Anandabazar Patrika office in Kolkata, and editor Anirban Chattopadhyay: Image: ThePrint Team
Anandabazar Patrika office in Kolkata, and editor Anirban Chattopadhyay: Image: ThePrint Team
Text Size:

Kolkata: The editor of Anandabazar Patrika, the highly respected and largest-circulated Bangla newspaper, has resigned, with the news emerging four days after Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee accused the 98-year-old daily of showing the state government in bad light and the editor was summoned by Kolkata Police for allegedly publishing fake news.

The resignation of Anirban Chattopadhyay, 62, is snowballing into a major political controversy, with allegations being made about “pressure” from the Mamata Banerjee government and the threat to media freedom in West Bengal.

On 27 May, Banerjee had launched a tirade against the media in general and Anandabazar Patrika in particular for what she said was pulling down the image of the state with their negative coverage of the government’s efforts to handle the coronavirus and cyclone Amphan crises.

Governor Jagdeep Dhankhar took up the issue even before Chattopadhyay’s resignation, tweeting the day after the police summons were issued that press freedom was non-negotiable, and that he had sought updates from the home secretary about the case in which the editor was summoned to the Hare Street police station.

Government officials like Chief Secretary Rajiva Sinha, Home Secretary Alapan Bandyopadhyay and Kolkata Police Commissioner Anuj Sharma did not respond to text messages and emails from ThePrint asking for a comment on this controversy, while Chattopadhyay did not answer calls or texts.


Also read: Indian media controlled by a few, a risk to press freedom and pluralism: Study


Mamata’s tirade

Speaking to journalists at the state secretariat Nabanna on 27 May, one week after cyclone Amphan had struck West Bengal, CM Mamata Banerjee specifically mentioned Anandabazar Patrika as part of a larger attack on the media’s “negative” coverage of the government’s handling of the Covid-19 crisis, and then Amphan.

We are deeply grateful to our readers & viewers for their time, trust and subscriptions.

Quality journalism is expensive and needs readers to pay for it. Your support will define our work and ThePrint’s future.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

“I am forced to say this, but the role of some media organisations has been terrible. I am sorry to say, the role of ABP, the newspaper, has been very bad to say the least. You (the paper) did not give the state government time to get its act in order; and started politicising the issue in a matter of two days. You created panic, spread apprehensions and provoked people,” she said.

She also made an unsubstantiated reference to the ABP Group being in a business relationship with private power utility CESC, and implied that the government was being maligned for the shortcomings of CESC.

“You people can have differences with CESC, but that should not be used as a handle to malign the state government,” the CM said.

At the time, both the government and the CESC were facing criticism for failing to prepare for cyclone Amphan and the resultant power failures and struggles to restore it. Banerjee claimed CESC got the rights to supply electricity in Kolkata during the Left Front government’s tenure, and blamed it for not being able to restore power when protests erupted.

Several localities in Kolkata faced almost a week-long power outage after Amphan hit the state, and the CESC even put out an advertisement apologising to people, claiming it was facing acute stuff shortage due to the coronavirus-induced lockdown.

ThePrint reached CESC through emails seeking its comments on what the CM said, but there was no response until the time of publishing this report.

Banerjee went on to accuse Anandabazar Patrika of damaging the state’s image.

“We were asking for help from select groups, but that did not materialise. You have caused unthinkable damage to the state’s image and you will realise this only when you yourselves face some problems,” she said, before making a reference to recent lay-offs and pay-cuts in the ABP Group.

“You people do business in Bengal, sack people here and even cut the salary of your employees. You would have been taught a lesson if you were in any other state, and under any other government. We are a humane government; we work in democratic ways and we do not believe in taking action against such acts that you do,” Banerjee said.


Also read: ‘Journalism without fear’ — importance of 2020 World Press Freedom Day theme amid Covid


Police case against Anandabazar Patrika

Within hours of Banerjee’s comments, Chattopadhyay was issued summons to appear before the Hare Street police station.

