New Delhi: Once the government regularises an employee, it cannot go back decades later and use the temporary nature of the employee’s original appointment to deny pension, the Supreme Court has held, striking down two Uttar Pradesh laws that sought to retrospectively exclude such service from pension calculations.
A Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma Wednesday held that regularisation brings an employee into the regular stream of public service and wipes away the distinction arising from how the employee originally entered service.
In a significant declaration on the rights of long-serving government workers, the court said, “The birthmark of being ad hoc/casual/daily-rated employees stands obliterated and they are integrated into the regular stream of service, with all consequential benefits.”
Once that status has been acquired, the court said, the state cannot resurrect the employee’s earlier status, even through retrospective legislation, to take away retirement benefits. Such an attempt would offend Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution.
The judgment declared unconstitutional the Uttar Pradesh Qualifying Service for Pension and Validation Act, 2021, and the Uttar Pradesh Entitlement to Pension and Validation Act, 2025, bringing another chapter to a close in a decades-long dispute over the pension rights of employees who spent years working for the state before their services were formally regularised.
The court also rejected Uttar Pradesh’s argument that recognising these claims could place an enormous financial burden on the state.
Pointing to the expenditure of thousands of crores on the construction and beautification of parks and public spaces, the Bench said a state cannot rely on a ‘scarcity’ of funds when faced with an obligation legally owed to its employees.
“The public exchequer exists not merely to finance projects reflecting the priorities of a particular dispensation, but also to fulfil the state’s obligations under law,” it said.
The court was sharper still: “The bogey of financial constraints of the state should never be raised, even in the passing, to defeat a legal obligation.”
A dispute stretching back decades
The case arose from the employment history of workers across several Uttar Pradesh government departments, including the Ground Water Department, Public Works Department and Irrigation Department, who had worked for years without initially holding regular posts.
A large number had joined government establishments between the late 1970s and mid-1980s as work-charged employees (workers hired by a government department for a specific project or task, where pay comes from the budget for the project). Others began as daily-wage or muster-roll workers (contractual employees), temporary employees or Seasonal Collection Amins (temporary revenue worker hired for a crop season to help collect government dues or taxes).
Many continued working for the government for years before they were eventually absorbed or regularised. Their difficulty emerged at retirement.
Under the pension regime operating in Uttar Pradesh before the ‘Prem Singh’ verdict in 2019, particularly Rule 3(8) of the Uttar Pradesh Retirement Benefits Rules, 1961, service spent in a work-charged establishment was excluded while determining qualifying service for pension. As a result, workers could spend decades serving government departments but find that a substantial part of that service disappeared from consideration when their pension was calculated.
The issue reached the Supreme Court in ‘Prem Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh’. In 2019, a three-judge Bench read down Rule 3(8) and held that service rendered in a work-charged establishment must be counted as qualifying service for pension. The employees’ appeals were allowed and the state’s appeals dismissed, although arrears were restricted to three years.
Uttar Pradesh sought a review, but the review petition was dismissed in February 2020. A curative petition was subsequently withdrawn. The state had also issued directions for compliance with the ‘Prem Singh’ verdict, and pensionary benefits were released in some cases.
The controversy, however, did not end there.
Uttar Pradesh introduced an Ordinance in 2020 and subsequently enacted the Validation Act, 2021, with retrospective effect from 1 April 1961. While challenges to that law were pending, the state introduced another pension law in 2025, which created the category of a “substantive appointee” and sought to validate earlier denials of pension, notwithstanding judgments and orders of courts.
In substance, the Supreme Court was now confronted with a larger question than pension alone: Could the legislature change the law after a Supreme Court judgment and thereby undo what the court had already decided?
‘Changing law is permissible, changing the result is not’
The Supreme Court made clear that legislatures are not powerless after a judicial decision. A legislature may amend a law and may even give the amendment retrospective operation. What it cannot do is simply change the language of the legislation while retaining the very defect that led the court to intervene in the first place.
The Bench framed the issue bluntly: “Legislature may change the law or basis of the judgment; but, can it by mere change of language, change the judgment?”
A validating law, the court explained, must satisfy three basic requirements: The legislature must be competent to enact it, the defect identified in the earlier judgment must actually be removed, and the new law must itself comply with the fundamental rights guaranteed under Part III of the Constitution.
Uttar Pradesh’s laws failed principally because the defect had not actually disappeared.
The court found that the ‘Prem Singh’ verdict had objected to excluding service genuinely rendered by employees in work-charged establishments before their eventual regularisation. The state’s later laws merely approached that exclusion from another direction.
Instead of excluding workers by referring to the establishment in which they had served, the legislation introduced new definitions concerning “qualifying service” and “substantive appointees”. But a new expression could not cure the constitutional problem.
“Usage of the expression ‘substantive appointee’ may be novel; but the consequence sought to be achieved is not,” the court said.
For the Bench, the crucial fact remained that these workers had actually rendered continuous service to the state and had subsequently been regularised. The government had failed to demonstrate why that earlier service should suddenly cease to matter only when pension became payable.
The court therefore held that “a change in the description of the excluded class is not… a constitutional justification to sustain the exclusion”.
‘A final judgment cannot simply be legislated away’
The ruling also contains a significant statement on the separation between legislative and judicial power.
The court noted that the ‘Prem Singh’ verdict was not merely an abstract interpretation of pension rules. The employees had won their appeals, the state’s appeals had been dismissed and specific directions had been issued for payment of benefits. Review proceedings had failed and the state later withdrew its curative proceedings. The judgment had therefore travelled “the full distance from contest to finality”.
While the legislature remained free to change the underlying law, it could not simply command that a final decision should effectively cease to exist.
“The Constitution permits the legislature to change the law; however, the Constitution does not permit the legislature, under the garb of changing the law, to command that a final judicial determination shall be construed as though it had never been made in the first place,” the Bench said.
The court consequently found both Validation Acts unconstitutional and held that the pension claims of eligible work-charged employees must instead be considered in terms of the ‘Prem Singh’ verdict.
Retired employees covered by the judgment may now approach the competent authority with details of their service, and such claims must be decided within six months. If the authority proposes to reject a claim, the employee must first be heard and the rejection must be supported by reasons.
The court generally retained the three-year restriction on monetary benefits adopted in ‘ the ‘Prem Singh’ decision. It did not impose interest immediately, but warned that failure to release payments within the prescribed period would attract 9 percent simple interest per annum until payment.
The court also dealt with contempt petitions filed by employees alleging that Uttar Pradesh had failed to implement the pension directions issued in the ‘Prem Singh’ verdict in 2019.
While noting that pension payment orders had been issued and payments made in some cases, the Bench said the record did not establish that every petitioner had received the complete amount due. It gave the state a “further and final opportunity” of six months to make the outstanding payments, warning that any further failure would be viewed “extremely seriously” and could constitute “aggravated contempt”.
The ruling ultimately turns a pension dispute into a broader constitutional proposition: The government may change its laws, but it cannot erase years of service already accepted from its employees, nor can it use a new statutory label to achieve the same result that the Supreme Court has already held to be unconstitutional.
Alfreza Ahmed is an alum of ThePrint School of Journalism, currently interning with ThePrint.
(Edited by Viny Mishra)
