New Delhi: He has a divorce decree from a British court for a marriage in India and a second wife in the UK. His first marriage remains intact in India, leaving him facing a ‘bigamy prosecution’ for remarrying.
The Supreme Court’s recent refusal to quash the proceedings has brought the problem of “limping marriages” into focus: relationships that have legally ended in one country but continue to exist in another. While the law seeks to protect the spouse left behind, legal experts say it can also leave women tied to marriages that have long ended in practice, raising questions about whether India’s approach offers protection or prolongs uncertainty.
The dispute traces back to April 2003, when two Indian citizens got married in Andhra Pradesh under Hindu rites. The husband moved to the United Kingdom in 2005, and the wife joined him in 2006.
A year later, in 2007, she returned to India to give birth to their son but did not return to the UK. Following a marital breakdown, the husband initiated divorce and custody proceedings in Andhra Pradesh. After these were dismissed and his High Court appeal was withdrawn, his Hindu marriage continued to subsist.
In 2013, he acquired British citizenship and within months, filed for divorce in Cambridge County Court, UK.
Overriding the wife’s jurisdictional objections, the UK court issued a decree provisionally on 27 November, 2013, making it absolute on 29 January, 2014, on the ground of “irretrievable breakdown of marriage”.
Shortly after, on 3 March, 2014, the husband married another woman in the UK. Two years later, his first wife filed a criminal complaint of bigamy under IPC sections in Andhra Pradesh.
In July 2019, the Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissed the husband’s petitions to quash the charges against him, prompting appeals to the apex court.
Before the Supreme Court, the husband, his parents and his second wife asked for the quashing of all criminal bigamy proceedings against them, contending that the foreign divorce was valid under Section 14 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) and that his British nationality exempted him from Indian criminal liability. His first wife countered that foreign decrees based on grounds unrecognised under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, cannot dissolve an Indian Hindu marriage.
Earlier this month, the Supreme Court gave a verdict with no relief to the husband.
Dismissing his appeal, the court sustained the bigamy prosecution against him, ruling that foreign decrees based on irretrievable breakdown violate Section 13 CPC and cannot shield a second marriage, nor does acquiring foreign citizenship negate liability for an Indian marriage.
In the same ruling, the parents and the second wife received complete relief. The top court clarified that criminal conspiracy requires specific overt acts or conscious facilitation, which were absent in their cases.
Now, with the non-recognition of the foreign decree, the first wife may preserve a legal basis to pursue financial claims, but it also leaves her tied to a marriage that has effectively ended in reality. The question, therefore, is whether keeping the marriage alive offers meaningful protection to the spouse left behind, or merely prolongs the uncertainty for everyone involved.
Legal experts are divided on where the balance should lie, but agree that the case exposes difficulties in resolving matrimonial disputes across jurisdictions.
While some see reforming India’s domestic divorce laws as an appropriate route to addressing the problem, some argue for a separate statutory framework governing the recognition of foreign matrimonial decrees.
Experts suggest amending the current matrimonial legislation governing marriages under the Hindu Marriage Act and Special Marriage Act to recognise irreconcilable breakdown as a ground for divorce with adequate safeguards. Instead of contesting the Supreme Court to validate a foreign decree, trial courts can dissolve a dead marriage on this ground.
Conflict between statutory rigidity & lived reality
Advocate Malavika Rajkotia, who has dealt with such matrimonial disputes for the past 30 years, said the Supreme Court’s ruling was legally correct, particularly given that irretrievable breakdown of marriage is not an independent ground for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act.
Recounting a previous case, Rajkotia said the husband had converted to Islam and married another woman under Dubai law without first dissolving his Hindu marriage. A bigamy case was subsequently initiated and eventually settled.
However, the case raises a larger question about the practical implications of keeping a marriage legally alive in India when one spouse has permanently settled abroad and established another family.
The issue in such disputes often goes beyond the breakdown of the relationship to financial obligations arising from it, Rajkotia said. “Finance is always at the root of it. The question is, what has he done financially for her? Most divorces are resisted by women for that reason”, she said.
Jwalika Balaji, who works with Vidhi Centre for Legal Policy, also agreed that while the Supreme Court’s ruling was legally correct, the non-recognition of foreign divorce decrees can have problematic practical consequences, particularly for women left behind in India.
She said the rationale behind this approach was to protect the spouse in India by ensuring that the marriage continued to subsist under Indian law. However, in practice, this can create what is known as a “limping marriage”, where one spouse is divorced and has remarried abroad, while the original marriage continues to legally exist in India.
She pointed out that criminal bigamy proceedings can sometimes become a bargaining tool in such disputes. When a husband residing abroad ignores court summons, courts may issue warrants or take steps such as the passport authorities impounding his passport. Lookout notices may also be issued in appropriate circumstances.
However, such measures can also produce the opposite result, Balaji cautioned. A husband who fears arrest upon entering India may simply avoid returning, leaving the wife with little practical recourse.
“The woman never ends up getting divorced; he too continues living his life. That’s also another issue,” she said, adding that the state machinery was often not adequately equipped to enforce such orders or monitor cross-border movements.
Balaji argued that continuing to recognise the foreign divorce could, in some cases, allow the woman to move on with her life rather than remain trapped in a marriage that has effectively ended.
However, she also acknowledged that there are substantive reasons why women might want to continue the marriage legally in India since divorce proceedings are often the primary route through which women seek maintenance, division of assets and other financial claims.
“Once you are divorced, unless you have a kid, it’s really hard to make any claims on your spouse for maintenance or to get any property because legally there is no relationship that you have with this person anymore,” she said.
