When the leader of a country goes on an official visit to another nation, s/he usually praises that country. But ‘Howdy, Modi!’ was not an official India-US event. It was a private affair organised by a little-known organisation of Indian-Americans, Texas India Forum. Modi lavishly praised Trump, and Trump lavishly praised Modi. It was a match made in heaven, two leaders for whom everything is always about themselves.
Modi began his speech by saying he represented 130 crore Indians. So, when they asked him ‘Howdy, Modi?’, he gave his short reply, in several Indian languages: ‘everything is fine’. Subtly but surely, he was equating himself with India. Modi is India, and India is Modi.
It is with this same formula of personal praise that Modi has finally won Trump over, after nearly three years of trying. “He was a household name,” Modi said of Trump, “and very popular even before he won to occupy the highest office in this great country.” This was only the beginning – Modi went on for quite a few minutes in his praise of Trump, saying exactly what Trump wanted to hear.
Trump has been playing hard to get since he became president in 2016, refusing to give Modi the photo-ops that he needs for the careful projection of his image. The biggest setback to India-US relations was not when the US offered to mediate between India and Pakistan in the Kashmir issue, or when the US withdrew preferential trade status for India. It was when Trump couldn’t make it as chief guest for India’s Republic Day celebrations a few months before Modi was up for re-election. That was the sort of photo-op Modi really needed, to show his voters how he is personal friends with the most powerful world leader.
All that Modi needed from Trump was optics. Work visas for Indians and their spouses, friction in trade relations, and tariffs were important issues for Trump in front of his domestic audience. He needed to show his voters he was being tough in bringing home more jobs, investments, and more money for exports.
Also read: ‘Howdy, Modi!’ risks dividing the US on relations with India
Friend request
This was surprising, because Modi and Trump are too much a mirror image to get along well.
“My good friend Barack,” is how Modi once famously addressed President Obama, who on his part stuck to protocol and addressed Modi as Mr Prime Minister. Trump, on the other hand, is just the sort of leader who wants to say ‘Modi is a friend of mine. He’s a great guy.’
For Modi, diplomacy is more about his relationship with foreign leaders than strengthening India’s ties with other nations. Ditto for Donald Trump, who likes to be seen as the man who can strike the best deals for America. Modi and Trump should have thus been a natural partnership. But Trump has been cold, if not often hostile, to India for most of his presidency.
Opposites attract. A liberal Obama and a populist Modi got along well because Obama saw India as a bulwark against China. It puzzled even some Americans why Modi and Obama loved each other so much. It might have helped that most Indian Americans are Democratic voters but Obama made it clear he wasn’t ever endorsing Hindu nationalism. Quite the contrary.
There’s so much in common between Trump and Modi that it almost seemed Trump had learnt from Modi. Trump became president two years after Modi first came to power in May 2014. Both are polarising leaders who claim to represent the marginalised masses from the hinterland against the elites who dominate the capital. Both vilify the liberal media, though Modi is more subtle. Both of them project a personality cult over and above established procedures and protocol. If Modi represents Hindu nationalism, Trump is about white supremacism, and both have a common enemy: “Islamic terrorism,” as Trump declared at the Texas event Sunday.
Also read: Is it smart diplomacy for PM Modi to align himself with Donald Trump’s campaign in Houston?
Friend request accepted
Modi finally won over Trump by giving him what he wants: a pre-election endorsement. Trump will do anything to win votes, and who could understand that better than Modi?
Trump has had recent political trouble in Texas. The traditionally Republican state saw the Democrats doing well in the mid-terms. Texas could spell trouble for Trump in the 2020 presidential election. In such a precarious scenario, every vote counts – and Modi is doing his bit to persuade Indian American voters to dump the Democrats.
Again, such open endorsement of Trump over Democrats isn’t kosher for a prime minister of India. What if the Democrats come to power? Won’t they snub Modi because of this partisan stand? It’s the sort of political risk Modi and Trump love to take, and it pays handsomely.
For now, the inevitable has happened. Modi and Trump are finally friends. The Indian American community has been leveraged in the US’ domestic politics by India. Modi and Trump going around a stadium, hand in hand, is just the sort of thing both leaders value the most. All is well.
Views are personal.
No wonder, not only Trump, but most centraist also dislike the liberal media for its balatent false reporting. How in the world “Trump supports white supremacism”? Any evidence? Which politician in the modern day American can win mayoral election, much less a presidential one while promoting white supremacism? Surely, Modi and Trump have minced no words in opposing ‘Islamic terrorism’, but where did Trump advocated “white supremacism”? With the number of resources available to an average reader, such statements are simply laughable because other than the rank hate-mongers among the liberal elite, nobody believes that. Though marginally more so, but more blacks and Hispanics voted for Trump than those voted for Romney in 2012.
If Trump looses, Modi Ji will become friend of new President with the help of Democrats Indians. Any thing for securing the interest of India.
Will it prove to be a case of penny wise pound foolish? Has Donald Trump harmed his interest in the eyes of the larger American voter cross section who value human rights dearly, by so brazenly aligning with Mr Modi who has wrecked havoc on 80 lakh civilians of Kashmir? Surely Modi is not a hero in the eyes of an average American.
Looks like you are not seeing the writing on the wall. Trump’s support is at least 42 %.your and authors favorite Modis rating is 30% and falling. It was never 42%.
30% ? NDA got 45% vote and BJP 38%
!! Asatyam Shivam Sadaa Sandesham !!
I suspect Shivam is a secret Bhakt of Modi. On close inspection, all his articles defending Congress (or opposition) are half-baked & absurd. What to do? He cannot directly name and admire Modi. Hey.. Why don’t you write a “Modi-Nama” ? Here is one story from Puranas.
A person with very bad deeds died and was admitted into Heaven. Many were surprised and asked Chitragupta. He said ‘while dying he called his son, named ‘Narayana’ many times. Hence, he is in heaven’ !!
So figure it out!!
The author are s a closet sanghi. He says Obama loved Modi which is the farthest you can come from truth. Obama used to take advice from Soniaji and even mentioned it when he visited last year. Of course paid media twisted that story to some treatment of minority story to divert . Trump is not a friend if Modi as he claims. If Trump likes whites then how come he will chose Modi over Soniaji . Modi is a Gujarat I by birth while Soniaji is European. We shouldn’t forget Trump’s all wives are from Europe.
Lol, you seem to be a xian convert from panaji. Obama got well with Modi, this is fact. He came for Republic Day.
Texas has 38 out of 538 votes in the electoral college. It has been with the Republicans since 1976. With President Trump’s approval rating down to 42%, and falling, each vote counts. True. But whether Indian Americans can swing major states is doubtful. As is the possibility that they would change their voting preferences based on supranational influences. In fact, such talk / speculation is unhealthy for all stakeholders. Nations do business with governments that elections throw up. That is the sensible course of action.
Obama carried Texas in 2008.
Indian-Americans are not going to vote for Trump in 2020. Trump is going to lose in 2020 election, most probably. Modi would have to deal with the new Democratic president from 2021 on.
Not really, the same thing was said of him in 2017 election.
If the bromance between Modi and Trump is for the benefit of India, then the Indian public should be happy about it; let the chatter group (so-called news analysts) break their heads in micro-analysis.
Whether for an individual investor or a nation it is seldom wise to put all your eggs in one basket.
When Imran Khan met Modi Pakistanis were gushing. Now Modi has met Trump and you are gushing (though not with pleasure). The mirror image is not Modi and Trump but India hating Indians and India hating Pakistanis (joke).