Monday, March 20, 2023
HomeWorldGandhi statue proposal sees Indian, Pakistani students go head-to-head in Manchester

Gandhi statue proposal sees Indian, Pakistani students go head-to-head in Manchester

A student protest led by Pakistani American has opposed the unveiling of a Mahatma Gandhi statue saying he was racist. Indian students have countered the stand.

Text Size:

New Delhi: The Manchester City Council’s decision to erect a statue of Mahatma Gandhi honouring him on his 150th year of birth has sparked protests from students at Manchester University, with the #Gandhimustfall trending on Twitter. 

The 9-foot bronze statue, set to be unveiled outside the Manchester Cathedral of Mahatma Gandhi on 25 November, was commissioned to ‘promote peace’ in the city which witnessed a terror attack in May 2017 during an Ariana Grande concert in Manchester Arena. Twenty-two people had died in the attack, while hundreds of others had sustained injuries, as a result of the suicide bombing by twenty-two year old Salman Abedi.

However, a group of student activists led by US Pakistani literature student Sara Khan, has opposed the move.

In an open letter, the students cited Gandhi’s “well-documented anti-black racism and complicity in the British Empire’s actions in Africa”. The protesters also highlighted how Gandhi’s references to Africans as “savages”, “half-heathen Natives” and “dirty” made him a “fellow-colonist”. The letter further notes historical instances wherein Gandhi appealed to Indians to fight against the South African Zulu community. The group also alleged Gandhi was being used as a “propaganda tool” by the Modi government now to cover up human rights abuses.

Apart from its arguments, the group articulated several demands, including redistribution of funds meant for the statue to commemorate Black anti-racist activists such as Olive Morris and Steve Biko, as well as a public apology from the council acknowledging Gandhi’s “anti-black racism”.

The protest divided support for the #Gandhimustfall movement. Some congratulated the student activists while others targeted the group on the grounds of religion and age.

Pakistani-Canadian author and journalist Tarek Fateh called out Sara Khan’s involvement in the protests, saying the “disease of Hindu-hatred is pernicious and almost incurable among Pakistan’s Punjabis”.

One Twitter user said the protest was a “denigration” of historical entities by a generation which “knows nothing about hard times, poverty, war or history”.  

Indians in UK respond

A group of Indian students from Manchester and other parts of the UK issued a statement flaying the #Gandhimustfall letter. Taking to Twitter, they said they had “immense respect for the Father of our Nation” who was a symbol of “peace, non-violence and anti-colonialism”. 

The statue, the Indian group said, was an initiative to “promote global peace and harmony”.

While they acknowledged the university had different students with diverse views on Gandhi, “dishonouring” him on the 150th birth anniversary year and linking the statue to “alleged actions of a current government” was unacceptable.

They added that claims that the statue was hurting the Kashmiri community in Manchester was deeply offensive to the Indian student body, one of the largest communities in the UK.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

Most Popular