Sunday, 4 December, 2022
HomeOpinionIf Modi can engage with a hostile China, why can’t Sidhu go...

If Modi can engage with a hostile China, why can’t Sidhu go to Pakistan?

Text Size:

If Sidhu’s presence at Imran Khan’s swearing-in was ‘anti-national’, the MEA would not have allowed him to travel to Pakistan.

A senior journalist criticised Punjab minister and former cricketer Navjot Singh Sidhu on Twitter for allowing himself to be seated next to Pakistan-occupied-Kashmir ‘president’ Masood Khan during Imran Khan’s oath-taking ceremony.

The journalist used the word “laanat” for Sidhu.

What if Prime Minister Narendra Modi returns to power in 2019, and decides to change the direction of his plane once again – like he did in December 2015 – to visit Lahore and wish his Pakistani counterpart Imran Khan on his birthday? Will our news channels, who think being anti-Pakistan and anti-minorities will get them the TRPs, hail it as a wonderful gesture or pan the leader for bowing down to the enemy?

Also read: Row over Sidhu in Pakistan exposes us as a nation of paranoid, ignorant, immature idiots

Is India in a permanent state of enmity with Pakistan and should there be no effort to engage with it – overtly or covertly?

How would the anti-Pakistan voices on Twitter and other social media platforms react if Atal Bihari Vajpayee and not Narendra Modi was still our Prime Minister and took one more bus to Lahore? Would he have been feted or showered with the vilest of abuse?

Will senior journalists on Twitter also label any such move from the government of India next time as “laanat”?

If India can engage with China despite Doklam, why can’t it talk to Pakistan? The Doklam crisis isn’t over. Read this report by my colleague Col Vinayak Bhat (retd) about China continuing to amass troops at Doklam, something that the Government of India officially denies. It is no secret that Pakistan’s army and the infamous ISI continue to foment trouble in Jammu and Kashmir. But, weren’t they doing the same when Modi visited then-Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif to wish him on his birthday? It was hailed as a masterstroke and a game-changing move at that time. The Pathankot air base attack by Pakistani terrorists took place within days of that visit.

But, times are changing fast and the trolls may not even spare Modi if such a (mis?)adventure is carried out again.

Also read: Outing a personal secret as a lesson for Imran: Featuring Vajpayee, Nawaz & a bit of me

This brings me back to my original question: Is Pakistan a permanent enemy?

If yes, then let all kinds of engagement with the Pakistani establishment end. If playing a cricket series is wrong, so is the hush-hush backchannel between Indian National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and his Pakistani counterpart Lt General (retd) Nasser Khan Janjua in Bangkok in December last year. Why then should the Indian high commissioner to Pakistan present Imran Khan with a cricket bat autographed by the Indian team?

But breaking all engagement with Pakistan may be easier said than done.

Sidhu had earlier announced at the Chandigarh Press Club that he would attend Khan’s swearing-in only if the Centre permitted him to do so. It appears that the government has decided to not let anything come in the way of a possible re-opening of talks with the nuclear-armed neighbour.

Allowing Sidhu to attend the swearing-in was a good move, as was sending India’s High Commissioner to Pakistan Ajay Bisaria to meet Khan on 10 August and gift him a cricket bat.

Had it been an anti-national move, the ministry of external affairs would certainly have refused permission to Sidhu to travel to Pakistan.

Diplomacy is a fine art, one that can’t be played out in the front of, or for the benefit of, TV cameras. But if Saturday’s big news on most TV channels was the anti-national move by Sidhu, the BJP must carry some responsibility for it. The party’s spokespersons have been constantly trying to whip up mass hysteria against Pakistan.

They possibly forget that their own government may eventually want to sit down and re-start negotiations with the government of Pakistan.

The Vajpayee formula:

How would Vajpayee have reacted to this clamour against Sidhu? Would he have joined the Sidhu-is-anti-national diatribe or used him to re-open the stalled talks with Pakistan? Would he have told his party spokespersons to go on the offensive against Sidhu or told them to concentrate on the floods in Kerala instead?

He may have done the smart thing and used Sidhu to break the ice with the Pakistani leadership. He was a leader who could not be swayed by the reductive voices on most TV channels. He could decide to take a bus to Lahore but also mobilise half of the armed forces along the borders during Operation Parakram following the attack on Parliament in December 2001. Or, he could give Pakistan’s plan to take our territory a bloody nose during the Kargil conflict.

He wasn’t the kind of leader who would constantly monitor what warmongers sitting in air-conditioned TV studios, masquerading as news anchors, say about Pakistan.

Also read: What would Vajpayee have thought of Narendra Modi’s ‘muscular’ policy?

I hope Indians will finally be told whether we should treat Pakistan as friend or foe. But that answer should come from the Narendra Modi government, not a BJP spokesperson or a journalist.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. Justice Chelameswar, Justice Gogoi and Justice Kurien Joseph are all coterie of Soniaji. They are encouraging PIL to rule the Centre. Whole of Supreme Court has become a coterie of Soniaji. Justice Balakrishnan keeps GOD Krishna’s photo in the verandah and the photo of Jesus Christ in his house (inside). Justice Balakrishnan immediately on retirement gets an apointment as Chairman courtesy Sonia Gandhi. NDTV has no problem with that. Justice Balakrishnan gave in writing to Government that he is a hindu Scheduled Caste and practices christianity.

  2. I use to see a bold Shekhar Gupta during the emergency. That Shekhar Gupta has become diluted in the company of Pronoy Roys NDTV.

  3. Mr. Imran Khan is a puppet in the hands of Gen. Bajwa. Imran cannot improve Pakistan. Pakistan will go down and down and down. Imran speaks about Islamic Welfare State. You people have no objectino to that. What will happen to Ahmedias, Hindus, Sikhs, Christians only GOD knows. When you people say secularism, please keep in mind India is secular because Hindus are in a majority. The moment Muslims outnumber Hindus in population Secularism will be thrtown into the Indian Ocean. Mr. Shekhar Gupta, You supported Mr. Kurien Joseph. A judge is supposed to work in the night whenever a citizen approaches him for justice. This Justice wrote to Modiji stating that on Good Friday he cannot work. You support this Judge Mr. Shekhar Gupta.

  4. Don’t Compare Modiji with Sidhu. Nobody in todays opposition is there who can be compared with Modiji, Modiji engages with China with inputs from the Army, Navy and Airforce. Sidhu simply defies Amrinder Singh and goes to Pakistan. Sunil Gavaskar and other people were also invited everybody skipped because everbody knows how General Bajwa behaves.

  5. Mr. Chidambarams son Karti Chidambaram says his net worth is 6 lakh crore. From where he built this empire. Kindly enquire if you have guts. I know your Indian express. Indian express fought against the autocratic Indira Gandhi. Please come out of the shackles of NDTV and start supporting the Swatchtha programme of building 8 crore toilets for the poor of this country and also 1 crore houses already built by Modiji. Ujwala and Adhaar linked schemes

  6. You and your NDTV supported The biggest thief of India Mr. Chidambaram the most. Mr. Chidambaram will soon be in jail

  7. Mr. Shekhar Gupta Amrinder Singh had already spoken about Sidhu the murderer whom Justice Chelameswar acquitted.

  8. Modibjp Govt’s foreign policy r worst in the world , not only foreign policy Economic policy also !our economy policy decided by corporate friends! Govt can’t decide what to do and when to amplimant all minister r only portfolio ministers they say only hamnare modiji hamare modiji and modiji ? Our neubure County s Qussing us china Sri Lanka Nepal Bangladesh even now USA Indian policy : modiji ko Raat main khwab aata hai morning main kanoon

  9. Such articles are not desirable. The author is totally biased or misinformed. All states have contributed to their might. Many individuals are contributing to Kerala chief minister’s distress fund. NDRF and Defence forces are on the job.Where is the need for creating North South divide. It is simply a sick mentality. Wish such articles should not be wrieen. it is disgusting.

  10. Just think if all citizen think themselves Prime Minister of India or the Judges of India then the union of India will head in what direction?

Comments are closed.

Most Popular