scorecardresearch

Sunday, November 22, 2026

Support our Journalism

Depth, context and analysis

Subscribe
HomePoliticsWhy was Ravi Hanj detained over Basavanna remarks? The book, the backlash...

Why was Ravi Hanj detained over Basavanna remarks? The book, the backlash and the Lingayat fault lines

Row over Hanj's book & remarks on Basavanna has united Lingayat factions in condemnation. But has also revived older contest over community's identity & political relationship with BJP & Congress.

Stay updated with ThePrint:

Bengaluru: The controversial, Chicago-based author Ravi Hanj was detained by security personnel at Kochi International Airport Saturday while attempting to leave India. The Karnataka Police had issued at least two lookout notices against Hanj following complaints over the contentious contents of his book, ‘Basava Mantapa’, and his allegedly offensive statements about the 12th-century social reformer Basavanna during a recent media interview.

Hanj’s book and statements sparked outrage among various sections of society, prompting government intervention, the registration of cases and the confiscation of copies of ‘Basava Mantapa’ from bookstores.

Priyank Kharge, Karnataka’s Minister for Home, said Saturday that Hanj stood accused of “distorting the history of Guru Basavanna and deeply hurting” the sentiments of Kannadigas.

“He initially attempted to create the impression that he had left India for the United States. However, verification by the Home Department established that he was in a neighbouring state. He has been traced and a formal notice has been issued directing him to appear before the investigating authorities,” Kharge said in a post.

The controversy

The 600-page book, released on 15 November, is a compilation of articles Hanj wrote over the past year and a half for the Kannada daily Vishwavani. The articles had largely gone unnoticed until Hanj’s interview with the media house, during which he made several controversial remarks that drew sharp criticism and sparked protests across the state.

In one of the FIRs filed at Bengaluru’s High Grounds police station, Arvind Jatti, the 78-year-old president of the Basava Samiti, alleged that Hanj had referred to Basavanna in a derogatory manner.

“Under the garb of discussing the book ‘Basava Mantapa’, he (Hanj) referred to the verse ‘Kalabada, Kolabada, Husiya Nudiyalu Beda (don’t steal, kill or lie)’ to portray Basavanna as a thief and murderer and disparaged him. And he distorted the word Lingayat and called it Lingahata,” Jatti said in his complaint.

Jatti named Hanj, the book’s publisher and Vishwavani editor Vishweshwara Bhat, among others, in the complaint.

The author faces several serious charges in multiple FIRs filed against him in various cities across Karnataka.

In the FIR filed at Bengaluru’s High Grounds police station, Hanj and Bhat have been booked under Sections 192 (provocation with intent to cause a riot), 196(1) (promoting enmity and hatred), 353(2) (creating or circulating false information) and 299 (malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings), among other provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.

During the interview, which has since been taken down, Hanj said the ‘Vachanas’—thousands of lyrical prose compositions outlining moral teachings—were full of contradictions.

In the same interview, Hanj said that while one ‘Vachana’ stated ‘Kalabeda, Kolabeda (don’t steal or kill)’, Basavanna had historically emptied (King) Bijjala’s treasury for the welfare of his followers (Jangamas).

“Did Basavanna have a right to that treasure? Doesn’t this amount to stealing? Also, it is said that Basavanna got Bijjala killed. This goes against Kolabeda,” Hanj said.

He later apologised for his statements during the interview, saying his views on Basavanna had been “misinterpreted”, and apologised.

Basavanna, and the Lingayats

Basavanna was a 12th-century social reformer whose teachings continue to be revered and quoted to this day.

According to H. Thipperudraswamy’s book ‘Makers of Indian Literature: Basaveshwara’, first published in 1975, Basavanna, as he was fondly known, was born in 1131 AD in Ingaleswara-Bagevadi (now in Bijapur district of Karnataka).

Although Basavanna studied ancient Hindu scriptures while growing up, he rejected many practices of the faith. His principal teachings included the rejection of caste and untouchability, Kayaka (work is worship), Dasoha (selfless sharing), worship of the Ishta Linga, monotheism, gender equality and a preference for Kannada over Sanskrit, among others.

His teachings and philosophy, expressed through thousands of lyrical prose compositions, which came to be known as ‘Vachanas’, were written exclusively in Kannada.

Inspired by the Bhakti movement, Basavanna was critical of Vedic practices and believed in a casteless society.

Over the centuries, several people from backward castes embraced Lingayatism to escape the rigid Hindu caste system.

However, differences exist between Lingayats and Veerashaivas, the latter being considered a sub-sect, although the two terms are often used interchangeably.

Like Brahmins, who believe they were born from the ear of Brahma, Veerashaivas believe themselves to have originated from Shiva’s lingam or phallus.

The major difference between Lingayats and Veerashaivas is that the former reject the Vedas and the caste system, while the latter do not. Lingayats worship Shiva as a formless entity through the Ishta Linga, while Veerashaivas worship the Vedic idol of Shiva, depicted with a snake around his neck.

These differences are among the reasons Lingayats have, since the framing of the Constitution, sought recognition as a religion independent of Hinduism.

There are over 100 sub-sects within the Lingayat community, which is arguably one of the biggest and most influential groups in Karnataka.

Of Karnataka’s 24 chief ministers, 10 have been Lingayats. The incumbent Deputy Chief Minister D. K. Shivakumar’s cabinet has seven members from the community. Lingayats across political parties won 56 of the 224 seats in the state’s 2023 Assembly elections, indicating the clout the community enjoys.

Has the controversy united Lingayat factions

Yes and no. The controversy has brought various warring factions on to the same page in condemning Hanj’s portrayal of Basavanna.

Lingayats are largely believed to support the BJP, although prominent community leaders also represent the Congress. B. S. Yediyurappa, Basavaraj Bommai, Arvind Bellad and several others represent the BJP, while Eshwar Khandre, M. B. Patil and Basavaraj Rayareddi are among the prominent ministers in the Congress-led government.

However, community ties often transcend party ideologies, with several leaders forging marriage alliances across party lines and finding themselves on the same platform on various community-related issues.

For instance, the late Shamnur Shivashankarappa, one of the senior-most Congress leaders, opposed the Siddaramaiah government’s 2018 decision to grant minority religion status to Lingayats because it drew a distinction between them and Veerashaivas.

Eshwar Khandre, the incumbent Minister for Rural Development and Panchayat Raj (RDPR), is the president of the All India Veerashaiva Mahasabha and endorses the view that Lingayats and Veerashaivas are the same, a position also held by BJP leader B. S. Yediyurappa.

Khandre’s cabinet colleague and Industries Minister M. B. Patil, however, is pushing for the formal separation of the two identities.

The fact that Shankar Bidari, the Karnataka president of the Mahasabha, was present at Hanj’s book launch has given other Lingayat groups ammunition to target the former Bengaluru city police commissioner and the organisation he represents.

On Saturday, S. M. Jamdar, a former civil servant and general secretary of the Jagathika Lingayat Mahasabha, said he would file a complaint against Bidari and former civil servant Manu Baligar for participating in the book launch despite the book’s allegedly disparaging contents.

“We have condemned it and will also file a complaint against them (Shankar Bidari and Manu Baligar),” Jamdar said.

He added that both Bidari and Baligar had since changed their positions and condemned Hanj.

The political fallout

It remains to be seen how the various Lingayat groups will navigate the ongoing controversy.

Local community leaders have accused the BJP and its ideological parent, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), of persistently seeking to discredit Basavanna and appropriate him into the Hindu fold.

In November 2024, intellectuals protested against ‘Vachana Darshana’, published by RSS-affiliated think tanks Ayodhya Publications and Prajna Pravah and released by BJP National General Secretary (Organisation) B. L. Santosh. The book argued that Basavanna’s teachings had been “misinterpreted” by Leftist thinkers and the Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) fraternity.

To counter these claims, author Meenakshi Bali released a 60-page book, ‘Vachana Nija Darshana (The True Teachings of Basavanna)’, challenging the arguments made in the RSS-backed publication. Among other things, the latter claimed that Basavanna’s teachings, or ‘Vachanas’, were an extension of Vedic teachings, a characterisation criticised as contrary to the social reformer’s beliefs.

A Lingayat leader from Belagavi questioned why children from the community were sent to RSS Shakhas. He also alleged that pro-Hindu groups were behind the killings of M. M. Kalaburagi and Gauri Lankesh, both of whom were Lingayats.

It remains to be seen whether community leaders will use the controversy surrounding Hanj, Vishweshwara Bhat and their continued patronage by pro-Hindu organisations to strengthen the narrative that Basavanna is being co-opted by the Right wing.

This narrative could also help the Congress drive home the argument that backing the BJP in successive elections might run counter to the interests of the Lingayat community.

What lies ahead for Hanj

While the controversy has taken various forms within Karnataka, Hanj faces an uncertain future.

Hanj is a US citizen, and Kharge said the state government had formally informed the American Embassy about the developments.

“Foreign citizenship does not place anyone above Indian law, nor does it provide immunity from investigation or accountability. Guru Basavanna’s legacy is an integral part of Karnataka’s history, identity and social conscience,” Kharge said.

Meanwhile, the Veerashaiva Samaja of North America (VSNA) has distanced itself from Hanj.

(Edited by Viny Mishra)


Also read: Author Ravi Hanj arrested as Karnataka cracks down on book that ‘distorts’ Basavanna’s teachings


 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

For readers who want the full political picture.

You read politics closely. Poligraph, our exclusive newsletter, goes further into the debates and the context behind them, straight to your inbox.

Join Poligraph →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular