scorecardresearch

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Support our Journalism

Depth, context and analysis

Subscribe
HomeJudiciaryPrison & punishment: Why HC quoted Roman jurist Ulpian as it freed...

Prison & punishment: Why HC quoted Roman jurist Ulpian as it freed realtor in stringent PMLA case

Section 45 of PMLA sets a famously high bar for bail—courts must be satisfied there are reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty & unlikely to offend again while on bail.

Stay updated with ThePrint:

Gurugram: Roman jurist Ulpian wrote in the second century that prison is meant to hold men and not to punish them.

The centuries-old line found its way into a Punjab and Haryana High Court bail order last week, as Justice Sumeet Goel freed real estate promoter Varun Puri in a Rs 46-crore money laundering Enforcement Directorate (ED) case, a year and 22 days after he was taken into custody.

The order was pronounced on 14 August and uploaded on the court website on 17 August.

Puri, a director of Gurugram-based Universal Buildwell Private Limited (UBPL), was arrested on 22 July 2025, in a case the ED registered under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act.

The ED alleges that UBPL—along with Puri, his father Raman Puri and brother Vikram Puri—collected money from home buyers for residential and commercial projects and routed it instead through a web of associate firms, such as Buildcon Private Limited, Vanya Developers and Universal Facility Private Limited.

The money then disappeared into land purchases and loan repayments that had nothing to do with the projects buyers had paid for.

Justice Goel opened his 31-page order by tracing the idea of liberty to the Roman era and England’s Magna Carta, saying pre-trial detention must remain brief and exceptional.

English jurist Sir William Blackstone’s 18th-century warning that secret, unaccounted confinement is a more dangerous tool of tyranny than open punishment found a place too, as did a clutch of recent Supreme Court verdicts on bail in economic offence cases.

Quoting Ulpian, the judgment says, “Carcer ad continendos homines, non ad puniendos haberi debet”, which the Court translates as: “A prison ought to be used strictly for keeping men, not for punishing them.”

The case against Puri

According to the ED’s prosecution complaint, Puri was no passive director. He is accused of signing cheques, executing Builder-Buyer Agreements for projects such as Universal Aura, Universal Greens and Universal Square, and acting as an authorised signatory across UBPL group companies. 

Investigators claim roughly Rs 46 crore was funnelled through Buildcon alone, with further amounts routed through Vanya Developers and Universal Facility. 

The ED also alleged that Puri had signed away family properties through conveyance deeds without consideration, and had once been declared a proclaimed offender in a predicate offence before later securing bail in that case.

Puri’s lawyers, senior advocates Randeep S. Rai and Chetan Mittal, with Rubina Virmani, Tarun Kumar Hooda and Shifali Goyal, countered that he held only a “minuscule shareholding” in UBPL and that the only amount the ED’s complaint attributed directly to him was Rs 59.64 lakh, shown as dues payable to him as a director, well below the Rs 1 crore threshold under the PMLA’s bail proviso.

They also pointed out that none of his personal bank accounts or properties had been attached, that the company’s finances were now under a resolution professional following insolvency proceedings, and that he had already secured bail in the underlying predicate offences.

The ED, represented by senior advocate Zoheb Hossain appearing over video link with Lokesh Narang and Shubhleen Dhariwal, argued the opposite.

It said Puri was a “promoter-director” who exercised real control, that money laundering is a continuing offence, and that home buyers cheated by the scheme and that the cheated home buyers were still waiting to get their money back.

What tipped the scales

Section 45 of the PMLA sets a famously high bar for bail: courts must be satisfied there are reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty and unlikely to offend again while out on bail, the so-called “twin conditions”.

Justice Goel’s order is built around when that bar gives way to Article 21 of the Constitution, the right to life and personal liberty, instead.

Leaning on the Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling in V. Senthil Balaji vs Deputy Director, ED, the order noted that “inordinate delay in the conclusion of the trial and the higher threshold for the grant of bail cannot go together”, and that stringent bail provisions like Section 45 “cannot become a tool” to keep an undertrial locked up indefinitely.

From Manish Sisodia vs Directorate of Enforcement (2024) came the reminder that bail is the rule and jail the exception—a principle the top court said trial courts and high courts had “forgotten” in their eagerness to play safe.

And from Kapil Wadhawan vs CBI (2025) came the underlying rationale: unduly long deprivation of liberty pending trial strikes at the heart of Article 21, even without any fixed formula for how long is too long.

Applying that reasoning to the facts, Justice Goel found that Puri’s investigation was complete, the prosecution complaint already filed, and the evidence, almost entirely documentary, already in the ED’s custody, leaving little scope for tampering.

With 49 witnesses still to be examined and over 10,000 pages of documents to be led as evidence, and the case still stuck at the cognizance stage, the court held that the trial’s conclusion “in near future is bleak”.

Puri, it noted, had not been declared a proclaimed offender in this case, and the ED had furnished no list of vulnerable witnesses or any concrete basis to fear he would flee or influence the prosecution’s case.

“The fetters imposed by Section 45 of PMLA stand diluted in light of Article 21,” the court held, ordering Puri’s release on a bond, a passport deposit, a monthly affidavit of good conduct, and a bank guarantee or FDR of Rs 20 lakh liable to forfeiture on default.

The court was careful to add that nothing in its order should be read as a comment on the merits of the ED’s case against Puri, which will now proceed to trial. 

(Edited by Sugita Katyal)


Also Read: With foreign nationals fleeing on fake sureties, SC draws up framework for their bail in drug cases


 

Subscribe to our channels on YouTube, Telegram & WhatsApp

For readers who want the full picture.

You read our articles closely. Subscribe to go further, with exclusive newsletters in your inbox, flagship events hosted by Shekhar Gupta, AMAs with our senior editors, the chance to write under your own byline, and more.

Subscribe to ThePrint →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular