New Delhi: Almost six months after releasing draft regulations on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the legal field, the Supreme Court’s AI committee has decided to hold a two-day meeting with industry experts before finalising the rules. The meeting is scheduled for December, before the top court closes for its winter recess towards the end of the month, ThePrint has learnt.
Sources said members of the committee, including its chairperson, Justice P.S. Narasimha would attend the meeting and hear stakeholders’ views.
When it released the draft regulations in June, the Supreme Court had invited suggestions and feedback from bar associations and independent lawyers. The upcoming consultation, however, will bring in industry experts from beyond the legal fraternity.
“The committee is seeking genuine, critical responses to the regulations. Therefore, it has decided to hold this physical interaction and not restrict it to just legal fraternity members. The committee is very keen to understand the consequences of the regulations on the legal profession as well as the judicial system,” one of the sources quoted above told ThePrint.
Following the consultation, the committee will hold internal deliberations before notifying the regulations, another source said.
“Given that several instances of fake case citations are coming to the fore, the committee wants to operationalise the regulations soon, but only after due diligence. Once it is done in the Supreme Court, the High Courts would follow suit,” the second source added.
Released in June, the draft regulations permit the use of AI in judicial and legal work, subject to strict human oversight and judicial authority. They state that AI systems must function only in an assistive capacity and must not compromise the independent exercise of judicial authority.
The ultimate authority to determine questions of law, fact and justice would rest exclusively with judicial officers of competent jurisdiction.
The regulations demand high standards of transparency, including a declaration by lawyers before arguments begin if they have used AI to prepare their cases.
This provision has faced opposition from the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association—a body of lawyers in the top court—which has sought its removal. The lawyers’ body has also called for AI deployment to be phased in, stronger data protection safeguards and greater representation for advocates in the proposed AI governance structure.
Also Read: Indian courts are using AI without accountability. SC already caught one fake case law
What the draft rules mandate
The proposed rules place responsibility on users for AI-generated material submitted to courts. If an AI-enabled document or pleading is found to be fabricated, false, misleading or inaccurate, the user would bear full responsibility, and the court “may” pass appropriate orders against them.
Courts would also have to inform all parties when AI tools have “significantly” assisted any aspect of case management, document analysis or judicial administration in ways that could affect the conduct of proceedings.
The draft prohibits AI-based surveillance or continuous monitoring of judicial officers, advocates, litigants and others within court premises.
It also proposes a grievance redressal mechanism under which an AI secretariat, functioning under the Supreme Court’s AI committee, would examine complaints of violations. The committee would have the power to suspend an AI system in cases involving genuine grievances.
Prior written approval from the appropriate authority would be mandatory before deploying AI for court management functions, including identifying defects in new filings.
The regulations also permit AI-powered assistants and guided chatbots to help litigants and other stakeholders access court services and understand procedural requirements, subject to human oversight. AI can also be used to improve accessibility through tools such as text-to-speech, speech-to-text, Braille translation and visual assistance for persons with disabilities or language barriers.
The draft prohibits the use of any person’s personal data to train, test or refine AI systems without prior approval. It also makes clear that AI-generated information, data or analysis cannot form the basis of any judicial outcome, including a judgment, order or finding of fact or law.
All AI tools would remain subject to mandatory human review, supervision and verification, with final decision-making authority and accountability resting with human officials.
The proposed rules also bar the use of AI to assess bail eligibility, determine the credibility of parties or witnesses, or evaluate flight risk.
Special committees would be constituted in the Supreme Court and High Courts to oversee, regulate and facilitate the integration of AI into the judicial system within their respective jurisdictions.
(Edited by Chingkheinganbi Mayengbam)
Also Read: Restriction vs regulation: How legal fraternity views use of AI in court
