Wednesday, February 1, 2023
HomeOpinionExtortion holding up Naga peace deal. And governor Ravi is taking the...

Extortion holding up Naga peace deal. And governor Ravi is taking the bull by its horns

Five years after Modi govt signed the framework agreement, there is no sign of a final accord in Nagaland even as NSCN-IM has understood governor RN Ravi’s larger game plan.

Text Size:

Lasting peace in Nagaland remains as elusive as ever. There have been many twists and turns in the road to the Naga peace process, and one such twist was added by some influential Naga insurgent groups when they accused Nagaland governor R.N. Ravi of creating tensions among the parties involved in the ongoing peace talks, asking for his removal as the interlocutor.

Last month, six militants belonging to the National Socialist Council of Nagalim (Isak-Muivah), or NSCN-IM, were killed in a gun battle with security forces in Arunachal Pradesh’s Longding district. A few days before this incident, Ravi had written a strongly worded letter to Nagaland Chief Minister Neiphu Rio, asserting the governor’s constitutional powers under Article 371A of the Indian Constitution. Expressing his annoyance over the culture of extortion and the collapse of law and order in Nagaland, Ravi had mentioned the “unrestrained depredations” by organised armed gangs who run their own parallel administrations and collect so-called taxes from the people.

R.N. Ravi is a former deputy national security advisor; he retained the interlocutor position even after becoming Nagaland’s governor in August 2019 due to his vast expertise and long experience of the matter. Ravi must be praised for underlining the rampant culture of extortions in the name of taxes in Nagaland. However, this is not an earth-shattering revelation; extortions have been a regular phenomenon in many northeastern states, irrespective of the party in power in New Delhi, where the highest administrative officials are aware of this practice, but prefer not to discuss it openly because they are helpless.

An outsider not familiar with the region might find it difficult to believe that businesses, small traders and government employees have to regularly pay “tax” to the Naga armed groups. Since the terms of ceasefire permit the NSCN-IM cadres to retain weapons, the refusal to pay extortions or donations can have life-threatening consequences. Insurgent footprints can be found in every economic, developmental and political activity in Nagaland. The problem has become so entrenched that people complain only when a certain threshold is crossed, otherwise they either pay or negotiate the amount of extortion. Hence, by pointing out the fundamental incompatibility of a state government’s claim of sovereignty cohabiting with the armed groups’ audacity to claim a right to extortion, Ravi has only taken the bull by the horns.


Also read: NSCN (I-M) resumes talks with Centre ‘without Governor Ravi’, says focus on contentious areas


Hurdles in Naga peace talks

One should be aware that the NSCN-IM’s insistence for a separate flag and constitution has been a major stumbling block in the delivery of the final Naga accord. And state governments in the northeast have been very apprehensive of its demand of ‘Greater Nagalim’. Although there is no clear indication yet, even if the outfit agrees to pursue a solution that will not require the redrawing of boundaries, New Delhi will find it difficult to fulfill many of its other demands.

The Naga problem, one of the longest political conflicts in Southeast Asia, can be traced to the politics of sub-nationalism. And in the era of the resurgence of nationalist feelings worldwide, it would be risky to underestimate the power of Naga sub-nationalism. Although these two elements often come into tension with each other, it is still possible to blend them through a democratic process of give and take. Seen in this context, the Naga interlocutor’s recent actions reflect the views of a leadership in New Delhi that is not willing to accept a downgrading of the government’s bargaining position in subsequent discussions with the Naga groups. One cannot disagree with this logic, but there is a dilemma.

At a time when New Delhi is negotiating hard with the Chinese to disengage from the disputed areas from the Line of Actual Control (LAC), the challenges of the Naga peace accord seem to have only multiplied. The manner in which Beijing is risking a military conflict with its nuclear-armed neighbour amid a global pandemic should leave nobody in doubt that China’s revisionist policies constitute a threat for India’s national security. Beijing’s brazen attempt to turn Nepal against India is also a matter of serious concern for New Delhi. Ravi should, therefore, take the geopolitics of the volatile region in the post-Galwan era into consideration if he is keen to push for peace with different insurgent groups, including the NSCN-IM.


Also read: Nagaland civil servants hit out at IAS officers, call them ‘suitcase bureaucrats’


Much ado about nothing

It needs to be noted that the NSCN-IM and the Narendra Modi government had signed the framework agreement in August 2015 amid much fanfare. It was then claimed that the final accord would be inked soon. But the prevalent sentiment of being very near to an accord was basically rooted in a combination of wishful thinking and misreading of ground realities of the northeastern region. There has been no sign of a final accord even after five years of this framework agreement and more than two decades of ceasefire.

However, the Modi government enlarged the peace process by roping in seven other extremist groups under the umbrella organisation Naga National Political Groups. The reason was simple and straightforward: involvement of all stakeholders in the process would effectively put New Delhi in a better bargaining position during negotiations. However, this strategy does not seem to have worked.

