Home Opinion Art in the time of CAA-NRC protests: India is seeing a creative...

Art in the time of CAA-NRC protests: India is seeing a creative renaissance under Modi & Shah

Anti-CAA protests are not in news because of Naseeruddin Shah or Javed Akhtar. They are in news because all Indians have taken to the streets to sing and paint against it.

Zainab Sikander
Anti-CAA protesters at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi
Anti-CAA protesters at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi | Photo: Manisha Mondal | ThePrint

If there’s anything we Indians should thank the Narendra Modi government for, it is the proliferation of art, poetry and creative content during its regime. Not that Modi and Amit Shah have helped with patronage. But the bulldozing of controversial bills through Parliament has made many critics of the Modi-Shah government express their dissent rather creatively – since saying it directly has landed many in jail.

The Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and National Register of Citizens (NRC) have been the recent catalysts for this creativity among Indians. Every street corner, there is comedy, poetry, memes, art, sloganeering and quirky posters.

From placards that ask India not to turn into a low-budget Israel to artwork that say “we’ll fight, but with love”, Indians have stumped the Modi government and its propaganda machinery with a messaging that’s hard to take legal action against. And yet, it is proving to be very effective.

I call this moment India’s renaissance.

Source: Social media

Also read: Modi’s India unhappy with protesters singing Faiz’s Hum Dekhenge. Zia’s Pakistan was too


A shift

The European Renaissance in the 14th-17th century was marked by modernisation of art, architecture, philosophy, science and politics. It was a shift from the Middle Ages to a Modern Age that focused on humanism and realism.

In India today, we are seeing a renaissance through art and literature – people are getting their voice back. And what is aiding it is the social media coverage of the protests. Art has always been a medium of dissent – but now, a lot of people are getting exposure to it, thanks to Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.

Pictures have a higher tendency to go viral. So, when a German student holds up a poster in an anti-CAA protest saying “1933-45, we’ve been there”, it is bound to make a statement. Anyone with a rudimentary knowledge of history would know that the poster is a reference to the Nazi era when Jews were brutally persecuted by Adolf Hitler. The student, Jakob Lindenthal, was sent back to Germany. The Ministry of External Affairs, however, denied forcing him out, saying he was going home for Christmas anyway.

German student Jakob Lindenthal | Twitter

I spoke to Avani Chokshi from Bangalore, member of a collective called Hum Bharat Ke Log and part of the nationwide strike on 19 December against CAA, about why are people turning to art in these protests. She said that to curb the protests and after imposition of Section 144 in Bangalore, hundreds of protestors were put in an enclosed hall where they turned to poetry and shayari. It unites people.

Another protester from Kolkata, Kamran Ahmed Khan, who made masks for anti-CAA protesters, told me that he turned to art because he felt he “was representing the Netflix and Amazon crowd, basically young people who usually don’t care about daily politics and want to stay away from the mess happening around”. “So, I decided to have these Dali masks made, which were used in the Netflix show Money Heist. Dali masks are a sign of resistance. I wanted to send a message that we the young people of India would resist this ridiculous and highly communal and divisive law,” said Khan.

Tribal people also joined the protests, especially against the NRC, which asks for citizenship proof.

Source: Social media

And then there are the senior citizens from Delhi’s Shaheen Bagh who recited Varun Grover’s ‘Hum Kaagaz Nahi Dikhayenge’. They have been sitting in protest for days through the cold winter.

Hindus are dressing as Muslims by wearing hijabs and skull caps, while Muslims are donning tilaks and turbans to show that Prime Minister Modi’s barb of protesters being easily identified by their clothes has no basis in reality. As I wrote before, it isn’t a Muslim-only protest, it’s an everyone, everywhere protest. Indians are turning away from the delusion of WhatsApp University. Indian renaissance indeed.

Source: Social media

Also read: The placards and songs that ruled the CAA protests across India


‘Hindustani Musalmaan’

Muslims also got their mojo back in these protests. From holding up posters saying “Miya bhai ek dawat na chore mulk kya ghanta chorega” (Muslims don’t give up a dinner party, and you expect them to leave their country) to being unapologetic about their clothes, identity and their overall “Muslimness”, these protests are addressing that awkward question that the Right-wing harangues Muslims with – “How ‘Indian’ are Muslims?”

Hussain Haidry questioning “main kaisa Musalmaan hoon? (What kind of a Muslim am I?)” through a poem he wrote, to a crowd in Azad Maidan, hits at the heart of the matter. Every Muslim is questioning their identity in this nation today. And the answer is in Haidry’s poem – “a Hindustani Musalmaan.”

Source: Social media

Also read: In 2020, don’t rely on routine rallies and marches. Modi’s India needs new ways to protest


Popular content floating on the internet, WhatsApp and print media shows the words ‘tyranny’ and ‘fascism’ now being associated with Narendra Modi and Amit Shah – and obviously, the art and literature had a part to play in this association. The content being produced in these protests are predominantly using these words as adjectives for the ruling duo.

Art has truly made people expand and push the boundaries of conversation.

Source: Social media

The anti-CAA-NRC protests are no longer just about Muslim “intelligentsia”. These protests are not in the news because of a Naseeruddin Shah, Javed Akhtar, Shabnam Hashmi or Shehla Rashid. They are in the news because Indians have taken to the streets to sing, chant, paint against it.

The author is a political observer and writer. Views are personal.

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Why news media is in crisis & How you can fix it

India needs free, fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism even more as it faces multiple crises.

But the news media is in a crisis of its own. There have been brutal layoffs and pay-cuts. The best of journalism is shrinking, yielding to crude prime-time spectacle.

ThePrint has the finest young reporters, columnists and editors working for it. Sustaining journalism of this quality needs smart and thinking people like you to pay for it. Whether you live in India or overseas, you can do it here.

Support Our Journalism

11 COMMENTS

  1. When you take on a job w/o knowing what you can and can not do, it implies you have not read the constitution and your legal advisor is piss poor Fire him first. Then read and re read your authorities. You are not a king.

    • nice dream! ask in assam. any way, what do they pay you? go on telling lies – no problem – may be you need the money but dont forget to ask for minimum wage.

  2. Many felt Bollywood, the fount of creativity and artistic endeavour, was not contributing to the national conversation around CAA and related issues. The silence of the lambs. See the list of invitees who turned up for that scrumptious dinner. Not one person of note.

        • By saying what a Hindu would and won’t do, u r bringing confinements to it and hence demeaning Hinduism. So I say, I reject caa-npr-nrc, ur dictatorship and ur hindutwa. I bet I’m a better hindu as well as human.

Comments are closed.

More