Police sources said a case had been lodged by the state’s information and cultural affairs department against the “editor and other responsible persons” on 5 April, and that multiple charges had been invoked, including “wantonly giving provocation with intent to cause riot”, providing “false information to provoke public servant to cause injury” to others, intentionally insulting and provoking one to breach public peace, and conducting public mischief.

A senior police officer who did not wish to be named said the government took action against the newspaper for what he said was publishing “fake news” in the middle of the Covid-19 pandemic, although he did not elaborate on what the alleged fake news items were. No reports or other articles have been cited officially, but sources within Anandabazar Patrika said they could’ve been about the state government’s handling of the Covid crisis, doctors not getting PPE kits, the condition of Covid hospitals or about post-Amphan management.

Chattopadhyay had been first summoned in connection with this case in early April, soon after the case was filed, but he had sent a legal response to the police, explaining his inability to go to the police station as he is a senior citizen and has been asked by doctors to avoid public places. He also attached a medical certificate.

This response was not followed up on, but Chattopadhyay was again summoned on 27 May, and didn’t appear for the same reason cited above. However, just four days after the second summons, news emerged that he had resigned as editor and was replaced by Ishani Datta Ray.

After the publication of this report, a top IPS source in the Kolkata Police contacted ThePrint and claimed that the first and only summons were issued to Chattopadhyay on 25 May, two days before Mamata’s outburst against the media and Anandabazar Patrika. The source said 28 May, the day after the CM spoke, was the scheduled date for Chattopadhyay’s appearance, when he sent the response saying he wouldn’t be able to appear.

Governor raises questions about press freedom

In his 28 May tweet, Governor Dhankhar also tagged the Editors Guild of India, and stated: “Press freedom is non negotiable. It is spine of democracy and guaranteed by Constitution.”

 

That wasn’t the last reference he made to press freedom in Bengal either — on 31 May, Governor Dhankhar was even more direct in his accusations against CM Mamata.

 

ThePrint approached several executive members of the Kolkata Press Club on their interaction with the governor, but none wished to come on record. A senior member said on the condition of anonymity: “It was just a courtesy call. The issue with the Anandabazar Patrika editor has not been raised and discussed.

“Moreover, the Press Club is a welfare organisation, and it has nothing to do with the internal affairs of a publication.”

Dhankhar also tweeted on 1 June, the day after the news of Chattopadhyay’s resignation emerged, squarely blaming CM Mamata.

 


Also read: ‘Pressure to toe Hindutva line’ sees India drop to 142 on World Press Freedom Index


Political storm

Also on 1 June, CPI(M) state secretary Surjya Kanta Mishra took to Twitter to demand a statement from CM Mamata, alleging that she had created political pressure on ABP, and also drawing parallels to allegations against BJP governments elsewhere.

“The chief minister should have the courage to make a statement about such a serious allegation. Otherwise, it has to be assumed that the media is being controlled according to the wishes of the CM herself, which means the BJP and the Trinamool are equal. Anandabazar editor resigned under the pressure of Mamata!” Mishra tweeted in Bangla.

Swapan Dasgupta, BJP Rajya Sabha MP and columnist, added that the situation was grim in West Bengal.

“Press freedom has been strangled in its true sense. This is not about Anirban Chattopadhyay of ABP; there can be a curious coincidence between the summons sent to him and his decision to resign, but it has become a general rule,” Dasgupta told ThePrint.

“The utterances of the chief minister threatening media in press conferences are out in the open. Many small news channels were intimidated and journalists were served with summons. It is a series of intimidation, and perhaps the highest degree of intolerance,” he added.

ThePrint emailed the Chief Minister’s Office seeking comment on the issue, but there was no response until the time of publishing this report.

On the Trinamool Congress side, meanwhile, MP Saugata Roy vouched for Chattopadhyay and espoused press freedom.