The NSCN-IM as well as some influential Naga political groups are unhappy with governor Ravi. The NSCN-IM, in response to the governor’s letter, said that if Ravi “finds pleasure to handle the Naga issue as a ‘law and order’ problem, he is not the right person to solve the long standing Indo-Naga problem.” The NSCN-IM has always believed that it has a sovereign right to collect taxes since it claims itself to be the “recognised and legitimate” representative of the Naga people.


Also read: We want peace but Governor Ravi is taking us back to fighting days, says NSCN (I-M)


Governor Ravi’s ‘game plan’

The main reason that the central government engages any insurgent group in the peace process is because of its influence with the local people. And the NSCN-IM is the most influential and powerful of the armed insurgent groups in Nagaland in terms of finance, cadre and weapons. Since the local people are forced to pay multiple, excessive ransom to insurgent groups, the final Naga pact cannot ignore this issue. Hence, it is entirely reasonable to believe that governor Ravi’s main purpose is to convey a strong message to the people in Nagaland that New Delhi is with them in their sufferings, while attempting to delegitimise the NSCN-IM’s claim of being their legitimate representatives.

Why the killing of some NSCN-IM cadres in Arunachal Pradesh raised eyebrows is because there are disputes regarding the territorial reach of ceasefire in Arunachal Pradesh and Manipur, where the NSCN-IM has a sizeable presence in addition to its stronghold in Nagaland. One can surmise that the purpose of this incident is to bring into question the ceasefire itself by promoting different interpretations of its terms. Moreover, the Nagaland government’s recent directive to all its employees to self-declare if any of their family members and relatives are members of underground organisations should also be understood in the wider context of Ravi’s thinking on the issue. The NSCN-IM has understood governor Ravi’s larger game plan of converting the Naga dispute into a ‘law and order’ issue.

If history is a guide, finding a lasting solution to Naga political issues acceptable to all groups is not going to be an easy task. One should remember that Nagaland and Jammu & Kashmir are geographically as well as culturally far apart. Thus, it is time to bring the tottering Naga peace process back on tracks, since the failure to do so could undermine not only the peace in the northeast but also the very foundations of India’s ‘Act East’ policy.

Mahendra L. Kumawat is former chairman, Ceasefire Monitoring Group, Nagaland and former Special Secretary, Internal Security, Ministry of Home Affairs; and Vinay Kaura is assistant professor, Sardar Patel University of Police, Security and Criminal Justice, Rajasthan. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism

8 COMMENTS

  1. The comments above simply show ignorance at its best, study and Understand Naga History, anthropology, ethnography and then come to state your opinion based on facts, Naga as People are spread out in Northeast India and Northwest Myanmmar, for a start before you comment as an expert on Naga Issue read J.P.Mills, J.H.Hutton, Verrier Edwin and dozens of Colonial writers and others who documented on the Naga People.FYI, Cannibalism is nowhere in the Naga Dictionary, if you ignorantly profess Headhunting to be cruel, then you should question all your great one-sided history book of the masscares, pillage and war of conqueror or conquest.

    Every civilization killed and butchered, inferior tribe or kingdom, some with Guns some with swords, then who is more cannibalistic or civilized, the one who used Guns to kill a lesser community? Talk about the Cast, Race, and treatment of the inferior human being. Being from the Northeast state I am sickened by the Caste, class, Race, color divide in the rest of the country, which still exists but people wish to live as if that does not exist.

    Where were you people when you were not even a country, Hindu against Muslim, Caste against caste, Rajputs against Marathas, and so forth. Do you understand what forced assimilation looks like, talked about forced marriage, does it ever work?

    Common sense is missing is Hunams all-over today. For Religion you will kill the other when for Nationalism you will kill the other without a thought, the Army in dying in No-Mans Land, in J&K and Northeast, you kill us we kill you, that solves all problem right, yeah that’s why the Nagas are fighting for their stand for the last more than 60-Years, thanks to AFSPA that has been there since 60+ years and make our life worse for your convenience of Nationalistic Pride! Kill the Nagas, the Bodos,The Khasis.The Kukis, the Tamils, the Dalits the Kashmiris, the Hindu, Muslims, and the Christians, the Sikhs, and that’s what you get for not trying to understand the other, for thinking that the other is wrong, we kill you in Tens, you kill us in thousands, your and my Desh Bhakti truly Amazes me! We will continue this Desh Bhakti by killing, stoning and Hanging, and Shooting anyone who opposes me, truly a great country with great people, indeed we are living in the Golden times of Ram Rajya!

  2. Views are more tilted towards government and when does delhi cared for north east . Delhi treats northeast as it’s step child

  3. What is Islam to Kashmir movement, the same is exportation to Naga insurgency. Take out religion from the former and money from the latter the sail will be without wind.

  4. Some Naga tribes practiced cannibalism even in the recent past. Consistent efforts by Christian missionaries finally made them leave this practice in the 1980s.
    One wonders for what purpose do they want “independence”. Maybe they wish to go back to the “golden” days of the past.

    • Lol yea bro. NSCN-IM must be told to prove they have support from naga people by telling them to run for elections.. if they win, that will be proof.

      Message should be – you can only rule through the Indian state not by running a parallel extortion racket

    • No , they were head hunters , they used to kill among themselves . You are no different than them .

Comments are closed.