Thursday, 24 November, 2022
HomeOpinionChina heads FATF, but India won’t lose any opportunity to isolate Pakistan

China heads FATF, but India won’t lose any opportunity to isolate Pakistan

The reviews conducted by the FATF over the last one year have exposed Pakistan’s so-called fight against terror financing.

Text Size:

In a pre-dawn strike on 10 February 2018, three Jaish-e-Mohammad fidayeen attackers laid siege at the Sunjuwan Military Station in Jammu, which was hardly a few miles away from the Jammu University. The attackers, who were believed to be from the FATA region of Pakistan, kept the gun-battle raging for more than 24 hours in which six Army soldiers and a civilian were killed.

While India was caught unawares by this fidayeen strike, the North Block was fast losing patience with Pakistan’s hypocrisy in fighting terror and instead unleashing a proxy war through home-grown terror groups. After a nod from the South Block, days before this attack, multiple agencies sitting in the North Block began the painstakingly long exercise of putting together hard-evidence of Pakistani state financially supporting various terror groups operating on its soil. On top of its list were terror groups Lashkar-e-Taiba and Jaish-e-Mohammad, led by Hafiz Saeed and Maulana Masood Azhar, who operated through various trusts, NGOs and charities.

“Pakistan, in spite of us giving dossiers after dossiers, has not taken any action. On the contrary, we find people who are directly responsible for Mumbai attacks and many others are free and happily roaming in Pakistan (sic). We will be providing every evidence to prove that the handlers are back in Pakistan,” India’s then-Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman told me in response to a question, minutes after the counter-terror operation ended in Jammu.

However, this time around, the evidence was not going to be shared with Islamabad unlike after the Mumbai 26/11 attacks or even after the Pathankot and Uri terror attacks. In an unprecedented exercise, India prevailed over the member-nations of the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) headquartered in Paris after one-on-one interaction with countries about the sponsorship of terror from Pakistan to India and its global consequences.

On 23 February 2018, the FATF decided to put Pakistan on the watchlist; the country was officially put on the grey list of the anti-money laundering watchdog on 27 June.

The US motion to put Pakistan on the grey list, which was firmly backed by France and the UK, was initially opposed by China during the internal deliberations on 20 February 2018, but Pakistan faced its all-weather friend China’s betrayal as it revoked its objections at the last minute. The setbacks had just begun for Pakistan.

Also read: Modi is not wrong in thinking Pakistan wants talks with India to earn global brownie points

Pakistan & Chinese interests

Yet another FATF plenary session started in Paris this Sunday. All eyes will be on the 39 members of FATF and the participants from 205 jurisdictions, and their focus on finding ways to disrupt the financial flows linked to crime and terrorism for global safety and security.

The international attention, however, is on Pakistan, which has ignored multiple warnings of the international watchdog during the grey list period and has refused to show actionable evidence of its commitment towards the 27-point action plan shared by the FATF. The question being asked in India is: Will Pakistan be now put on the FATF blacklist?

The answer to that question cannot be given in isolation, without understanding the organisational structure of the FATF that has changed in the recent times. On 1 July 2019, Xiangmin Liu, Director General of the Legal Department at People’s Bank of China, was appointed president of the FATF.

Liu, who is known as the architect of China’s anti-terror financing policies, could be next in line to become the chief of the People’s Bank of China after his tenure at the FATF ends. The top appointment, however, needs the blessings of both Xi Jinping and the Communist Party.

With its massive investment in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), Beijing would never let Islamabad suffer an economic onslaught, which would end up hurting its own interests. During the recent ‘Chennai Connect’, which was a sequel to the ‘Wuhan Spirit, Xi Jinping may have committed to fighting terrorism and radicalism along with India with focus on uprooting terror financing, but in the current scheme of global diplomacy, Beijing is unlikely to publicly give a cold-shoulder to Pakistan.

Also read: Pakistan has not taken sufficient steps to tackle terror, says FATF ahead of Paris meet

FATF losing patience

Liu, however, cannot give Pakistan a long rope. During his tenure as the vice-president of the FATF, Pakistan has often failed to demonstrate action against terror financing as per the initial 10-point action plan or the 27-point action plan shared at a later stage. The reviews conducted by the FATF over the last one year have exposed Pakistan’s so-called fight against terror financing.

