Friday, 2 December, 2022
HomeOpinionManohar Parrikar to Sonia Gandhi: Does India deserve to be ruled by...

Manohar Parrikar to Sonia Gandhi: Does India deserve to be ruled by unhealthy politicians?

Text Size:

Asking whether our politicians are fit to do their jobs would be considered blasphemy.

Speaking in Mumbai Monday, NCP chief Sharad Pawar said he wished someone had stopped him from consuming tobacco 40 years ago. He has survived oral cancer but lost his teeth, has trouble eating and talking. He is 77.

It’s the sort of question we don’t ask of India’s politicians: Is Mr Pawar really fit to be a Rajya Sabha member?

It’s considered an impolite question in India. We’re supposed to respect the elderly and not ask them to sit home and watch TV when they want to be out and about. We’ll express sympathy about their health condition but never, never ask if they’re fit to hold office.

Mostly away from the public eye, the age and health of politicians strongly affect their ability to be full-time politicians and govern well.

Goa chief minister Manohar Parrikar, 62, is suffering from a pancreatic ailment so serious he’s gone to the United States for treatment for weeks. In his absence, the state’s administration has slowed down. He told the Goa governor he’d chair the cabinet meeting, “whenever it is held”, by video conferencing.

“If that is not possible for any reason, or I may decide at a later point of time, the minister nominated by me shall preside (sic) the meeting and I will separately instruct the chief secretary in such exigency,” Parrikar’s letter to the governor said. His ministers can take financial decisions up to Rs 5 crore in his absence.

We finally know what rare disease has struck Irrfan Khan, the Bollywood actor, but we are not going to be told what pancreatic ailment Mr Parrikar is suffering from.

The United States example

In 2002, Time magazine’s Delhi correspondent Alex Perry published a story that asked if Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, then 77, was fit to preside over India’s nuclear button given he allegedly fell asleep in cabinet meetings. The government was so aghast it threatened to deport Perry. Vajpayee had had knee replacement surgery in 2001 and his health deteriorated quickly after he demitted office in 2004.

In the United States, it is a question asked routinely of politicians. In fact, the candidate’s health is a major issue in US elections. A cough, a sneeze, a fall, and Hillary Clinton’s health became an issue in the 2016 presidential race.

For a while, the corridors of power were abuzz with rumours that Odisha chief minister Naveen Patnaik was seriously unwell. Those close to him now claim a party rebel maliciously spread the false information to undermine his hold over Odisha politics.

Sleeping at the wheel?

It is a scientific fact that age makes your mind less sharp, and reduction in physical strength takes a toll on your ability to work. That’s why we have the concept of retirement but that doesn’t seem to apply to politicians. Prime Minister Modi, 67, imposed the age limit of 75 for anyone to be a minister in his cabinet — making it the oldest retirement age for any profession in the country.

During his time as prime minister, Dr Manmohan Singh had as many as five surgeries. He became Prime Minister for a second time months after a 14-hour bypass surgery in 2009.

Did his health affect his ability to govern? We can’t say. What we did see was that the UPA-II faltered so badly that it damaged the Congress’ claim to be a party of governance for a long time.

Meanwhile, UPA chairperson and the then Congress party president Sonia Gandhi suffered from cervical cancer in 2011. The then party vice-president Rahul Gandhi, also her son, often travelled abroad to be by her side during treatment. There has, to date, not been an official word on what cancer she suffered. It was around this time that the party and the government alike began to falter.

When Tamil Nadu chief minister Jayalalithaa Jayaram was in hospital, her ministers lied about her recovery. When she was in hospital from September to December 2016, the state’s functioning came to a standstill, while she was writing letters from hospital. Many doubted the signatures.

Pushed aside

Most don’t give up despite going and coming out of hospital, despite age catching on, and indeed, some like Lalu Yadav put up a brave fight even after bypass surgeries. Others are just pushed aside.

Lal Krishna Advani, 90, is the oldest member of Parliament ever and still hopes to be re-elected from Gandhinagar. Age must definitely have been a factor in how easily he was sidelined by Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi for the Prime Minister’s job. His wife Kamla Advani had been unwell for many years when she died in 2016. A lot of Mr Advani’s time, energy and emotional investment went towards looking after her in her last years, affecting his ability to be active in politics.

Mulayam Singh Yadav, 78, suffers from short-term memory loss. In 2015, pneumonia took him to the ICU in Gurgaon’s Medanta hospital. His age and health were likely among the factors why and how his son Akhilesh Yadav did a coup and ousted his own father from the post of party president on 1 January last year.

The diabetes epidemic

It is a tiring, stressful and tedious job to be a full-time politician, especially if you’re holding an office. It should worry Indians that Punjab chief minister Amarinder Singh, 76, is suffering from diabetes. As do Arun Jaitley, Sushma Swaraj and so many others.

Finance minister Arun Jaitley, 65, and external affairs minister Sushma Swaraj, 66, have both spent time in hospital while being in the Modi government’s cabinet.

Swaraj had a kidney replacement in 2016 and Jaitley had a bariatric surgery in 2014 to manage his diabetes better.

There were concerns about the health of AAP leader Arvind Kejriwal, 49, when he would sit on a fast to demand the Lokpal bill. He is also diabetic.

Diabetes is an epidemic among the Indian elite. Which one of us hasn’t had a dear one in that age suffer from that disease? We’ve seen how it weakens people. Yet, asking whether Swaraj and Jaitley are fit to do their jobs would be considered blasphemy.

Many VIPs hide their bariatric surgeries. They want it known they are fit as a fiddle to govern us. The people of India deserve to know more about that.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. ThePrint, please be careful while selecting a title for your posts. There have been posts on FB and some videos on YouTube which are referring to your article and claiming that Mr. Parrikar had commented on ill Sonia Gandhi that India didn’t deserved to be ruled by unhealthy leaders. These people are also mocking the illness and then death of Mr. Parrikar. Please either take some action on them or be careful while giving a title next time. We have some people who blindly spread false news without even reading the whole article.

  2. If the health of a Politician even in old age does not impair his capability to work, why do candidates applying for jobs have to undergo Medical Tests & have to retire at 58/60? Why allow sick & medically unfit candidates to fight Elections and then stick to the chair and undergo treatment at home & abroad at Tax Payers cost & also destroy governance? Make it mandatory to get medically & physically fit to stand for Election. Why shouldn’t PM ask medically unfit Ministers to resign or dismissed? Let someone fit replace them and such politicians be accommodated honourable in Margdarshak Mandal, if Party so desires?

  3. “Lal Krishna Advani, 90, is the oldest member of Parliament ever”. Heard of Rishang Keishing? Or Ram Sundar Das?
    The great Prof. N G Ranga was an MP till age 91.

  4. Shivam Vij: I think you need to make a distinction between the cases where the person has a temporary illness and where the condition chronically impair his or her ability to perform the duties of office. The central argument in your article is totally weakened by your inclusion of politicians who did not hold office (other than being an MP, leader of their party etc.)

  5. People are entitled to privacy on matters of personal health. We admire those like Irrfan Khan who are candid. It is not someone’s fault if he develops a life threatening ailment. Not sharing details is a matter of choice. However, when that impairs an abikity to work, most obviously in the case of Ms Jayalalithaa, the public interest outweighs the guarding of personal space. In the case of someone like CM Parrikar, one option would have been to swear in an acting CM, leave him unburdened and free to focus on his treatment. Keeping Jinnah’s ailment hidden was necessary for the creation of Pakistan, there was no time to lose.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular