scorecardresearch
Wednesday, March 27, 2024
Support Our Journalism
HomeOpinionPakistan military won’t take budget cuts easily, even for Covid. So this...

Pakistan military won’t take budget cuts easily, even for Covid. So this man has been hired

A lot of Pakistan’s defence budget may get redirected in the post-Covid era, but army isn’t going to let go. It now eyes revocation of a constitutional amendment.

Follow Us :
Text Size:

Like every crisis, Covid-19 will bring its set of challenges and opportunities. For starters, the guns-versus-butter debate may be back on the table.

With the overall size of the world economy shrinking, leaders will have to decide how much they are willing to spend on real security of citizens in the form of health and personal development versus traditional military security. How Pakistan calibrates these priorities will be telling. Despite the need for A lot of its defence budget to get redirected in the post-Covid-19 era, this will not be allowed. As it eyes the revocation of a controversial constitutional amendment that stands in the way of the military getting more resources, a recent move that everyone is watching in Pakistan is the appointment of a former ISPR official to Prime Minister Imran Khan’s media management team.

Military unlikely to rethink budget

Count it as an indirect blessing but the pandemic may just have put a brake on an incessant arms race between India and Pakistan. Although New Delhi signed arms deals during the pandemic, an aggressive military modernisation may not be possible.

This situation should not appear as a worry since the entire region finds itself in a similar situation. Pakistan, for instance, doesn’t have too many options despite getting a debt relief of US $1.38 billion from the International Monetary Fund (IMF). These resources will mostly get diverted to Islamabad paying its burgeoning external debt of US $112 billion. Pakistan’s GDP growth rate had plummeted before the coronavirus outbreak from 5.7 per cent in FY 2017-18 to 2.4 per cent in FY 2019-20. Such figures do not seem to have made any dent in Islamabad’s security paradigm that continues to be tied to military security. In fact, soon after the outbreak, the government announced a supplementary grant of Pakistan Rs 11.48 billion for the China-Pakistan Security Force–South, Rs 468.2 million to the Special Communication Organisation, and Rs 90.45 million for the Nuclear Regulatory Authority.

However, the fact remains that according to the IMF predictions, Pakistan’s GDP growth rate will further reduce by -1.5 per cent in FY 2020-21. This means that Islamabad will have to strategise to balance its budget or divert resources to development areas. The military does not seem inclined to take the hard step of rethinking its budget. Though DG ISPR Babar Iftikhar claimed that the army would not claim the extra allowance it is paid for domestic deployment under Article 245 of the 1973 Constitution, the organisation is not about to give up more of its share. It’s certainly eyeing revocation of the 18th Amendment to the constitution, which was passed in 2010 to give greater financial autonomy to the provinces.

Notwithstanding the lack of capacity of provinces to manage money and general mismanagement, autonomy had its benefits. For example, according to a detailed study on expenditure in the health sector, all provinces had increased spending under this head.


Also read: I now speak for Pakistan army. And unlike Ghafoor, my actions speak louder than my tweets


Bajwa is the man for the job

But the military is deeply bothered because the federal government has lesser resources to give to the armed forces. Sources claim that one of the final battles between Ishaq Dar, the finance minister of the previous government and the army chief, General Qamar Javed Bajwa, was regarding funds. Dar could not give more because the funds were with the provinces. Bajwa also spoke publicly against the 18thAmendment, equating it with Sheikh Mujibur Rahman’s six points in the early 1970s.

Not surprisingly, the former DG ISPR, Lt General (retd) Asim Bajwa, has been brought back to play a more central role in media management for Imran Khan. But the retired general is certainly not being brought in to explain why there is a shortage of ventilators or masks in different parts of the country, or that the lockdown has been extended. Some believe that the general’s role will be to manage opinion as the above-mentioned constitutional amendment is got rid of.

Asim Bajwa will probably pull out all the tricks he used as the army’s media Tsar – from soft to direct coercion, stopping newspapers from printing certain news and even columns from dissenting voices or those that don’t fit the bill, creating and managing a team of social media warriors, bribing media people and much more. The retired general was very effective in building a tall image of an otherwise dwarf-like army chief, General Raheel Sharif, and in the process, enormously expanding the military’s media wing to the degree that it was noticed and appreciated by people from across the border. In 2019, India’s Lt General (retd) Ata Hasnain, speaking at the International Institute of Strategic Studies, London, praised the ISPR’s ability to manipulate information.


Also read: Global lockdown and Covid crisis haven’t stopped Pakistan from its anti-India agenda


Motivation requires hefty package

The new media team is likely to ensure that things are calm at the political and societal front while the 18th Amendment is gotten rid of. This will probably be termed as fighting a hybrid-war, a concept increasingly popular in the army. Any opinion in favour of provincial autonomy will be presented as propaganda war against the state, something that the former DG ISPR is adept in. The opposition parties are already weak to the extent that no voice was raised about Asim Bajwa’s appointment who also holds the charge as the head of the CPEC Authority with a hefty pay. The silence from both the main opposition parties indicate what lies in the future – more silence as a strategic change is brought about.