“I am not aware of this particular case. But I know Anirban; he is a brilliant student of Presidency College and an erudite person. I will also support press freedom; it should be upheld and preserved by the government and by all media houses,” Roy said.


Also read: New panel of officials, ‘credible journalists’ to help improve India’s press freedom rank


Anandabazar Patrika and its former editor

Anandabazar Patrika is the No.1 circulated daily in the Bangla language, and is almost considered a part of the fabric of Bengali society. On several occasions, it has faced criticism for taking sides politically, but has remained at the forefront of Bangla journalism.

The ABP Group, meanwhile, has expanded to a massive media conglomerate of other publications as well as television channels in various languages.

The group’s patriarch, Aveek Sarkar, who was also editor of Anandabazar Patrika, stepped down in 2016 and handed over control of the group to his younger brother, Arup Sarkar. At the same time, Chattopadhyay became the editor of the group’s flagship paper, the first person outside the Sarkar family to assume the responsibility.

According to a brief biography on its website, before taking charge of the paper, the 62-year-old Chattopadhyay was responsible for its editorial pages, the book review section, the Sunday section ‘Rabibashoriyo’, fortnightly education supplement Prastuti, and a number of special supplements.

Chattopadhyay also writes a column on economic development. In fact, he started his career with the paper as a writer on economic issues in 1983, and moved to the editorial department two years later.

He is an alumnus of Kolkata’s Presidency College, and worked there as a research fellow in the Centre for Economic Studies.

ThePrint’s texts to Aveek Sarkar and group CEO D.D. Purakayastha for this report remained unanswered. Arup Sarkar could not be reached for comment — his office refused to share his contact details or email ID, saying he and his secretaries were working from home. An email sent to Anandabazar Patrika’s general email id, letters@abp.in, received no response.


Also read: On World Press Freedom day, stories of journalism without fear or favour by ThePrint


(This report has been updated after a senior IPS source claimed the summons to Chattopadhyay were issued before Mamata’s outburst, not after.)

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

News media is in a crisis & only you can fix it

You are reading this because you value good, intelligent and objective journalism. We thank you for your time and your trust.

You also know that the news media is facing an unprecedented crisis. It is likely that you are also hearing of the brutal layoffs and pay-cuts hitting the industry. There are many reasons why the media’s economics is broken. But a big one is that good people are not yet paying enough for good journalism.

We have a newsroom filled with talented young reporters. We also have the country’s most robust editing and fact-checking team, finest news photographers and video professionals. We are building India’s most ambitious and energetic news platform. And we aren’t even three yet.

At ThePrint, we invest in quality journalists. We pay them fairly and on time even in this difficult period. As you may have noticed, we do not flinch from spending whatever it takes to make sure our reporters reach where the story is. Our stellar coronavirus coverage is a good example. You can check some of it here.

This comes with a sizable cost. For us to continue bringing quality journalism, we need readers like you to pay for it. Because the advertising market is broken too.

If you think we deserve your support, do join us in this endeavour to strengthen fair, free, courageous, and questioning journalism, please click on the link below. Your support will define our journalism, and ThePrint’s future. It will take just a few seconds of your time.

Support Our Journalism

9 Comments Share Your Views

9 COMMENTS

  1. Didi always criticized Modi dada on press freedom. It seems to me whole W.B under chinises rule govern by representative goodi DIDI

