New Delhi: A bench of Justices P.V.Sanjay Kumar and Sanjiv Sachdeva has recused itself from hearing a suo-motu cognizance case over the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) at Shastri Bhawan.
On Friday, Justice Kumar said that although the Chief Justice of India’s office was informed when the matter was registered as a suo-motu case, his bench would no longer hear since it does not have the roster to hear a Public interest litigation (PIL).Accordingly, he told the government counsel, his bench was referring the case to the CJI for listing it before an appropriate bench.
The withdrawal comes days after Chief Justice of India Surya Kant issued an administrative order to move two cases from a two-judge bench led by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah to different benches on the ground it did not have the jurisdiction to hear them.
Beginning as individual disputes, the two cases over a period of time, through multiple orders, were expanded and converted into PILs. As per the current roster, Justice Amanullah’s bench cannot hear PIL issues.
Exercising his power as the master of the roster, the CJI ordered the withdrawal of the cases and reassigned them to appropriate benches empowered to hear them.
Judicially, the CJI is first amongst equals, which means all judges hold equal judicial power. On the administrative side, however, the master of the roster power puts him on a higher pedestal compared to any other judge of the Supreme Court.
Even though case listing is done through a computerised mechanism, the CJI can exercise the exclusive administrative discretionary power to allocate ‘sensitive’ cases, which are normally PILs, to a particular bench.
The first case withdrawn from Justice Amanullah is on the functioning of private universities, which is now earmarked to a bench led by Justice Vikram Nath, who is next in line to become the CJI. The second concerns unauthorised constructions that would now be listed before Justice B.. Nagarathna’s bench. Justice Nagarathna will take over as CJI following Justice Nath’s retirement in September next year.
ThePrint has learnt that besides withdrawing the two cases from Justice Amanullah’s bench, CJI Surya Kant also shot a letter to the registry, asking for a collated data on benches that are hearing PIL matters without being officially assigned.
Sources told ThePrint that the CJI took this step after a senior judge red-flagged the issue before him. The judge specifically referred to Justice Amanullah’s bench and pointed to the two cases that now stand withdrawn.
Thereafter, during a full court meeting with all the judges, before court shut for Diwali break, the CJI shared his concern about benches taking up PILs without having the jurisdiction to do so.
CJI Kant quoted a five-judge bench judgement on the CJI being the master of the roster. Notably, this judgement came in July 2018, months after four SC judges held an unprecedented press conference where they shared their apprehension over allocation of politically-sensitive cases to a few select benches comprising junior judges.
After discussing the issue before the full court, CJI Surya Kant informed the four senior most judges after him about his decision to withdraw the cases from Justice Amanullah’s bench.
As per the current Supreme Court’s judges’ roster, PILs are assigned exclusively to benches headed by the seven senior-most judges: CJI Surya Kant, Justices Vikram Nath, B.V.Nagarathna, M.M.Sundresh, P.S. Narasimha, J.B. Pardiwala, and Dipankar Datta.
Justice Amanullah, who is currently ninth in seniority, does not hold PILs in his roster. The two cases withdrawn from his bench are not the only ones where a bench led by him has broadened the scope of the case before it.
On Friday, when Justice Kumar’s bench took up the library case, it made an indirect reference to the developments related to the cases before Justice Amanullah.
“Let’s follow the procedure. You know what happened recently,” Justice Kumar said, adding that the case might even come back to it. However, it should be decided by the CJI and until it is not done, the bench won’t hear it.
Justice Kumar’s bench initiated the suo motu case following a report published by The Indian Express highlighting concerns over the proposed relocation of the library from Shastri Bhawan amid the building’s proposed demolition as part of the Central Vista redevelopment project. The report mentioned the lack of adequate arrangements at the new site.
The library, which functions under the Union Ministry of Culture, was established as the Imperial Secretariat Library in Calcutta in 1891. It was subsequently shifted to Delhi and has been housed at Shastri Bhawan since 1969. It houses more than 8.5 lakh volumes, including rare books, government publications and official records.
(Edited by Tony Rai)