‘Real issue is whether exit is fair’
Former ASG and senior advocate with over 40 years of practice, Pinky Anand told ThePrint that the marriage is kept alive as a form of protection for the wife, advocating for a more effective civil remedy and a specific framework for recognising foreign decrees with financial safeguards.
She argues that the first marriage cannot be viewed merely as a legal status that should automatically end once one spouse has moved abroad and established a new life.
Referring to the facts of this case, “The forum changed. The facts did not,” she told ThePrint.
To her, the question is not simply whether a marriage should remain alive on paper, but whether its dissolution is accompanied by a fair settlement of the obligations arising from it. “Ending a marriage is not just about ending a status. It is about settling what is owed: maintenance, a home and security for the child”, she says.
She acknowledges, however, that refusing to recognise a foreign divorce can have a dual effect. While it may protect an abandoned spouse, it can also turn criminal proceedings into a means of prolonging disputes or extracting concessions.
“For many women, non-recognition is the only real leverage they have,” Anand says. With husbands living abroad, maintenance orders may go unpaid, summons may be ignored, and civil decrees can be difficult to enforce across borders. The prospect of a criminal case, she argues, may be the only thing that brings a husband back to the negotiating table. “In that sense, it is a necessary evil,” she says.
But Anand cautioned that the same proceedings can be used to reopen property disputes, gain an advantage in custody battles or prevent the other party from moving on. Elderly parents and second spouses may also be dragged into cases without sufficient material against them.
The answer, she argues, is not to withdraw this protection altogether, but to create an effective civil mechanism through which abandoned spouses can enforce their financial rights, leaving criminal law to address genuine wrongdoing.
Bigamy & the question of extradition
Rajkotia also pointed to the criminal consequences of entering into a second marriage while the first remains legally subsisting, arguing that bigamy is an offence against the State and not merely a private matrimonial dispute.
On whether the husband could face extradition proceedings, she acknowledged that the dual-criminality requirement could make extradition possible, given that bigamy is also an offence in the UK.
She added that even if the first wife decided not to pursue the complaint, that would not necessarily bring the criminal proceedings to an end as the offence of bigamy is an offence against the State. So even the wife saying, ‘I don’t want to contest,’ is not good enough, she said.
On whether criminal proceedings were an effective solution for women in such situations, Balaji expressed reservations about using criminal law to regulate matrimonial relationships.
She said that while the state could continue pursuing a bigamy case through summons and arrest warrants, these measures were unlikely to compel a husband living abroad to return or resume the marriage.
She noted that the first wife could potentially use the proceedings as leverage to secure a financial settlement, including money or property to support herself and her children.
However, she stressed that the ultimate course of action would depend on what the woman wanted to achieve.
On the practical outcomes of bigamy prosecutions involving spouses living abroad, Anand says very few cases reach a final verdict. A trial requires strict proof that the second marriage was validly solemnised, while the marriage, witnesses and accused may all be outside India’s jurisdiction.
Many cases, she says, remain at the stage of summons and warrants for years. In the absence of official data on how these cases ultimately conclude, she argues that the pressure generated by the possibility of a Lookout Circular or passport action can sometimes achieve what a trial does not: a financial settlement.
For a woman abandoned with a child and left without maintenance, she says, the criminal case may be “the last door that remains open”. But she also acknowledges that the same measures can be used to settle scores, stall divorce proceedings or extract an unjust bargain. Requests for LOCs or passport-related action, she argues, must therefore be assessed on their individual facts and on whether they serve a genuine enforcement need.
Why Parliament needs to step in
Balaji argued that the solution lies not necessarily in changing the rules governing recognition of foreign judgments, but in making irretrievable breakdown of marriage an independent statutory ground for divorce in India.
She said Parliament could incorporate the grounds into the Hindu Marriage Act and the Special Marriage Act, with appropriate safeguards, rather than attempting to legislate on the validity of foreign decrees themselves.
“It’s not like Parliament can make any law about resolving the conflict between foreign and Indian decrees. This is a pure conflict of laws issue,” she said.
Referring to Vidhi’s Model Family Law Code, published in 2024, she said irretrievable breakdown could be introduced as a ground for divorce, subject to safeguards such as a minimum one-year duration of marriage before filing and a cooling-off period.
On whether India should introduce a mechanism to recognise foreign divorce decrees based on irretrievable breakdown, Rajkotia was categorical that a ground not recognised under Indian law could not simply be imported from another jurisdiction, adding that such cross-border matrimonial disputes were becoming increasingly common as international migration increased.
Anand sees the Supreme Court’s increasing use of Article 142 to dissolve marriages that have irretrievably broken down as evidence that the existing divorce law has fallen behind social realities.
“When a constitutional power meant for the exceptional case begins to be used routinely, it is a clear sign that the statute has fallen behind the society it governs,” she says.
She points to the uneven access to this remedy: while the Supreme Court can dissolve a marriage under Article 142, an ordinary litigant before a family court cannot invoke the same power, irrespective of how long the marriage has been over in practical terms.
She argues that ordinary litigants should not have to approach the Supreme Court to obtain relief on a ground that the court itself recognises. Legislative reform, however, must be accompanied by safeguards: a substantial minimum period of separation, a fair financial settlement as a condition of divorce, and the power of courts to refuse dissolution where it would cause grave hardship.
Anand went further than simply advocating the inclusion of irretrievable breakdown as a ground for divorce in Indian law. She believes Parliament should create a specific mechanism for recognising foreign matrimonial decrees, subject to safeguards.
Citing the Law Commission’s 287th Report of 2024 on marriages involving non-resident Indians and overseas citizens of India, she says Parliament could build on the recommendations to establish a clearer framework.
(Edited by Anupama Yadav)