  2. In crisis times, all leaders are tested. Mamata here, Udav in Maharashtra, Naveenbabu in Odisha, Adityanath in UP…..even Modi in Delhi…will happen surely as the Corona and Economy peak to their worst crisis ever in two centuries, with 1.3 billion to feed, clothe and keep in check by October. Let us ot fool ourselves..
    Leaders are never born, hey are bred. But even breeding has its refinements including ambiance, ego containment , humility….. How parents, teachers, mentors inculcate human values and not animal values.
    Look at Trump, the Nth Korean, few African, few Sth American leaders…and many Indian Leaders too. Doe Imraan Khan come across as ore understanding? I wonder.
    May be we need to embrace the Chines system. At least we are fully wrapped up in the capsule if we do and know the State is ALL .
    This leader in this State of Waste Bengal, is disproving many issues fundamental to which is that she is leading not the people but because she believes the people approve of her past and current typical subnormal tantrums . Our crisis does not allow any protest except through newspapers.
    The crisis Bengal has today calls for maturity, resilience, leadership and hope….unlike Naveenji in Odisha, she is just ranting each day….And her anger stems from personal affront by the Communist Party in the State when she was smashed in the head but not killed. She is incapable of manging the 3Ms.
    She led her brigade of lumpen, won her victory over a sleeping Buddha (Bhattacharya) and got all HIS lumpen elements over to her side. To these she handed over the running of the State at local levels. She abdicated and devotes her time to dreaming of PM of India and fighting/quarreling with the State Governor.
    The day she becomes PM many lives will evaporate. Mine not included.
    She has her a right to lead the emotional Bengali brigade. She is protected, her family is (may be she will and they shall migrate to Bahamas when push comes to shove!) ,and the stupid administration, which knows not constitution , is behind her. Our Constitution is at error because it never imagined such lumpen elements to become CM and or aspiring PMs as Ambedkar did fully not imagine the crisis in a DISASTER INDIA such as this nor could he imagine the leaders and people of India will have evolved into such cabbages as they have become by April 2020.
    I am interested to see how PRINT follows this lady a with what pro people balance as they do report ….basic Constitutional issues are involved. India has to amend Constitution against such rise of corrupt persons like Lallu Yadavs, the Lady of Bengal and many others . I /WE HAVE TO SURVIVE FUTURE AND THE FUTURE IS FASTER THAN WE THINK!!!
    May the ABP Editor be happier but return to his job earlier for he people. What support can the PRINT provide him and the people of Waste Bengal?
    Jai Jagannatho

  3. Why is corrupt Congress silent on this?Press freedom in Democracy is vital and only Congress has muzzled free speech.But since The Print is run by Congress cash it won’t say anything?

  4. Rosana Podesta played the role of Helen of Troy, Rohingya or similar Mamata Bannerji is fit to play the role in Helen of Destroy.

  5. Who says there is democracy in WB ? None !! Press freedom ? Laughable story!!! Humanity ? Ha …Ha …Ha…!!! Witch hunt begins now !! 2021 nearing and some body will be restless and afraid of loosing election !!

  6. The editors guild of India is headed by Shekhar Gupta of The Print. Why is Shekhar silent ? Readers would like to know the reason of his continued silence when journalists are being attacked by politicians. First Arnab Goswami was physically attacked by two congress members in Mumbai, followed by 12 hour interrogation of Arnab Goswami by the Uddhav Thackeray, NCP and Congress Maha Vikas Aghadi’s police. Shekhar Gupta maintained a total silence then also. And even now when Mamta Banerjee has been regularly threatning journalists he is again maintaining silence. I guess Shekhar Gupta is in a serious dilema. Both Maharashtra and Bengal are ruled by anti BjP forces. If Editors Guild of India criticises the action of these two state governments it might give some handle to the BJP, which Is the real apprehension of Guptaji. And keeping politics above everything else the staunch supporter of congress doesnt want BJP to gain advantage due to this situation. So he dumps ethics, integrity and character on the backburner and choses to look other way. Wah bhai wah Guptaji. How much more will you fall ?

  7. Smt Mamata Banerjee is the darling of the liberal, chattering class because of her trenchant opposition to the BJP. Earlier Calcutta News, a local TV channel, was blacked out because of their critical reporting of the government’s handling of the Amphan crisis. Now that a big name editor had to resign, the eyes of the media suddenly seems to have opened.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here