Moreover, good media management will be required as the military battles other financial needs of the state. The Army GHQ understands that its personal needs are well taken care of. The state land is appropriated systemically to ensure that by the time an officer gets promoted from the rank of a major to a three-star general, he has about a dozen properties. Every promotion, war course and performance is rewarded materially. A Corps Commander’s net value in property terms is approximately Pakistan Rs 1 billion (calculation based on value of properties that a general gets starting from rank of a major to a 3-star). The army chief’s is even higher. The more ambitious generals try to find other means to maximise benefits. For instance, Lt General Javed Iqbal Awan was involved in espionage for which he was awarded rigorous life imprisonment. According to sources in military accounts, the Former Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee (JCSC), General Zubair Hayat ensured a hefty compensation of millions of rupees to be added to his monthly pension for life at the two key key position he served. Over the years, the relationship between the officer cadre and national security has become extremely transactional. To motivate for better performance or to keep national secrets requires a hefty resource package.

However, these personal benefits are meant as a motivator rather than any contribution in fulfilling the military’s actual institutional needs. Though in these conditions, the threat level between India and Pakistan will remain manageable and low, the need for military modernisation remains.


Also read: Covid blurs distinction between war and peace as soldiers worldwide fight the third army


Covid is time for restraint

Besides the search for a fifth-generation fighter aircraft, Pakistan has bought military equipment from China, Italy, Russia and Turkey. But the imports only comprise limited major weapons systems and have reduced by over 30 per cent as compared to 2010. The military could cater to its needs by reducing wastage that can be calculated at anything between 20-30 per cent.

Nonetheless, the Army GHQ does not seem to be in a mood to rethink its options. While the army may opt for the most obvious method of silencing dissent, the attention that Covid-19 will bring to military expenditure cannot be avoided. A friend, whom I would normally consider apolitical, was most upset at the navy’s recent missile test. Hence, in the post-Covid age, more visible acts of self-restraint and sacrifice will be required even from the most powerful of institutions.

The author is a research associate at SOAS, London and author of Military Inc. She tweets as: @iamthedrifter. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

140 COMMENTS

  1. Siddiqa knows everything about Pakistan while living in London but she couldn’t see the weight she has gained over the years.

  2. In a way its good pakistan using most of its budget in Army.
    Frankly, India-pakistan will not hv direct war…they will fight proxy war or small scale fire exchange.
    But biggest gsin to India n issue eith pakistan is, they are spending lot more compare to its GDP, there external dept are increasing and economy is almost down with growth rate below 3%.
    Pakistan people are not have long term sight how this loans and economy is going to hurt them.
    In long run, there external dept will be so high that other countries will dictate there terms n eill run pakistan. And those country will manipulate n will loot pakistan resources in name to dept payment.
    So as indian, i am happy pakistan using most if budget on defense and slowly cutting down there roots.
    India on other hand…are on offensive n keeping pressure in Pak army so they use max budget and countrys economy goes down…..well played India

  3. This amol guy is really mad on Pakistan… Well nations feed the armies and for good cause…. I won’t question why India does too coz its what nations do as per their own needs and requirements. Pakistan army is not perfect but it is professional and it has and always will be serving nation… Those who are now putting question mark on pak army being professional should have been seen when they were weeping after capture of abhinandan…. Indians should concentrate on their own country which is consuming itself with fascist mentality of hate…

    • Damn man u r sick and filled with filthy mentality from head to toe. U r just like an ass which has their eyes covered with the blinds…n the worst part is u literally dont want to see the truth.

  4. Somehow all these anti Army citizens never refuse Army’s help during earthquakes, floods and civil disorders. And they certainly have no idea of the war capability of our enemies. Pak Armed Forces are world class and highly commended by countries where our Army serves as UN Peacekeeping forces. Sad that Army will have to save you as well in case of next war.

  5. The author is a pakistani origion living in London. Hates Pakistan Army to the extant that she wrote a book just to defame this glorious institution . False allegations have been against General Officers for financial gains. There is a system of welfare from a sepoy to a general, which gives financial benefits to every soldier. Pakistan Army a very powerful force srounded by enimies all around, is a unique army who is keeping an enemy 3 times more power full with its military budget 6 times. Author as usuall forgot to mention this aspect. Author mentioned the pension of General Zubair Hayat also forgot to tell us about his daring stance against Israel. These are always opposite winds who take you to the Zenith of skies and same is the case, where an author is throwing mud just for few dollars.

  6. Good to see burning asses of randians . Funny to see how our enemy praises our ISPR for its effective role in defeating randians in hybrid war and have so much pain for Pakistani people ( Army utilizing max budget). So if the enemies are bursting in tears that means we are moving in right direction. Hail Bajwa doctrine.

  7. Paky army is top heavy for every one captain there is Lieutenant General … could be said reverse or inverted pyramid

  8. All these things are 1000 times true. Every Paki general is a billionaire at retirement. Check the FBR records. But no one can dare to ask them to give their due taxes. It is so amusing to read about greedy and dwarf character Raheel Sharif who grabbed the most expensive plot so far. Rest of the generals were rightly jealous of him.

  9. All these things are 1000 times true. Every Paki general is a billionaire at retirement. Check the FBR records. But no one can dare to ask them to give their due taxes. It is so amusing to read about greedy and dwarf character Raheel Sharif who grabbed the most expensive plot so far. Rest of the generals were rightly jealous of him.

  10. The writer possesses a strong hatred for Pakistan and its Armed Forces. Therefore, her words carry no weight. Actually, she is serving her foreign masters by writing such articles. But she should remember, Pakistan is for ever and its Armed Forces are its true saviours. Pakistan is our Mother and no sane pakistani can betray it less spineless people like the unluckey writer…thats all !!!

  11. Looks like PORKI ispr let loose it’s key board filthy warriors to open their gutter mouth😂😂😂
    Damn, one woman made all these guys so much triggered

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular