directors granted the sanction on 15 May 2023.

Kochhar subsequently approached the Bombay High Court, challenging the authority of the board to grant such sanction.

Why RBI is the competent authority

The central issue before the court was the interpretation of Section 19(1)(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

The provision requires prior sanction from the authority competent to remove a public servant from office before a court can take cognisance of certain corruption offences. Since Kochhar was the former managing director of a private sector bank, the question was whether the power to remove her rested with ICICI Bank’s board or the RBI.

Her lawyer, senior advocate Abad Ponda, argued that the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, which governs banking companies, gives the RBI overriding powers in matters concerning the appointment and removal of senior bank officials.

The CBI, represented by Additional Solicitor General Anil Singh, opposed this interpretation. It argued that ICICI Bank’s board of directors had the authority to appoint and remove its managing director under the Companies Act 2013, and Clause 151(a) (clause which empowers bank to appoint managing director and other directors) of the bank’s Articles of Association. It further contended that the RBI’s powers were regulatory in nature and did not take away the board’s existing powers.

The court rejected the CBI’s argument after quoting multiple provisions of the Banking Regulation Act (mentioned below).

The court relied on Section 5A, which states that the Banking Regulation Act will prevail over any conflicting provisions in a bank’s memorandum, Articles of Association, agreements or board resolutions.

The court also examined Section 35B(1)(b), which requires prior RBI approval for the appointment, reappointment or termination of appointment of a managing director, whole-time director or other specified senior officials of a banking company.

More importantly, it relied on Section 36AA which empowers the RBI to remove a chairman, director, CEO or other officer of a banking company in specified circumstances, including where such action is necessary in public interest or to secure proper management of the bank.

Reading these provisions together, Justice Jadhav held that the statutory power of removal in Kochhar’s case vested with the RBI and could not be exercised by ICICI Bank’s board by relying on its internal Articles of Association.

The judge also rejected the CBI’s contention that Kochhar had earlier referred to the bank’s board as the competent authority in her petition. He held that an admission or drafting error cannot override a statutory provision or alter what the law requires.

The court concluded that the CBI ought to have approached the RBI for sanction under Section 19 of the PC Act.

Why was sanction ‘invalid’ even on procedural grounds

The court examined a second issue: Whether the board of directors had independently applied its mind before granting sanction.

Kochhar argued that the CBI had not placed the entire investigation material before the board. According to her, the minutes of the board meeting showed that only the investigating agency’s letter and report had been circulated, without the supporting documents and witness statements.

The CBI maintained that the board had been briefed on the investigation, had considered a summary of its findings and had also consulted an eminent jurist before granting sanction.

The court, however, found that neither the sanction order nor the minutes of the board meeting demonstrated any independent assessment of the evidence against Kochhar. It noted that the board had relied on the CBI’s letter and report without examining the underlying material.

Justice Jadhav relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in CBI v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal (2014), which held that the entire relevant investigation record, including material that could favour the accused, must be placed before the sanctioning authority.

The authority must independently scrutinise the material rather than merely endorse the investigating agency’s recommendation.

The court also referred to State of Karnataka v. Ameerjan (2007), in which the Supreme Court held that a sanction granted without proper application of mind cannot be sustained.

Applying these principles, the High Court found that the ICICI Bank board had not demonstrated that it considered the evidence, witness statements or other relevant documents before granting sanction.

It also noted that the sanction order did not explain the basis on which the board had concluded that prosecution was warranted.

The court also pointed out the contradiction between the bank’s claim that it had followed proper lending procedures and suffered no losses, and the CBI’s allegation that the bank had incurred a loss of Rs 1,033.39 crore.

Why did the court intervene before Kochhar trial?

The CBI argued that any challenge to the validity of the sanction should be examined during the trial, when both sides could produce evidence on the material placed before the sanctioning authority.

The court rejected this argument, distinguishing between an irregularity in an existing sanction and the absence of a legally valid sanction.

The court relied on Supreme Court judgments in Abdul Wahab Ansari v. State of Bihar (2000) and Nanjappa v. State of Karnataka (2015) to hold that a special court cannot take up a case under the PC Act without a valid sanction from the competent authority.

It also cited State of Karnataka v. C. Nagarajaswamy (2005), which said that the question of whether the authority granting sanction was legally competent should be examined at an early stage.

The court noted that Kochhar had challenged the sanction before charges were framed and had therefore raised the issue at the right time.

The CBI’s request for an eight-week stay to challenge the judgment before the Supreme Court was also rejected.

(Edited by Viny Mishra)


Also read: Why tribunal upheld ED’s attachment of Chanda Kochhar’s Mumbai flat in ICICI Bank loan fraud case


 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

For readers who want the full picture.

You read our articles closely. Subscribe to go further, with exclusive newsletters in your inbox, flagship events hosted by Shekhar Gupta, AMAs with our senior editors, the chance to write under your own byline, and more.

Subscribe to ThePrint →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular