The vaccines are stored in extreme cold storage | Photo: Manisha Mondal | ThePrint
The coronavirus vaccines are kept in extreme cold storage | (Representational Image) | Photo: Manisha Mondal | ThePrint
Text Size:

Even as India is scrambling to start the coronavirus vaccination drive, Muslims have raised concern over the use of pork products – forbidden in Islam – in the vaccine.

However, three firms – Pfizer, AstraZeneca and Moderna – have rejected the allegations of using pork gelatine, but in vain. The issue has triggered an intense debate among the ulema, prompting some to write to the World Health Organization (WHO) and seek details of the contents of the drug.

In India, which has the second-largest Muslim population, the concern can have a significant impact because of its potential to disrupt the vaccination drive, although the Narendra Modi government has maintained that it would not be mandatory. Vaccine advocates swiftly responded to the concern of the hesitant groups, prompting several Muslim bodies to clarify Islam’s stand on the controversial issue. The concerns must be quickly addressed in the interest of public health and the community’s willing participation.

Fatwa brigades and Islamophobes 

Islamic scholars are divided on the issue with the majority of them citing verses from the Quran to advocate for the vaccine. However, the controversy came to light after the respected Muslim religious body, the Raza Academy, along with some other organisations, reportedly issued a fatwa against its use. The fatwa was sufficient fodder for Islamophobic Indians, who jumped in joy and started Islam/Muslim bashing.

The television studios were gleamingly adorned with misconstrued mullahs and anchors cunningly putting Islam in the dock. But, thankfully, the biggest Islamic seminaries came in quick succession to denounce the fatwa and the hesitancy against the vaccine. The prominent organisations and individuals include the Jamiat Ulema-i-Hind, Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, Darul Uloom Deoband, Dargah-e-Ala Hazrat, and prominent scholars like Maulana Kalbe Jawad and Maulana Khalid Rasheed Firangi Mahali. Above all, the Gulf countries, mainly Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, have started the vaccination drive and even announced that a vaccine with pork product is permissible. Perhaps, these views took away the TV anchors’ smiles.

Further, noted scientist and Islamic scholar M.G.H. Zaidi, who teaches in G.B. Pant University of Agriculture & Technology, has made it clear, according to a report in Amar Ujala, that pork-derived gelatine is used in the drug as a stabiliser and asked everyone, including Muslims, to take it.


Also read: ‘Ignore baseless rumours’ — Muslim scholars say Covid vaccine permissible even if it has pork


Vaccine hesitancy not a Muslim problem alone

It is not only the Muslims who are hesitant about the vaccine, Jews too remain in doubt about the drugs allegedly made from forbidden food. Since the Abrahamic faiths have a set of dietary guidelines, Muslims and Jews often raise questions on such issues. (St Paul, the most revered man who is viewed as the founder of Christianity, had separated Christianity from Judaism, arguing that Moses’ Commandments are not applicable for Christians).

Islam has a set of codified guidelines for all aspects of life. The main focus of Islam is purification of the soul, for which it prescribes certain ritual practices. Besides insisting on purification of the inner self, Islam also asks its believers to exercise restraints in the intake of food and drinks. However, the Quran allows even the use of forbidden items to save a person’s life. But, there are differences in jurisprudence over the interpretation of the Quran’s verses.

Some clarify that even a ‘haram’ item can be considered ‘halal’ and fit for consumption or use if its original form transforms radically. However, Imam Sha’afi, one of the four jurisprudence that the majority of Sunni Muslims follow, does not consider it valid if the transformation is through man’s intervention.

“According to the Jewish law, the prohibition on eating pork or using pork is only forbidden when it’s a natural way of eating it,” said Rabbi David Stav, chairman of Tzohar, an Israeli rabbinical organisation. The Jewish religious scholars clarify that if the item is injected into the body, not (eaten) through the mouth, then it is permissible.

The Muslim world is often seen as the epicentre of vaccine hesitancy. But it is factually incorrect.

A London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine survey of 67 countries, published in 2016, showed that the European region had one of the lowest confidence levels in vaccination safety.

And, so far as hostility towards the polio campaign in north-west Pakistan is concerned, the border conflict played a major factor. Further, the long-cherished perception that the Christianised West was ever-ready to usurp Muslims strengthened in the post-9/11 world.  Didn’t the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) try to use a fake vaccination campaign to acquire DNA from Osama bin Laden’s relatives in Abbottabad?

Referring to a study, Al Jazeera writes, “Polio prevalence in Pakistan is correlated with the frequency of US drone attacks between 2004 and 2011. Militants suspected that polio vaccination campaigns were a smokescreen for intelligence-gathering operations, and were therefore reluctant to grant them access to areas under their control.”


Also read: Malaysia’s Islamic authorities allow use of Covid vaccine, make it mandatory for some


Theories and veracity 

Many groups and ulema are casting aspersions on the nexus between vaccine firms and certain governments. Fake claims of infertility resulting from the coronavirus vaccine are also adding to public fear. Even though it has been fact-checked multiple times.

These suspicions, no matter how small, should be addressed. It is the responsibility of both corporations/scientific community and Muslim leaders to dispel fears. If these questions are not addressed, it will be naïve to expect that people, especially Muslims, will come forward for vaccination.

The writer is founder-editor of MuslimMirror.com. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism

VIEW COMMENTS

14 COMMENTS

  1. Inventing a vaccine for a pandemic like Corona is no joke. Scientists will test the efficacy of the vaccine against this virus. They are not retailers to introduce pork free,, alcohol free versions of a vaccine. If a community has reservations against a vaccine, let them invent their own and administer it on themselves.

  2. Muslims have right to decide what is good or bad to them religiously. However, the Fatwa from Raza Academy is laughable. Both Pork and Alcohol are not allowed in Islam to be ingested by mouth. If Pork gelatine can not be used in a life saving injection – would the Raza Academy ( Barelvis) also stop using Alcohol used in many medicines and cremes when they get accident for example?

  3. It was interesting to know that the mullah brigades have fallen to line as orthodoxy in the Jewish community.

  4. If some people refuse to take the vaccine for whatever reasons, it is fine. Taking the vaccine is not compulsory.

  5. Do you have a vacancy in your organization for Begum Zainab Sikandar? I had actually suggested to her in a comment in connection with an article written in The Print, where she had proudly declared her religion, that Muslim Mirror would be a more appropriate vehicle for her persuits. And by the way, it was nice to read that Islam is such a forward looking religion. Can we now move towards an Uniform Civil Code in our country?

  6. Let the people who are concerned nit take it. Who need morons like that? Earth will be lighter. This goes to people who are concerned about cow fat and pig fat.

  7. So called religious scholars taking a call on vaccine is a insult to educated and science based society the majority in INDIA wants to have.

    Pandering to such conservative community will bring INDIA to its knees.

  8. In simple terms Islam can change rules as per their convince,
    But nobody should question the Quran and Hadits written 300 years after Mohammad death!! Sorry Peace be upon him

    • My brother, try to understand the concept of dissension in Islam. Islam itself allows forbidden items to save humans. Further, convenience is not bad thing. Islam says it has come to free the human being from the claws of religious heads, convention and tradition. That’s why it asks believers to surrender or prostrate or follow before none but before your Creator. Secondly, the Quran was written simultaneously when verses were being revealed upon Prophet Muhammad, the last prophet of Islam. The Hadith compilation begins after 100 years, and you should know that Muslims have differences over authenticity of several saying of Prophet (Hadith). Lastly, who asked you not to question Quran or Hadith? If you have some point of objection, you can reach out to any scholar for clarification, If he clarifies, it’s ok. If it does not, you have full freedom to criticism or question, but of course it doesn’t require me to say that universal standard with regard to choice of words must be maintained..

  9. Nobody is doing anybody else, but themselves, a favour by accepting a vaccine be it polio or Covid 19. Those who wish to take it need no clarifications. Those who do not will not accept any. Not taking the polio vaccine is the people’s loss in Pakistan not America’s. Same is the case with the Covid 19 vaccine.

  10. Fool me once shame on me..fool me twice…

    Author has succinctly put a charade about the violent tribalism suiting a certain narrative which has been propagating since ages.

    Anyway onto to gist

    Vaccine are haram plain and simple

    If tabligis were not spreaders then what is the point in vaccinating

    Raza academy is the one who caused mayhem in azaad maidan by descecrting soldiers jyoti. And the author calls them respected.

    That is the line where I lost it. This jihadi idealogy is right under India nose yet Indians are not able to see.

    And this apologist of an author has the gall to eulogize the breaking India forces as respected.

    What next calling the lakhs of congregation of mawali maskin in Mumbai paying respects to a terrorist responsibile for killing innocent souls in Mumbai blast martyr???

    Enough of this charade. The fundamental jihadi wahabi tribalism had no space in the secular nation.

Comments are closed.