Chandigarh: A cow the size of a dog could soon be at the centre of a debate in the Panchkula Municipal Corporation. Ward 4 councillor Bharat Hiteshi has moved a special agenda item, urging the House to allow residents to keep Nadipathy cows, up to two feet tall, as pets.
He has modelled the proposal on the Nadipathy Goshala in Andhra Pradesh. The item requests the House to frame rules on space, cleanliness, animal care, animal welfare and public health after consulting the concerned departments, and to grant permission under those conditions.
“Hindus worship the cow and keep it at home. Panchkula is a planned city developed largely by the Haryana Shahri Vikas Pradhikaran (HSVP), where keeping milch animals is prohibited,” Hiteshi told ThePrint.
A miniature cow, he said, is the size of a dog and can easily be kept in a house. The meeting certainly would be held by the end of the month, Hiteshi added.
Strictly speaking, Nadipathy is not a breed. It is the name of a goshala at Lingamparthi village in Andhra Pradesh’s Eluru region, and the brand founded by its founder and Ayurvedic practitioner P. Krishnam Raju. The goshala says its animals grow to just two feet. These miniature cows gained attention after Raju presented them to PM Narendra Modi.
The cattle are descended from the Punganur, a dwarf breed from Chittoor district of Andhra Pradesh. Punganur is among the world’s smallest humped cattle breeds, and its milk has a high fat content.
Krishnam Raju is said to have devoted 14 years breeding ever-smaller animals, using semen from the smallest Punganur bulls and artificial insemination, and introduced his miniature version in 2019.
Panchkula Mayor Shyam Lal Bansal, meanwhile, said he noticed the proposal and personally saw nothing wrong with it.
“I will discuss the matter with Urban Local Bodies Minister Vipul Goel and also with Chief Minister Nayab Singh Saini. A miniature cow is just the size of a dog and should be allowed to be kept as a pet in houses. People can also enjoy its milk. A condition can be kept that they will not be brought on the roads,” Bansal told ThePrint.
Congress spokesperson Pawan Jain declined to be drawn in, saying the Panchkula corporation would take a call.
The legal position
The law, as it stands, does not favour the proposal. Section 331A of the Haryana Municipal Corporation Act, 1994, inserted by a 2022 amendment, prohibits keeping and rearing quadruped animals within municipal corporation limits. The exceptions cover domestic pets, milch animals in specified peripheral villages, designated zones and registered gaushalas.
Whether a miniature cow would count as a ‘domestic pet’ is not settled, and the exact location of a property would first have to be established.
Section 241 of the Act separately bars tethering animals on public streets and milking cows or buffaloes there. Animals found in violation can be removed and impounded. The Haryana Municipal (Cow-houses) Bye-laws, 1978, lay down licensing and sanitation conditions for cow houses and allow limited relaxation for a householder keeping one milch animal for personal use.
For HSVP sectors, the courts have already spoken. In Om Parkash and Another vs State of Haryana (9 October 2012), the Punjab and Haryana High Court dealt with dairy activity in Sector 19, Panchkula.
It relied on a 2009 ruling which held that residential plots were allotted for residential use and dairy business could not be run from them. The earlier ruling also directed the Haryana Shahari Vikas Pradhikaran, formerly Haryana Urban Development Authority, to frame a scheme for alternative plots for dairy owners.
(Edited by Tony Rai)
