Sunday, March 26, 2023
HomeOpinionTrump's latest sanctions on Iran aren't a sign of madness, but a...

Trump’s latest sanctions on Iran aren’t a sign of madness, but a saner alternative to war

Donald Trump may just have to wait till 2021 for Iran's presidential elections for Hassan Rouhani to be dethroned and profit from a shift in regime.

Text Size:

Poor Hassan Rouhani: Iran’s president is so inconsequential that the Trump administration didn’t even bother to impose sanctions on him. The U.S. has now levied them on Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei and eight military commanders, and is preparing similar measures against Foreign Minister Javad Zarif. It had already sanctioned Qasem Soleimani, commander of the Qods Force, and designated the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps as a terrorist group.

In the virulently anti-American politics of the Islamic Republic, being targeted in this way by the ‘Great Satan’ is something of a badge of honor – one that has been denied the Iranian president, who is regarded with open contempt by his hardline opponents and by his boss. In a certain light, then, Rouhani’s latest description of the White House as having a “mental disorder” might be read as a petulant complaint that his name wasn’t on President Trump’s hit-list.

The sanctions on Khamenei may not have a great deal of impact on the ayatollah himself – he doesn’t travel beyond Iran’s borders, nor does he have any known holdings abroad. (Zarif, on the other hand, will miss his access to the salons and think-tanks of New York.) It is hard to know which portions of Khamenei’s multibillion-dollar business empire might be affected, but an enterprise built by seizing the property and businesses of his subjects can, presumably, be rebuilt by seizing some more.

Whatever the efficacy of the new measures, however, they are hardly a sign of madness. On the contrary, they are a sane alternative to what Donald Trump briefly contemplated last week: A military response to Iran’s many provocations.

The regime in Tehran has said the latest sanctions close the door for negotiations forever. This is plainly disingenuous. Khamenei had already slammed that door in the face of Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who made a good-faith effort to mediate talks between the U.S. and Iran, only to be humiliated by the Supreme Leader. Tehran has also ignored offers of mediation from Oman and Qatar, and has dismissed out of hand statements from Trump and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo that the U.S. was open to negotiations, without preconditions.

And there were plenty of other signs that the Iranians had no intention of negotiating – the attacks on neutral shipping, on Saudi oil installations, on an American drone.

There is no such thing as forever in geopolitics. Khamenei, it would appear, is inclined to wait until after the 2020 U.S. presidential election before reconsidering his intransigence about negotiations. He is hoping that Trump will lose the election, and that the 46th U.S. president will be more favorably inclined toward the Islamic Republic. In the meantime, Iran will build up some leverage – enhancing its uranium stockpile and threatening the stability of the Middle East and safety of crucial shipping lanes.

But Trump, too, might profitably run down the clock on the current government in Tehran. There, the next presidential election is only due in 2021: Rouhani cannot run again, and it is all but certain that he will be replaced by one of the regime’s hardliners. Zarif, who is in bad odor with the same group, will be out, too – so the sanctions on him will be moot. The unelected Khamenei will remain.

Rather than embark now on a lengthy process of negotiations, the White House might think it better to give the sanctions two more years to wreak more destruction on the Iranian economy and weaken Tehran’s position. If the Islamic Republic keeps enriching uranium and attacking shipping lanes in the meantime it will antagonize the international community, prompting more countries – and especially the Europeans – to support the U.S. position.

And when the negotiations do eventually begin, the sanctions on Khamenei could be one more piece of leverage for the American side, their removal one more small incentive to dangle before the Supreme Leader. In the meantime, Khamenei can enjoy his badge of honor – much to Rouhani’s envy.

Also read: Donald Trump approves ‘retaliatory’ military strikes on Iran, then pulls back


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Who is Bobby Ghosh? And why his opinion is worth publishing? Is he an American republican or an NRI?

Comments are closed.