In its Mutual Evaluation Report on Pakistan, released earlier this month, the Asia Pacific Group on Money Laundering (APG), which is a subsidiary of the FATF and based in Australia, has come down hard on Islamabad. “Pakistan has not taken sufficient measures to fully implement UNSCR 1267 obligations against all listed individuals and entities – especially those associated with Lashkar-e-Tayyiba (LeT)/Jamaat-ud-Dawa (JuD), and Falah-i-Insaniat Foundation (FiF) as well as the groups’s leader Hafiz Saeed,” the report read.

“Despite being listed by the UNSCR 1267 Committee in 2008 (JuD) and 2012 (FiF), before February 2018, JuD/FiF openly operated in Pakistan, including holding public rallies and fundraising events. Numerous Pakistani media reports showed FiF raising funds ostensibly for humanitarian relief, as well as operating a large ambulance fleet, which calls into question whether the prohibition on providing funds and financial services was being fully implemented’, the 229-page report said.

It’s evident that the FATF is fast losing patience with Pakistan. India on the other hand isn’t going to lose any opportunity to isolate Islamabad diplomatically, more so after the Pulwama terror attack on 14 February, which killed 40 paramilitary personnel and also brought about a paradigm shift in New Delhi’s Pakistan policy. Earlier, India had submitted a dossier to the FATF members, linking the Pulwama suicide attack to Pakistan-based terror group Jaish-e-Mohammad and revealing the funding network of the group through various trusts and charities.

Fighting the perception battle

Pakistan has satisfied the FATF only on six of the 27 parameters, which means that the global economic isolation of Pakistan could be imminent. An economic nightmare would entail Pakistan losing trust of not just the International Monetary Fund (IMF), but also the European Union (EU) and the World Bank – all of them have come to Pakistan’s rescue one way or the other in recent times.

It may take a little more than a week to know if Pakistan makes it to the blacklist, which already has countries like Iran and North Korea. But fighting the perception battle won’t be easy for Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan who has been lobbying desperately with China, US, Saudi Arabia and Turkey to avoid an economic deathtrap.

“Our Foreign Office did an analysis about the loss to the Pakistani government due to grey-listing,” a worried Pakistani Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi told media-persons in April while answering questions on the FATF warning to Pakistan on the lack of steps taken against terror-financing on its soil. “Experts calculated the loss figure to $10 billion. It’s a scary picture. We have now asked experts to analyse the loss due to blacklisting. God save us from the blacklist,” he pleaded.

God may save Pakistan for the time being, with the country likely to move from the grey to the dark grey list, even as it continues to estimate the losses. Yet, how many shades of grey can come to Pakistan’s rescue before the black shadow engulfs it?

Also read: Under global pressure, Pakistan is scrambling to hide its terror group — but it’s short-lived

The author is an independent journalist. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Support Our Journalism

India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. ThePrint – with exceptional reporters, columnists and editors – is doing just that.

Sustaining this needs support from wonderful readers like you.

Whether you live in India or overseas, you can take a paid subscription by clicking here.

Support Our Journalism


  1. The FATF is surely biased. If it was not, India was to be considered a terrorist country first. But as USA needs a puppet to counter China, India is a best bet. As it has always supported Israel, now it support India despite gross human rights violation in Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir. And btw we have proof of Indian sponsered terrorists in Pakistan, mainly in Sindh and Balochistan, but interests of US are with India. Bitter truth!

  2. Pakistan will not fall into the debt trap of blacklisted for 2 reasons. The US needs Pakis to solve their Afghan headache so the Pakis will be there not for free. If Trump thinks Taliban can be tamed without Pakistan, then ISI is in trouble. And next the FATF chairman needs the Pakis for all their dream and pet projects which has lost the Chinese trust in some way but still in action, Needs the Pakis here, So the Pakis will be moving around all the Multiple Grey Shades of FATF for the centuries to come. And terror will be incubated for all future needs of nations that require terror as their weapon to achieve their objectives, And Pakis have their own agenda to destroy Hindu India, and convert it by force to Islamic country, Jai Hind,

  3. The Pakistani establishment has single point program of destroying India. It is willing to do anything, even lick boots, for those who will help it in its project against India. The people of Pakistan should be made to understand, that because of wrong goals of Pakistan establishment they have massively suffered in the hands of terrorist, economic downturn, social tension and loss of respect for Pakistani passport. A program for education of Pakistani people should be started on radio and television and social media.

Comments are closed.

Most Popular